SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
 
FORM 6-K
 
Report of Foreign Private Issuer

Pursuant to Rule 13a-16 or 15d-16 of
the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
 
28 May 2009
 
The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc
 
Gogarburn
PO Box 1000
Edinburgh EH12 1HQ
Scotland
United Kingdom
 
(Address of principal executive offices)
 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant files or will file annual reports under cover of Form 20-F or Form 40-F.
 
Form 20-F  X    Form 40-F___
 
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is submitting the Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(1):___
 
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is submitting the Form 6-K in paper as permitted by Regulation S-T Rule 101(b)(7):___
 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant by furnishing the information contained in this Form is also thereby furnishing the information to the Commission pursuant to Rule 12g3-2(b) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
 
Yes     No  X 
 
If “Yes” is marked, indicate below the file number assigned to
the registrant in connection with Rule 12g3-2(b): 82-
___
 
 

 
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND plc
 
CONTENTS
Page
   
Explanatory note
2
   
Presentation of information
2
   
Forward-looking statements
3
   
Selected financial data
4
   
Description of business
6
   
Risk factors
7
   
Risk, capital and liquidity management
15
   
Financial statements
 
 
Independent auditors' report
56
 
Consolidated income statement
57
 
Balance sheets
58
 
Statements of recognised income and expense
59
 
Cash flow statements
60
 
Accounting policies
61
 
Notes on the accounts
71
 
 
Signature
137
 
 
1

 
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND plc

Explanatory note
The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc is filing this report in order for its wholly-owned subsidiary, The Royal Bank of Scotland plc (hereafter  “the Royal Bank”, the “Bank” or “Company”), to meet the requirements of item 1115 of Regulation AB issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission. This report contains selected financial data (on pages 4 - 5) and audited financial statements (on pages 56 - 135) as required by Item 3.A. and Item 17 of Form 20-F respectively and other related information.

Presentation of information
For the purpose of this report, the term 'Group' mean the Bank and its subsidiary and associated undertakings and the term 'RBS Group' means The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc and its subsidiary and associated undertakings. The term 'the holding company' means The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc.
 
The Bank publishes its financial statements in pounds sterling (“£” or “sterling”). The abbreviations ‘£m’ and ‘£bn’ represent millions and thousands of millions of pounds sterling, respectively, and references to ‘pence’ represent pence in the United Kingdom (“UK”). Reference to ‘dollars’ or ‘$’ are to United States of America (“US”) dollars. The abbreviations ‘$m’ and ‘$bn’ represent millions and thousands of millions of dollars, respectively, and references to ‘cents’ represent cents in the US. The abbreviation ‘€’ represents the ‘euro’, the European single currency and the abbreviations ‘€m’ and ‘€bn’ represent millions and thousands of millions of euros, respectively.
 
The results, assets and liabilities of individual business units are classified as trading or non-trading based on their predominant activity. Although this method may result in some non-trading activity being classified as trading, and vice versa, the Group believes that any resulting misclassification is not material.
 
International Financial Reporting Standards
As required by the Companies Act 1985 and Article 4 of the European Union IAS Regulation, the consolidated financial statements of the Group are prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) and interpretations issued by the International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee of the IASB (together ‘IFRS’) as adopted by the European Union. It also complies with IFRS as issued by the IASB. On implementation of IFRS on 1 January 2005, the Group took advantage of the option in IFRS 1 ‘First-time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards’ to implement IAS 39 ‘Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement’ and IAS 32 ‘Financial Instruments: Disclosure and Presentation’ from 1 January 2005 without restating its 2004 income statement and balance sheet. The date of transition to IFRS for the Group and the date of its opening IFRS balance sheet is 1 January 2004.
 
The Group is no longer required to include reconciliations of shareholders' equity and net income under IFRS and US GAAP in its filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission in the US.
 
 
2

 
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND plc
 
Forward-looking statements
 
Certain sections in this document contain ‘forward-looking statements’ as that term is defined in the United States Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, such as statements that include the words ‘expect’, ‘estimate’, ‘project’, ‘anticipate’, ‘believes’, ‘should’, ‘could’, ‘intend’, ‘plan’, ‘probability’, ‘risk’, ‘Value-at-Risk (“VaR”)’, ‘target’, ‘goal’, ‘objective’, ‘may’, ‘will’, ‘endeavour’, ‘outlook’, ‘optimistic’, ‘prospects’ and similar expressions or variations on such expressions.
 
In particular, this document includes forward-looking statements relating, but not limited, to the Group’s potential exposures to various types of market risks, such as interest rate risk, foreign exchange rate risk and commodity and equity price risk. Such statements are subject to risks and uncertainties. For example, certain of the market risk disclosures are dependent on choices about key model characteristics and assumptions and are subject to various limitations. By their nature, certain of the market risk disclosures are only estimates and, as a result, actual future gains and losses could differ materially from those that have been estimated.
 
Other factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those estimated by the forward-looking statements contained in this document include, but are not limited to: the extent and nature of future developments in the credit markets, including the sub-prime market, and their impact on the financial industry in general and the Group in particular; general economic conditions in the UK and in other countries in which the Group has significant business activities or investments, including the United States; the monetary and interest rate policies of the Bank of England, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and other G-7 central banks; inflation; deflation; unanticipated fluctuations in interest rates, foreign currency exchange rates, commodity prices and equity prices; changes in UK and foreign laws, regulations and taxes; changes in competition and pricing environments; natural and other disasters; the inability to hedge certain risks economically; the adequacy of loss reserves; acquisitions or restructurings; technological changes; changes in consumer spending and saving habits; and the success of the Group in managing the risks involved in the foregoing.
 
The forward-looking statements contained in this report speak only as of the date of this report, and the Group does not undertake to update any forward-looking statement to reflect events or circumstances after the date hereof or to reflect the occurrence of unanticipated events.
 
For a further discussion on certain risks faced by the Group, see Risk Factors on page 7.
 
3

 
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND plc
 
SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA
 
The Group’s accounts are prepared in accordance with IFRS as issued by the IASB. Selected data under IFRS for each of the five years ended 31 December 2008 are presented on pages 4 and 5.
 
The dollar financial information included below has been translated for convenience at the of £1.00 to US$1.4619, the Noon Buying Rate on 31 December 2008.
 
Amounts in accordance with IFRS
Summary consolidated income statement — IFRS
 
2008
$m
     
2008
£m
     
2007
£m
     
2006
£m
     
2005
£m
     
2004
£m
 
Net interest income
  19,749       13,509       11,116       10,392       9,711       8,790  
Non-interest income
  3,432       2,348       11,191       11,176       9,963       8,441  
Total income
  23,181       15,857       22,307       21,568       19,674       17,231  
Operating expenses (1)
  29,527       20,198       11,287       11,341       10,672       9,225  
(Loss)/profit before impairment
  (6,346 )     (4,341 )     11,020       10,227       9,002       8,006  
Impairment
  6,880       4,706       1,865       1,873       1,709       1,485  
Operating (loss)/profit before tax
  (13,226 )     (9,047 )     9,155       8,354       7,293       6,521  
Tax
  (738 )     (505 )     1,903       2,433       2,267       1,751  
(Loss)/profit from continuing operations
  (12,488 )     (8,542 )     7,252       5,921       5,026       4,770  
Profit from discontinued operations, net of tax
                                258  
(Loss)/profit for the year
  (12,488 )     (8,542 )     7,252       5,921       5,026       5,028  
                                               
(Loss)/profit attributable to:
                                             
Minority interests
  304       208       53       45       27       53  
Other owners
  933       638       331       252       154       315  
Ordinary shareholders
  (13,725 )     (9,388 )     6,868       5,624       4,845       4,660  
 
Note:
(1) Includes integration and restructuring expenditure of £647 million (2007 - £92 million, 2006 - £120 million, 2005 - £349 million, 2004 - £499 million).
 
Summary consolidated balance sheet — IFRS
 
2008
$m
     
2008
£m
     
2007
£m
     
2006
£m
     
2005
£m
     
2004
£m
 
Loans and advances
  1,021,707       698,890       647,795       547,042       485,488       405,512  
Debt securities and equity shares
  263,810       180,457       169,941       126,621       120,351       91,356  
Derivatives and settlement balances (1)
  1,386,361       948,328       211,301       109,548       89,479       15,297  
Other assets
  73,468       50,255       42,701       50,416       49,806       50,436  
Total assets
  2,745,346       1,877,930       1,071,738       833,627       745,124       562,601  
                                               
Shareholders’ equity
  67,186       45,958       47,683       37,936       34,510       34,320  
Minority interests
  1,889       1,292       152       396       104       679  
Subordinated liabilities
  58,404       39,951       27,796       27,786       28,422       21,262  
Deposits
  928,469       635,111       594,490       516,462       452,729       383,669  
Derivatives, settlement balances and short positions(1)
  1,396,205       955,062       256,921       152,989       128,295       43,812  
Other liabilities
  293,193       200,556       144,696       98,058       101,064       78,859  
Total liabilities and equity
  2,745,346       1,877,930       1,071,738       833,627       745,124       562,601  
 
Note:
(1) Derivative balances in 2007 to 2004 have been restated for the netting of certain balances with the London Clearing House.
 
 
4

 
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND plc
 
SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA (continued)
 
Other financial data
 
Based upon IFRS
2008   2007  
2006
 
2005
 
2004
Return on average total assets(1)
(0.64%
)
0.72%
 
0.71%
 
0.74%
 
0.93%
Return on average ordinary shareholders' equity(2)
(22.7%
)
19.9%  
18.4%
  16.9%  
17.6%
Average shareholders' equity as a percentage of total assets
3.4%   4.2%  
4.4%
  4.4%  
6.2%
Risk asset ratio
                 
- Tier 1
8.5%   7.9%  
6.7%
 
6.8%
 
N/A(4)
- Total
14.2%   12.8%  
12.1%
 
12.3%
 
N/A(4)
Ratio of earnings to fixed charges and preference dividends(3)
               
 
- including interest on deposits
0.48   1.50  
1.57
   1.62  
1.83
- excluding interest on deposits
(2.94
)
5.68  
6.30
 
6.77
 
6.79
Ratio of earnings to fixed charges only(3)
                 
- including interest on deposits
0.50   1.53  
1.59
 
1.64
 
1.91
- excluding interest on deposits
(3.97
)
6.89  
7.54
 
7.73
 
9.37
 
Notes:
(1)
Return on average total assets represents profit attributable to ordinary shareholders as a percentage of average total assets.
(2)
Return on average ordinary shareholders' equity represents profit attributable to ordinary shareholders expressed as a percentage of average ordinary shareholders' equity.
(3)
For this purpose, earnings consist of income before taxes and minority interests, plus fixed charges less the unremitted income of associated undertakings (share of profits less dividends received). Fixed charges consist of total interest expense, including or excluding interest on deposits and debt securities in issue, as appropriate, and the proportion of rental expense deemed representative of the interest factor (one third of total rental expenses).
(4)
Upon adoption of IFRS by listed banks in the UK on 1 January 2005, the Financial Services Authority ("FSA") changed its regulatory requirements such that the measurement of capital adequacy was based on IFRS subject to a number of prudential filers. The Risk Asset Ratios as at 31 December 2008, 2007, 2006 and 2005 have been presented in compliance with these revised FSA requirements. 
 
 
5

 


Description of business

Introduction

The Royal Bank of Scotland plc (“the Royal Bank” or the Bank”) is a wholly-owned subsidiary of The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc (“the holding company”), a large banking and financial services group. The “Group” comprises the Bank and its subsidiary and associated undertakings. The Group has a large and diversified customer base and provides a wide range of products and services to personal, commercial and large corporate and institutional customers. “RBS Group” comprises the holding company and its subsidiary and associated undertakings.

Following a placing and open offer in December 2008, Her Majesty's Treasury in the United Kingdom (HM Treasury) owned approximately 58% of the enlarged ordinary share capital of the holding company and £5 billion of non-cumulative sterling preference shares. In April 2009, the holding company issued new ordinary shares by way of a second placing and open offer, the proceeds from which were used in full to fund the redemption of the preference shares held by HM Treasury at 101% of their issue price together with the accrued dividend and the commissions payable to HM Treasury under the second placing and open offer agreement. The second placing and open offer was underwritten by HM Treasury and as a result, HM Treasury currently owns approximately 70% of the enlarged ordinary share capital of the holding company.

Organisational structure and business overview

The Groups activities are organised in the following business divisions: Global Markets (comprising Global Banking & Markets and Global Transaction Services), Regional Markets (comprising UK Retail & Commercial Banking, US Retail & Commercial Banking, Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking and Asia Retail & Commercial Banking), Group Manufacturing and the Centre. A description of each of the divisions is given below.
 
The RBS Group has undertaken a strategic review to re-focus the RBS Group on those businesses with clear competitive advantages and attractive marketing positions, primarily in stable, low-to-medium risk sectors.
 
Global Banking & Markets is a leading banking partner to major corporations and financial institutions around the world, providing an extensive range of debt and equity financing, risk management and investment services to its customers. In 2008 the division was organised along four principal business lines: rates, currencies, and commodities, including RBS Sempra Commodities LLP (the commodities-marketing joint venture between RBS and Sempra Energy which was formed on 1 April 2008); equities; credit markets; and asset and portfolio management.
 
Following the RBS Group’s strategic review, GBM is planning to re-focus its business around its core corporate and institutional clients, concentrating its activities in major financial centres and scaling back its presence elsewhere. It will exit illiquid proprietary trading and balance sheet-heavy niche products segments.

Globally, the intention is for GBM to move increasingly towards a “hub-and- spoke” model. Risk will be managed from regional hubs. It is intended that distribution and coverage will be delivered from a mix of hub countries and a scaled-back presence in some local offices. The aim, over time, will be to reduce much of the on-shore trading activity outside the key financial centres.
 
Assets, products and geographies that fit GBMs new client-focused proposition will be defined as “core” and will remain within the division.  Assets, business lines and some geographies that are non-core will be transferred to the new Non-Core Bank. These non-core activities accounted for approximately £205 billion of third party assets at end 2008.
 
Global Transaction Services ranks among the top five global transaction services providers, offering global payments, cash and liquidity management, as well as trade finance, United Kingdom and international merchant acquiring and commercial card products and services. It includes the Groups corporate money transmission activities in the United Kingdom and the United States.
 
Following the RBS Group’s strategic review, Global Transaction Services intends to reduce its international network while retaining the capability to serve multinational clients globally.
 
The business also plans to increase efficiency through development of a lower cost front and back-office operating model and explore joint ventures for growth and selective disposals.

UK Retail & Commercial Banking (RBS UK) comprises retail, corporate and commercial banking and wealth management services. It operates through a range of channels including on-line and fixed and mobile telephony, and through two of the largest networks of branches and ATMs in the UK.
 
UK Retail Banking offers a full range of banking products and related financial services to the personal market. It serves customers through two of the largest networks of branches and ATMs in the United Kingdom, and also through telephone and internet channels and, according to Gfk NOP, is the second largest provider of personal current accounts. The division also issues credit and charge cards, including through other brands such as MINT.
 
UK Business & Commercial Banking is the largest provider of banking, finance, and risk management services to the SME sector in the United Kingdom. It offers a full range of banking products and related financial services through a nationwide network of relationship managers, and also through telephone and internet channels. The product range includes asset finance, in which, according to the Finance Lease Association, it has a strong market presence through the Lombard brand.

According to Ph. Group, UK Corporate Banking holds the largest market share in the United Kingdom of relationships with larger companies, offering a full range of banking, finance, and risk management services.

US Retail & Commercial Banking provides financial services primarily through the Citizens and Charter One brands. Citizens is engaged in retail and corporate banking activities through its branch network in 12 states in the United States and through non-branch offices in other states.
 
Following the RBS Group’s strategic review, Citizens intends to invest in its core business through increased marketing activity and targeted technology investments while reducing activity in its out-of-footprint national businesses in consumer and commercial finance.
 
This strategy will allow Citizens to become fully funded from its own customer deposits over time, and will support a low risk profile.

Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking comprises Ulster Bank and the Groups combined retail and commercial businesses in Europe and the Middle East.

Ulster Bank, including First Active, provides a comprehensive range of financial services across the island of Ireland. Its retail banking arm has a network of branches and operates in the personal, commercial and wealth management sectors, while its corporate markets operations provide services in the corporate and institutional markets.
 
The retail and commercial businesses in Europe and the Middle East have smaller activities in Romania, Kazakhstan and the United Arab Emirates. Following the Group’s strategic review, the Group has decided to exit sub-scale retail and commercial activities outside its core markets in the United Kingdom, Europe and the United States.
 
Asia Retail & Commercial Banking is present in markets including India, Pakistan, China, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore. It provides financial services across four segments: affluent banking, cards and consumer finance, business banking and international wealth management, which offers private banking and investment services to clients in selected markets through the RBS Coutts brand.
 
Following the RBS Group’s strategic review, the Group has decided to exit sub-scale retail and commercial activities outside its core markets in the United Kingdom, Europe and the United States.
 
Group Manufacturing comprises the Groups worldwide manufacturing operations. It supports the customer-facing businesses and provides operational technology, customer support in telephony, account management, lending and money transmission, global purchasing, property and other services. Manufacturing drives efficiencies and supports income growth across multiple brands and channels by using a single, scalable platform and common processes wherever possible. It also leverages the Groups purchasing power and has become the centre of excellence for managing large-scale and complex change.

The Centre comprises group and corporate functions, such as capital raising, finance, risk management, legal, communications and human resources. The Centre manages the Groups capital requirement and Group-wide regulatory projects and provides services to the operating divisions.
 
Non-core division
The Group intends to create during the second quarter of 2009 a non-core division to manage separately approximately £240 billion of third party assets, £145 billion of derivative balances and £155 billion of risk weighted assets that it intends to run off or dispose of over the next three to five years. The division will contain primarily assets from the GBM division linked to proprietary trading portfolios, excess risk concentrations and other illiquid portfolios. It will also include excess risk concentrations from other divisions as well as a number of small Regional Markets businesses that the Group has concluded are no longer strategic.


Recent developments
 
Asset Protection Scheme
On 26 February 2009, the RBS Group confirmed its intended participation in HM Treasurys Asset Protection Scheme (APS). The arrangements between the RBS Group and HM Treasury will, if completed, allow the RBS Group to secure asset protection in respect of some of its riskiest assets that enhances its financial strength and provides improved stability for customers and depositors, and also enhances the RBS Groups ability to lend into the UK market.

The proposed entry by the RBS Group into the APS is subject to the approval of independent shareholders of the RBS Group.
 
Litigation Update
Note 29 of the Notes on the Accounts provides disclosure regarding, among other things, litigation claims in the United Kingdom. With respect to the claims regarding unarranged overdraft charges, the House of Lords has granted the RBS Group and other banks leave to appeal the Court of Appeals decision. That further appeal is scheduled to take place on 23 June 2009.
 
Debt Tender and Exchange Offer
On 26 March 2009, RBS Financing Limited ("RBSF"), a subsidiary of the RBS Group, launched a cash tender offer in the United States (the “RBSF US Tender Offer”) for any and all of the outstanding securities of ten different series previously issued by the Group and certain of its affiliates.  Concurrently therewith, RBSF also launched a cash tender offer outside of the United States (the “RBSF Non-US Tender Offer”) for five different series of securities previously issued by The Royal Bank and certain of its affiliates and an offer outside of the United States to exchange (the “RBSF Exchange Offer”) any or all of the outstanding securities of fourteen different series previously issued by The Royal Bank and certain of its affiliates for new senior unsecured notes of The Royal Bank.
 
The RBSF Tender Offers and the RBSF Exchange Offer expired on 22 April 2009. In the RBSF US Tender Offer, an aggregate of approximately US $4.1 billion principal amount of securities were validly tendered, resulting in an aggregate purchase consideration paid for the tendered securities of approximately US $1.7 billion.
 
In the RBSF Non-US Tender Offer, an aggregate of approximately €2.3 billion principal amount of Euro-denominated securities and approximately US $264 million principal amount of Dollar-denominated securities were validly tendered, resulting in aggregate purchase consideration paid for the tendered securities of approximately €1.1 billion and US $100 million, respectively.
 
In the RBSF Exchange Offer, an aggregate of approximately £3.5 billion principal amount of securities were validly offered for exchange and exchanged for new senior unsecured notes of The Royal Bank in an aggregate principal amount of approximately £1.8 billion.
 
 
6



 
Competition

The Group faces strong competition in all the markets it serves. However, the global banking crisis has reduced the capacity of many institutions to lend and has resulted in the withdrawal or disappearance of a number of market participants and significant consolidation of competitors, particularly in the US and UK. Competition for retail deposits has intensified significantly reflecting the difficulties in the wholesale money markets.

Competition for corporate and institutional customers in the UK is from UK banks and from large foreign financial institutions who are also active and offer combined investment and commercial banking capabilities. In asset finance, the Group competes with banks and specialised asset finance providers, both captive and non-captive. In European and Asian corporate and institutional banking markets the Group competes with the large domestic banks active in these markets and with the major international banks.

In the small business banking market, the Group competes with other UK clearing banks, specialist finance providers and building societies.

In the personal banking segment, the Group competes with UK banks, building societies and major retailers. In the mortgage market, the Group competes with UK banks and building societies. A number of competitors have either left or scaled back their lending in the mortgage and unsecured markets.

In the UK credit card market, large retailers and specialist card issuers, including major US operators, are active in addition to the UK banks. In addition to physical distribution channels, providers compete through direct marketing activity and the internet.

In Europe, Asia and the Middle East, the Group competes in retail banking with local and international banks. In a number of these markets there are regulatory barriers to entry or expansion, and the state ownership of banks. Competition is generally intensifying as more players enter markets that are perceived to be de-regulating and offer significant growth potential.

In Wealth Management, The Royal Bank of Scotland International competes with other UK and international banks to offer offshore banking services. Coutts and Adam & Company compete as private banks with UK clearing and private banks, and with international private banks. Competition in wealth management remains strong as banks maintain their focus on competing for affluent and high net worth customers.

In Ireland, Ulster Bank and First Active compete in retail and commercial banking with the major Irish banks and building societies, and with other UK and international banks and building societies active in the market.

In the United States, Citizens competes in the New England, Mid-Atlantic and Mid West retail and mid-corporate banking markets with local and regional banks and other financial institutions. The Group also competes in the US in large corporate lending and specialised finance markets, and in fixed-income trading and sales. Competition is principally with the large US commercial and investment banks and international banks active in the US.
 
Risk factors
 
The Royal Bank of Scotland plc is a principal subsidiary of The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc. Consequently, the risk factors facing RBS Group also apply to the Royal Bank and are therefore discussed in this section. References in this section to RBS refer to The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc.

Set out below are certain risk factors which could affect the RBS Groups future results and cause them to be materially different from expected results. The RBS Groups results are also affected by competition and other factors. The factors discussed in this report should not be regarded as a complete and comprehensive statement of all potential risks and uncertainties.

RBS may face the risk of full nationalisation and under such circumstances shareholders may lose the full value of their shares.
 
Under the provisions of the Banking Act, substantial powers have been granted to HM Treasury, the Bank of England and the Financial Services Authority (FSA) as part of the Special Resolution Regime to stabilise banks that are in financial difficulties. The Special Resolution Regime gives the authorities three stabilisation options: private sector transfer, of all or part of the business of a UK-incorporated institution with permission to accept deposits (a “relevant entity”); transfer of all or part of the business of the relevant entity to a “bridge bank” established by the Bank of England; and temporary public ownership (nationalisation) of the relevant entity or its UK-incorporated holding company.

The purpose of the stabilising options is to address the situation where all or part of the business of the relevant entity has encountered, or is likely to encounter, financial difficulties. Accordingly, the stabilisation options may only be exercised if the FSA is satisfied that a relevant entity such as the RBS Groups banking subsidiaries, including the Royal Bank, (i) is failing, or is likely to fail, to satisfy the threshold conditions set out in Schedule 6 to the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (the “FSMA”) and (ii) having regard to timing and other relevant circumstances it is not reasonably likely that action will be taken that will enable the relevant entity to satisfy those threshold conditions. The threshold conditions are conditions which an FSA-authorised institution must satisfy in order to retain its FSA authorisation. They are relatively wide-ranging and deal with most aspects of a relevant entitys business, including, but not limited to, minimum capital resource requirements. It is therefore possible that the FSA may exercise one of the stabilisation options before a relevant entity is in severe difficulties and before an application for insolvency or an administration order could be made.

The stabilisation options may be exercised by means of powers to transfer property, rights or liabilities of a relevant entity and shares and other securities issued by a relevant entity. HM Treasury may also take the parent company of a relevant entity (such as RBS) into temporary public ownership provided that certain conditions set out in Section 82 of the Banking Act are met. Temporary public ownership is effected by way of a share transfer order.

If HM Treasury makes the decision to take the holding company of a relevant entity into temporary public ownership, it may take various actions in relation to securities issued by the holding company, including:

·  
to transfer securities free from any contractual or legislative restrictions on transfer;
·  
to transfer securities free from any trust, liability, or encumbrance;
·  
to extinguish rights to acquire securities;
·  
to delist securities; or
·  
to convert securities into another form or class.
 
7

 
Where HM Treasury has made a share transfer order in respect of securities issued by the holding company of a relevant entity, HM Treasury may make an order providing for the property, rights or liabilities of the holding company or of any relevant entity in the holding company group to be transferred.

Shareholders may have a claim for compensation under one of the compensation schemes provided for in the Banking Act. For the purposes of determining an amount of compensation, an independent valuer must disregard actual or potential financial assistance provided by the Bank of England or HM Treasury.

There can be no assurance that Shareholders would thereby recover compensation promptly and/or equal to any loss actually incurred.

If the RBS Group were made subject to the Special Resolution Regime and a partial transfer of the RBS Groups business was effected, the nature and mix of the assets and liabilities not transferred may adversely affect its financial condition and increase the risk that the RBS Group may eventually become subject to administration or insolvency proceedings.

Over the last six months, the UK Government has taken action under the Banking (Special Provisions) Act 2008 in respect of a number of UK financial institutions including, in extreme circumstances, full and part nationalisation. There have been concerns in the market in recent months regarding the risks of such nationalisation in relation to RBS and other UK banks. If economic conditions in the UK or globally continue to deteriorate, or the events described in the following risk factors occur to such an extent that they have a materially adverse impact on the financial condition, perceived or actual credit quality, results of operations or business of any of the relevant entities in the RBS Group, the UK Government may decide to take similar action in relation to RBS. Given the extent of HM Treasurys and the Bank of Englands powers under the Banking Act, it is difficult to predict what effect such actions might have on RBS and any securities issued by it. However, potential impacts may include full nationalisation of RBS and the total loss of value in RBS shares.

If RBS is unable to participate in the APS, or the operation of the APS fails to have the desired effect on RBSs financial and capital position, RBS may face the increased risk of full nationalisation. If the costs of participation outweigh the benefits, this could have a negative impact on RBSs business, earnings and financial prospects and its Share price may suffer.
 
On 26 February 2009, RBS announced its intention to participate in the APS. However, its ability to participate in the APS is subject to the satisfaction of a number of conditions which may not be satisfied, including, among others, the completion of due diligence by (and to the satisfaction of) HM Treasury, the receipt of certain regulatory approvals (including European Commission State Aid clearance), the approval of a majority of RBSs Independent Shareholders, finalisation of the terms of the APS and RBSs participation therein and the satisfaction by RBS of certain specified application criteria. The failure to satisfy these conditions could result in RBS being unable to participate in the APS and therefore failing to obtain protection against stressed losses through the economic cycle as well as failing to improve its capital ratios at the RBS consolidated Group level. The result of this may mean intervention by the UK Government, which could include full nationalisation, under which circumstances any compensation payable to Shareholders would be subject to the provisions of the Banking Act, and Shareholders may lose the full value of their Shares.

Furthermore, even if RBS is able to participate in the APS, there can be no assurance that such participation will enable RBS to achieve all of the stated goals of the APS. While the APS is expected to limit losses associated with assets to be covered by the APS, RBS would remain fully exposed in respect of a specified “first loss” amount and exposed to 10 per cent. of losses exceeding that “first loss” amount. In addition, RBS would continue to be exposed to the risk of losses, impairments and write-downs with respect to assets not covered by the APS. Although RBS would have the option to obtain an additional £6 billion in capital from HM Treasury (in the form of a subscription for further B Shares) there can be no assurance that such additional capital, together with RBSs strengthened capital position as a result of the Placing and Open Offer, and the capital resulting from the proposed issue of the £6.5 billion and £13 billion of B Shares, will be sufficient to maintain the RBS Groups capital ratios in the event of further losses, which could cause RBSs business, results of operation and financial condition to suffer, its credit rating to drop, its ability to lend and access funding to be further limited, its cost of funding to increase and its Share price to decline, any of which would increase the risk of the full nationalisation of RBS.

In addition, there can be no assurance that the costs to RBS of its participation in the APS will not outweigh any benefits received. For example, RBS has agreed in principle that if it accedes to the APS, it will give up the right to certain tax losses and allowances which may affect the after-tax returns of the RBS Group in future years. As a result of RBSs agreement to give up such UK tax losses and allowances it is likely that RBS will pay UK corporation tax in earlier accounting periods than it would otherwise have done.
 
8

 
The RBS Groups businesses, earnings and financial condition have been and will continue to be affected by the continued deterioration in the global economy, as well as ongoing instability in the global financial markets.
 
The performance of the RBS Group has been and will continue to be influenced by the economic conditions of the countries in which it operates, particularly the United Kingdom, the United States and other countries throughout Europe and Asia. Recessionary conditions are present in many of these countries, including the United Kingdom and the United States, and such conditions are expected to continue or worsen over the near to medium term. In addition, the global financial system is continuing to experience the difficulties which first manifested themselves in August 2007, and the financial markets have deteriorated significantly since the bankruptcy filing by Lehman Brothers in September 2008. These conditions have led to severe and continuing dislocation of financial markets around the world and unprecedented levels of illiquidity, resulting in the development of significant problems at a number of the worlds largest corporate institutions operating across a wide range of industry sectors, many of whom are the RBS Groups customers and counterparties in the ordinary course of its business. In response to this economic instability and illiquidity in the market, a number of governments, including the UK Government, the governments of the other EU member states and the US Government, have intervened in order to inject liquidity and capital into the financial system, and, in some cases, to prevent the failure of these institutions.

Despite such measures, the volatility and disruption of the capital and credit markets have continued at unprecedented levels, and global recessionary conditions are expected to continue. These conditions have produced and will continue to produce downward pressure on stock prices and on availability and cost of credit for financial institutions, including the RBS Group, and will continue to impact on the credit quality of the RBS Groups customers and counterparties. Such conditions, alone or in combination with regulatory changes or actions of other market participants, may cause the RBS Group to experience further reductions in business activity, increased funding costs and funding pressures, lower share prices, decreased asset values, additional write downs and impairment charges and lower profitability or to incur losses.

In addition, the RBS Group will continue to be exposed to the risk of loss if major corporate borrowers or counterparty financial institutions fail or are otherwise unable to meet their obligations. The RBS Groups performance may also be affected by future recovery rates on assets and the historical assumptions underlying asset recovery rates, which may no longer be accurate given the unprecedented market disruption and general economic instability. The precise nature of all the risks and uncertainties the RBS Group faces as a result of current economic conditions cannot be predicted and many of these risks are outside the RBS Groups control.

Any conversion of the B Shares would significantly increase HM Treasurys ownership interest in RBS, have a corresponding dilutive effect on other RBS Shareholders and could result in the delisting of RBSs securities.
 
At the same time as RBS announced its proposed participation in the APS, RBS announced that, if it participated in the APS, it would issue £6.5 billion of B Shares to HM Treasury. RBS also announced that it would issue a further £13 billion of B Shares to HM Treasury on or after implementation of the APS, and HM Treasury would grant RBS the option to require HM Treasury to purchase a further £6 billion of B Shares from it. The B Shares, if issued, will rank pari passu with the Ordinary Shares on a winding-up. The B Shares would be convertible, at the option of the holder at any time, into Ordinary Shares at an initial conversion price of £0.50 per Ordinary Share. HM Treasury would agree not to convert any B Shares it holds if, as a result of such conversion, it would hold 75 per cent. or more of the Ordinary Shares, unless the price of the Ordinary Shares is equal to or exceeds £0.65 for a specified period in which case conversion is mandatory in any event. In addition, HM Treasury will not be entitled to vote in respect of Ordinary Shares acquired by it as a result of the conversion of B Shares into Ordinary Shares to the extent, but only to the extent, that votes cast on such Ordinary Shares, together with any other votes which HM Treasury is entitled to cast in respect of any other Ordinary Shares held by or on behalf of HM Treasury would exceed 75 per cent. of the total votes eligible to be cast on a resolution presented at a general meeting of RBS. If all £25.5 billion of B Shares are issued, such conversion of the B Shares would significantly increase HM Treasurys ownership interest in RBS up to approximately 84.4 per cent. of the RBSs issued share capital, and have a corresponding dilutive effect on other RBS Shareholders (as would the issue of the B Shares themselves in the event of a winding-up) although any such conversion would have no impact on the RBS Groups Tier 1 capital position. Furthermore, a mandatory conversion of the B Shares by HM Treasury would put RBS in breach of the Listing Rules requirement that 25 per cent. of its issued share capital must be in public hands. Although RBS may apply to the UKLA for a waiver in such circumstances, there is no guarantee that such a waiver would be granted, the result of which could be the delisting of RBS from the Official List and potentially other exchanges where its securities are currently listed and traded.

Lack of liquidity is a risk to the RBS Groups business and its ability to access sources of liquidity has been, and will continue to be, constrained.
 
Liquidity risk is the risk that a bank will be unable to meet its obligations, including funding commitments, as they fall due. This risk is inherent in banking operations and can be heightened by a number of enterprise specific factors, including an over-reliance on a particular source of funding (including, for example, short term and overnight funding), changes in credit ratings or market-wide phenomena such as market dislocation and major disasters. Credit markets worldwide have experienced and continue to experience a severe reduction in liquidity and term-funding in the aftermath of events in the US sub-prime residential mortgage market and the current severe market dislocation. Perception of counterparty risk between banks has also increased significantly following the bankruptcy filing by Lehman Brothers. This increase in perceived counterparty risk has led to further reductions in inter-bank lending, and hence, in common with many other banks, the RBS Groups access to traditional sources of liquidity has been, and may continue to be, restricted.

The RBS Groups liquidity management focuses on maintaining a diverse and appropriate funding strategy for its operations, controlling the mismatch of maturities and carefully monitoring its undrawn commitments and contingent liabilities. However, the RBS Groups ability to access sources of liquidity (for example, through the issue or sale of financial and other instruments or through the use of term loans) during the recent period of liquidity stress has been constrained to the point where it, like other banks, has had to rely on shorter term and overnight funding with a consequent reduction in overall liquidity, and to increase its recourse to liquidity schemes provided by central banks.
 
9

 
In addition, there is also a risk that corporate and institutional counterparties with credit exposures may look to reduce all credit exposures to banks, given current risk aversion trends. It is possible that credit market dislocation becomes so severe that overnight funding from non-government sources ceases to be available.

Furthermore, like many banks, the RBS Group relies on customer deposits to meet a considerable portion of its funding requirements and such deposits are subject to fluctuation due to certain factors outside the RBS Groups control, such as a loss of confidence, competitive pressures or the encouraged or mandated repatriation of deposits by foreign wholesale or central bank depositors which could result in a significant outflow of deposits within a short period of time. Any material decrease in the RBS Groups deposits could, particularly if accompanied by one of the other factors described above, have a negative impact on the RBS Groups liquidity unless corresponding actions were taken to improve the liquidity profile of other deposits or to reduce assets.

The governments of some of the countries in which the RBS Group operates have taken steps to guarantee the liabilities of the banks and branches operating in their respective jurisdiction. Whilst in some instances the operations of the RBS Group are covered by government guarantees alongside other local banks, in other countries this may not necessarily always be the case. This may place subsidiaries operating in those countries, such as Ulster Bank Ireland Ltd, which did not participate in such government guarantee schemes, at a competitive disadvantage to the other local banks and therefore may require the RBS Group to provide additional funding and liquidity support to these operations.

There can be no assurance that these measures, alongside other available measures, will succeed in improving the funding and liquidity in the markets in which the RBS Group operates, or that these measures, combined with any increased cost of any funding currently available in the market, will not lead to a further increase in the RBS Groups overall cost of funding, which could have an adverse impact on the RBS Groups financial condition and results of operations or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

Governmental support schemes are subject to cancellation, change or withdrawal (on a general or individual basis), which may have a negative impact on the availability of funding in the markets in which the RBS Group operates.
 
Governmental support schemes are subject to cancellation, change or withdrawal (on a general or individual basis) subject to contract, based on changing economic and political conditions in the jurisdiction of the relevant scheme. Furthermore, certain schemes which have been recently announced have in fact not been fully implemented, or their terms have not yet been finalised. To the extent government support schemes are cancelled, changed or withdrawn in a manner which diminishes their effectiveness, or to the extent such schemes fail to generate additional liquidity or other support in the relevant markets in which such schemes operate, the RBS Group, in common with other banks, may continue to face limited access to, have insufficient access to, or incur higher costs associated with, funding alternatives, which could have a material adverse impact on the RBS Groups business, financial condition, results of operations and prospects and result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The financial performance of the RBS Group has been and will be affected by borrower credit quality.
 
Risks arising from changes in credit quality and the recoverability of loans and amounts due from counterparties are inherent in a wide range of the RBS Groups businesses. The outlook for the global economy over the near to medium term has continued to deteriorate, particularly in the UK, the United States and other European economies. For example, there is an expectation of further reductions in residential and commercial property prices, higher unemployment rates and reduced profitability of corporate borrowers. As a result, the RBS Group has seen and expects to continue to see adverse changes in the credit quality of its borrowers and counterparties, with increasing delinquencies, defaults and insolvencies across a range of sectors. This trend has led and may lead to further impairment charges, higher costs, additional write downs and losses for the RBS Group or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The actual or perceived failure or worsening credit of the RBS Groups counterparties has adversely affected and could continue to adversely affect the RBS Group.
 
The RBS Groups ability to engage in routine funding transactions has been and will continue to be adversely affected by the actual or perceived failure or worsening credit of its counterparties, including other financial institutions and corporate borrowers. The RBS Group has exposure to many different industries and counterparties and routinely executes transactions with counterparties in the financial industry, including brokers and dealers, commercial banks, investment banks, mutual and hedge funds and other institutional clients. As a result, defaults by, or even the perceived creditworthiness of or concerns about, one or more corporate borrowers, financial services institutions, or the financial services industry generally, have led to market-wide liquidity problems and could lead to losses or defaults by the RBS Group or by other institutions. Many of these transactions expose the RBS Group to credit risk in the event of default of the RBS Groups counterparty or client. In addition, the RBS Groups credit risk is exacerbated when the collateral it holds cannot be realised or is liquidated at prices not sufficient to recover the full amount of the loan or derivative exposure that is due to the RBS Group, which is most likely to occur during periods of illiquidity and depressed asset valuations, such as those currently experienced. Any such losses could have a material adverse effect on the RBS Groups results of operations and financial condition or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.
 
The RBS Groups earnings and financial condition have been, and its future earnings and financial condition are likely to continue to be, affected by depressed asset valuations resulting from poor market conditions.
 
Financial markets are currently subject to significant stress conditions, where steep falls in perceived or actual asset values have been accompanied by a severe reduction in market liquidity, as exemplified by recent events affecting asset backed collateralised debt obligations (CDOs), the US subprime residential mortgage market and the leveraged loan market. In dislocated markets, hedging and other risk management strategies have proven not to be as effective as they are in normal market conditions due in part to the decreasing credit quality of hedge counterparties, including monoline and other insurance companies and credit derivative product companies. Severe market events have resulted in the RBS Group recording large write-downs on its credit market exposures in 2007 and 2008. The RBS Group expects that the deterioration in economic and financial market conditions will lead to further impairment charges and write-downs during the current financial year. Moreover, recent market volatility and illiquidity has made it difficult to value certain of the RBS Groups exposures. Valuations in future periods, reflecting, among other things, then-prevailing market conditions and changes in the credit ratings of certain of the RBS Groups assets, may result in significant changes in the fair values of the RBS Groups exposures, even in respect of exposures, such as credit market exposures, for which the RBS Group has previously recorded write-downs. In addition, the value ultimately realised by the RBS Group may be materially different from the current or estimated fair value. Any of these factors could require the Group to recognise further significant write-downs or realise increased impairment charges, any of which may adversely affect its capital position, its financial condition and its results of operations or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The value or effectiveness of any credit protection that the RBS Group has purchased from monoline and other insurers and other market counterparties (including credit derivative product companies) depends on the value of the underlying assets and the financial condition of the insurers and such counterparties.
 
The RBS Group has credit exposure arising from over-the-counter derivative contracts, mainly credit default swaps (CDSs), which are carried at fair value. The fair value of these CDSs, as well as the RBS Groups exposure to the risk of default by the underlying counterparties, depends on the valuation and the perceived credit risk of the instrument against which protection has been bought. Since 2007, monoline and other insurers and other market counterparties (including credit derivative product companies) have been adversely affected by their exposure to residential mortgage linked and corporate credit products. As a result, their actual and perceived credit worthiness deteriorated significantly in 2008 and may continue to be so impacted in 2009. If the financial condition of these counterparties or their actual and perceived credit worthiness deteriorates further, the RBS Group may record further credit valuation adjustments on the CDSs bought from these counterparties in addition to those already recorded.
 
10

 
Changes in interest rates, foreign exchange rates, bond, equity and commodity prices, and other market factors have significantly affected and will continue to affect the RBS Groups business.
 
Some of the most significant market risks the RBS Group faces are interest rate, foreign exchange, bond, equity and commodity price risks. Changes in interest rate levels, yield curves and spreads may affect the interest rate margin realised between lending and borrowing costs, the effect of which may be heightened during periods of liquidity stress, such as those experienced in recent months. Changes in currency rates, particularly in the sterling-US dollar and sterling-euro exchange rates, affect the value of assets, liabilities, income and expenses denominated in foreign currencies and the reported earnings of the RBS Groups non-UK subsidiaries (principally ABN AMRO, Citizens and RBS Greenwich Capital) and may affect income from foreign exchange dealing. The performance of financial markets may affect bond, equity and commodity prices and, therefore, cause changes in the value of the RBS Groups investment and trading portfolios. This has been the case during the period since August 2007, with market disruptions and volatility resulting in significant reductions in the value of such portfolios. While the RBS Group has implemented risk management methods to mitigate and control these and other market risks to which it is exposed, it is difficult, particularly in the current environment, to predict with accuracy changes in economic or market conditions and to anticipate the effects that such changes could have on the RBS Groups financial performance and business operations or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The RBS Groups borrowing costs and its access to the debt capital markets depend significantly on its credit ratings.
 
On 19 January 2009, S&P affirmed the long-term and short-term counterparty credit ratings for the Royal Bank at A+ and A-1 respectively. The outlook for all entities of the RBS Group was confirmed as stable, reflecting S&Ps view that the RBS Group is of systemic importance to the UK banking system and that S&P now explicitly factor four notches of uplift into their long-term counterparty credit rating on the RBS Group. At the same time S&P lowered its ratings on the RBS Groups hybrid capital issues to BB from BBB, additionally the BB rating was placed under CreditWatch with negative implications. On the same date, Fitch affirmed the RBS Group and the Royal Banks Long-term and Short-term Issuer Default Ratings at AA- and F1+ respectively and downgraded the RBS Group and the Royal Banks individual ratings to E from B/C. The outlook for the Issuer Default Ratings remains stable reflecting Fitchs expectation of continued strong government support for the RBS Group. The RBS Groups support rating was upgraded from 1 to 5 and its support floor revised to AA- from No Floor. Fitch also downgraded the RBS Group and the Royal Banks Tier 1 preference shares to BB- from A+, and upper tier 2 hybrid capital instruments issued by RBS Group companies to BB from A+ and placed all of these securities on Rating Watch Negative. Moodys on 20 January 2009 downgraded the senior unsecured rating of the Royal Bank to Aa3 from Aa1 with a negative outlook. The RBS Groups senior debt rating was downgraded to A1 from Aa2 again with a negative outlook. The Bank Financial Strength Rating was lowered to C- from B and remains under review for further possible downgrade. The short term P-1 ratings of both the RBS Group and the Royal Bank were affirmed. The outlook for all RBS Group entities incorporates Moodys view on the long-term credit profile of the RBS Group beyond the current government support phase as well as their view of the very high probability of on-going support from the Aaa-rated UK Government. Any future reductions in the long-term credit ratings of the RBS Group or one of its principal subsidiaries (particularly the Royal Bank) could further increase its borrowing costs. Any further reductions may also limit the RBS Groups access to the capital markets and trigger additional collateral requirements in derivative contracts and other secured funding arrangements. Credit ratings of the RBS Group and the Royal Bank are also important to the RBS Group when competing in certain markets, such as over-the-counter derivatives. As a result, any further reductions in the RBS Groups or the Royal Banks credit ratings could adversely affect its access to liquidity and competitive position, increase its funding costs and have a negative impact on the RBS Groups earnings and financial condition or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.
 
The RBS Groups business performance could be adversely affected if its capital is not managed effectively.
 
Effective management of the RBS Groups capital is critical to its ability to operate its businesses, to grow organically and to pursue its strategy. The RBS Group is required by regulators in the United Kingdom, the United States, the Netherlands and in other jurisdictions in which it undertakes regulated activities, to maintain adequate capital. The maintenance of adequate capital is also necessary to enhance the RBS Groups financial flexibility in the face of continuing turbulence and uncertainty in the global economy. Accordingly, the purpose of the First Placing and Open Offer and the issue of the Preference Shares was to allow RBS to strengthen its capital position. As at 31 December 2008 the RBS Groups Tier 1 and Core Tier 1 capital ratios were 10.0 per cent. and 6.8 per cent. respectively, using the Basel II methodology. Although the net proceeds of the First Placing and Open Offer and the Preference Share Issue strengthened the RBS Groups capital base significantly, and the net proceeds of the Second Placing and Open Offer were used to redeem the existing £5 billion of Preference Shares and which thereby improved the quality of the RBS Groups capital by increasing the RBS Groups Core Tier 1 capital ratio, any change that limits the RBS Groups ability effectively to manage its balance sheet and capital resources going forward (including, for example, reductions in profits and retained earnings as a result of write-downs or otherwise, increases in risk-weighted assets, delays in the disposal of certain assets or the inability to syndicate loans as a result of market conditions or otherwise) or to access funding sources, could have a material adverse impact on its financial condition and regulatory capital position or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The value of certain financial instruments recorded at fair value is determined using financial models incorporating assumptions, judgements and estimates that may change over time or may ultimately not turn out to be accurate.
 
Under IFRS, the RBS Group recognises at fair value: (i) financial instruments classified as held-for-trading or designated as at fair value through profit or loss; (ii) financial assets classified as available-for-sale; and (iii) derivatives, each as further described in Accounting Policies on page 64 of the financial statements. Generally, to establish the fair value of these instruments, the RBS Group relies on quoted market prices or, where the market for a financial instrument is not sufficiently active, internal valuation models that utilise observable market data. In certain circumstances, the data for individual financial instruments or classes of financial instruments utilised by such valuation models may not be available or may become unavailable due to changes in market conditions, as has been the case during the current financial crisis. In such circumstances, the RBS Groups internal valuation models require the RBS Group to make assumptions, judgements and estimates to establish fair value. In common with other financial institutions, these internal valuation models are complex, and the assumptions, judgements and estimates the RBS Group is required to make often relate to matters that are inherently uncertain, such as expected cash flows, the ability of borrowers to service debt, residential and commercial property price appreciation and depreciation, and relative levels of defaults and deficiencies. Such assumptions, judgements and estimates may need to be updated to reflect changing facts, trends and market conditions. The resulting change in the fair values of the financial instruments has had and could continue to have a material adverse effect on the RBS Groups earnings and financial condition. Also, recent market volatility and illiquidity has challenged the factual bases of certain underlying assumptions and has made it difficult to value certain of the RBS Groups financial instruments. Valuations in future periods, reflecting prevailing market conditions, may result in further significant changes in the fair values of these instruments, which could have a negative effect on the RBS Groups results of operations and financial condition or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The RBS Groups future earnings and financial condition in part depend on the success of the RBS Groups strategic refocus on core strengths and its disposal programme.
 
In light of the recently changed global economic outlook, the RBS Group has embarked on a restructuring which focused on achieving appropriate risk adjusted returns under these changed circumstances, reducing reliance on wholesale funding and lowering exposure to capital intensive businesses. The RBS Group will also continue with its disposal programme and continue to review its portfolio to identify further disposals of certain non-core assets. Although the proceeds of the Second Placing and Open Offer improved the quality of the RBS Group's capital by replacing the existing £5 billion of Preference Shares with £5 billion of Core Tier 1 capital, the global credit markets remain challenging and the RBS Groups execution of its current and future strategic plans may not be successful. In connection with the implementation of these plans, the RBS Group may incur restructuring charges, which may be material. Furthermore, if the RBS Groups plans, including any planned disposals, are not successful or fail to achieve the results expected, the RBS Groups business, capital position financial condition, results of operations and future prospects may be negatively impacted or this could result in a loss of value in RBS shares.
 
11

 
The RBS Group operates in markets that are highly competitive and consolidating. If the RBS Group is unable to perform effectively, its business and results of operations will be adversely affected.
 
Recent consolidation among banking institutions in the United Kingdom, the United States and throughout Europe is changing the competitive landscape for banks and other financial institutions. This consolidation, in combination with the introduction of new entrants into the US and UK markets from other European and Asian countries, could increase competitive pressures on the RBS Group. Moreover, if financial markets continue to be volatile, more banks may be forced to consolidate.

In addition to the effects of consolidation, increased government ownership of, and involvement in, banks generally may have an impact on the competitive landscape in the major markets in which the RBS Group operates. Although, at present, it is difficult to predict what the effects of this increased government ownership and involvement will be or how it will differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, such involvement may cause the RBS Group to experience stronger competition for corporate, institutional and retail clients and greater pressure on profit margins. Since the markets in which the RBS Group operates are expected to remain highly competitive in all areas, these and other changes to the competitive landscape could adversely affect the RBS Groups business, margins, profitability and financial condition or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.
 
The RBS Group has agreed to certain undertakings in relation to the operation of its business in the First Placing and Open Offer Agreement, the Second Placing and Open Offer Agreement and in connection with the proposed APS, which may serve to limit the RBS Groups operations.
 
Under the terms of the First Placing and Open Offer Agreement, the RBS Group provided certain undertakings aimed at ensuring that the subscription by HM Treasury for the relevant Ordinary Shares and the Preference Shares and the RBS Groups potential participation in the guarantee scheme promoted by HM Treasury as part of its support for the UK banking industry are compatible with the common market under EU law. These undertakings include (i) supporting certain initiatives in relation to mortgage lending and lending to SMEs until 2011, (ii) regulating management remuneration and (iii) regulating the rate of growth of the RBS Groups balance sheet. Under the terms of the Second Placing and Open Offer Agreement, the RBS Groups undertakings in relation to mortgage lending and lending to SMEs were extended to larger commercial and industrial companies in the United Kingdom. These undertakings may serve to limit the RBS Groups operations. In addition, pursuant to the Lending Commitments Letter, the RBS Group is subject to further undertakings, which supersede the lending commitments made to HM Treasury in October 2008 and January 2009 by agreeing to lend £16 billion above the amount the RBS Group had budgeted to lend to UK businesses and £9 billion above the amount the RBS Group had budgeted to lend to UK homeowners in the year commencing 1 March 2009, with a commitment to lend at similar levels in the year commencing 1 March 2010.

The RBS Group could fail to attract or retain senior management or other key employees.
 
The RBS Groups ability to implement its strategy depends on the ability and experience of its senior management and other key employees. The loss of the services of certain key employees, particularly to competitors, could have a negative impact on the RBS Groups business. The RBS Groups future success will also depend on its ability to attract, retain and remunerate highly skilled and qualified personnel competitively with its peers. This cannot be guaranteed, particularly in light of heightened regulatory oversight of banks and heightened scrutiny of, and (in some cases) restrictions placed upon, management compensation arrangements, in particular those in receipt of Government funding (such as the RBS Group). The RBS Group recently announced changes to its compensation structure which included significant reductions in bonuses to be paid in respect of 2008, and limitations on pay rises in 2009. In addition to the effects of such measures on the RBS Groups ability to retain senior management and other key employees, the marketplace for skilled personnel is becoming more competitive, which means the cost of hiring, training and retaining skilled personnel may continue to increase. The failure to attract or retain a sufficient number of appropriately skilled personnel could prevent the RBS Group from successfully implementing its strategy, which could have a material adverse effect on the RBS Groups financial condition and results of, operations or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

Each of the RBS Groups businesses is subject to substantial regulation and oversight. Any significant regulatory developments could have an effect on how the RBS Group conducts its business and on its results of operations and financial condition.
 
The RBS Group is subject to financial services laws, regulations, administrative actions and policies in each location in which it operates. All of these are subject to change, particularly in the current market environment, where there have been unprecedented levels of government intervention and changes to the regulations governing financial institutions, including recent nationalisations in the United Kingdom, the United States and other European countries. As a result of these and other ongoing and possible future changes in the financial services regulatory landscape (including requirements imposed by virtue of the RBS Groups participation in any government or regulator-led initiatives), the RBS Group expects to face greater regulation in the United Kingdom, the United States, the Netherlands and other countries in which it operates, including throughout the rest of Europe.

Compliance with such regulations may increase the RBS Groups capital requirements and costs and have an adverse impact on its business, the products and services it offers and the value of its assets or result in a loss of value in RBS shares. Other areas where governmental policies and regulatory changes could have an adverse impact include, but are not limited to:

·  
the monetary, interest rate, capital adequacy and other policies of central banks and regulatory authorities;
·  
general changes in government or regulatory policy or changes in regulatory regimes that may significantly influence investor decisions in particular markets in which the RBS Group operates or may increase the costs of doing business in those markets;
·  
changes to financial reporting standards;
·  
other general changes in the regulatory requirements, such as prudential rules relating to the capital adequacy framework and the imposition of onerous compliance obligations, restrictions on business growth or pricing and requirements to operate in a way that prioritises objectives other than shareholder value creation;
·  
changes in competition and pricing environments;
·  
further developments in the financial reporting environment;
·  
differentiation amongst financial institutions by governments with respect to the extension of guarantees to bank customer deposits and the terms attaching to such guarantees, including requirements for the entire RBS Group to accept exposure to the risk of any individual member of the RBS Group, or even third party participants in guarantee schemes, failing;
·  
implementation of, or costs related to, local customer or depositor compensation or reimbursement schemes;
·  
transferability and convertibility of currency risk;
·  
expropriation, nationalisation and confiscation of assets;
·  
changes in legislation relating to foreign ownership; and
·  
other unfavourable political, military or diplomatic developments producing social instability or legal uncertainty which, in turn, may affect demand for the RBS Groups products and services.

The RBS Groups results have been and could be further adversely affected in the event of goodwill impairment.
 
The RBS Group capitalises goodwill, which is calculated as the excess of the cost of an acquisition over the net fair value of the identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent liabilities acquired. Acquired goodwill is recognised initially at cost and subsequently at cost less any accumulated impairment losses. As required by IFRS, the RBS Group tests goodwill for impairment annually or more frequently, at external reporting dates, when events or circumstances indicate that it might be impaired. An impairment test involves comparing the recoverable amount (the higher of value in use and fair value less cost to sell) of an individual cash generating unit with its carrying value. The value in use and fair value of the RBS Groups cash generating units are affected by market conditions and the performance of the economies in which the RBS Group operates. Where the RBS Group is required to recognise a goodwill impairment, it is recorded in the RBS Groups income statement, although it has no effect on the RBS Groups regulatory capital position. For the year ended 31 December 2008, the Group recorded a £8.1 billion accounting write-down of goodwill and other intangibles relating to prior year acquisitions.
 
12

 
The RBS Group may be required to make further contributions to its pension schemes if the value of pension fund assets is not sufficient to cover potential obligations.
 
The RBS Group maintains a number of defined benefit pension schemes for past and current employees. Pensions risk is the risk that the liabilities of the RBS Groups various defined benefit pension schemes which are long term in nature will exceed the schemes assets, as a result of which the RBS Group is required or chooses to make additional contributions to the schemes. The schemes assets comprise investment portfolios that are held to meet projected liabilities to the scheme members. Risk arises from the schemes because the value of these asset portfolios and returns from them may be less than expected and because there may be greater than expected increases in the estimated value of the schemes liabilities. In these circumstances, the RBS Group could be obliged, or may choose, to make additional contributions to the schemes, and during recent periods, the RBS Group has voluntarily made such contributions. Given the current economic and financial market difficulties and the prospects for them to continue over the near and medium term, the RBS Group may be required or elect to make further contributions to the pension schemes and such contributions could be significant and have a negative impact on the RBS Groups capital position results of operations or financial condition or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The RBS Group is and may be subject to litigation and regulatory investigations that may impact its business.
 
The Groups operations are diverse and complex and it operates in legal and regulatory environments that expose it to potentially significant litigation, regulatory investigation and other regulatory risk. As a result, the Group is, and may in the future be, involved in various disputes, legal proceedings and regulatory investigations in the United Kingdom, the United States and other jurisdictions, including class-action litigation. Furthermore, the RBS Group, like many other financial institutions, has come under greater regulatory scrutiny over the last year and expects that environment to continue for the foreseeable future, particularly as it relates to compliance with new and existing corporate governance, employee compensation, conduct of business, anti-money laundering and anti-terrorism laws and regulations, as well as the provisions of applicable sanctions programmes. Disputes, legal proceedings and regulatory investigations are subject to many uncertainties, and their outcomes are often difficult to predict, particularly in the earlier stages of a case or investigation. Adverse regulatory action or adverse judgements in litigation could result in restrictions or limitations on the Groups operations or result in a material adverse effect on the RBS Groups reputation or results of operations or result in a loss of value in RBS shares. For details about certain litigation and regulatory investigations in which the Group is involved, see Note 29 on the financial statements.

Operational risks are inherent in the RBS Groups operations.
 
The RBS Groups operations are dependent on the ability to process a very large number of transactions efficiently and accurately while complying with applicable laws and regulations where it does business. The RBS Group has complex and geographically diverse operations and operational risk and losses can result from internal or external fraud, errors by employees or third-parties, failure to document transactions properly or to obtain proper authorisation, failure to comply with applicable regulatory requirements and conduct of business rules (including those arising out of anti-money laundering and anti-terrorism legislation, as well as the provisions of applicable sanctions programmes), equipment failures, natural disasters or the inadequacy or failure of systems and controls, including those of the RBS Groups suppliers or counterparties. Although the RBS Group has implemented risk controls and loss mitigation actions, and substantial resources are devoted to developing efficient procedures, to identifying and rectifying weaknesses in existing procedures and to training staff, it is not possible to be certain that such actions have been or will be effective in controlling each of the operational risks faced by the RBS Group. Any weakness in these systems or controls, or any breaches or alleged breaches of applicable laws or regulations could have a materially negative impact on the RBS Groups business, reputation, results of operations and share price. Notwithstanding anything contained in this risk factor, it should not be taken as implying that either RBS or the RBS Group will be unable to comply with its obligations as a company with securities admitted to the Official List or as a supervised firm regulated by the FSA.

The RBS Group is exposed to the risk of changes in tax legislation and its interpretation and to increases in the rate of corporate and other taxes in the jurisdictions in which it operates.
 
The RBS Groups activities are subject to tax at various rates around the world computed in accordance with local legislation and practice. Action by governments to increase tax rates or to impose additional taxes would reduce RBSs profitability. Revisions to tax legislation or to its interpretation might also affect the RBS Groups results in the future.

The acquisition of a majority shareholding in the RBS Group by HM Treasury in December 2008 could lead to certain adverse tax consequences for the RBS Group.
 
The acquisition by HM Treasury of a majority shareholding in the RBS Group in consequence of the First Placing and Open Offer could, in certain circumstances, have adverse tax consequences which could affect the post-tax profitability of the RBS Group. However, if the RBS Group enters into the APS it has agreed, in principle, to give up the right to certain UK tax losses and allowances and this may limit the adverse tax consequences of the acquisition by HM Treasury of a majority shareholding in the RBS Group.
 
13

 
The RBS Groups operations have inherent reputational risk.
 
Reputational risk, meaning the risk to earnings and capital from negative public opinion, is inherent in the RBS Groups business. Negative public opinion can result from the actual or perceived manner in which the RBS Group conducts its business activities or from actual or perceived practices in the banking and financial industry. Negative public opinion may adversely affect the RBS Groups ability to keep and attract customers and, in particular, corporate and retail depositors. The RBS Group cannot ensure that it will be successful in avoiding damage to its business from reputational risk.

In the United Kingdom and in other jurisdictions, the RBS Group is responsible for contributing to compensation schemes in respect of banks and other authorised financial services firms that are unable to meet their obligations to customers.
 
In the United Kingdom, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (the “Scheme”) was established under the FSMA and is the UKs statutory fund of last resort for customers of authorised financial services firms. The Scheme can pay compensation to customers if a firm is unable, or likely to be unable, to pay claims against it and, if the Banking Bill is enacted in its current form, may be required to make payments either in connection with the exercise of a stabilisation power or in exercise of the bank insolvency procedures under that Bill. The Scheme is funded by levies on firms authorised by the FSA, including the RBS Group. In the event that the Scheme raises funds from the authorised firms, raises those funds more frequently or significantly increases the levies to be paid by such firms, the associated costs to the RBS Group may have a material impact on its results of operations and financial condition. During the financial year ended 31 December 2008, the RBS Group made a provision of £150 million related to a levy by the Scheme.

In addition, to the extent that other jurisdictions where the RBS Group operates have introduced or plan to introduce similar compensation, contributory or reimbursement schemes (such as in the United States with the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation), the RBS Group may make further provisions and may incur additional costs and liabilities, which may negatively impact its financial condition and results of operations or result in a loss of value in RBS shares.

The RBS Groups business and earnings may be affected by geopolitical conditions.
 
The performance of the RBS Group is significantly influenced by the geopolitical and economic conditions prevailing at any given time in the countries in which it operates, particularly the United Kingdom, the United States and other countries in Europe and Asia. For example, the RBS Group has a presence in countries where businesses could be exposed to the risk of business interruption and economic slowdown following the outbreak of a pandemic, or the risk of sovereign default following the assumption by governments of the obligations of private sector institutions. Similarly the RBS Group faces the heightened risk of trade barriers, exchange controls and other measures taken by sovereign governments which may impact a borrowers ability to repay. Terrorist acts and threats and the response to them of governments in any of these countries could also adversely affect levels of economic activity and have an adverse effect upon the RBS Group's business.

The restructuring proposals for ABN AMRO are complex and may not realise the anticipated benefits for the RBS Group.
 
The restructuring plan in place for the integration and separation of ABN AMRO into and among the businesses and operations of the consortium members is complex, involving substantial reorganisation of ABN AMROs operations and legal structure. In addition, the plan contemplates activities taking place simultaneously in a number of businesses and jurisdictions. Although integration efforts are well underway and are being advanced on a number of fronts, the implementation of the reorganisation and the realisation of the forecast benefits within the planned timescales, particularly given current market and economic conditions, remains challenging, although the RBS Group remains confident that such goals will be achieved. Execution of the restructuring requires management resources previously devoted to the RBS Group businesses and the retention of appropriately skilled ABN AMRO staff. The RBS Group may not realise the benefits of the acquisition or the restructuring when expected or to the extent projected. The occurrence of any of these events, including as a result of staff losses or performance issues, may have a negative impact on the RBS Groups financial condition and results of operations. It is not expected that the Dutch States acquisition of Fortis Bank Nederlands shares in RFS Holdings, which was effected in December 2008, will materially affect the integration benefits envisaged by the RBS Group.

The recoverability of certain deferred tax assets recognised by the RBS Group depend on the RBS Group's ability to generate sufficient future taxable profits and there being no adverse changes to tax legislation.
 
In accordance with IFRS, the RBS Group has recognised deferred tax assets on losses available to relieve future profits from tax only to the extent that it is probable that they will be recovered. The losses are quantified on the basis of current tax legislation and are subject to change in respect of the rate of tax or the rules for computing taxable profits and allowable losses. Failure to generate sufficient future taxable profits or changes in tax legislation may reduce the recoverable amount of the recognised deferred tax assets.

RBSs ability to pay dividends on or make other distributions in respect of the Ordinary Shares will depend on the availability of distributable reserves and may be limited by the terms of the B Shares.
 
RBSs ability to pay dividends is limited under UK company law, which limits a company to only paying cash dividends to the extent that it has distributable reserves and cash available for this purpose. As a holding company, RBSs ability to pay dividends in the future is affected by a number of factors, principally its ability to receive sufficient dividends from subsidiaries. The payment of dividends to RBS by its subsidiaries is, in turn, subject to restrictions, including certain regulatory requirements and the existence of sufficient distributable reserves and cash in RBSs subsidiaries. The ability of these subsidiaries to pay dividends and RBSs ability to receive distributions from its investments in other entities are subject to applicable local laws and regulatory requirements and other restrictions, including, but not limited to, applicable tax laws and covenants in some of RBSs debt facilities. These laws and restrictions could limit the payment of future dividends and distributions to RBS by its subsidiaries, which could restrict RBSs ability to fund other operations or to pay, in due course, a dividend to holders of the Existing Shares or the New Shares.

In addition, if the B Shares are issued, no cash dividend may be paid on the Ordinary Shares unless the cash dividend payable in respect of the same period on the B Shares is paid in full, and no scrip dividend may be paid on the Ordinary Shares unless the cash or scrip dividend payable in respect of the same period on the B Shares is paid in full.
 
 
 
14

 
 
Risk, capital and liquidity management
Risk, capital and liquidity management is conducted on an overall basis within the RBS Group. Therefore the discussion on risk, capital and liquidity management (pages 15 to 55) refers principally to policies and procedures in the RBS Group. Data is also provided for the Bank and its subsidiaries (the Group) and the Bank.

On pages 15 to 55 certain information has been audited and is labelled as such.

Risk governance (unaudited)
Risk and capital management strategy is owned and set by the RBS Groups Board of Directors, and implemented by executive management led by the Group Chief Executive. There are a number of committees and executives that support the execution of the business plan and strategy.
 

The role and remit of these committees is as follows:

Group Audit Committee (GAC): Financial reporting and the application of accounting policies as part of the internal control and risk assessment process. GAC monitors the identification, evaluation and management of all significant risks throughout the RBS Group.

Advances Committee (AC): Deals with transactions that exceed the Group Credit Committees delegated authority and large exposures.

Group Executive Management Committee (GEMC): Ensures implementation of strategy consistent with risk appetite.

Executive Risk Forum (ERF): Acts on all strategic risk and control matters across the RBS Group including, but not limited to, credit risk, market risk, operational risk, compliance and regulatory risk, enterprise risk, treasury and liquidity risk, reputational risk, insurance risk and country risk.

Group Risk Committee (GRC): Recommends limits and approves processes and policies to ensure the effective management of all material risks across the RBS Group.
 
Group Credit Committee (GCC): Approves credit proposals under the authority delegated to the committee by the Board and/or the Advances Committee.

Group Asset and Liability Management Committee (GALCO): Identifies, manages and controls the RBS Group balance sheet risks.
 
Group Chief Executives Advisory Group (GCEAG): Acts as a forum for the provision of information and advice to the Group Chief Executive. Forms part of the control process of the RBS Group.

Risk and capital (unaudited)
It is the RBS Groups policy to optimise return to shareholders while maintaining a strong capital base and credit rating to support business growth and meet regulatory capital requirements at all times.

Risk appetite is measured as the maximum level of retained risk the RBS Group will accept to deliver its business objectives. Risk appetite is generally defined through both quantitative and qualitative techniques including stress testing, risk concentration, value-at-risk and risk underwriting criteria, ensuring that appropriate principles, policies and procedures are in place and applied.

15

 
Risk appetite (unaudited)

Risk and capital management across the RBS Group is based on the risk appetite set by the Board, which is established through setting strategic direction, contributing to, and ultimately approving annual plans for each division and regularly reviewing and monitoring the RBS Groups performance in relation to risk through monthly Board reports.

Risk appetite is defined in both quantitative and qualitative terms as follows:

Quantitative: encompassing stress testing, risk concentration, value- at-risk, liquidity and credit related metrics.

Qualitative: focusing on ensuring that the RBS Group applies the correct principles, policies and procedures.

Different techniques are used to ensure that the RBS Groups risk appetite is achieved.

The GEMC is responsible for ensuring that the implementation of strategy and operations are in line with the risk appetite determined by the Board. This is reinforced through a policy framework ensuring that all staff within the RBS Group make appropriate risk and reward trade- offs within pre-agreed boundaries.

The main risks facing the RBS Group are as follows:

Credit risk: the risk arising from the possibility that the RBS Group will incur losses from the failure of customers to meet financial obligations to the RBS Group.

Funding and liquidity risk: the risk that the RBS Group is unable to meet obligations as they fall due.

Market risk: the risk that the value of an asset or liability may change as a result of a change in market rates.

Operational risk: the risk of financial loss or reputational impact resulting from fraud; human error; ineffective or inadequately designed processes or systems; improper behaviour; legal events; or from external events.

Regulatory risk: the risks arising from regulatory changes/enforcement.

Other risk: the risks arising from reputation and pension fund risk.

Credit risk

Principles for credit risk management (audited)

The key principles for credit risk management in the RBS Group are as follows:

A credit risk assessment of the customer and credit facilities is undertaken prior to approval of credit exposure. Typically, this includes both quantitative and qualitative elements including, the purpose of the credit and sources of repayment; compliance with affordability tests; repayment history; ability to repay; sensitivity to economic and market developments; and risk-adjusted return based on credit risk measures appropriate to the customer and facility type.
 
Credit risk authority is specifically granted in writing to individuals involved in the granting of credit approval, whether this is individually or collectively as part of a credit committee. In exercising credit authority, individuals are required to act independently of business considerations and must declare any conflicts of interest.

Credit exposures, once approved, are monitored, managed and reviewed periodically against approved limits. Lower quality exposures are subject to more frequent analysis and assessment.

Credit risk management works with business functions on the ongoing management of the credit portfolio, including decisions on mitigating actions taken against individual exposures or broader portfolios.

Customers with emerging credit problems are identified early and classified accordingly. Remedial actions are implemented promptly and are intended to restore the customer to a satisfactory status and minimise any potential loss to the RBS Group.

Stress testing of portfolios is undertaken to assess the potential credit impact of non-systemic scenarios and wider macroeconomic events on the RBS Groups income and capital.

Specialist credit risk teams oversee the credit process independently, making credit decisions within their discretion, or recommending decisions to the appropriate credit committee. Assessments of corporate borrower and transaction risk are undertaken using fundamental credit analysis and the application of general corporate and certain specialist counterparty credit risk models.

Financial markets counterparties are approved by a dedicated credit function which specialises in traded market product risk. Specialist credit grading models exist for certain bank and non-bank financial institutions.

Different approaches are used for the management of wholesale and retail businesses:

Wholesale businesses: exposures are aggregated to determine the appropriate level of credit approval required and to facilitate consolidated credit risk management. Credit applications for corporate customers are prepared by relationship managers (RMs) in the units originating the credit exposures, or by the RM team with lead responsibility for a counterparty where a customer has relationships with different divisions and business units across the RBS Group. This includes the assignment of counterparty credit grades and LGD estimates using approved models, which are also independently checked by the credit team.

Retail businesses: the retail business makes a large volume of small value credit decisions. Credit decisions will typically involve an application for a new or additional product or a change in facilities on an existing product. The majority of these decisions are based upon automated strategies utilising industry standard credit and behaviour scoring techniques.

16

 
Credit risk models (audited)
Credit risk models are used throughout the RBS Group to support the analytical elements of the credit risk management framework, in particular the risk assessment part of the credit approval process, ongoing monitoring as well as portfolio analysis and reporting. Credit risk models used by the RBS Group can be broadly grouped into three categories.

Probability of default (PD): models estimate the likelihood that a customer will fail to make full and timely repayment of credit obligations over a one year time horizon. Customers are assigned an internal credit grade which corresponds to probability of default. Every customer credit grade across all grading scales in the RBS Group can be mapped to a RBS Group level credit grade.

Exposure at default (EAD): models estimate the expected level of utilisation of a credit facility at the time of a borrowers default. The EAD may be assumed to be higher than the current utilisation (e.g. in the case where further drawings are made on a revolving credit facility prior to default) but will not typically exceed the total facility limit.

Loss given default (LGD): models estimate the economic loss that may occur in the event of default and represents, the debt that cannot be recovered. The RBS Groups LGD models take into account the type of borrower, facility and any risk mitigation such as security or collateral held.

Model validation (audited)
The performance and accuracy of credit models is critical, both in terms of effective risk management and also the calculation of risk parameters (PD, LGD and EAD) used by the RBS Group to calculate RWAs. The models are subject to frequent validation internally and, if used as part of the AIRB Basel II framework, have been reviewed and approved for use by the FSA.

Independent model validation is performed by the RBS Group. This includes an evaluation of the model development and validation for the data set used, logic and assumptions, and performance of the model analysis. Where required, the RBS Group has engaged external risk management consultants to undertake independent reviews and report their findings to the Wholesale or Retail Credit Model Committee. This provides a benchmark against industry practices.

The validation results are a key factor in deciding whether a model is recommended for ongoing use.

The frequency, depth and extent of the validation are consistent with the materiality and complexity of the risk being managed. The RBS Groups validation processes include:

Developmental evidence: to ensure that the credit risk model adequately discriminates between different levels of risk and delivers accurate risk estimates.

Process verification: whether the methods used in the credit risk models are being used, monitored and updated in the way intended in the design of the model. Initial testing and validation is performed when the model is developed with the performance of models being assessed on an ongoing basis.


 
17

 
Credit risk mitigation (audited)
The RBS Group takes a number of steps to mitigate credit risk. The key risk mitigants are as follows:

Real estate: the most common form of security held is real estate within the consumer and wholesale businesses.

Financial collateral: is taken to support credit exposures in the non- trading book. Financial collateral is also taken in Global Markets and Regional Markets to support trading book exposures and is incorporated in E* (adjustment to the exposure value) calculations.

Other physical collateral: the RBS Group takes a wide range of other physical collateral including business assets (stock and inventory, plant and machinery, equipment), project assets, intangible assets which provide a future cashflow and real value, commodities, vehicles, rail stock, aircraft, ships and receivables (not purchased).

Guarantees: third party guarantees are taken from banks, government entities, export credit agencies, and corporate entities. The RBS Groups recovery value estimation methodology is sensitive to the variations in the credit quality of guarantors. Standby letters of credit are also given value in LGD models. Conditional guarantees are accepted, in accordance with internal requirements, and are included as appropriate in PD and LGD estimates (e.g. small firms loan guarantee schemes, completion guarantees). Personal guarantees are considered in the normal credit process where there is a charge over specific assets. While personal guarantees may be called for and are always accepted, no value is given to unsupported personal guarantees in any credit models.

Credit derivatives: credit derivative activity is conducted through designated units within GBM to ensure consistency and appropriate control. RBS Group policies are designed to ensure that the credit protection is appropriate to support offset for an underlying trading book asset or improvement to the LGD of a banking book asset. Within the banking book, credit derivatives are used as risk and capital management tools. The principal counterparties are banks, investment firms and other market participants, with the majority subject to collateralisation under a credit support annex. In accordance with internal policy, stress testing is conducted on the counterparty credit risk created by the purchase of credit protection.

Minimum standards (for example loan to value, legal certainty) are ensured through the policy framework.

Credit risk assets (audited)
Credit risk assets consist of loans and advances (including overdraft facilities), instalment credit, finance lease receivables and other traded instruments across all customer types. The RBS Group uses a series of models to measure the size of its exposure to credit risk and to calculate expected EAD in both its trading and banking books. In so doing, the RBS Group recognises the effects of credit risk mitigation that reduces potential loss.
 
Credit concentration risk (including country risk) (audited)
The RBS Group defines three key areas of concentration in credit risk that are monitored, reported and managed at RBS Group and divisional levels. These are single name concentration, industry/sector and country risk. The RBS Group has a series of quantitative and qualitative controls in place to limit the amount of concentration risk in credit portfolios. A threshold is set on the aggregate LGD to a single customer group above which approval is required from the RBS Groups most senior credit committee, the Advances Committee.

During the year work progressed on an enhancement of the frameworks for managing single name and sector concentrations. These enhancements are planned to be fully implemented in 2009 to improve the identification and management of concentrations in the portfolio through the introduction of additional parameters and increased scrutiny of concentration limit excesses.

A stress testing framework, Correlated Exposure Loss Testing, assesses the impact on the RBS Groups impairment charge of non-systemic events that affect groups of inter-related sectors in order to limit the impact of these scenarios to within defined tolerances.

Country risk arises from sovereign events (e.g. default or restructuring); economic events (e.g. contagion of sovereign default to other parts of the economy, cyclical economic shock); political events (e.g. convertibility restrictions and expropriation or nationalisation) and natural disaster or conflict. Losses are broadly defined and include credit, market, liquidity, operational and franchise risk related losses. It is the RBS Groups policy to monitor and control country risk exposures and to avoid excessive concentrations.

The RBS Groups appetite is expressed by a matrix of limits by country risk grade and is approved by GEMC. The RBS Groups exposure is managed and measured within this appetite by the Group Country Risk Management Committee (GCRMC), that has delegated authority from the GRC to manage country risk and agree related policy. Membership of GCRMC comprises the Group Chief Credit Officer, Heads of Credit and business representatives from those divisions with material country risk exposures. GCRMC sets limits for each country based on a risk assessment taking into account the RBS Groups franchise and business mix in that country. Additional limitations on product types with higher loss potential and longer tenor transactions, for example may be established depending on the country outlook and business strategy. A country watch list framework is in place to proactively monitor emerging issues and facilitates the development of mitigation strategies.

Global Restructuring Group (GRG) (audited)
GRG was formed in 2008, tasked with managing the RBS Groups problem and potential problem exposures to help rejuvenate and restore customers to profitable business. This may include assisting with the restructuring of their businesses and/or renegotiation.

GRG brings together previously disparate functions across the RBS Group. Its primary function is to work closely with the RBS Groups customer facing businesses to support the proactive management of any problem lending. This is based on a clear process (watch listing) which requires the transfer of problem credits to GRG. GRG reports to the Group Chief Risk Officer.
18


Given the current economic outlook, it is particularly important that potential problems are identified early and referred to GRG as the RBS Groups past experience has shown that the sooner specialists in restructuring are engaged, the greater the likelihood of a successful outcome. Early identification of potential problems therefore has a benefit to the borrower as well as to the RBS Group.

GRG is structured with specialist teams focused on: large corporate cases (higher value, multiple lenders); small/mid size business cases (lower value, bilateral relationships); and recovery/litigations. Given the negative trends in the portfolio in 2008, the size of GRG has grown substantially and further investment in staffing is expected in 2009.

Originating business units liaise with GRG upon the emergence of a potentially negative event or trend that may impact a borrowers ability to service its debt. This may be a significant deterioration in some aspect of the borrowers activity, such as trading, where a breach of covenant is likely or where a borrower has missed or is expected to miss a material contractual payment to the RBS Group or another creditor.

On transfer of a relationship to GRG a strategy is devised to:

Work with the borrower to facilitate changes that will maximise the potential for turnaround of their situation and return them to profitability.

Define the RBS Groups role in the turnaround situation and assess the risk/return dimension of the RBS Groups participation.

Return customers to the originating business unit in a sound and stable condition or, if such recovery can not be achieved, avoid additional losses and maximise recoveries.

Ensure key lessons learned are fed back into origination policies and procedures.

Retail collections and recoveries (audited)
There are collections and recoveries functions in each of the four regional markets. Their role is to provide support and assistance to customers who are currently experiencing difficulties meeting their financial obligations.

Where possible, the aim of collections and recoveries teams is to return the customer to a satisfactory position, by working with them to restructure their finances and/or business. If this is not possible, the team has the objective of reducing the loss to the RBS Group.

There have been material increases in staffing levels in all collections functions to manage the increase in the number of customers in financial difficulty. In the UK and Ireland, there is a common collection and recovery operational model managed by Group Manufacturing. During 2008, there was significant investment in systems development and staff training to make collections activity more efficient and effective.

In the UK there have been several initiatives to ensure fair and appropriate treatment of customers experiencing difficulties. For mortgage customers the RBS Group will not initiate repossession proceedings for at least six months after arrears are evident.

Preventative measures have also been a key focus throughout 2008, and as a result, the RBS Group has announced the introduction of over 1,000 dedicated Money Sense advisers in its branch network who will provide free financial counselling to both customers and non-customers. The RBS Group has also implemented a programme to proactively contact customers who exhibit early signs of financial stress but are not yet in Collections to offer them assistance in managing their finances more effectively.

Credit risk asset quality (audited)
Internal reporting and oversight of risk assets is principally differentiated by credit grades. Customers are assigned credit grades, based on various credit grading models that reflect the key drivers of default for the customer type. All credit grades across the RBS Group map to both a RBS Group level asset quality scale, used for external financial reporting, and a master grading scale for wholesale exposures used for internal management reporting across disparate portfolios. Accordingly, measurement of risk is easily aggregated and can be reported at increasing levels of granularity depending on audience and business need.

The RBS Group has adopted, as part of the move to Basel II, a new master grading scale for wholesale exposures which comprises 27 grades. These in turn map to ten asset quality (AQ) bands used for both wholesale and retail exposures. This replaced the less granular AQ1-5 bands used prior to 2008.

The relationship between these measures is shown below (unaudited).

                          PD Range
New AQ1-
Old AQ1-5
Master grading scale
Lower
Upper
10 bands
bands
1
0%
0.006%
   
2
0.006%
0.012%
   
3
0.012%
0.017%
AQ1
 
4
0.017%
0.024%
   
5
0.024%
0.034%
 
AQ1
6
0.034%
0.048%
AQ2
 
7
0.048%
0.067%
AQ3
 
8
0.067%
0.095%
   
9
0.095%
0.135%
   
10
0.135%
0.190%
AQ4
 
11
0.190%
0.269%
 
   
12
0.269%
0.381%
 
AQ2
13
0.381%
0.538%
   
14
0.538%
0.761%
AQ5
 
15
0.761%
1.076%
 
AQ3
16
1.076%
1.522%
AQ6
 
17
1.522%
2.153%
 
AQ4
18
2.153%
3.044%
 
   
19
3.044%
4.305%
AQ7
 
20
4.305%
6.089%
   
21
6.089%
8.611%
   
22
8.611%
12.177%
AQ8
 
23
12.177%
17.222%
 
AQ5
24
17.222%
24.355%
   
25
24.355%
34.443%
AQ9
 
26
34.443%
100%
   
27
100%
100%
AQ10
 


19

 
Asset grades (unaudited)
Expressed as an annual probability of default, the upper and lower boundaries and the midpoint for each of these RBS Group level asset quality grades are as follows:

                 
Annual probability of  default
 
Asset quality grade
             
Minimum
Midpoint
Maximum
 
             
%
%
%
 
AQ1
             
0.00
0.10
0.20
 
AQ2
             
0.21
0.40
0.60
 
AQ3
             
0.61
1.05
1.50
 
AQ4
             
1.51
3.25
5.00
 
AQ5
             
5.01
52.50
100.00
 
 
The following table provides an analysis of  the credit quality of  financial assets by the RBS Groups internal credit ratings (audited).
 
                           
Group
                       
                                 
Balances
                         
                                 
with Group
   
Accruing
   
Non-
   
Impairment
       
   
AQ1
   
AQ2
   
AQ3
   
AQ4
   
AQ5
   
companies
   
past due
   
accrual
   
provision
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Cash and balances
                                                                               
at central banks
    6,806                                                       6,806  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to banks (1)
    68,885       91       77       28       230       7,297             83       (83 )     76,608  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to customers
    231,688       108,005       144,408       74,314       36,736       4,484       12,797       13,643       (6,572 )     619,503  
Debt securities
    171,685       847       263       3,736       1,220                   33       (18 )     177,766  
Settlement balances
    5,651       516       290       129       256             4,029                   10,871  
Derivatives
    812,895       33,632       24,984       4,077       5,434       56,424       11                   937,457  
Other financial instruments
    32                                                       32  
      1,297,642       143,091       170,022       82,284       43,876       68,205       16,837       13,759       (6,673 )     1,829,043  
Commitments
    173,350       44,710       43,765       20,983       18,278       51                         301,137  
Contingent liabilities
    20,946       5,976       2,989       2,519       487                               32,917  
Total off-balance sheet
    194,296       50,686       46,754       23,502       18,765       51                         334,054  
                                                                                 
                                                                                 
2007
                                                                               
Cash and balances at
                                                                               
central banks
    5,559                                                       5,559  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to banks (1)
    89,357       1,772       426       94       2       1,966             2       (2 )     93,617  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to customers
    191,451       109,460       163,792       46,293       19,850       9,088       9,083       6,665       (4,233 )     551,449  
Debt securities
    153,391       8,026       1,383       466       1,165                   1             164,432  
Settlement balances
    3,228       98       344       21       68             1,567                   5,326  
Derivatives
    175,770       21,166       4,801       894       394       2,950                         205,975  
Other financial instruments
    19                                                       19  
      618,775       140,522       170,746       47,768       21,479       14,004       10,650       6,668       (4,235 )     1,026,377  
Commitments
    95,664       73,221       60,895       19,797       12,177                               261,754  
Contingent liabilities
    7,658       7,915       4,989       1,214       1,100                               22,876  
Total off-balance sheet
    103,322       81,136       65,884       21,011       13,277                               284,630  
 
Note:
(1)   Excluding items in the course of  collection of  £2,779 million (2007  £2,729 million).
 
20

 
                           
Bank
                         
                                 
Balances
                         
                                 
with Group
   
Accruing
   
Non-
   
Impairment
       
   
AQ1
   
AQ2
   
AQ3
   
AQ4
   
AQ5
   
companies
   
past due
   
accrual
   
provision
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Cash and balances at
                                                                               
central banks
    3,714                                                       3,714  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to banks(1)
    54,403       66       50       8       225       36,481             81       (81 )     91,233  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to customers
    127,883       50,267       60,255       28,830       9,727       44,368       2,482       5,622       (2,394 )     327,040  
Debt securities
    153,490       804       206       3,396       1,079       708             17       (2 )     159,698  
Settlement balances
    4,051       120       129             25             1,010                   5,335  
Derivatives
    807,283       31,173       23,224       3,367       4,587       68,860       11                   938,505  
      1,150,824       82,430       83,864       35,601       15,643       150,417       3,503       5,720       (2,477 )     1,525,525  
Commitments
    131,942       23,847       17,102       6,659       7,511       346                         187,407  
Contingent liabilities
    16,804       3,093       1,155       1,081       182                               22,315  
Total off-balance sheet
    148,746       26,940       18,257       7,740       7,693       346                         209,722  
                                                                                 
                                                                                 
2007
                                                                               
Cash and balances
                                                                               
at central banks
    3,333                                                       3,333  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to banks(1)
    66,418       574       275       70             24,115                         91,452  
Loans and advances
                                                                               
to customers
    97,715       59,825       75,432       12,645       5,874       74,340       2,501       2,088       (1,273 )     329,147  
Debt securities
    98,303       5,699       1,254       338       1,044       612                         107,250  
Settlement balances
    1,273       89       130             39             515                   2,046  
Derivatives
    174,288       20,879       4,575       795       367       7,009                         207,913  
      441,330       87,066       81,666       13,848       7,324       106,076       3,016       2,088       (1,273 )     741,141  
Commitments
    61,866       39,825       31,604       6,478       5,784       258                         145,815  
Contingent liabilities
    5,876       5,187       2,962       278       703                               15,006  
Total off-balance sheet
    67,742       45,012       34,566       6,756       6,487       258                         160,821  
 
Note:
(1)  Excluding items in the course of  collection of  £484 million (2007  £530 million).
 
21

 
Industry risk geographical analysis (audited)
         
Group
       
   
Loans and
advances to banks
and customers
   
Debt
securities and
equity shares
   
Derivatives
   
Other(1)
   
Total
   
Netting
offset(2)
 
2008
 
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
 
UK
                                   
Central and local government
    6,033       34,942       3,998       1       44,974       1,636  
Manufacturing
    23,640       263       5,929       56       29,888       3,812  
Construction
    13,346       33       744             14,123       1,485  
Finance
    140,951       64,174       494,667       3,454       703,246       426,522  
Service industry and business activities
    82,006       4,980       13,229       586       100,801       7,710  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    3,118             34       1       3,153       87  
Property
    73,632       1,662       5,073       2       80,369       1,026  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    80,941             14             80,955       52  
Other
    26,182       248       36             26,466       5  
Finance leases and instalment credit
    17,363       3       25             17,391        
Interest accruals
    2,690       774                   3,464        
Total UK
    469,902       107,079       523,749       4,100       1,104,830       442,335  
US
                                               
Central and local government
    352       24,784       45       33       25,214        
Manufacturing
    10,569       102       1,809       128       12,608       217  
Construction
    885       63       122       6       1,076        
Finance
    25,517       36,408       364,544       5,445       431,914       323,910  
Service industry and business activities
    25,291       1,133       8,535       907       35,866       2,346  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    30             3       1       34        
Property
    6,475       7       97             6,579        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    34,235                         34,235        
Other
    14,368                         14,368        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    3,066                         3,066        
Interest accruals
    488       466                   954        
Total US
    121,276       62,963       375,155       6,520       565,914       326,473  
Europe
                                               
Central and local government
    742       1,335       8       5       2,090        
Manufacturing
    11,174       1       31             11,206        
Construction
    4,380             57             4,437        
Finance
    6,145       455       212       110       6,922       7  
Service industry and business activities
    20,116       48       136       1       20,301        
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    1,095       1       1             1,097        
Property
    18,618       1       299             18,918        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    23,132                         23,132        
Other
    3,933             19             3,952        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    1,793                         1,793        
Interest accruals
    337       1                   338        
Total Europe
    91,465       1,842       763       116       94,186       7  
Rest of  the World
                                               
Central and local government
    534       5,164       268       142       6,108        
Manufacturing
    1,032       155       94             1,281        
Construction
    421             2             423        
Finance
    10,928       2,657       37,035       25       50,645       31,262  
Service industry and business activities
    6,001       337       328             6,666        
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    15             10             25        
Property
    1,951       402       53             2,406        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    439                         439        
Other
    1,466                         1,466        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    24                         24        
Interest accruals
    91                         91        
Total Rest of  the World
    22,902       8,715       37,790       167       69,574       31,262  
22


               
Group
             
   
 Loans and advances to banks and customers
   
Debt
securities and
equity shares
   
Derivatives
   
Other(1)
   
Total
   
Netting
offset (2)
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Total
                                               
Central and local government
    7,661       66,225       4,319       181       78,386       1,636  
Manufacturing
    46,415       521       7,863       184       54,983       4,029  
Construction
    19,032       96       925       6       20,059       1,485  
Finance
    183,541       103,694       896,458       9,034       1,192,727       781,701  
Service industry and business activities
    133,414       6,498       22,228       1,494       163,634       10,056  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    4,258       1       48       2       4,309       87  
Property
    100,676       2,072       5,522       2       108,272       1,026  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    138,747             14             138,761       52  
Other
    45,949       248       55             46,252       5  
Finance leases and instalment credit
    22,246       3       25             22,274        
Interest accruals
    3,606       1,241                   4,847        
      705,545       180,599       937,457       10,903       1,834,504       800,077  

Notes:
(1)
Includes settlement balances of  £10,871 million.
(2)
This column shows the amount by which the Groups credit risk exposure is reduced through arrangements, such as master netting agreements, which give the Group a legal right to set-off the financial asset against a financial liability due to the same counterparty. In addition, the Group holds collateral in respect of individual loans and advances to banks and customers. This collateral includes mortgages over property (both personal and commercial); charges over business assets such as plant, inventories and trade debtors; and guarantees of lending from parties other than the borrower. The Group obtains collateral in the form of securities in reverse repurchase agreements. Cash and securities are received as collateral in respect of derivative transactions.
 
               
Group
             
     Loans and advances to banks and customers    
 Debt
securities and
equity shares
     
Derivatives
     
Other(1)
     
Total
   
 Netting
offset(2)
 
2007
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
UK
                                               
Central and local government
    4,722       15,280       1,157             21,159       1,531  
Manufacturing
    19,574       211       1,517             21,302       4,031  
Construction
    12,249       3       741             12,993       1,684  
Finance
    173,741       74,137       186,041       1,678       435,597       190,316  
Service industry and business activities
    69,011       5,125       4,412             78,548       6,690  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    2,564       1       58             2,623       104  
Property
    59,821       603       969       7       61,400       2,033  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    72,726             5             72,731        
Other
    27,408       260       15             27,683       7  
Finance leases and instalment credit
    15,632       131       27             15,790        
Interest accruals
    2,202       857                   3,059        
Total UK
    459,650       96,608       194,942       1,685       752,885       206,396  
US
                                               
Central and local government
    347       22,982             212       23,541        
Manufacturing
    5,412       236                   5,648        
Construction
    793       96                   889        
Finance
    26,722       36,843       9,470       2,800       75,835       7,417  
Service industry and business activities
    14,254       1,388       233             15,875       1  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    20                         20        
Property
    6,339                         6,339        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    27,882                         27,882        
Other
    10,879                         10,879        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    2,228                         2,228        
Interest accruals
    619       379                   998       2  
Total US
    95,495       61,924       9,703       3,012       170,134       7,420  
 
23

 
Industry risk geographical analysis (audited) continued
               
Group
             
 
 
Loans and
advances to banks and customers
   
Debt
securities and
equity shares
   
Derivatives
   
Other(1)
   
Total
   
Netting
offset(2)
 
2007
    £m    
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
 
Europe
                                     
Central and local government
    551       960       10             1,521        
Manufacturing
    5,868                         5,868        
Construction
    3,519                         3,519        
Finance
    10,984       790       1,011       28       12,813        
Service industry and business activities
    13,391       19       7             13,417       16  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    588                         588        
Property
    12,971       67                   13,038        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    16,276       18                   16,294        
Other
    5,111                         5,111        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    1,620                         1,620        
Interest accruals
    277       1                   278        
Total Europe
    71,156       1,855       1,028       28       74,067       16  
Rest of  the World
                                               
Central and local government
    239       1,054                   1,293        
Manufacturing
    214                         214        
Construction
    463       4                   467       1  
Finance
    18,176       8,477       38       575       27,266       69  
Service industry and business activities
    3,103       1       9             3,113       2  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    11                         11        
Property
    1,751       52       1             1,804        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    477                         477        
Other
    1,149                         1,149        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    18             254       45       317        
Interest accruals
    128       11                   139        
Total Rest of  the World
    25,729       9,599       302       620       36,250       72  
Total
                                               
Central and local government
    5,859       40,276       1,167       212       47,514       1,531  
Manufacturing
    31,068       447       1,517             33,032       4,031  
Construction
    17,024       103       741             17,868       1,685  
Finance
    229,623       120,247       196,560       5,081       551,511       197,802  
Service industry and business activities
    99,759       6,533       4,661             110,953       6,709  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    3,183       1       58             3,242       104  
Property
    80,882       722       970       7       82,581       2,033  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    117,361       18       5             117,384        
Other
    44,547       260       15             44,822       7  
Finance leases and instalment credit
    19,498       131       281       45       19,955        
Interest accruals
    3,226       1,248                   4,474       2  
      652,030       169,986       205,975       5,345       1,033,336       213,904  
 
Notes:
(1)
Includes settlement balances of  £5,326 million.
(2)
This column shows the amount by which the Groups credit risk exposure is reduced through arrangements, such as master netting agreements, which give the Group a legal right to set-off the financial asset against a financial liability due to the same counterparty. In addition, the Group holds collateral in respect of individual loans and advances to banks and customers. This collateral includes mortgages over property (both personal and commercial); charges over business assets such as plant, inventories and trade debtors; and guarantees of lending from parties other than the borrower. The Group obtains collateral in the form of securities in reverse repurchase agreements. Cash and securities are received as collateral in respect of derivative transactions.

 
                      Bank                 
     
Loans and
advances to banks
and customers
     
Debt
securities and
equity shares
     
Derivatives
     
Settlement
balances
     
Total
     
Netting
offset(1)
 
2008
   
£m
     
£m
     
£m
     
£m
     
£m
     
£m
 
UK
                                               
Central and local government
    3,559       33,099       4,003       1       40,662       352  
Manufacturing
    16,047       263       5,516       15       21,841       1,904  
Construction
    6,614       33       687             7,334       405  
Finance
    167,225       101,653       502,642       3,462       774,982       426,102  
Service industry and business activities
    57,456       4,787       11,935       478       74,656       2,290  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    836             21       1       858       71  
Property
    44,390       2,296       4,509       2       51,197       433  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    39,409             5             39,414       52  
Other
    7,857             6             7,863        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    652             25             677        
Interest accruals
    2,453       761                   3,214        
Total UK
    346,498       142,892       529,349       3,959       1,022,698       431,609  
US
                                               
Central and local government
    75       319       45       3       442        
Manufacturing
    3,769       44       1,308       5       5,126        
Construction
    203       3       123             329        
Finance
    7,937       11,611       365,575       1,314       386,437       320,460  
Service industry and business activities
    12,305       330       3,838       54       16,527       151  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
                2             2        
Property
    1,057             97             1,154        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
                                   
Other
                                   
Finance leases and instalment credit
    120                         120        
Interest accruals
    74       61                   135        
Total US
    25,540       12,368       370,988       1,376       410,272       320,611  
Europe
                                               
Central and local government
    598             8             606        
Manufacturing
    8,862                         8,862        
Construction
    1,031                         1,031        
Finance
    1,765       59                   1,824       7  
Service industry and business activities
    10,986                         10,986        
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    2                         2        
Property
    5,893                         5,893        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    4                         4        
Other
    1                         1        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    90                         90        
Interest accruals
    149       1                   150        
Total Europe
    29,381       60       8             29,449       7  
Rest of  the World
                                               
Central and local government
    534       1,622       268             2,424        
Manufacturing
    1,032       155       94             1,281        
Construction
    421             2             423        
Finance
    9,227       2,934       37,405             49,566       31,262  
Service industry and business activities
    5,979       336       328             6,643        
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    15             10             25        
Property
    1,930       397       53             2,380        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    439                         439        
Other
    3                         3        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    147                         147        
Interest accruals
    86                         86        
Total Rest of  the World
    19,813       5,444       38,160             63,417       31,262  
 
25

 
               
Bank
             
   
Loans and
advances to banks
and customers
   
Debt
securities and
equity shares
   
Derivatives
   
Settlement
balances
   
Total
   
Netting
offset(1)
 
2008
 
 £m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
 
Total
                                   
Central and local government
    4,766       35,040       4,324       4       44,134       352  
Manufacturing
    29,710       462       6,918       20       37,110       1,904  
Construction
    8,269       36       812             9,117       405  
Finance
    186,154       116,257       905,622       4,776       1,212,809       777,831  
Service industry and business activities
    86,726       5,453       16,101       532       108,812       2,441  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    853             33       1       887       71  
Property
    53,270       2,693       4,659       2       60,624       433  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    39,852             5             39,857       52  
Other
    7,861             6             7,867        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    1,009             25             1,034        
Interest accruals
    2,762       823                   3,585        
      421,232       160,764       938,505       5,335       1,525,836       783,489  

Note:
(1)
This column shows the amount by which the Banks credit risk exposure is reduced through arrangements, such as master netting agreements, which give the Bank a legal right to set-off the financial asset against a financial liability due to the same counterparty. In addition, the Bank holds collateral in respect of individual loans and advances to banks and customers. This collateral includes mortgages over property (both personal and commercial); charges over business assets such as plant, inventories and trade debtors; and guarantees of lending from parties other than the borrower. The Bank obtains collateral in the form of securities in reverse repurchase agreements. Cash and securities are received as collateral in respect of derivative transactions.
 
               
Bank
             
   
Loans and
   
Debt
                         
   
advances to banks
   
securities and
         
Settlement
         
Netting
 
   
and customers
   
equity shares
   
Derivatives
   
balances
   
Total
   
offset(1)
 
2007
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
UK
                                               
Central and local government
    2,396       13,379       1,158             16,933       387  
Manufacturing
    11,470       209       1,416             13,095       1,775  
Construction
    5,834       3       716             6,553       768  
Finance
    178,673       73,290       188,740       1,673       442,376       189,948  
Service industry and business activities
    42,694       5,710       4,228             52,632       2,143  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    800             56             856       87  
Property
    33,741       545       866       7       35,159       588  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    35,710             1             35,711        
Other
    8,213             6             8,219        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    708       128       27             863        
Interest accruals
    1,554       854                   2,408        
Total UK
    321,793       94,118       197,214       1,680       614,805       195,696  
US
                                               
Central and local government
    73       1,892                   1,965        
Manufacturing
    2,307       124                   2,431        
Construction
    217       48                   265        
Finance
    31,867       10,799       10,400       321       53,387       4,932  
Service industry and business activities
    6,640       558                   7,198        
Property
    724                         724        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    36                         36        
Interest accruals
    67       83                   150        
Total US
    41,931       13,504       10,400       321       66,156       4,932  
 
26

               
Bank
                   
   
Loans and
   
Debt
                         
   
advances to banks
   
securities and
         
Settlement
         
Netting
 
   
and customers
   
equity shares
   
Derivatives
   
balances
   
Total
   
offset(1)
 
2007
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Europe
                                               
Central and local government
    389             10             399        
Manufacturing
    3,910                         3,910        
Construction
    630                         630        
Finance
    18,964       37                   19,001        
Service industry and business activities
    6,897                         6,897        
Property
    4,938                         4,938        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    3                         3        
Other
    1                         1        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    113                         113        
Interest accruals
    100       1                   101        
Total Europe
    35,945       38       10             35,993        
Rest of  the World
                                               
Central and local government
    239       1,053                   1,292        
Manufacturing
    214                         214        
Construction
    443                         443       1  
Finance
    6,211       2,530       24             8,765       69  
Service industry and business activities
    13,497             10             13,507       2  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    11                         11        
Property
    1,751       26       1             1,778        
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    280                         280        
Other
    3                         3        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    18             254       45       317        
Interest accruals
    66                         66        
Total Rest of  the World
    22,733       3,609       289       45       26,676       72  
Total
                                               
Central and local government
    3,097       16,324       1,168             20,589       387  
Manufacturing
    17,901       333       1,416             19,650       1,775  
Construction
    7,124       51       716             7,891       769  
Finance
    235,715       86,656       199,164       1,994       523,529       194,949  
Service industry and business activities
    69,728       6,268       4,238             80,234       2,145  
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
    811             56             867       87  
Property
    41,154       571       867       7       42,599       588  
Individuals:
                                               
Home mortgages
    35,993             1             35,994        
Other
    8,217             6             8,223        
Finance leases and instalment credit
    875       128       281       45       1,329        
Interest accruals
    1,787       938                   2,725        
      422,402       111,269       207,913       2,046       743,630       200,700  

Note:
(1)
This column shows the amount by which the Banks credit risk exposure is reduced through arrangements, such as master netting agreements, which give the Bank a legal right to set-off the financial asset against a financial liability due to the same counterparty. In addition, the Bank holds collateral in respect of individual loans and advances to banks and customers. This collateral includes mortgages over property (both personal and commercial); charges over business assets such as plant, inventories and trade debtors; and guarantees of lending from parties other than the borrower. The Bank obtains collateral in the form of securities in reverse repurchase agreements. Cash and securities are received as collateral in respect of derivative transactions.

27

 
Impairment (audited)
The RBS Group classifies impaired assets as either Risk Elements in Lending (REIL) or Potential Problem Loans (PPL). REIL represents non-accrual loans, loans that are accruing but are past due 90 days and restructured loans. PPL represents impaired assets which are not included in REIL but where information about possible credit problems cause management to have serious doubts about the future ability of the borrower to comply with loan repayment terms.
 
Both REIL and PPL are reported gross of  the value of  any security held, which could reduce the eventual loss should it occur, and gross of  any provision marked. Therefore impaired assets which are highly collateralised, such as mortgages, will have a low coverage ratio of provisions held against reported impaired balance. The analyses of  risk elements and impairment charges as discussed below form a key part of  the data provided to senior management on the credit performance of  the Groups portfolios.
 
The table below sets out loans that are classified as REIL and PPL.
 
   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
 £m
   
 £m
 
Non-accrual loans (1)
    13,726       6,667  
Accrual loans past due 90 days (2)
    1,669       256  
Total REIL
    15,395       6,923  
PPL (3)
    226       64  
Total REIL and PPL
    15,621       6,987  
REIL and PPL as % of  customer loans and advances  gross (4)
    2.60 %     1.47 %

The sub-categories of  REIL and PPL are calculated as described in notes 1 to 4 below.

Notes:
(1)
All loans against which an impairment provision is held are reported in the non-accrual category.
(2)
Loans where an impairment event has taken place but no impairment recognised. This category is used for fully collateralised non-revolving credit facilities.
(3)
Loans for which an impairment event has occurred but no impairment provision is necessary. This category is used for fully collateralised advances and revolving credit facilities where identification as 90 days overdue is not feasible.
(4)
Gross of  provisions and excluding reverse repurchase agreements.
 
28

 
Impairment loss provision methodology (audited)
Provisions for impairment losses are assessed under three categories:
 
•     Individually assessed provisions: provisions required for individually significant impaired assets which are assessed on a case by case basis, taking into account the financial condition of  the counterparty and any guarantor and collateral held after being stressed for downside risk. This incorporates an estimate of  the discounted value of  any recoveries and realisation of  security or collateral. The asset continues to be assessed on an individual basis until it is repaid in full, transferred to the performing portfolio or written-off.
 
•     Collectively assessed provisions: provisions on impaired credits below an agreed threshold which are assessed on a portfolio basis, to reflect the homogeneous nature of  the assets, such as credit cards or personal loans. The provision is determined from a quantitative review of  the relevant portfolio, taking account of  the level of  arrears, security and average loss experience over the recovery period.
 
     Latent loss provisions: provisions held against the estimated impairment in the performing portfolio which have yet to be identified as at the balance sheet date. To assess the latent loss within the portfolios, the RBS Group has developed methodologies to estimate the time that an asset can remain impaired within a performing portfolio before it is identified and reported as such.
 
Provision analysis (audited)
The RBS Groups consumer portfolios, which consist of  high volume, small value credits, have highly efficient largely automated processes for identifying problem credits and very short timescales, typically three months, before resolution or adoption of  various recovery methods. Corporate portfolios consist of  higher value, lower volume credits, which tend to be structured to meet individual customer requirements. Provisions are assessed on a case by case basis by experienced specialists with input from professional valuers and accountants. The RBS Group operates a clear provisions governance framework which sets thresholds whereby suitable oversight and challenge is undertaken and significant cases will be presented to a committee chaired by the Group Chief  Executive or the Group Finance Director.
 
Impairment charge (audited)
The following table shows total impairment losses charged to the income statement.

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
New impairment losses
    4,917       2,110  
less: recoveries of  amounts previously written-off
    (211 )     (245 )
Charge to income statement
    4,706       1,865  
Comprising:
               
Loan impairment losses
    4,555       1,843  
Impairment losses on available-for-sale securities
    151       22  
Charge to income statement
    4,706       1,865  


Analysis of  loan impairment charge (audited)
   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
    £m     £m  
Latent loss impairment charge
    582       2  
Collectively assessed impairment charge
    2,183       1,644  
Individually assessed impairment charge (1)
    1,709       197  
Charge to income statement
    4,474       1,843  
Charge as a % of  customer loans and advances gross (2)
    0.75 %     0.39 %

Notes:
(1)
Excludes loan impairment charge against loans and advances to banks of  £81 million (2007  nil).
(2)
Gross of  provisions and excluding reverse repurchase agreements.
 
 
29

 
Analysis of  loan impairment provisions (audited)
   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Latent loss provisions
    1,328       600  
Collectively assessed provisions
    3,380       2,996  
Individually assessed provisions
    1,864       637  
Total provisions (1)
    6,572       4,233  
                 
Total provision as a % of  customer loans and advances – gross (2)
    1.10 %     0.89 %

Notes:
     
(1) Excludes provisions against loans and advances to banks of  £83 million (2007 – £2 million).
     
(2) Gross of  provisions and excluding reverse repurchase agreements.
     

Provisions coverage (audited)
The provision coverage ratios are shown in the table below.
 
   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Total provision expressed as a:
               
% of  REIL
    43 %     61 %
% of  REIL and PPL
    43 %     61 %

The coverage ratio of closing provisions to REIL and PPL decreased from 61% to 43% during 2008. The lower coverage ratio reflects amounts written- off and the changing mix from unsecured to secured exposures.

Movement in loan impairment provisions (audited)
The following table shows the movement in the provision for impairment losses for loans and advances.
 
   
  Group
 
   
Individually
   
Collectively
         
Total
       
   
assessed
   
assessed
   
Latent
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January
    639       2,996       600       4,235       3,929  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    164       113       176       453       30  
(Disposals)/acquisitions
          (148 )     (30 )     (178 )     6  
Amounts written-off
    (636 )     (1,811 )           (2,447 )     (1,652 )
Recoveries of  amounts previously written-off
    23       188             211       245  
Charged to the income statement
    1,790       2,183       582       4,555       1,843  
Unwind of  discount
    (33 )     (141 )           (174 )     (166 )
At 31 December (1)
    1,947       3,380       1,328       6,655       4,235  

Note:
(1)   The provision for impairment losses at 31 December 2008 includes £83 million relating to loans and advances to banks (2007 £2 million).

30


Liquidity risk (audited)
The RBS Groups liquidity policy is designed to ensure that it can at all times meet its obligations as they fall due.

Liquidity management within the RBS Group addresses the overall balance sheet structure and the control, within prudent limits, of risk arising from the mismatch of maturities across the balance sheet and from exposure to undrawn commitments and other contingent obligations. The management of liquidity risk within the RBS Group is undertaken within a formal governance structure. The Group Board of Directors oversees the liquidity risk appetite and strategy of the RBS Group; the Group Executive Management Committee reviews the key liquidity metrics and trends in the context of the RBS Groups overall risk profile; the Group Asset and Liability Management Committee (GALCO), chaired by the Group Finance Director and including the chief executives of the business divisions as well as the Group Treasurer, Group Chief Risk Officer and heads of other relevant Group functions, sets explicit metrics across a number of asset and liability targets and these are cascaded to the business and monitored by the Group Treasury and risk functions.

Group Treasury has overall responsibility for the daily monitoring and control of the RBS Groups liquidity and funding positions. The Liquidity Managers Forum is chaired and directed by the Group Treasurer with membership including the Head of Short Term Markets and Financing, GBM. The forum typically meets weekly with more frequent, ad hoc, meetings as necessary. There are Regional and Country ALCOs that oversee RBS Group policy in our business in Europe, Asia and the Americas. The RBS Group is divided into Liquidity Reporting Units each of which is required to have its own liquidity limits and contingency funding plan. In addition, all subsidiaries and branches outside the UK are required to comply with local regulatory liquidity requirements and are subject to Group Treasury oversight.

Management of  term structure
The RBS Group evaluates on a regular basis its structural liquidity risk and applies a variety of balance sheet management and term funding strategies to maintain this risk within its normal policy parameters. The degree of maturity mismatch within the overall long-term structure of the RBS Groups assets and liabilities is managed within internal policy guidelines, aimed at ensuring term asset commitments may be funded on an economic basis over their life. In managing its overall term structure, the RBS Group analyses and takes into account the effect of retail and corporate customer behaviour on actual asset and liability maturities where they differ materially from the underlying contractual maturities.

Daily management
The primary focus of the daily management activity is to ensure access to sufficient liquidity to meet cash flow obligations within key time horizons, in particular out to one month ahead. The short-term maturity structure of the RBS Groups liabilities and assets is managed daily to ensure that all material or potential cash flow obligations, arising from undrawn commitments and other contingent obligations can be met. Potential sources include cash inflows from maturing assets, new borrowings or the sale of various debt securities held (after allowing for appropriate haircuts). Short-term liquidity risk is generally managed on a consolidated basis with liquidity mismatch limits in place for subsidiaries and non-UK branches which have material local treasury activities, thereby assuring that the daily maintenance of the RBS Groups overall liquidity risk position is not compromised. Citizens Financial Group manages liquidity locally, given different regulatory regimes, subject to review by Group Treasury.

Stress testing
The RBS Group performs stress tests to simulate how events may impact its funding and liquidity capabilities. Such tests inform the overall balance sheet structure and help define suitable limits for control of the risk arising from the mismatch of maturities across the balance sheet and from undrawn commitments and other contingent obligations. The form and content of stress tests are updated where required as market conditions evolve.

Contingency planning
Contingency funding plans have been developed to anticipate and respond to approaching or actual material deterioration in market conditions. The RBS Group reviews its contingency plans in the light of evolving market conditions. The contingency funding plan covers: the available sources of contingent funding to supplement cash flow shortages; the lead times to obtain such funding; the roles and responsibilities of those involved in the contingency plans, including the communication lines for escalation of events which give rise to liquidity stress; assumptions, including the expected change impact of market conditions; and the ability and circumstances within which the RBS Group accesses central bank liquidity.

Liquidity management in 2008 (audited)
The amount of unsecured wholesale funding of the Group represented by bank funding and debt securities increased from £206 billion in December 2007 to £298 billion in December 2008. The gap between customer loans and customer deposits increased over this period from £109 billion to £199 billion. The market disruption during 2008 had a marked effect on the Groups liquidity and funding which was at its most acute in the autumn of 2008 following the collapse of Lehman Brothers. During that period, the Groups credit ratings were downgraded constraining both access to and tenor of wholesale funding and there was an outflow of customer deposits. The effective closure of the term funding markets and sharp reduction in the quantity and maturity of short term bank funding had profound consequences for the Group.

Whilst the Groups customer funding sources remain well diversified and its retail franchise proved resilient, the availability of longer term funding diminished. The Group therefore increased its shorter term wholesale funding exposure, increased its access to central bank funding and issued government guaranteed debt to fund the balance sheet. The government schemes have enabled the mitigation of the financial crisis as the Group rebalances its asset and liability structure.
 
 
31

 
An analysis of  the Groups funding is set out below.
 
Group
 
2008
   
2007
Sources of  funding
£m
 
%
    £m  
%
Customer accounts (excluding repos)
               
Repayable on demand
248,978
 
27
   
226,451
 
27
Time deposits
150,056
 
16
   
141,502
 
17
Total customer accounts (excluding repos)
399,034
 
43
   
367,953
 
44
Debt securities in issue over one year
               
remaining maturity
57,447
 
6
   
50,580
 
6
Subordinated liabilities
39,951
 
4
   
27,796
 
3
Owners’ equity
45,958
 
5
   
47,683
 
5
Total customer accounts and long term funds
542,390
 
58
   
494,012
 
58
Repo agreements with customers
54,095
 
6
   
75,029
 
9
Repo agreements with banks
66,006
 
7
   
75,154
 
9
Total customer accounts, long term funds
               
and collateralised borrowing
662,491
 
71
   
644,195
 
76
Debt securities in issue up to one year
               
remaining maturity
122,495
 
13
   
79,552
 
9
Deposits by banks (excluding repos)
115,976
 
12
   
76,354
 
9
Short positions
37,172
 
4
   
47,058
 
6
Total
938,134
 
100
   
847,159
 
100

Customer accounts the principal source of funds for the Group is its core customer deposits gathered by its retail banking, private client, corporate and SME franchises. The underlying strength of the franchise is demonstrated by the performance of the Group in these markets as customer deposits increased from £368 billion in December 2007 to £399 billion at the end of December 2008. There was a fluctuation in balances at the height of the market disruption in October 2008 but this was recovered by the year end. The Groups multi-brand offering and strong client focus is a key part of the funding strategy and continues to benefit the Groups funding position.

Repo agreements are borrowings collateralised by a range of debt securities and other assets undertaken with a range of corporate and institutional customers and banks. These reduced in the course of 2008 as the Group took strategic actions and wholesale markets retrenched.

Short positions in various securities are held primarily by GBM including RBS Greenwich Capital in the US.

Debt securities in issue over one year, subordinated liabilities and equity during 2008, the debt markets saw reduced activity, in both the term and the securitisation markets; as a result the maturity profile of the Groups wholesale funding has become shorter in duration over the course of the year. This was partly offset by issues of government guaranteed debt in the latter part of 2008. The maturity profile of debt securities is predominantly concentrated under one year and this is a source of refinancing risk in the coming twelve months.

Short term debt and bank deposits the Group saw considerable pressure and risk aversion in the short term debt and bank deposit markets. In order to relieve funding shortages in the market, central banks across the world allowed banks to pledge assets to access funding. The Group has used central bank schemes to support its funding and pledged assets into several of these schemes in a number of countries in which it operates. The Group has set up a series of initiatives to improve the liquidity value of its assets to assist in relieving funding pressures.
 
Undrawn commitments the Group provides undrawn commitments to both its corporate and personal customers in the form of products such as overdrafts and credit card facilities. The commitments portfolio is well diversified in terms of customers, geography and business type. The total amount of the Groups undrawn commitments at the end of 2008 was £294 billion.

Conduits the Groups most significant multi-seller conduits have thus far continued to fund the vast majority of their assets solely through asset backed commercial paper (ABCP) issuance. There were significant disruptions to the liquidity of the financial markets during the year following the bankruptcy filing of Lehman Brothers in September 2008 and this required a small amount of the assets held in certain conduits to be funded by the Group rather than through ABCP issuance. By the end of 2008 there had been an improvement in market conditions, supported by central bank initiatives, which enabled normal ABCP funding to replace this Group funding of the conduits.

The average maturity of ABCP issued by the Groups conduits as at 31 December 2008 was 72.4 days (2007 60.4 days).

The total assets held by the Groups sponsored conduits are £31.5 billion (2007 £10.7 billion). Since these liquidity facilities are sanctioned on the basis of total conduit purchase commitments, the liquidity facility commitments will exceed the level of assets held, with the difference representing undrawn commitments.

The Group values the funding flexibility and liquidity provided by the ABCP market to fund client and Group-originated assets. Whilst there are plans to decrease the multi-seller conduit business in line with the Groups balance sheet, the Group is reviewing the potential for new own-asset conduit structures to add funding diversity.
 
 
32


Balance sheet (audited)

The following tables show the contractual undiscounted cash flows receivable and payable up to a period of 20 years including future payments of interest.

On balance sheet assets by contractual maturity
 
   
  Group
 
   
0-3 months
 
 
3-12 months
   
1-3 years
   
3-5 years
   
5-10 years
   
10-20 years
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Cash and balances at central banks
    6,804                         2        
Loans and advances to banks
    14,356       3,037       650       343       156       1  
Loans and advances to customers
    112,181       63,785       117,538       106,942       137,546       129,999  
Debt securities
    21,104       4,785       14,647       7,983       16,509       23,742  
Derivatives held for hedging
    5       734       1,842       911       876       268  
Settlement balances
    10,869                         2        
Other financial assets
    2                   10       20        
      165,321       72,341       134,677       116,189       155,111       154,010  

On balance sheet liabilities by contractual maturity

   
Group
 
   
0-3 months
   
3-12 months
   
1-3 years
   
3-5 years
   
5-10 years
   
10-20 years
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Deposits by banks
    83,879       5,938       3,114       1,758       662       34  
Customer accounts
    368,115       18,634       2,313       2,811       4,105       2,718  
Debt securities in issue
    110,728       30,213       22,461       3,581       5,600       4,038  
Derivatives held for hedging
    67       755       1,926       674       597       317  
Subordinated liabilities
    972       2,659       5,113       5,583       17,213       13,287  
Settlement balances and other liabilities
    10,407       5       7       4       7       6  
      574,168       58,204       34,934       14,411       28,184       20,400  
 
 
33

 
Other contractual cash obligations
           
Other contractual obligations are summarised by payment date in the tables below
         

   
  Group
 
   
0-3 months
   
3-12 months
   
1-3 years
   
3-5 years
   
5-10 years
   
10-20 years
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Operating leases
    103       304       743       611       1,174       1,836  
Contractual obligations to purchase goods or services
    176       696       262       22             1  
      279       1,000       1,005       633       1,174       1,837  
                                                 
2007
                                               
Operating leases
    89       261       638       555       1,073       1,937  
Contractual obligations to purchase goods or services
    371       815       526       194       3       2  
      460       1,076       1,164       749       1,076       1,939  
                                               
 
     
  Bank
 
   
0-3 months
   
3-12 months
   
1-3 years
   
3-5 years
   
5-10 years
   
10-20 years
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Operating leases
    41       118       299       287       599       1,209  
Contractual obligations to purchase goods or services
    65       170       162       22              
      106       288       461       309       599       1,209  
                                                 
2007
                                               
Operating leases
    35       106       269       256       582       1,176  
Contractual obligations to purchase goods or services
    100       249       199       34       2        
      135       355       468       290       584       1,176  

Undrawn formal facilities, credit lines and other commitments to lend were £294,349 million (2007 £259,263 million) for the Group and £187,041 million (2007 £144,185 million) for the Bank. While the Bank and its subsidiaries have given commitments to provide these funds, some facilities may be subject to certain conditions being met by the counterparty. Not all facilities are expected to be drawn, and some may lapse before drawdown.

The tables above show the timing of cash inflows and outflows to settle financial assets and liabilities. They have been prepared on the following basis:

Financial assets have been reflected in the time band of the latest date on which they could be repaid unless earlier repayment can be demanded by the reporting entity; financial liabilities are included at the earliest date on which the counterparty can require repayment regardless of whether or not such early repayment results in a penalty. If the repayment of a financial asset or liability is triggered by, or is subject to, specific criteria such as market price hurdles being reached, the asset is included in the latest date on which it can repay regardless of early repayment whereas the liability is included at the earliest possible date that the conditions could be fulfilled without considering the probability of the conditions being met. For example, if a structured note is automatically prepaid when an equity index exceeds a certain level, the cash outflow will be included in the less than three months period whatever the level of the index at the year end. The settlement date of debt securities in issue issued by certain securitisation vehicles consolidated by the Group depends on when cash flows are received from the securitised assets. Where these assets are prepayable, the timing of the cash outflow relating to securities assumes that each asset will be prepaid at the earliest possible date. As the repayment of assets and liabilities are linked, the repayment of assets in securitisations are shown on the earliest date that the asset can be prepaid as this is the basis used for liabilities.

Assets and liabilities with a contractual maturity of greater than 20 years  the principal amounts of financial assets and liabilities that are repayable after 20 years or where the counterparty has no right to repayment of the principal are excluded from the table as are interest payments after 20 years.

Held-for-trading assets and liabilities  held-for-trading assets and liabilities amounting to £1,148.7 billion (assets) and £1,091.7 billion (liabilities) have been excluded from the table in view of their short term nature.

This contractual analysis highlights the maturity transformation of the balance sheet that is fundamental to the structure of banking. In practice, this is not a reflection of the actual behaviour of assets or liabilities. In particular the customer funding of the balance sheet exhibits much greater stability and maturity than the tables indicate. This is because the funding franchise of the Group is diversified across an extensive retail network.


34


Regulatory environment (audited)

The RBS Group is subject to the FSAs liquidity regime, whilst overseas subsidiaries and branches are subject to local regimes.

Sterling liquidity
The FSA requires the RBS Group, on a consolidated basis, to maintain daily a minimum ratio of 100% between:

a stock of qualifying high quality liquid assets (primarily UK and EU government securities, treasury bills and cash held in branches); and

the sum of: sterling wholesale net outflows contractually due within five working days (offset up to a limit of 50%, by 85% of sterling certificates of deposit held which mature beyond five working days); and 5% of retail deposits with a residual contractual maturity of five working days or less. The FSA also sets an absolute minimum level for the stock of qualifying liquid assets that the RBS Group is required to maintain each day.

Given the developments in 2008 the FSA has published new proposals for liquidity management (CP08/22) to replace the current regulatory framework. The FSA is proposing a major overhaul of liquidity risk regulation that will include:

Improved systems and controls including governance standards, pricing, intra day systems and collateral management.

Individual liquid assessments that will include mandatory scenarios and an analysis of principal liquidity exposure factors.

Reporting standards improved both in scope and frequency by enhanced mismatch reporting.

Market risk (audited)

Market risk arises from changes in interest rates, foreign currency, credit spread, equity prices and risk related factors such as market volatilities. Market risk is actively managed and aligned with the RBS Groups risk appetite. Market conditions were difficult throughout 2008 with significant volatility and write-downs across markets and portfolios. The RBS Group manages market risk in the trading and non-trading (treasury) portfolios using the market risk management framework. The framework includes value-at-risk (VaR) limits, backtesting, stress testing, scenario analysis, position/sensitivity analysis and model validation. The focus through 2008 has been on overhauling and reviewing the market risk limits for trading book activities, reflecting market performance and events.

Measurement (audited)
A number of techniques are used to calculate the RBS Groups exposure to market risk, including VaR, sensitivity analysis and stress testing. VaR is a technique that produces estimates of the potential change in the market value of a portfolio over a specified time horizon at given confidence levels. For internal risk management purposes, the RBS Groups VaR assumes a time horizon of one trading day and a confidence level of 95%. The trading book market risk is calculated using VaR at a confidence level of 99% and a time horizon of ten trading days. From 2009, the RBS Group is adopting 99% confidence limits, in line with industry practice.

The RBS Group calculates VaR using historical simulation models but does not make any assumption about the nature or type of underlying loss distribution. The methodology uses the previous 500 trading days of market data and calculates both general market risk (i.e. the risk due to movement in general market benchmarks) and idiosyncratic market risk (i.e. the risk due to movements in the value of securities by reference to specific issuers). All VaR models have limitations, which include:

Historical data may not provide the best estimate of the joint distribution of risk factor changes in the future and may fail to capture the risk of possible extreme adverse market movements which have not occurred in the historical window used in the calculations.

VaR using a one-day time horizon does not fully capture the market risk of positions that cannot be liquidated or hedged within one day.

VaR using a 95% confidence level does not reflect the extent of potential losses beyond that percentile.

 
 
35

 
Traded portfolios (audited)
The primary focus of the RBS Groups trading activities is client facilitation. The Group also undertakes:

Market making quoting firm bid (buy) and offer (sell) prices with the intention of profiting from the spread between the quotes.

Arbitrage entering into offsetting positions in different but closely related markets in order to profit from market imperfections.

Proprietary activity taking positions in financial instruments as principal in order to take advantage of anticipated market conditions.

Financial instruments held in the RBS Groups trading portfolios include, but are not limited to: debt securities, loans, deposits, equities, securities sale and repurchase agreements and derivative financial instruments (futures, forwards, swaps and options).

The RBS Group participates in exchange traded and over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives markets. The RBS Group buys and sells financial instruments that are traded or cleared on an exchange, including interest rate swaps, futures and options. Holders of exchange traded instruments provide margin daily with cash or other security at the exchange, to which the holders look for ultimate settlement. The RBS Group also buys and sells financial instruments that are traded OTC, rather than on a recognised exchange. These instruments range from commoditised transactions in derivative markets, to trades where the specific terms are tailored to the requirements of the RBS Groups customers. In many cases, industry standard documentation is used, most commonly in the form of a master agreement, with individual transaction confirmations. The RBS Group calculates the VaR of trading portfolios at the close of business and positions may change substantially during the course of a trading day. Further controls are in place to limit the RBS Groups intra-day exposure, such as the calculation of the VaR for selected portfolios. The RBS Group cannot guarantee that losses will not exceed the VaR amounts indicated due to the limitations and nature of VaR measurements.

Assets and liabilities in the trading book are measured at their fair value. Fair value is the amount at which the instrument could be exchanged in a current transaction between willing parties. The fair values are determined following IAS 39 guidance which requires banks to use quoted market prices or valuation techniques (models) that make the maximum use of observable inputs. When marking to market using a model, the valuation methodologies are reviewed and approved either by the market risk function in the business or at RBS Group level. Group Risk provides an independent evaluation of the model for transactions deemed by the Model Product Review Committee (MPRC) to be large, complex and/or innovative. Any profits or losses on the revaluation of positions are recognised in the daily profit and loss.

 
36


The VaR for the trading portfolios segregated by type of  market risk exposure, including idiosyncratic risk, is presented in the table below.

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Average
   
Period end
   
Maximum
   
Minimum
   
Average
   
Period end
   
Maximum
   
Minimum
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Interest rate
    18.9       25.8       38.8       9.2       11.7       9.6       17.6       7.6  
Credit spread
    35.0       40.4       51.3       19.4       17.7       37.9       44.0       12.6  
Currency
    3.9       7.0       10.8       2.1       2.6       2.6       6.9       1.1  
Equity
    3.4       2.4       11.0       1.5       2.4       1.9       6.8       1.4  
Commodity
    6.3       5.7       17.4             0.2       0.1       1.6        
Diversification
            (31.0 )                             (12.4 )                
Total trading VaR
    42.3       50.3       63.9       24.8       20.3       39.7       45.5       13.2  

The average total VaR utilisation increased in 2008 compared with 2007 as a result of increased market volatility. This increase was offset by a reduction in trading book exposure throughout the period, due to a reduction in the size of the inventory held on the balance sheet as a result of sales, reclassification of assets to the non-trading book and write-downs.

The 2008 data in the table above excludes exposures to super-senior tranches of asset backed CDOs, as VaR no longer produces an appropriate measure of risk for these exposures due to the illiquidity and opaqueness of the pricing of these instruments over an extended period. For these exposures, the maximum potential loss is equal to the aggregate net exposure, which was £734 million as at 31 December 2008. For more information, please refer to the discussion of Credit market and related exposures Super senior CDOs on page 46 and Financial statements: Note 10, Financial instruments Valuation level 3 portfolios collateralised debt obligations on pages 87 and 88. RBS Sempra Commodities LLP, the commodities-marketing joint venture between RBS and Sempra Energy, was formed on 1 April 2008, and its trading risks were included in the disclosed VaR from that date.

Backtesting, stress testing and sensitivity analysis (audited)
The RBS Group undertakes a programme of daily backtesting, which compares the actual profit or loss realised in trading activity to the VaR estimation. The results of the backtesting process are one of the methods by which the RBS Group monitors the ongoing suitability of its VaR model.

A Risks not in VaR framework has been developed to address those market risks not adequately captured by the market standard VaR methodology. Where risks are not included in the model various non-VaR controls (e.g. position monitoring, sensitivity limits, triggers or stress limits) are in place.

The RBS Group undertakes daily stress testing to identify the potential losses in excess of VaR. Stress testing is used to calculate a range of trading book exposures which result from exceptional but plausible market events. Stress testing measures the impact of abnormal changes in market rates and prices on the fair value of the RBS Groups trading portfolios. GEMC approves the high-level market stress test limit for the RBS Group. The RBS Group calculates historical stress tests and hypothetical stress tests.

Historical stress tests calculate the loss that would be generated if the market movements that occurred during historical market events were repeated. Hypothetical stress tests calculate the loss that would be generated if a specific set of adverse market movements were to occur.

Stress testing is also undertaken at key trading strategy level, for those strategies where the associated market risks are not adequately captured by VaR. Stress test exposures are discussed with senior management and are reported to GRC, GEMC and the Board. Breaches in the RBS Groups market risk stress testing limits are monitored and reported.

In addition to VaR and stress testing, the RBS Group calculates a wide range of sensitivity and position risk measures, for example interest rate ladders or option revaluation matrices. These measures provide valuable additional controls, often at individual desk or strategy level.

Model validation governance (audited)
Pricing models are developed and owned by the front office. Where pricing models are used as the basis of books and records valuations, they are all subject to independent review and sign-off. Models are assessed by MPRC as having either immaterial or material model risk (valuation uncertainty arising from choice of modelling assumptions), the assessment being made on the basis of expert judgement.

Those models assessed as having material model risk are prioritised for independent quantitative review. Independent quantitative review aims to quantify model risk by comparing model outputs against alternative independently developed models. The results of independent quantitative review are used by Market Risk to inform risk limits and by Finance to inform reserves. Governance over this process is provided by MPRC, a forum which brings together front office quants, market risk, finance and QuaRC (Quantitative Research Centre, Group Risks independent quantitative model review function). Risk (market risk, incremental default risk, counterparty credit risk) models are developed both within business units and by Group functions. Risk models are also subject to independent review and sign-off. Meetings are held with the FSA every quarter to discuss the traded market risk, including changes in models, management, back testing results, other risks not included in the VaR framework and other model performance statistics.

Risk control (audited)
All divisions that are exposed to market risk in the course of their business are required to comply with the requirements of the RBS Groups Market Risk Policy Standards (MRPS). The main risk management tools are delegated authorities, specifically hard limits and discussion triggers, independent model valuation, a robust and efficient risk system and timely and accurate management information.

 
37

 
Limits form part of the dealing authorities and constitute one of the cornerstones of the market risk management framework. Upon notification of a limit breach, the appropriate body must take one of the following actions:

Instructions can be given to reduce positions so as to bring the RBS Group within the agreed limits.

A temporary increase in the limit (for instance, in order to allow orderly unwinding of positions) can be granted.

A permanent increase in the limit can be granted.

Non-traded portfolios (audited)
Risks in non-traded portfolios mainly arise in retail and commercial banking assets and liabilities and financial investments designated as available-for-sale and held-to-maturity.

Group Treasury is responsible for setting and monitoring the adequacy and effectiveness of management, using a framework that identifies, measures, monitors and controls the underlying risk. GALCO approves the RBS Groups non-traded market risk appetite, expressed as statistical and non-statistical risk limits, which are delegated to the businesses responsible.

Various banking regulators review non-trading market risk as part of their regulatory oversight. As home regulator, the FSA has responsibility for reviewing non-trading market risk at a RBS Group consolidated level.

The RBS Group is exposed to the following non-traded risks:

Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (IRRBB) represents exposures to instruments whose values vary with the level or volatility of interest rates. These instruments include, but are not limited to, loans, debt securities, equity shares, deposits, certificates of deposits, and other debt securities issued, loan capital and derivatives. Hedging instruments used to mitigate these risks include related derivatives such as options, futures, forwards and swaps. Interest rate risk arises from the RBS Groups non-trading activities in four principal forms:

Repricing risk arises from differences in the repricing terms of the RBS Groups assets and liabilities.

Optionality  arises where a customer has an option to exit a deal early.

Basis risk arises, for example, where one month LIBOR is used to fund base rate assets.

Yield curve risk arises as a result of non-parallel changes in the yield curve.

From an economic perspective, it is the RBS Groups policy to minimise the sensitivity to changes in interest rates in its retail and commercial businesses and, where interest rate risk is retained, to ensure that appropriate resources, measures and limits are applied.

Non-trading interest rate risk is calculated in each business on the basis of establishing the repricing behaviour of each asset, liability and off- balance sheet product. For many retail and commercial products, the actual interest rate repricing characteristics differ from the contractual repricing. In most cases, the repricing maturity is determined by the market interest rate that most closely fits the historical behaviour of the product interest rate. For non-interest bearing current accounts, the repricing maturity is determined by the stability of the portfolio. The repricing maturities used are approved by Group Treasury and divisional asset and liability committees at least annually. Key conventions are reviewed annually by GALCO.

A static maturity gap report is produced as at the month-end for each business, in each functional currency based on the behavioural repricing for each product. It is RBS Group policy to include in the gap report, non-financial assets and liabilities, mainly property, plant and equipment and the RBS Groups capital and reserves, spread over medium and longer term maturities. The report includes hedge transactions, principally derivatives.

Any residual non-trading interest rate exposures are controlled by limiting repricing mismatches in the individual business balance sheets. Potential exposures to interest rate movements in the medium to long- term are measured and controlled using a version of the same VaR methodology that is used for the RBS Groups trading portfolios. Net accrual income exposures are measured and controlled in terms of sensitivity over time to movements in interest rates.

Risk is managed within VaR limits approved by GALCO, through the execution of cash and derivative instruments. Execution of the hedging is carried out by the relevant division through the RBS Groups treasury functions. The residual risk position is reported to divisional asset and liability committees, GALCO and the Board.

Foreign Exchange Risk in the Banking Book (FXRBB) represents exposures to changes in the values of current holdings and future cashflows denominated in other currencies. Hedging instruments used to mitigate these risks include foreign currency options, currency swaps, futures, forwards and deposits. Foreign exchange risk results from the RBS Groups investments in overseas subsidiaries, associates and branches in three principal forms:

(i)
Structural foreign currency exposures that arise from net investment in overseas subsidiaries, associates and branches;

(ii)
Transactional/commercial foreign currency exposures that arise from mismatches in the currency balance sheet; and

(iii)
Foreign currency profit streams.

Equity Risk in the Banking Book (ERBB) is defined as the potential variation in the RBS Groups non-trading income and reserves arising from changes in equity prices/income. This risk may crystallise during the course of normal business activities or in stressed market conditions.

38

 
Equity positions in the RBS Groups banking book are retained to achieve strategic objectives, support venture capital transactions or in respect of restructuring arrangements. From an economic perspective, it is the RBS Groups policy to ensure that equity exposures in the banking book are identified, monitored and controlled, with the aim of maximising their potential strategic or business value.

The types, nature and amounts of exchange-traded exposures, private equity exposures, and other exposures vary significantly. Such exposures may take the form of listed and unlisted equity shares, linked equity fund investments, private equity and venture capital investments, preference shares classified as equity and Federal Home Loan Stock.

The commercial decision to invest in equity holdings is taken by GEMC, GCC or an appropriate sub-committee within delegated authority. Investments of a strategic nature are referred to GEMC for approval; those involving the purchase or sale by the Group or subsidiary companies also require Board approval, after consideration by GEMC.

Treasury (audited)
The RBS Group’s treasury activities include its money market business and the management of internal funds flow within the RBS Group’s businesses. In addition, this includes GBM trading portfolio assets that have been reclassified to available-for-sale. Money market portfolios include cash instruments (principally debt securities, loans and deposits) and related hedging derivatives.


Non-trading interest rate VaR (audited)
Non-trading interest rate VaR for the Groups treasury and retail and commercial banking activities was £117.8 million at 31 December 2008 (2007 £65.1 million) with the major exposure being to changes in longer term US dollar interest rates. During 2008, the maximum VaR was £171.7 million (2007 £71.8 million), the minimum was £75.9 million (2007  £51.5 million) and the average was £109.6 million (2007 £62.9 million).

Citizens Financial Group (CFG) was the main contributor to overall non-trading interest rate VaR. CFG manages non-trading interest rate risk with the objective of minimising accrual accounted earnings volatility.

To do so it uses a variety of income simulation and valuation risk measures that more effectively capture the risk to earnings due to mortgage prepayment and competitive deposit pricing behaviour than a VaR based methodology would. This balance sheet management approach is common for US retail banks. Interest rate risk in the banking book is managed by a professional treasury function which optimises the yield, whilst staying within approved limits on interest rate risk, liquidity and capitalisation.

Mortgages, home equity loans and mortgage-backed securities (MBS) comprise a large portion of CFG’s assets. In the US, mortgage and home equity customers may prepay loans without penalty. However, under the requirements of FAS 133, the risk that they may do so cannot be hedged in a cost effective manner and must be born by the lender. Prepayment risk is a primary component of interest rate risk in the banking book at CFG.
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
         
Carrying
         
Carrying
 
   
Principal(1)
   
amount
   
Principal(1)
   
amount
 
   
US$m
   
US$m
   
US$m
   
US$m
 
Total MBS and mortgages
    63,542       63,165       69,948       69,672  
MBS – total
                               
– high grade (AA or AAA rated)
    26,268       25,893       26,848       26,572  
– rated C to A
    602       600              
MBS – commercial
                               
– high grade (AA or AAA rated)
    2,253       2,089       2,205       2,211  
MBS – retail
                               
– high grade (AA or AAA rated)
    24,015       23,804       24,643       24,361  
– rated C to A
    602       600              
Residential mortgage and home equity loans (non-securitised, fixed rate and ARM, prepayable)
    36,672       36,672       43,100       43,100  

Note:
(1) 
The principal on MBS is the redemption amount on maturity or, in the case of  an amortising instrument, the sum of  future redemption amounts through the residual life of  the security.

 
39

 
In addition to VaR, the following measures are reported to CFG ALCO, Group Treasury, GALCO and the Board:

The sensitivity of net accrual earnings to a variety of parallel and non-parallel movements in interest rates.
 
Economic value of equity (EVE) sensitivity to a series of parallel movements in interest rates. EVE is only used within CFG and to meet the FSA prescribed standard shock test of +/- 200bp parallel shock.
 
   
Percent increase/
decrease in CFG EVE(1)
 
         
2% parallel
 
         
downward
 
   
2% parallel
   
movement in
 
   
upward
   
US interest
 
   
movement in
   
rates (No
 
   
US interest
   
negative rates
 
(Unaudited)  
rates
   
allowed)
 
Period end
    (0.7 )     (19.0 )
Maximum
    (18.2 )     (20.8 )
Minimum
    (0.7 )     (4.4 )
Average
    (12.2 )     (12.6 )

Note:
(1)
Economic value of equity is the net present value of assets and liabilities calculated by discounting expected cash flows of each instrument over its expected life. Risk to EVE is quantified by calculating the impact of interest rate changes on the net present value of equity and is expressed as a percentage of CFG regulatory capital.


Currency risk (audited)

The RBS Group does not maintain material non-trading open currency positions other than the structural foreign currency translation exposures arising from its investments in foreign subsidiaries and associated undertakings and their related currency funding. The RBS Groups policy in relation to structural positions is to match fund the structural foreign currency exposure arising from net asset value, including goodwill, in foreign subsidiaries, equity accounted investments and branches, except where doing so would materially increase the sensitivity of either the RBS Groups or the subsidiarys regulatory capital ratios to currency movements. The policy requires structural foreign exchange positions to be reviewed regularly by GALCO. Foreign exchange differences arising on the translation of foreign operations are recognised directly in equity together with the effective portion of foreign exchange differences arising on hedging instruments.

Equity classification of foreign currency denominated preference share issuances requires that these shares be held on the balance sheet at historic cost. Consequently, these share issuances have the effect of increasing the RBS Groups structural foreign currency position.
 
The table below sets out the Groups structural foreign currency exposures.
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
 Net investments in foreign operations
   
 Net investment hedges
   
 Structural foreign currency exposures
   
 Net investments in foreign operations
   
 Net investment hedges
   
 Structural foreign currency exposures
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
US dollar
    16,710       (4,302 )     12,408       13,919       (2,437 )     11,482  
Euro
    4,571       (617 )     3,954       3,483             3,483  
Swiss franc
    912       (912 )           563       (561 )     2  
Other non-sterling
    877       (844 )     33       185       (153 )     32  
      23,070       (6,675 )     16,395       18,150       (3,151 )     14,999  

Retranslation gains and losses on the Groups net investments in operations together with those on instruments hedging these investments are recognised directly in equity. Changes in foreign currency exchange rates will affect equity in proportion to the structural foreign currency exposure. A five percent strengthening in foreign currencies would result in a gain of £820 million (2007 £750 million) recognised in equity, while a five per cent weakening in foreign currencies would result in a loss of £780 million (2007 £715 million) recognised in equity. These movements in equity would offset retranslation effects on the Group's foreign currency denominated risk weighted assets, reducing the sensitivity of the Group's Tier 1 capital ratio to movements in foreign currency exchange rates.
 
Equity risk (audited)
Equity positions are measured at fair value. Fair value calculations are based on available market prices wherever possible. In the event that market prices are not available, fair value is based on appropriate valuation techniques or management estimates.

The types, nature and amounts of exchange-traded exposures, private equity exposures, and other exposures vary significantly. Such exposures may take the form of listed and unlisted equity shares, linked equity fund investments, private equity and venture capital investments, preference shares classified as equity and Federal Home Loan Stock.

 
40


Credit market and related exposures (unaudited)
These disclosures provide information on certain of the Groups business activities affected by the unprecedented market events of 2008, the majority of which arose within Global Banking & Markets (GBM), and are focussed around GBMs credit markets activities, including the conduit business, which have been particularly affected by the widespread market disruptions, as well as similar exposures in US Retail & Commercial (Citizens).

Market background (unaudited)
Overall, 2008 has been characterised by rapid dislocation in financial markets. In many cases, the dramatic liquidity squeeze and rise in funding costs for financial institutions has resulted in reluctance or inability of market participants to transact, and has adversely affected the performance of most financial institutions globally, including the Group. Stock markets have experienced extraordinary falls, and levels of volatility have been at record highs. Commodity prices have reduced sharply in the second half of the year, and credit spreads continued to widen. Market perception of counterparty risk increased and the failure of major credit protection providers caused fair value losses for the Group and other market participants and further increased the costs of mitigating credit exposure. Sustained falls globally in both residential and commercial real estate prices, fund valuations and worsening loan performance combined with a sustained lack of liquidity in the market, resulted in a greater amount of assets being valued at significantly lower prices.

The first quarter of 2008 saw a continuation of credit and liquidity shortages experienced during 2007, culminating in the collapse of Bear Stearns in March. The centre of the credit issues remained the ABS market with worsening US economic data supporting higher levels of default expectation in the property market. However, these default expectations started to go beyond the sub-prime market with Alt A and other non-conforming classes of loans particularly seeing significant price deterioration. In addition, wider economic concerns led to heavy fair value losses in the commercial mortgage backed securities market, in corporate debt and in leveraged loan exposures. Following this tightening of conditions, the Group incurred significant losses in March and the holding company took steps in April to materially strengthen its capital base through a £12 billion rights issue which was completed in June.
 
During the second quarter ABS prices initially rallied and steadied, however towards the end of the quarter a negative house price trend in the UK became clear, and in the US, market reaction to sub-prime mortgages extended to prime and near prime lending. Corporate credit spreads followed a similar pattern reacting to rising oil prices, inflationary pressures and continuing high LIBOR despite base rate cuts to 5% in April 2008.

Credit spreads continued to widen across the market through the third quarter and liquidity levels reduced further, resulting in pressure on banks and economies worldwide. This culminated in the demise of Lehman Brothers in September and further market consolidation and global state intervention to provide support to the banking sector.

During the fourth quarter there was a continued lack of confidence in the inter-bank market, with demand for stable investments resulting in US treasuries reaching negative spreads. Corporate and ABS prices fell further particularly in the last two months of the year increasing pressure on banks capital positions. The year concluded with S&P downgrading the credit ratings of eleven global banks, including the Group.

Asset-backed exposures (audited)
Significant risk concentrations
The Groups credit markets activities gives rise to risk concentrations that have been particularly affected by the market turmoil experienced since the second half of 2007. The Group structures, originates, distributes and trades debt in the form of loan, bond and derivative instruments in all major currencies and debt capital markets in North America, Western Europe, Asia and major emerging markets.

During 2008, certain assets identified as being high risk were also transferred to a centrally managed asset unit, set up to provide specific management of this portfolio of higher risk assets. Transferred assets are predominantly ABS and associated protection purchased from monoline insurers and other counterparties.
 
 
41

 
The table below summarises, for the Group, the net exposures and balance sheet carrying values of  these securities by measurement classification.
 
   
Held-for-trading
   
Available-for-sale
   
Loans and receivables
   
Designated at fair value
   
All ABS
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
Net exposure
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
RMBS
    20,932       30,616       26,039       12,495       2,248             1             49,220       43,111  
CMBS
    908       2,870       917       409       1,151       500                   2,976       3,779  
CDOs/CLOs
    1,790       4,722       2,225       20       1,141                   16       5,156       4,758  
Other ABS
    195       2,996       3,208       679       3,375                   186       6,778       3,861  
Total
    23,825       41,204       32,389       13,603       7,915       500       1       202       64,130       55,509  
                                                                                 
                                                                                 
Carrying value
                                                                               
RMBS
    24,304       32,794       26,381       12,501       2,248             1             52,934       45,295  
CMBS
    2,431       2,969       938       409       1,151       500                   4,520       3,878  
CDOs/CLOs
    7,531       9,568       5,525       20       1,141                   17       14,197       9,605  
Other ABS
    1,505       5,275       3,208       679       3,375                   186       8,088       6,140  
Total
    35,771       50,606       36,052       13,609       7,915       500       1       203       79,739       64,918  

Notes:
(1)
Net exposure is carrying value after taking account of hedge protection purchased from monolines and other counterparties but excludes the effect of counterparty credit valuation adjustment. The protection provides credit protection against the notional and interest cash flows due to the holders of debt instruments in the event of default by the debt security counterparty. The value of the protection is based on the underlying instrument being protected.
(2)
Carrying value is the amount recorded on the balance sheet.
(3)
Certain instruments have been reclassified from the held-for-trading category to loans and receivables or available-for-sale categories, as permitted by the amendment to IAS 39 issued in October 2008, therefore affecting comparability by measurement classification.

Asset backed securities are securities that represent an interest in an underlying pool of referenced assets. The referenced pool can comprise any assets which attract a set of associated cash flows but are commonly pools of residential or commercial mortgages and, in the case of collateralised debt obligations (CDOs), the referenced pool may be ABS or other classes of assets. The process by which the risks and rewards of the pool are passed on to investors via the issuance of securities with varying seniority is commonly referred to as securitisation.

During 2008, as the problems in the sub-prime sector spread to other asset classes on a global basis and credit spreads widened due to concerns over creditworthiness of underlying assets, securitisation volumes continued to be thin. Over the preceding years Global Banking & Markets (GBM) had established itself as an active arranger of third- party securitisations and a secondary dealer in these securities, and GBM had therefore accumulated assets that became difficult to sell given market conditions.

The Group has exposures to ABS which are predominantly debt securities but can be held in derivative form. These positions had been acquired primarily through the Groups activities in the US leveraged finance market which were expanded during 2007. These include residential mortgage backed securities (RMBS), commercial mortgage backed securities (CMBS), ABS CDOs, collateralised loan obligations (CLOs) and other ABS. In many cases the risk on these assets is hedged via credit derivative protection purchased over the specific asset or relevant ABS indices. The counterparty to some of these hedge transactions are monoline insurers.

The net exposure of the Groups holdings of ABS increased from £55.5 billion at 31 December 2007 to £64.1 billion by 31 December 2008, where underlying reductions have been more than offset by the effect of exchange rates. The net exposure incorporates hedge protection but excludes counterparty credit valuation adjustments. All hedge protection referred to in the credit market and related exposures section relates to economic hedges that do not qualify for hedge accounting.

Through a sustained de-risking exercise, the Group made reductions to the overall risk through a combination of direct asset sales and switching to lower risk assets through trading activities. As a large proportion of the ABS are denominated in US dollars, these reductions in exposure were partially offset due to the movement in the exchange rate against sterling. The majority of the Groups RMBS portfolio at 31 December 2008, in terms of net exposure, was AAA rated guaranteed or effectively guaranteed securities of £33.5 billion of US agency securities.


 
42

 

The table below analyses, for the Group, carrying values of  these debt securities by measurement classification and rating.
 
   
RMBS
                         
               
Prime
                         
   
Sub-prime
   
Non conforming
   
Guaranteed
   
Other
   
CMBS
   
CDOs/CLOs
   
Other ABS
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Held-for-trading
    1,578       352       18,586       3,788       2,431       7,531       1,505       35,771  
Available-for-sale
    899       2,184       14,898       8,400       938       5,525       3,208       36,052  
Loans and receivables
    282       1,482             484       1,151       1,141       3,375       7,915  
Designated at fair value
                      1                         1  
Total
    2,759       4,018       33,484       12,673       4,520       14,197       8,088       79,739  
 
Of  which:
                                                               
AAA rated (1)
    1,132       3,532       33,475       11,174       2,928       9,192       3,189       64,622  
BBB and above rated (1)
    878       338             1,391       1,552       2,810       3,422       10,391  
Non-investment grade (1)
    749       146             106       39       1,512       241       2,793  
Not publicly rated
          2       9       2       1       683       1,236       1,933  
      2,759       4,018       33,484       12,673       4,520       14,197       8,088       79,739  
 
2007
                                                               
Held-for-trading
    4,246       2,884       15,627       10,037       2,969       9,568       5,275       50,606  
Available-for-sale
    7       640       10,533       1,321       409       20       679       13,609  
Loans and receivables
                            500                   500  
Designated at fair value
                                  17       186       203  
Total
    4,253       3,524       26,160       11,358       3,878       9,605       6,140       64,918  
 
Of  which:
                                                               
AAA rated (1)
    1,191       2,733       26,034       10,643       2,820       7,186       3,324       53,931  
BBB and above rated (1)
    2,384       526             557       1,010       1,352       1,179       7,008  
Non-investment grade (1)
    589       146             27       35       248       104       1,149  
Not publicly rated
    89       119       126       131       13       819       1,533       2,830  
      4,253       3,524       26,160       11,358       3,878       9,605       6,140       64,918  

Note:
(1)   Credit ratings are based on those from rating agencies Standard & Poors (S&P), Moodys and Fitch and have been mapped onto S&P scale.
 
Residential mortgage-backed securities (audited)
Residential mortgage backed securities (RMBS) are securities that represent an interest in a portfolio of residential mortgages. Repayments made on the underlying mortgages are used to make payments to holders of the RMBS. The risk of the RMBS will vary primarily depending on the quality and geographic region of the underlying mortgage assets and the credit enhancement of the securitisation structure.

Several tranches of notes are issued, each secured against the same portfolio of mortgages, but providing differing levels of seniority to match the risk appetite of investors. The most junior (or equity) notes will suffer early capital and interest losses experienced by the referenced mortgage collateral, with each more senior note benefiting from the protection provided by the subordinated notes below. Additional credit enhancements may be provided to the holder of senior RMBS notes, including guarantees over the value of the exposures, often provided by monoline insurers.

The main categories of mortgages that serve as collateral to RMBS held by the Group are described below. As can be seen from the tables below, the Groups RMBS portfolio covers a range of geographic locations and there different categories used to classify the exposures depending on the geographical region of the underlying mortgage.
 
 
 
43

 
The categories are described below. The US market has more established definitions of differing underlying mortgage quality and these are used as the basis for the Groups RMBS categorisation.

Sub-prime mortgages: are loans to sub-prime borrowers typically having weakened credit histories that include payment delinquencies, and potentially more severe problems such as court judgements and bankruptcies. They may also display reduced repayment capacity as measured by credit scores, high debt-to-income ratios, or other criteria indicating heightened risk of default.

Non-conforming mortgages (or Alt-A used for US exposures) have a higher credit quality than sub-prime mortgages, but lower than those prime borrowers. Within the US mortgage industry, non-conforming mortgages are those that do not meet the lending criteria for US agency mortgages (described below). For non-US mortgages, judgement is applied in identifying loans with similar characteristics to US nonconforming loans and also include self-certified loans. Alt-A describes a category of mortgages in which lenders consider the risk to be greater than prime mortgages though less than sub-prime. The offered interest rate is usually representative of the associated risk level.

Guaranteed mortgages are mortgages that form part of a mortgaged backed security issuance by a government agency, or in the US, an entity that benefits from a guarantee (direct or indirect) provided by the US government. For US RMBS, this category includes, amongst others, RMBS issued by Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae and Ginnie Mae.

Other prime mortgages are those of a higher credit quality than nonconforming and sub-prime mortgages, and exclude guaranteed mortgages.

The table below shows, for the Group, RMBS net exposures and carrying values by underlying asset type, geographical location of the property that the mortgage is secured against and the year in which the underlying mortgage was originated.
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
               
Prime
                     
Prime
       
   
Sub-prime
   
Non
conforming
   
Guaranteed(3)
   
Other
   
Total
   
Sub-prime
   
Non
Conforming
   
Guaranteed(3)
   
Other
   
Total
 
Net exposure (1)
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
United States
    358       1,106       33,458       5,548       40,470       2,662       2,800       26,005       2,643       34,110  
United Kingdom
    390       2,906       26       2,998       6,320       9       724       149       2,185       3,067  
European Union
    136                   1,784       1,920                         5,787       5,787  
Rest of the World
    300                   210       510       5                   142       147  
      1,184       4,012       33,484       10,540       49,220       2,676       3,524       26,154       10,757       43,111  
 
Carrying values (2)
                                                                               
United States
    1,822       1,112       33,458       5,623       42,015       3,986       2,800       26,005       2,643       35,434  
United Kingdom
    419       2,906       26       4,084       7,435       9       724       155       2,514       3,402  
European Union
    155                   2,725       2,880       3                   6,059       6,062  
Rest of the World
    363                   241       604       255                   142       397  
      2,759       4,018       33,484       12,673       52,934       4,253       3,524       26,160       11,358       45,295  
 
Of which originated in:
                                                                               
- 2004 and earlier
    646       122       5,537       1,647       7,952       922       176       2,548       1,819       5,465  
- 2005
    348       1,372       6,014       4,306       12,040       1,113       437       3,209       2,185       6,944  
- 2006
    1,214       872       1,698       4,023       7,807       1,721       1,188       5,570       4,787       13,266  
- 2007 and later
    551       1,652       20,235       2,697       25,135       497       1,723       14,833       2,567       19,620  
      2,759       4,018       33,484       12,673       52,934       4,253       3,524       26,160       11,358       45,295  

 
Notes:
(1)
Net exposures reflect the effect of  hedge protection purchased from monolines and other counterparties but excludes the effect of  counterparty credit valuation adjustment.
(2)
Carrying values are amounts recorded on the balance sheet.
(3)
Prime guaranteed exposures and carrying values include:
(a)
£5.7 billion (2007 £5.0 billion) guaranteed by US government via Ginnie Mae of  which £0.5 billion (2007 £0.3 billion) are held-for-trading.
(b)
£27.8 billion (2007 £21.0 billion) effectively guaranteed by the US government via its support for Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae of  which £17.9 billion (2007 £15.1 billion) are held-for-trading.

 
 
44

 
The Groups largest concentration of RMBS assets relate to a portfolio of US agency asset backed securities comprising mainly of current year vintage positions of £33.5 billion at 31 December 2008 (2007 £26.2 billion). Due to the US government backing implicit in these securities, the counterparty credit risk exposure is low. Financial markets and economic conditions have been extremely difficult in the US throughout 2008, particularly in the last quarter. Credit conditions have deteriorated and financial markets have experienced widespread illiquidity and elevated levels of volatility due to forced de-leveraging. Transaction activity in the securities portfolio has been reduced due to general market illiquidity. Residential mortgages have been affected by the stress that consumers experienced from depreciating house prices, rising unemployment and tighter credit conditions, resulting in higher levels of delinquencies and foreclosures. In particular, the deteriorating economy and financial markets have negatively impacted the valuation, liquidity, and credit quality of private-label securities.

Citizens maintains an available-for-sale investment securities portfolio to provide high-quality collateral to provide a liquidity buffer and to enhance earnings. The size of the portfolio has been relatively stable through 2008, but both the absolute and relative size (% of earning assets) declined in 2006-2007. The portfolio comprises high credit quality mortgage-backed securities, to ensure both pledgeability and liquidity. The US Government guarantees on MBS, whether explicit or implicit, put most of the portfolio in a secure credit position. The non- agency MBS holdings derive credit support in two ways. Firstly, there is senior and subordinated structuring, and Citizens hold only the most senior tranches. Secondly, there is high quality supporting loan collateral. The collateral quality is evidenced (a) by the vintages, with 82% issued in 2005 and earlier, (b) by the borrowers weighted loan to value (LTV) ratio of 65%, and (c) by the borrowers weighted-average FICO score of 734.

The Group has other portfolios of RMBS from secondary trading activities, warehoused positions previously acquired with the intention of further securitisation and a portfolio of assets from the unwinding of a securities arbitrage conduit. This conduit was established to benefit from the margin between the assets purchased and the notes issued. The majority of these heldfortrading RMBS have been grouped together for management purposes.

Some of these assets (£6.7 billion) were reclassified from held-for- trading category to the loans and receivables (£1.5 billion) and available-for-sale (£5.2 billion) categories during the year.

Overall, the Group has recognised significant fair value losses on RMBS assets during the year due to reduced market liquidity and deteriorating credit ratings of these assets. The Group has reduced its exposure to RMBS predominantly through fair value hedges and asset sales during the year. These decreases in were partially offset by the weakening of sterling relative to the US dollar and the euro.

Commercial mortgage-backed securities (audited)
Commercial mortgages backed securities (CMBS) are securities that are secured by mortgage loans on commercial land and buildings. The securities are structured in the same way as an RMBS but typically the underlying assets referenced will be of greater individual value. The performance of the securities are highly dependent upon the sector of commercial property referenced and the geographical region.

The Group accumulated CMBS for the purpose of securitisation and secondary trading. The largest holding of CMBS arose as a result of the Groups purchase of senior tranches in mezzanine and high grade CMBS structures from third parties. These securities are predominantly hedged with monoline insurers. As a result, the Groups risk is limited to the counterparty credit risk exposure to the hedge. The Group also holds CMBS arising from securitisations of European commercial mortgages originated by the Group.

45

 
Asset-backed collateralised debt and loan obligations (audited)
Collateralised debt obligations (CDOs) are securities whose performance is dependant on a portfolio of  referenced underlying securitised assets. The referenced assets generally consist of  ABS, but may also include other classes of  assets. Collateralised loan obligations represent securities in special purpose entities, the assets of  which are primarily cash flows from underlying leveraged loans.
 
The Groups ABS CDO and CLO net exposures comprised super senior CDOs and other CDOs and CLOs. The Groups CDO exposures were structured by the Group from 2003 to 2007 that were unable to be sold to third parties due to prevailing illiquid markets as well as exposures purchased from third parties some of  which are fully hedged through CDS with other banks or monoline insurers.
 
Super senior CDOs
Super senior CDOs represent the most senior positions in a CDO, having subordination instruments (usually represented by a combination of  equity, mezzanine and senior notes) which absorb losses before the super senior note is affected. Losses will only be suffered by the super senior note holders after a certain threshold of  defaults of  the underlying reference assets has been reached. The threshold is usually referred to in percentage terms of  defaults of  the remaining pool, and known as the ‘attachment point’. These super senior instruments carry an AAA rating at point of  origination or are senior to other AAA rated notes in the same structure. The level of  defaults occurring on recent vintage sub-prime mortgages and other asset classes has been higher than originally expected. This has meant that the subordinate positions have diminished significantly in value, credit quality and rating and, as a result, the super senior tranches of  the CDOs have a higher probability of  suffering losses than at origination. The ratings of  the majority of  the underlying collateral are now below investment grade.
 
Depending on the quality of  the underlying reference assets at issuance, the super senior tranches will be either classified as high grade or mezzanine. The majority of  the Group’s total exposure relates to high grade super senior tranches of  ABS CDOs. The table below summarises, for the Group, the carrying amounts and net exposures after hedge protection of  the super senior CDOs as at 31 December 2008. The collateral rating is determined with reference to S&P ratings where available. Where S&P ratings are not available the lower of Moody’s and Fitch ratings have been used.

         
2008(1)
               
2007
       
   
High grade
   
Mezzanine
   
Total
   
High grade
   
Mezzanine
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Gross exposure
    4,210       3,720       7,930       3,396       3,040       6,436  
Hedges and protection
    (2,525 )     (691 )     (3,216 )     (2,150 )     (1,250 )     (3,400 )
      1,685       3,029       4,714       1,246       1,790       3,036  
Write-downs on net open position
    (1,095 )     (2,885 )     (3,980 )     (147 )     (537 )     (684 )
Net exposure after hedges
    590       144       734       1,099       1,253       2,352  
                                     
   
%
   
%
   
%
   
%
   
%
   
%
 
Average price
    35       6       18       90       70       78  
Underlying RMBS sub-prime assets (origination)
    58       91       79       58       91       79  
Of  which originated in:
                                               
2005 and earlier
    53       23       34       53       23       34  
2006
    41       69       59       41       69       59  
2007
    6       8       7       6       8       7  
Collateral by rating at reporting date: (2)
                                               
AAA
    19             7       36             9  
BBB- and above
    40       5       17       62       31       32  
Non-investment grade
    41       95       76       2       69       59  
Attachment point (3)
    29       46       40       30       46       40  
Attachment point post write down
    75       97       89       40       62       54  

Notes
(1)  
The above table includes data for two trades liquidated in the last quarter of  2008, to provide consistency with comparatives.
(2)  
Credit ratings are based on those from rating agencies Standard & Poors (S&P), Moodys and Fitch and have been mapped onto S&P scale.
(3)  
Attachment point is the minimum level of losses in a portfolio which a tranche is exposed to, as a percentage, of the total notional size of the portfolio. For example, a 5 10% tranche has an attachment point of 5% and a detachment point of 10%. When the accumulated loss of the reference pool is less than 5% of the total initial notional of the pool, the tranche will not be affected. However, when the loss has exceeded 5%, any further losses will be deducted from the tranches notional principal until detachment point, 10%, is reached.
 
46

 
The change in net exposure during the year is analysed below.
   
High grade
   
Mezzanine
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Net exposure at 1 January 2008
    1,099       1,253       2,352  
Net income statement
    (723 )     (1,140 )     (1,863 )
Foreign exchange and other movements
    214       31       245  
Net exposure at 31 December 2008
    590       144       734  


The fair value of these assets has fallen significantly during the period, representing the decline in performance in the underlying reference assets and the lack of an active market for the securities. Some of the Groups holdings have been hedged with monoline counterparties.

The majority of the Groups high grade super senior exposures represent securities retained in CDO structures originated by the Group. At origination, the reference assets of the high grade structures predominantly comprised investment grade tranches of sub-prime residential mortgage securitisations along with other senior tranches of some combination of other ABS assets, including prime and Alt-A RMBS, CMBS, trust preferred ABS, student loan backed ABS and CDO assets. The underlying assets referenced by these super senior securities are primarily more recent vintages (the year the underlying loan was originated), with 6% being 2007. Generally, loans with more recent vintages carry greater discounts, reflecting the market expectation of greater default levels than on earlier loan vintages.

The mezzanine super senior tranches of CDOs have suffered a greater level of price decline than high grade tranches, due to the relative credit quality of the underlying assets. The majority of the Groups mezzanine super senior exposures represent securities retained in CDO structures originated by the Group.

Other CDOs and CLOs
The Groups net exposure to other CDOs and CLOs was £4.4 billion (2007 £2.4 billion) after hedge protection with bank or monoline counterparties and include transfers from ABN AMRO in 2008. The unhedged exposures comprise CDOs representing positions with various types of underlying collateral, rating and vintage characteristics.

The positions hedged with derivative protection from banks include a number of positions referencing early vintages of RMBS and other ABS assets against which it purchased protection from bank counterparties through CDS. The Group therefore has no net exposure to these certain CDOs before credit valuation adjustment. Due to the early vintage, the assets underlying these structures have not deteriorated to the same degree as the more recently issued securities. The protection purchased is from banks as opposed to monoline insurers and the credit valuation adjustment on banks is less than on monoline insurers.

Additionally, the Group has one exposure that, while not structured as a super senior security, incorporates similar risk characteristics. The exposure results from options sold to a third-party conduit structure on a portfolio of ABS. The Group assumes the risk of these securities only after the first loss protection has been eroded. The Group also has protection purchased against the remainder of this exposure through a CDS purchased from a monoline insurer. The Group holds other subordinated note positions in CDO vehicles which have experienced significant reductions in value since inception. The majority of these positions are junior notes that have been fully written down by the Group with no ongoing exposure remaining at the balance sheet date.

Collateralised loan obligations represent securities in special purpose entities the assets of which are primarily cash flows from underlying leveraged loans. The Group has CLO exposures resulting from a number of trading activities. They consist of exposures retained by the Group and from notes purchased from third-party structures. The Group holds super senior securities in two CLO structures which were originated by the Group in 2005 and 2007. The underlying collateral of these structures predominantly references leveraged loans.

£5.5 billion of these assets were reclassified from the held-for-trading category to the loans and receivables (£0.9 billion) and available-for- sale (£4.6 billion) categories during the year.

Other asset backed securities
Other assets backed securities are securities issued from securitisation vehicles, similar to those in RMBS and CMBS structures, which reference cash flow generating assets other than mortgages. The Group has accumulated these assets from a range of trading and funding activities.

47

 
Counterparty valuation adjustments (audited)
Credit valuation adjustments
Credit valuation adjustments (CVAs) represent an estimate of the adjustment to fair value that a market participant would make to incorporate the credit risk inherent in counterparty derivative exposures. During 2008, as credit spreads have widened, there has been a significant increase in the Groups CVA as set out in the table below.
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Monoline insurers
    3,289       452  
CDPCs
    746        
Other counterparties
    1,089       128  
Total CVA adjustments
    5,124       580  


The widening of credit spreads of corporate and financial institution counterparties during the year contributed to a significant increase in the level of CVA adjustments recorded across all counterparties, particularly monoline insurers and credit derivative product companies (CDPCs).

The monoline insurer CVA is calculated on a trade-by-trade basis, and is derived using market observable monoline credit spreads. The majority of the monoline CVA is taken against credit derivatives hedging exposures to ABS. The CDPC CVA is calculated using a similar approach. However, in the absence of market observable credit spreads, the cost of hedging the counterparty risk is estimated by analysing the underlying trades and the cost of hedging expected default losses in excess of the capital available in each vehicle.

The CVA for all other counterparties, including in respect of derivatives with banks, is calculated either on a trade-by-trade basis, reflecting the estimated cost of hedging the risk through credit derivatives, or on a portfolio basis reflecting an estimate of the amount a third party would charge to assume the risk.

Monoline insurers
The Group has purchased protection from monoline insurers, mainly against specific ABS, CDOs and CLOs. Monoline insurers are entities which specialise in providing credit protection against the notional and interest cash flows due to the holders of debt instruments in the event of default by the debt security counterparty. This protection is typically held in the form of derivatives such as credit default swaps (CDS) referencing the underlying exposures held by the Group.

During the year the market value of securities protected by monoline insurers continued to decline as markets deteriorated. As the fair value of the protected assets declined, the fair value of the CDS protection from monoline insurers increased. As the monoline insurers had concentrated their exposures to credit market risks, their perceived credit quality deteriorated as concerns increased regarding their ability to meet their contractual obligations. This resulted in increased levels of CVA being recorded on the purchased protection.

The change in the Groups exposure to monoline insurers during the year has been driven by the increased value of purchased derivative protection and the strengthening of the US$ against sterling as significantly all of the exposures are US$ denominated. The combination of greater exposure and widening credit spreads has increased the level of CVA required. Towards the end of the year the Group reached settlement on a group of contracts with one monoline counterparty, thereby reducing the overall exposure.

48


The tables below analyse, for the Group, holdings of  CDS with monoline counterparties.
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Gross exposure to monolines
    6,531       2,275  
Hedges with bank counterparties
    (518 )      
Credit valuation adjustment
    (3,289 )     (452 )
Net exposure to monolines
    2,724       1,823  
                 
                 
The change in CVA is analysed in the table below:
               
              £m  
At 1 January 2008
            452  
CVA realised in 2008
            (662 )
Net benefit on counterparty hedges
            189  
Foreign currency movements
            748  
Net benefit on reclassified debt securities
            741  
Net income statement effect
            1,821  
At 31 December 2008
            3,289  

         
2008
                     
2007
             
   
Notional
                     
Notional
                   
   
amount
   
Fair value
         
Credit
   
amount
   
Fair value
         
Credit
 
   
protected
   
protected
   
Gross
   
valuation
   
protected
   
protected
   
Gross
   
valuation
 
   
assets
   
assets
   
exposure
   
adjustment
   
assets
   
assets
   
exposure
   
adjustment
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
AAA/AA rated
                                                               
CDO of  RMBS
                            3,475       1,799       1,676       76  
RMBS
    3       2       1             73       73              
CMBS
    96       70       26       12       493       475       18       2  
CLOs
    3,742       2,780       962       435       6,135       5,993       142       13  
Other ABS
    91       41       50       24       1,105       1,052       53       1  
Other
    267       167       100       47       295       269       26        
      4,199       3,060       1,139       518       11,576       9,661       1,915       92  
A/BBB rated
                                                               
CDO of  RMBS
    4,250       964       3,286       1,549                          
RMBS
    90       63       27       10                          
CMBS
    566       251       315       182                          
CLOs
    4,000       2,951       1,049       565                          
Other ABS
    493       221       272       140                          
      9,399       4,450       4,949       2,446                          
Sub-investment grade
                                                               
CDO of  RMBS
    161             161       121       464       167       297       297  
CLOs
    350       268       82       60                          
Other ABS
    1,208       1,037       171       123                          
Other
    155       126       29       21       63             63       63  
      1,874       1,431       443       325       527       167       360       360  
Total
                                                               
CDO of  RMBS
    4,411       964       3,447       1,670       3,939       1,966       1,973       373  
RMBS
    93       65       28       10       73       73              
CMBS
    662       321       341       194       493       475       18       2  
CLOs
    8,092       5,999       2,093       1,060       6,135       5,993       142       13  
Other ABS
    1,792       1,299       493       287       1,105       1,052       53       1  
Other
    422       293       129       68       358       269       89       63  
      15,472       8,941       6,531       3,289       12,103       9,828       2,275       452  
49

 
The Group also has indirect exposure through wrapped securities and assets which have an intrinsic credit enhancement from a monoline insurer. These securities are traded with the benefit of  this credit enhancement and therefore any deterioration in the credit rating of  the monoline is reflected in the fair value of  these assets.
 
Credit derivative product companies
A credit derivative product company (CDPC) is a company that sells protection on credit derivatives. CDPCs are similar to monoline insurers. However, unlike monoline insurers, they are not regulated as insurers. 
 
The Group has £2.6 billion of  gross exposures with CDPCs which predominantly relates to tranched credit derivatives. Tranched credit derivatives have exposure to certain default losses that arise in reference portfolio of  assets. The Group has bought protection on tranched credit derivatives from CDPCs. The reference portfolios of assets are predominantly investment grade loans and bonds. CDS spreads have widened and credit protection has become more valuable and the gross exposure to CDPC counterparties has increased. At the same time, the credit quality of  CDPC counterparties has declined, reflecting the negative impact of  their concentrated credit risk in a declining market. As a result CVA adjustments taken against exposures to these counterparties have increased significantly as described above. 
 
The tables below present a comparison of  the protected assets and the fair value and CVA of  the CDPC protection for the Group.
 
     
2008
     
2007
 
     
£m
     
£m
 
Gross exposure to CDPCs
    2,638       90  
Credit valuation adjustment
    (746 )      
Net exposure to CDPCs
    1,892       90  
 
     
2008
     
2007
 
      Notional amount protected assets       Fair value protected assets         Gross exposure       Credit valuation adjustment       Notional amount protected assets       Fair value protected assets        Gross exposure       Credit valuation adjustment  
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
AAA/AA rated
    12,835       10,435       2,400       663       1,557       1,467       90        
A/BBB rated
    1,707       1,469       238       83                          
      14,542       11,904       2,638       746       1,557       1,467       90        
 
The movement in the year in CDPC CVA is analysed below:
 
                                                              £m  
At 1 January 2008
                                                             
Novations from ABN AMRO                                                             621  
Net effect of counterparty hedges                                                             (38
Foreign currency movement
                                                            20  
Net income statement effect                                                              143  
At 31 December 2008
                                                            746  
 
50

 
Leveraged finance (audited)
Leveraged finance is commonly employed to facilitate corporate finance transactions, such as acquisitions or buy-outs. A bank acting as a lead manager will typically underwrite the loan, alone or with others, and then syndicate the loan to other participants. The Groups syndicated loan book represent amounts retained from underwriting positions where the Group was lead manager or underwriter, in excess of  the Groups intended long term participation.
 
Since the beginning of  the credit market dislocation in the second half  of 2007, investor appetite for leveraged loans and similar risky assets has fallen dramatically, with secondary prices falling due to selling pressure and margins increasing, thus also affecting the primary market.
 
There were a small number of  deals executed in the first half  of  2008 which were much less significant in overall quantum and leverage and which were priced at less than mid-2007 levels. Concerted efforts to sell positions during the first half  of  2008 were only partially successful due to the rapid change in market conditions since origination of  the loans. Most of  the leveraged finance loans were reclassified from the held-for- trading category to loans and receivables category in the second half of  2008.
 
The table below shows the carrying value of  leveraged finance exposures by industry and geography for the Group.
 
               
2008
                           
2007
             
   
Americas
   
UK
   
Europe
   
ROW
   
Total
   
Americas
   
UK
   
Europe
   
ROW
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
TMT
    1,472       628       265       3       2,368       6,824       424       138             7,386  
Retail
    166       550       201       10       927       542       1,318       157       38       2,055  
Industrial
    280       391       164             835       225       1,613       231             2,069  
Other
          552       15       35       602       16       339       163       13       531  
      1,918       2,121       645       48       4,732       7,607       3,694       689       51       12,041  
Of  which:
                                                                               
Held-for-trading
    31       31       41             103       7,607       3,694       689       51       12,041  
Loans and receivables
    1,887       2,090       604       48       4,629                                
      1,918       2,121       645       48       4,732       7,607       3,694       689       51       12,041  
Of  which:
                                                                               
Drawn
    1,887       2,090       634       48       4,659       2,116       3,662       687       51       6,516  
Undrawn
    31       31       11             73       5,491       32       2             5,525  
      1,918       2,121       645       48       4,732       7,607       3,694       689       51       12,041  
                                                                               
The table below analyses the movement in the amounts reported above.
         
                                                           
Held-for trading
   
Loans and receivables
   
Total
 
                                                              £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January 2008
                                                            12,041             12,041  
Reclassifications
                                                            (3,602 )     3,602        
Reclassifications  income effect
                                                      216       16       232  
Additions
                                                            1,853             1,853  
Sales
                                                            (5,708 )           (5,708 )
Realised losses on sale
                                                            (298 )           (298 )
Lapsed/collapsed deals
                                                            (4,153 )           (4,153 )
Changes in fair value
                                                            (618 )           (618 )
Exchange and other movements
                                                      372       1,011       1,383  
At 31 December 2008
                                                            103       4,629       4,732  

 
In addition to the leveraged finance syndicated portfolio discussed above, the Group has £6.1 billion of portfolio positions, mostly to European companies, that have been classified as loans and receivables since origination.
 
51

 
SPEs and conduits (audited)
SPEs
The Group arranges securitisations to facilitate client transactions and undertakes securitisations to sell financial assets or to fund specific portfolios of assets. The Group also acts as an underwriter and depositor in securitisation transactions involving both client and proprietary transactions. In a securitisation, assets, or interests in a pool of assets, are transferred generally to a special purpose entity (SPE) which then issues liabilities to third party investors. SPEs are vehicles established for a specific, limited purpose, usually do not carry out a business or trade and typically have no employees. They take a variety of legal forms trusts, partnerships and companies and fulfil many different functions. As well as being a key element of securitisations, SPEs are also used in fund management activities to segregate custodial duties from the fund management advice provided by the Group. It is primarily the extent of risks and rewards assumed that determines whether these entities are consolidated in the Groups financial statements. The following section aims to address the significant exposures which arise from the Groups activities through specific types of SPEs.
 
The Group sponsors and arranges own-asset securitisations, whereby the sale of assets or interests in a pool of assets into an SPE is financed by the issuance of securities to investors. The pool of assets held by the SPE may be originated by the Group, or (in the case of whole loan programmes) purchased from third parties, and may be of varying credit quality. Investors in the debt securities issued by the SPE are rewarded through credit-linked returns, according to the credit rating of their securities. The majority of securitisations are supported through liquidity facilities, other credit enhancements and derivative hedges extended by financial institutions, some of which offer protection against initial defaults in the pool of assets. Thereafter, losses are absorbed by investors in the lowest ranking notes in the priority of payments. Investors in the most senior ranking debt securities are typically shielded from loss, since any subsequent losses may trigger repayment of their initial principal. The Group also employs synthetic structures, where assets are not sold to the SPE, but credit derivatives are used to transfer the credit risk of the assets to an SPE. Securities may then be issued by the SPE to investors, on the back of the credit protection sold to the Group by the SPE. In general residential and commercial mortgages and credit card receivables form the types of assets generally included in cash securitisations, while corporate loans and commercial mortgages typically serve as reference obligations in synthetic securitisations.

The Group sponsors own-asset securitisations as a way of diversifying funding sources, managing specific risk concentrations, and achieving capital efficiency. The Group purchases the securities issued in own- asset securitisations set up for funding purposes. During 2008, the Group was able to pledge AAA-rated asset-backed securities as collateral for repurchase agreements with major central banks under schemes such as the Bank of Englands Special Liquidity Scheme, launched in April 2008, which allowed banks to temporarily swap high- quality mortgage-backed and other securities for liquid UK Treasury Bills. This practice has contributed to the Groups sources of funding during 2008 in the face of the contraction in the UK market for inter- bank lending and the investor base for securitisations.
 
Conduits
The Group sponsors and administers a number of ABCP conduits. A conduit is an SPE that issues commercial paper and uses the proceeds to purchase or fund a pool of assets. The commercial paper is secured on the assets and is redeemed either by further commercial paper issuance, repayment of assets or liquidity drawings. Commercial paper is typically short-dated the length of time from issuance to maturity of the paper is typically up to three months.

The Groups conduits are multi-seller conduits. In line with market practice, the Group consolidates a conduit where it is exposed to the majority of risks and rewards of ownership of these entities. The Group also extends liquidity commitments to multi-seller conduits sponsored by other banks, but typically does not consolidate these entities as it is not exposed to the majority of the risks and rewards.

The multi-seller conduits were established by the Group for the purpose of providing its clients with access to diversified and flexible funding sources. A multi-seller conduit typically purchases or funds assets originated by the banks clients. The multi-seller conduits form the vast majority of the Groups conduit business. The Group sponsors six multi- seller conduits, four of which were transferred from ABN AMRO in 2008, that finance assets from Europe, North America and Asia-Pacific. The Groups most significant multi-seller conduits have thus far continued to fund the vast majority of their assets solely through ABCP issuance. There were significant disruptions to the liquidity of the financial markets during the year following the bankruptcy filing of Lehman Brothers in September 2008 and this required a small amount of the assets held in certain conduits to be funded by the Group rather than through ABCP issuance. By the end of 2008 there had been an improvement in market conditions, supported by central bank initiatives, which enabled normal ABCP funding to replace this Group funding of the conduits. The average maturity of ABCP issued by the Groups conduits as at 31 December 2008 was 72.4 days (2007 60.4 days).

The total assets held by the Groups sponsored conduits are £31.5 billion (2007 £10.7 billion). Since these liquidity facilities are sanctioned on the basis of total conduit purchase commitments, the liquidity facility commitments will exceed the level of assets held, with the difference representing undrawn commitments. Assets purchased or financed by the multi-seller conduits include auto loans, credit card receivables, residential mortgages, consumer loans and trade receivables. Most of the assets held by the conduits are recorded on the Groups balance sheet as loans and receivables.

The third-party assets financed by the conduits are structured with a significant degree of first-loss credit enhancement provided by the originators of the assets. This credit enhancement, which is specific to each transaction, can take the form of over-collateralisation, excess spread or subordinated loan, and typically ensures the conduit asset has a rating equivalent to at least a single-A credit. In addition and in line with general market practice, the Group provides a small second- loss layer of programme-wide protection to the multi-seller conduits. Given the nature and investment grade equivalent quality of the first loss enhancement provided to the structures, the Group has only a minimal risk of loss on its program wide exposure. The issued ABCP is rated P-1 / A1 by Moodys and Standard & Poors.

52


The Group provides liquidity back-up facilities to the conduits it sponsors. These facilities can be drawn upon by the conduits in the event of a disruption in the ABCP market, or when certain trigger events occur such that ABCP cannot be issued. For a very small number of transactions within two of the multi-seller conduits sponsored by the Group these liquidity facilities have been provided by third-party banks. This typically occurs on transactions where the third-party bank does not use, or have, its own conduit vehicles. Conduit commercial paper issuance is managed such that the spread of maturity dates of the issued ABCP mitigates the short-term contingent liquidity risk of providing back-up facilities. Group limits sanctioned for such facilities as at 31 December 2008 totalled approximately £40.9 billion (2007 £15.8 billion). The Groups maximum exposure to loss on its multi-seller conduits is £38.8 billion (2007 £15.3 billion), being the total amount of the Groups liquidity commitments plus the extent of programme-wide credit enhancements which relate to conduit assets for whom liquidity facilities were provided by third parties.

Exposure from both its consolidated conduits and its involvement with third-party conduits for the Group are set out below.
 
         
2008
               
2007
       
   
Consolidated
               
Consolidated
             
   
conduits
   
Third party
   
Total
   
conduits
   
Third party
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Total assets held by the conduits
    31,473                       10,733                  
Commercial paper issued
    30,833                       10,733                  
Liquidity and credit enhancements:
                                               
deal specific drawn liquidity
                                               
– drawn
    640       3,078       3,718             2,280       2,280  
– undrawn
    38,201       198       38,399       15,272       490       15,762  
programme-wide credit enhancements
    2,072             2,072       552             552  
      40,913       3,276       44,189       15,824       2,770       18,594  
Maximum exposure to loss (1)
    38,841       3,276       42,117       15,272       2,770       18,042  

Note:
(1)  
Maximum exposure to loss is determined as the Groups total liquidity commitments to the conduits and additionally programme-wide credit support which would absorb first loss on transactions where liquidity support is provided by a third party.


Collateral analysis, geographic, profile, credit ratings and weighted average lives of the assets in the assets relating to the consolidated conduits and related undrawn commitments of the Group are set out in the tables below.
 
               
2008
                                       
2007
             
         
Funded
assets
               
 
   
 
         
Funded
assets
               
 
   
 
 
                   
Liquidity
from third
                     
Liquidity
from third
 
                           
Total
                           
Total
 
   
Loans
   
Securities
   
Total
   
Undrawn
   
parties
   
exposure
   
Loans
   
Securities
   
Total
   
Undrawn
   
parties
   
exposure
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Auto loans
    9,670       383       10,053       1,871             11,924       3,119             3,119       1,281       (102 )     4,298  
Credit card receivables
    5,632             5,632       918             6,550       2,123             2,123       501             2,624  
Trade receivables
    2,706             2,706       1,432       (71 )     4,067       223             223       15             238  
Student loans
    2,555             2,555       478       (132 )     2,901       329             329       545       (132 )     742  
Consumer loans
    2,371             2,371       409             2,780       562             562       207             769  
Corporate loans
    430             430       31             461                                      
Mortgages
                                                                                               
Prime
    1,822             1,822       456             2,278       1,663             1,663       153             1,816  
Non-conforming
    2,181             2,181       727             2,908       1,289             1,289       633             1,922  
Commercial
    1,069       507       1,576       61       (23 )     1,614       525       503       1,028       65       (23 )     1,070  
Other
    1,664       483       2,147       985             3,132       397             397       1,138             1,535  
      30,100       1,373       31,473       7,368       (226 )     38,615       10,230       503       10,733       4,538       (257 )     15,014  

53

 
                           
CP funded assets
                         
   
Geographic distribution
     
Credit ratings (S&P equivalent)
 
                                 
Weighted
                     
BBB and
       
   
UK
   
Europe
   
US
   
ROW
   
Total
   
average
   
AAA
   
AA
     
A
   
below
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m    
life
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Auto loans
    801       1,706       7,402       144       10,053       1.7       6,075       868       3,110             10,053  
Credit card receivables
    633             4,999             5,632       0.7       3,465       62       1,959       146       5,632  
Trade receivables
    68       922       1,371       345       2,706       0.8       120       1,025       1,561             2,706  
Student loans
    144             2,411             2,555       0.3       2,296       144       115             2,555  
Consumer loans
    708       1,195       468             2,371       1.7       387       993       923       68       2,371  
Corporate loans
    320       110                   430       1.7                   430             430  
Mortgages
                                                                                       
Prime
                      1,822       1,822       3.7       17       1,806                   1,823  
Non-conforming
    960       1,221                   2,181       4.6       351       368       475       987       2,181  
Commercial
    713       453       74       336       1,576       12.1       274       518       315       469       1,576  
Other
    166       1,198       684       99       2,147       2.1       3       601       1,309       233       2,146  
      4,513       6,805       17,409       2,746       31,473       2.0       12,988       6,385       10,197       1,903       31,473  
                                                                                         
2007
                                                                                       
Auto loans
    2,071       324       724             3,119       1.6       30       1,755       1,334             3,119  
Credit card receivables
    629             1,494             2,123       0.4       443             1,680             2,123  
Trade receivables
    175             48             223       0.8                   223             223  
Student loans
    140             189             329       2.4       184       140       5             329  
Consumer loans
    528             34             562                   229       333               562  
Mortgages
                                                                                       
Prime
                      1,663       1,663       4.4       26       1,638                   1,664  
Non-conforming
    1,133       156                   1,289       5.8       93       610       586             1,289  
Commercial
    729             28       271       1,028       16.4       271       507       250             1,028  
Other
    122       179             96       397       2.7       96             300             396  
      5,527       659       2,517       2,030       10,733       3.7       1,143       4,879       4,711             10,733  
 
 
Structured investment vehicles (unaudited)
The Group does not sponsor any structured investment vehicles.
 
54

 
Investment funds set up and managed by the Group (unaudited)
The Groups investment funds are managed by RBS Asset Management (RBSAM), which is an integrated asset management business, which manages investments on behalf of third-party institutional and high net worth investors, as well as for the Group. RBSAM is active in most traditional asset classes and employs both fund of funds structures and multi-manager strategies. Its offering includes money market funds, long only funds and alternative investment funds.

Money market funds
The Group has established and manages a number of money market funds for its customers. When a new fund is launched, RBSAM as fund manager typically provides a limited amount of seed capital to the funds. RBSAM does not have investments in these funds greater than £25 million. As RBSAM does not have holdings in these funds of significant size and as the risks and rewards of ownership are not with the Group, these funds are not consolidated by the Group.

The funds have been authorised by the Irish Financial Services Regulatory Authority as UCITS pursuant to the UCITS Regulations (UCITS Regulations refer to the European Communities Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities Regulations) and are therefore restricted in the types of investments and borrowings they can make. The structure of the assets within the funds is designed to meet the liabilities of the funds to their investors who have no recourse other than to the assets of the funds. The risks to the Group as a result are restricted to reputational damage if the funds were unable to meet withdrawals when requested on a timely basis or in full.

Money market funds had total assets of £13.6 billion at 31 December 2008 (2007 £11.2 billion). The sub categories of money market funds are:

  
£8.0 billion (2007 £5.1 billion) in Money Funds denominated in sterling, US dollars and euro, which invest in short-dated, highly rated money market securities with the objective of providing security, performance and liquidity.

  
£4.9 billion (2007 £5.5 billion) in multi-manager money market funds denominated in sterling, US dollars and euro, which invest in short dated, highly rated securities.
 
  
£0.7 billion (2007 £0.6 billion) in Money Funds Plus denominated in sterling, US dollars and euro, which invest in longer-dated, highly rated securities with the objective of providing security, enhanced performance and liquidity.

Non-money market funds
RBSAM has also established a number of non-money market funds to enable investors to invest in a range of assets including bonds, equities, hedge funds, private equity and real estate. The Group does not have investments in these funds greater than £200 million. As RBSAM does not have holdings in these funds of significant size and as the risks and rewards of ownership are not with the Group, these funds are not consolidated by the Group.

The non-money market funds had total assets of £18.7 billion at 31 December 2008 (31 December 2007 £19.4 billion). The sub categories of non-money market funds are:

  
£16.0 billion (2007 £17.0 billion) in multi-manager funds, which offer fund of funds products across bond, equity, hedge fund, private equity and real estate asset classes.

  
£1.6 billion (2007 £1.3 billion) in committed capital to private equity investments, which invests primarily in equity and debt securities of private companies.

  
£1.1 billion (2007 £1.1 billion) in credit investments, which invests in various financial instruments.

The structure of the assets within the funds is designed to meet the liabilities of the funds to their investors who have no recourse other than to the assets of the funds. The risks to the Group as a result are restricted to reputational damage if the funds were unable to meet withdrawals when requested on a timely basis or in full, and the Groups own investment in the funds.

The Groups maximum exposure to non-money market funds is represented by the investment in the shares of each fund and was £200 million at 31 December 2008 (2007 £171 million).

55

 
Independent auditors report to the members of  The Royal Bank of  Scotland plc

 
We have audited the financial statements of The Royal Bank of Scotland plc (“the Bank”) and its subsidiaries (together “the Group”) for the year ended 31 December 2008 which comprise the accounting policies, the balance sheets as at 31 December 2008 and 2007, the consolidated income statements, the cash flow statements, the statements of recognised income and expense for each of the three years in the period ended 31 December 2008, the related Notes 1 to 40 and the information identified as audited in the Risk, capital and liquidity management section of the Financial review. These financial statements have been prepared under the accounting policies set out therein.
 
Respective responsibilities of directors and auditors
 
The directors responsibilities for preparing the annual report and the financial statements in accordance with applicable law and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) as adopted by the European Union are set out in the statement of directors responsibilities.

Our responsibility is to audit the financial statements in accordance with relevant legal and regulatory requirements and International Standards on Auditing (UK and Ireland).

We report to you our opinion as to whether the financial statements give a true and fair view and whether the financial statements have been properly prepared in accordance with the Companies Act 1985 and as regards the Groups consolidated financial statements, Article 4 of the IAS Regulation. We also report to you whether in our opinion, the information given in the directors report is consistent with the financial statements.

In addition we report to you if, in our opinion, the Bank has not kept proper accounting records, we have not received all the information and explanations we require for our audit, or if information specified by law regarding directors remuneration and other transactions is not disclosed.

We read the other information contained in the Annual Report and Accounts 2008 as described in the contents section and consider whether it is consistent with the audited financial statements. We consider the implications for our report if we become aware of any apparent misstatements or material inconsistencies with the financial statements. Our responsibilities do not extend to any other information outside the Annual Report and Accounts 2008.

Basis of audit opinion
 
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK and Ireland) issued by the Auditing Practices Board and with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States). An audit includes examination, on a test basis, of evidence relevant to the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. It also includes an assessment of the significant estimates and judgements made by the directors in the preparation of the financial statements and of whether the accounting policies are appropriate to the circumstances of the Bank and the Group, consistently applied and adequately disclosed.
 
We planned and performed our audit so as to obtain all the information and explanations which we considered necessary in order to provide us with sufficient evidence to give reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatement, whether caused by fraud or other irregularity or error. In forming our opinion, we also evaluated the overall adequacy of the presentation of information in the financial statements.

The Group is not required to have, nor were we engaged to perform, an audit of its internal control over financial reporting. Our audit included consideration of internal control over financial reporting as a basis for designing audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the Groups internal control over financial reporting. Accordingly, we express no such opinion.

UK opinion
 
In our opinion:

  
the Group financial statements give a true and fair view, in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union, of the state of the Groups affairs as at 31 December 2008 and of its loss and cash flows for the year then ended;

  
the Bank financial statements give a true and fair view, in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union as applied in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act 1985, of the state of affairs of the Bank as at 31 December 2008;

  
the financial statements have been properly prepared in accordance with the Companies Act 1985 and, as regards the Group financial statements, Article 4 of the IAS Regulation; and

  
the information given in the directors report is consistent with the financial statements.
 
Separate opinion in relation to IFRS
 
As explained in the accounting policies, the Group, in addition to complying with its legal obligation to comply with IFRS as adopted by the European Union, has also complied with IFRS as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB).

In our opinion the financial statements give a true and fair view, in accordance with IFRS, of the state of the Groups affairs as at 31 December 2008 and of its loss and cash flows for the year then ended.

US opinion
 
In our opinion, the financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Group as at 31 December 2008 and 2007 and the results of its operations and its cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended 31 December 2008, in accordance with IFRS as adopted for use in the European Union and IFRS as issued by the IASB.

The financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2007 were restated for the matters disclosed in Note 1 of the Accounting policies.

Deloitte LLP
Chartered Accountants and Registered Auditors
Edinburgh, United Kingdom
25 March 2009

56

 

Consolidated income statement for the year ended 31 December 2008
 
         
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
   
Note
    £m      £m      £m   
Interest receivable
    1       31,413       28,310       24,319  
Interest payable
    1       (17,904 )     (17,194 )     (13,927 )
Net interest income
    1       13,509       11,116       10,392  
Fees and commissions receivable
    2       7,483       7,519       7,060  
Fees and commissions payable
    2       (1,733 )     (1,496 )     (1,426 )
(Loss)/income from trading activities
    2       (5,583 )     1,142       2,543  
Other operating income
    2       2,181       4,026       2,999  
Non-interest income
            2,348       11,191       11,176  
Total income
            15,857       22,307       21,568  
Staff  costs
    3       5,973       6,181       6,280  
Premises and equipment
    3       1,760       1,521       1,405  
Other administrative expenses
    3       2,759       2,147       2,241  
Depreciation and amortisation
    3       1,562       1,438       1,415  
Write-down of  goodwill and other assets
    3       8,144              
Operating expenses
    3       20,198       11,287       11,341  
(Loss)/profit before impairment
            (4,341 )     11,020       10,227  
Impairment
    11       4,706       1,865       1,873  
Operating (loss)/profit before tax
            (9,047 )     9,155       8,354  
Tax
    6       (505 )     1,903       2,433  
(Loss)/profit for the year
            (8,542 )     7,252       5,921  
                                 
(Loss)/profit attributable to:
                               
Minority interests
            208       53       45  
Preference shareholders
    7       638       331       252  
Ordinary shareholders
            (9,388 )     6,868       5,624  
              (8,542 )     7,252       5,921  

The accompanying notes on pages 71 to 135, the accounting policies on pages 61 to 70 and the audited sections of the Financial review: Risk, capital and liquidity management on pages 15 to 55 form an integral part of these financial statements.

57



Balance sheets at 31 December 2008

 
         
Group
   
Bank
 
               
Restated
         
Restated
 
         
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Note
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                     
Cash and balances at central banks
    10       6,806       5,559       3,714       3,333  
Loans and advances to banks
    10       79,387       96,346       91,717       91,982  
Loans and advances to customers
    10       619,503       551,449       327,040       329,147  
Debt securities subject to repurchase agreements
    27       75,660       75,001       70,206       30,633  
Other debt securities
            102,106       89,431       89,492       76,617  
Debt securities
    13       177,766       164,432       159,698       107,250  
Equity shares
    14       2,691       5,509       1,020       4,019  
Investments in Group undertakings
    15                   26,814       22,210  
Settlement balances
            10,871       5,326       5,335       2,046  
Derivatives
    12       937,457       205,975       938,505       207,913  
Intangible assets
    16       12,591       17,761       136       295  
Property, plant and equipment
    17       16,628       13,025       2,368       2,116  
Deferred taxation
    21       2,833       240       1,323       319  
Prepayments, accrued income and other assets
    18       11,397       6,116       5,930       1,680  
Total assets
            1,877,930       1,071,738       1,563,600       772,310  
                                         
Liabilities
                                       
Deposits by banks
    10       181,982       151,508       201,266       196,968  
Customer accounts
    10       453,129       442,982       229,266       197,926  
Debt securities in issue
    10       179,942       130,132       115,149       79,877  
Settlement balances and short positions
    19       45,957       53,849       29,361       33,677  
Derivatives
    12       909,105       203,072       911,174       204,234  
Accruals, deferred income and other liabilities
    20       16,685       12,167       9,618       5,783  
Retirement benefit liabilities
    4       1,446       334       23       11  
Deferred taxation
    21       2,483       2,063              
Subordinated liabilities
    22       39,951       27,796       33,698       22,745  
Total liabilities
            1,830,680       1,023,903       1,529,555       741,221  
                                         
Equity
                                       
Minority interests
    23       1,292       152              
Equity owners
    25       45,958       47,683       34,045       31,089  
Total equity
            47,250       47,835       34,045       31,089  
                                         
                                         
Total liabilities and equity
            1,877,930       1,071,738       1,563,600       772,310  


The accompanying notes on pages 71 to 135, the accounting policies on pages 61 to 70 and the audited sections of the Financial review: Risk, capital and liquidity management on pages 15 to 55 form an integral part of these financial statements.

The accounts were approved by the Board of  directors on 25 March 2009 and signed on its behalf  by:

 
Philip Hampton
Stephen Hester
Guy Whittaker
Chairman
Group Chief  Executive
Group Finance Director

58


Statements of recognised income and expense for the year ended 31 December 2008

 
   
  Group
   
 Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Available-for-sale investments
                                               
Net valuation (losses)/gains taken direct to equity
    (2,585 )     511       340       (2,592 )     249       122  
Net (profit)/loss taken to income on sales
    (11 )     (465 )     (196 )     49       (231 )     (71 )
                                                 
Cash flow hedges
                                               
Net (losses)/gains taken direct to equity
    (461 )     (408 )     (108 )     1,292       60       (138 )
Net losses/(gains) taken to earnings
    185       (141 )     (143 )     (54 )     25       2  
                                                 
Exchange differences on translation of foreign operations
    4,968       9       (1,347 )     (331 )     5       1  
Actuarial (losses)/gains on defined benefit plans
    (1,716 )     2,153       1,776       (2 )     2       2  
Income/(expense) before tax on items recognised direct in equity
    380       1,659       322       (1,638 )     110       (82 )
Tax on items recognised direct in equity
    1,627       (449 )     (512 )     372       (34 )     13  
Net income/(expense) recognised direct in equity
    2,007       1,210       (190 )     (1,266 )     76       (69 )
(Loss)/profit for the year
    (8,542 )     7,252       5,921       (1,140 )     7,255       3,519  
Total recognised income and expense for the year
    (6,535 )     8,462       5,731       (2,406 )     7,331       3,450  
                                                 
Attributable to:
                                               
Equity shareholders
    (7,087 )     8,420       5,756       (2,406 )     7,331       3,450  
Minority interests
    552       42       (25 )                  
      (6,535 )     8,462       5,731       (2,406 )     7,331       3,450  
 
The accompanying notes on pages 71 to 135, the accounting policies on pages 61 to 70 and the audited sections of the Financial review: Risk, capital and liquidity management on pages 15 to 55 form an integral part of these financial statements.
 
59



Cash flow statements for the year ended 31 December 2008
 
         
Group
   
Bank
 
         
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
   
Note
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Operating activities
                                                     
Operating (loss)/profit before tax
          (9,047 )     9,155       8,354       (2,204 )     7,759       4,039  
                                                       
Adjustments for:
                                                     
Depreciation and amortisation
          1,562       1,438       1,415       483       485       390  
Write-down of  goodwill and other assets
          8,144                   215              
Interest on subordinated liabilities
          1,694       1,452       1,161       1,487       1,200       878  
Charge for defined benefit pension schemes
          351       479       578       8       5       8  
Cash contribution to defined benefit pension schemes
          (491 )     (536 )     (533 )     (8 )     (16 )     (1 )
Elimination of  foreign exchange differences
          (20,997 )     (2,137 )     4,515       (16,892 )     (2,034 )     1,345  
Other non-cash items
          4,905       (833 )     (1,134 )     4,835       (575 )     218  
Net cash (outflow)/inflow from trading activities
          (13,879 )     9,018       14,356       (12,076 )     6,824       6,877  
Changes in operating assets and liabilities
          2,845       6,869       3,292       41,418       8,578       16,815  
Net cash flows from operating activities before tax
          (11,034 )     15,887       17,648       29,342       15,402       23,692  
Income taxes (paid)/received
          (886 )     (1,802 )     (2,122 )     83       (526 )     (298 )
Net cash flows from operating activities
    30       (11,920 )     14,085       15,526       29,425       14,876       23,394  
                                                         
Investing activities
                                                       
Sale and maturity of  securities
            37,877       23,775       25,810       30,455       17,268       15,240  
Purchase of  securities
            (50,360 )     (26,160 )     (17,803 )     (80,693 )     (20,726 )     (10,609 )
Sale of  property, plant and equipment
            2,363       5,596       2,926       90       857       180  
Purchase of  property, plant and equipment
            (5,153 )     (3,886 )     (3,938 )     (719 )     (449 )     (509 )
Net investment in business interests and intangible assets
            (908 )     (430 )     (19 )     (3,264 )     (590 )     (445 )
Net cash flows from investing activities
    31       (16,181 )     (1,105 )     6,976       (54,131 )     (3,640 )     3,857  
                                                         
Financing activities
                                                       
Issue of  ordinary shares
            10,000                   10,000              
Issue of  equity preference shares
                  3,650       1,092             3,650       1,092  
Issue of  subordinated liabilities
            5,055       1,018       3,027       5,055       968       2,936  
Proceeds of  minority interests issued
            812             427                    
Redemption of  minority interests
            (140 )     (247 )     (81 )                  
Repayment of  subordinated liabilities
            (1,035 )     (1,708 )     (1,318 )     (1,035 )     (1,288 )     (672 )
Dividends paid
            (4,722 )     (2,362 )     (3,531 )     (4,638 )     (2,331 )     (3,502 )
Interest on subordinated liabilities
            (1,511 )     (1,431 )     (1,181 )     (1,325 )     (1,173 )     (890 )
Net cash flows from financing activities
            8,459       (1,080 )     (1,565 )     8,057       (174 )     (1,036 )
Effects of  exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents
            15,295       2,714       (3,475 )     12,849       2,601       (2,036 )
                                                         
Net (decrease)/increase in cash and cash equivalents
            (4,347 )     14,614       17,462       (3,800 )     13,663       24,179  
Cash and cash equivalents 1 January
            84,761       70,147       52,685       77,249       63,586       39,407  
Cash and cash equivalents 31 December
            80,414       84,761       70,147       73,449       77,249       63,586  
 
 
The accompanying notes on pages 71 to 135, the accounting policies on pages 61 to 70 and the audited sections of the Financial review: Risk, capital and liquidity management on pages 15 to 55 form an integral part of these financial statements.


 
60


 

 
1. Presentation of accounts 
The accounts, which should be read in conjunction with the Directors report, are prepared on a going concern basis and in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), and interpretations issued by the International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee of the IASB (together “IFRS”) as adopted by the European Union (EU). The EU has not adopted the complete text of IAS 39 'Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement'; it has relaxed some of the standard's hedging requirements. The Group has not taken advantage of this relaxation and has adopted IAS 39 as issued by the IASB: the Groups financial statements are prepared in accordance with IFRS as issued by the IASB. The date of transition to IFRS for the Group and the Bank and the date of their opening IFRS balance sheets was 1 January 2004.
 
The Group adopted IFRS 8 Operating Segments with effect from 1 January 2008. Early adoption of IFRS 8 has not materially affected segmental disclosures.
 
In October 2008, the IASB issued, and the European Union endorsed, amendments to IAS 39 Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement to permit the reclassification of financial assets out of the held-for-trading (HFT) and available-for-sale (AFS) categories subject to certain restrictions. Transfers must be made at fair value and this fair value becomes the instruments new cost or amortised cost. The amendments are effective from 1 July 2008. Reclassifications made before 1 November 2008 were backdated to 1 July 2008; subsequent reclassifications were effective from the date the reclassification was made.
 
The Group has reclassified certain loans and debt securities out of the held-for-trading and available-for-sale categories into the loans and receivables category. It has also reclassified certain debt securities out of the held-for-trading category into the available-for-sale category. The balance sheet values of these assets, the effect of the reclassification on the income statement and the impairment losses relating to these assets are shown in Note 10 Financial instruments on pages 91 and 92.
 
The 2007 comparative amounts have been restated for the netting of certain derivative asset and derivative liability balances with the London Clearing House, as described in Note 12.
 
The Bank is incorporated in the UK and registered in Scotland. The accounts are prepared on the historical cost basis except that the following assets and liabilities are stated at their fair value: derivative financial instruments, held-for-trading financial assets and financial liabilities, financial assets and financial liabilities that are designated as at fair value through profit or loss, available-for-sale financial assets and investment property. Recognised financial assets and financial liabilities in fair value hedges are adjusted for changes in fair value in respect of the risk that is hedged.
 
The Bank accounts are presented in accordance with the Companies Act 1985.
 
2. Basis of consolidation
The consolidated financial statements incorporate the financial statements of the Bank and entities (including certain special purpose entities) that continue to be controlled by the Group (its subsidiaries). Control exists where the Group has the power to govern the financial and operating policies of the entity; generally conferred by holding a majority of voting rights. On acquisition of a subsidiary, its identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent liabilities are included in the consolidated accounts at their fair value. Any excess of the cost (the fair value of assets given, liabilities incurred or assumed and equity instruments issued by the Group plus any directly attributable costs) of an acquisition over the fair value of the net assets acquired is recognised as goodwill. The interest of minority shareholders is stated at their share of the fair value of the subsidiarys net assets.

The results of subsidiaries acquired are included in the consolidated income statement from the date control passes until the Group ceases to control them through sale or significant change in circumstances.

All intra-group balances, transactions, income and expenses are eliminated on consolidation. The consolidated accounts are prepared using uniform accounting policies.

3. Revenue recognition
Interest income on financial assets that are classified as loans and receivables, available-for-sale or held-to-maturity and interest expense on financial liabilities other than those at fair value through profit or loss are determined using the effective interest method. The effective interest method is a method of calculating the amortised cost of a financial asset or financial liability (or group of financial assets or liabilities) and of allocating the interest income or interest expense over the expected life of the asset or liability. The effective interest rate is the rate that exactly discounts estimated future cash flows to the instruments initial carrying amount. Calculation of the effective interest rate takes into account fees payable or receivable, that are an integral part of the instruments yield, premiums or discounts on acquisition or issue, early redemption fees and transaction costs. All contractual terms of a financial instrument are considered when estimating future cash flows.

Financial assets and financial liabilities held-for-trading or designated as at fair value through profit or loss are recorded at fair value. Changes in fair value are recognised in profit or loss together with dividends and interest receivable and payable.

Commitment and utilisation fees are determined as a percentage of the outstanding facility. If it is unlikely that a specific lending arrangement will be entered into, such fees are taken to profit or loss over the life of the facility otherwise they are deferred and included in the effective interest rate on the advance.

61


Accounting policies continued

 
Fees in respect of services are recognised as the right to consideration accrues through the provision of the service to the customer. The arrangements are generally contractual and the cost of providing the service is incurred as the service is rendered. The price is usually fixed and always determinable. The application of this policy to significant fee types is outlined below.

Payment services: this comprises income received for payment services including cheques cashed, direct debits, Clearing House Automated Payments (the UK electronic settlement system) and BACS payments (the automated clearing house that processes direct debits and direct credits). These are generally charged on a per transaction basis. The income is earned when the payment or transaction occurs. Charges for payment services are usually debited to the customers account, monthly or quarterly in arrears. Accruals are raised for services provided but not charged at period end.

Card related services: fees from credit card business include:

Commission received from retailers for processing credit and debit card transactions: income is accrued to the income statement as the service is performed.

Interchange received: as issuer, the Group receives a fee (interchange) each time a cardholder purchases goods and services. The Group also receives interchange fees from other card issuers for providing cash advances through its branch and Automated Teller Machine networks. These fees are accrued once the transaction has taken place.

An annual fee payable by a credit card holder is deferred and taken to profit or loss over the period of the service i.e. 12 months.

Insurance brokerage: this is made up of fees and commissions received from the agency sale of insurance. Commission on the sale of an insurance contract is earned at the inception of the policy as the insurance has been arranged and placed. However, provision is made where commission is refundable in the event of policy cancellation in line with estimated cancellations.

Investment management fees: fees charged for managing investments are recognised as revenue as the services are provided. Incremental costs that are directly attributable to securing an investment management contract are deferred and charged as expense as the related revenue is recognised.

4. Pensions and other post-retirement benefits
The Group provides post-retirement benefits in the form of pensions and healthcare plans to eligible employees.

For defined benefit schemes, scheme liabilities are measured on an actuarial basis using the projected unit credit method and discounted at a rate that reflects the current rate of return on a high quality corporate bond of equivalent term and currency to the scheme liabilities. Scheme assets are measured at their fair value. Any surplus or deficit of scheme assets over liabilities is recognised in the balance sheet as an asset (surplus) or liability (deficit). The current service cost and any past service costs together with the expected return on scheme assets less the unwinding of the discount on the scheme liabilities is charged to operating expenses. Actuarial gains and losses are recognised in full in the period in which they occur outside profit or loss and presented in the statement of recognised income and expense.

Contributions to defined contribution pension schemes are recognised in the income statement when payable.

5. Intangible assets and goodwill
Intangible assets that are acquired by the Group are stated at cost less accumulated amortisation and impairment losses. Amortisation is charged to profit or loss over the assets estimated economic lives using methods that best reflect the pattern of economic benefits and is included in depreciation and amortisation. The estimated useful economic lives are as follows:

Core deposit intangibles
6 to 10 years
   
Other acquired intangibles
5 to 10 years
   
Computer software
3 to 5 years

Expenditure on internally generated goodwill and brands is written-off as incurred. Direct costs relating to the development of internal-use computer software are capitalised once technical feasibility and economic viability have been established. These costs include payroll, the costs of materials and services, and directly attributable overhead. Capitalisation of costs ceases when the software is capable of operating as intended. During and after development, accumulated costs are reviewed for impairment against the projected benefits that the software is expected to generate. Costs incurred prior to the establishment of technical feasibility and economic viability are expensed as incurred as are all training costs and general overhead. The costs of licences to use computer software that are expected to generate economic benefits beyond one year are also capitalised.

Acquired goodwill being the excess of the cost of an acquisition over the Groups interest in the net fair value of the identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent liabilities of the subsidiary, associate or joint venture acquired is initially recognised at cost and subsequently at cost less any accumulated impairment losses. Goodwill arising on the acquisition of subsidiaries and joint ventures is included in the balance sheet caption Intangible assets and that on associates within their carrying amounts. The gain or loss on the disposal of a subsidiary, associate or joint venture includes the carrying value of any related goodwill.

On implementation of IFRS, the Group did not restate business combinations that occurred before January 2004. Under previous GAAP, goodwill arising on acquisitions after 1 October 1998 was capitalised and amortised over its estimated useful economic life. Goodwill arising on acquisitions before 1 October 1998 was deducted from equity. The carrying amount of goodwill in the Groups opening IFRS balance sheet (1 January 2004) was £12,342 million, its carrying value under previous GAAP.

62



6. Property, plant and equipment
Items of property, plant and equipment are stated at cost less accumulated depreciation and impairment losses. Where an item of property, plant and equipment comprises major components having different useful lives, they are accounted for separately. Property that is being constructed or developed for future use as investment property is classified as property, plant and equipment and stated at cost until construction or development is complete, at which time it is reclassified as investment property.

Depreciation is charged to profit or loss on a straight-line basis so as to write-off the depreciable amount of property, plant and equipment (including assets owned and let on operating leases (except investment property see accounting policy 8)) over their estimated useful lives. The depreciable amount is the cost of an asset less its residual value. Land is not depreciated. Estimated useful lives are as follows:

Freehold and long leasehold buildings
50 years
Short leaseholds
unexpired period of  the lease
Property adaptation costs
10 to 15 years
Computer equipment
up to 5 years
Other equipment
4 to 15 years

Under previous GAAP, the Groups freehold and long leasehold property occupied for its own use was recorded at valuation on the basis of existing use value. The Group elected to use this valuation as at 31 December 2003 as deemed cost for its opening IFRS balance sheet (1 January 2004).

7. Impairment of intangible assets and property, plant and equipment
At each reporting date, the Group assesses whether there is any indication that its intangible assets, or property, plant and equipment are impaired. If any such indication exists, the Group estimates the recoverable amount of the asset and the impairment loss if any. Goodwill is tested for impairment annually or more frequently if events or changes in circumstances indicate that it might be impaired. If an asset does not generate cash flows that are independent from those of other assets or groups of assets, recoverable amount is determined for the cash-generating unit to which the asset belongs. The recoverable amount of an asset is the higher of its fair value less cost to sell and its value in use. Value in use is the present value of future cash flows from the asset or cash-generating unit discounted at a rate that reflects market interest rates adjusted for risks specific to the asset or cash generating unit that have not been reflected in the estimation of future cash flows. If the recoverable amount of an intangible or tangible asset is less than its carrying value, an impairment loss is recognised immediately in profit or loss and the carrying value of the asset reduced by the amount of the loss. A reversal of an impairment loss on intangible assets (excluding goodwill) or property, plant and equipment is recognised as it arises provided the increased carrying value does not exceed that which it would have been had no impairment loss been recognised. Impairment losses on goodwill are not reversed.
 
8. Investment property
Investment property comprises freehold and leasehold properties that are held to earn rentals or for capital appreciation or both. It is not depreciated but is stated at fair value based on valuations by independent registered valuers. Fair value is based on current prices for similar properties in the same location and condition. Any gain or loss arising from a change in fair value is recognised in profit or loss. Rental income from investment property is recognised on a straight-line basis over the term of the lease. Lease incentives granted are recognised as an integral part of the total rental income.

9. Foreign currencies
The Groups consolidated financial statements are presented in sterling which is the functional currency of the Bank.

Transactions in foreign currencies are translated into sterling at the foreign exchange rate ruling at the date of the transaction. Monetary assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies are translated into sterling at the rates of exchange ruling at the balance sheet date. Foreign exchange differences arising on translation are reported in income from trading activities except for differences arising on cash flow hedges and hedges of net investments in foreign operations. Non- monetary items denominated in foreign currencies that are stated at fair value are translated into sterling at foreign exchange rates ruling at the dates the values were determined. Translation differences arising on non-monetary items measured at fair value are recognised in profit or loss except for differences arising on available-for-sale non-monetary financial assets, for example equity shares, which are included in the available-for-sale reserve in equity unless the asset is the hedged item in a fair value hedge.

The assets and liabilities of foreign operations, including goodwill and fair value adjustments arising on acquisition, are translated into sterling at foreign exchange rates ruling at the balance sheet date. The revenues and expenses of foreign operations are translated into sterling at average exchange rates unless these do not approximate to the foreign exchange rates ruling at the dates of the transactions. Foreign exchange differences arising on the translation of a foreign operation are recognised directly in equity and included in profit or loss on its disposal.

10. Leases
Contracts to lease assets are classified as finance leases if they transfer substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership of the asset to the customer. Other contracts to lease assets are classified as operating leases.

Finance lease receivables are stated in the balance sheet at the amount of the net investment in the lease being the minimum lease payments and any unguaranteed residual value discounted at the interest rate implicit in the lease. Finance lease income is allocated to accounting periods so as to give a constant periodic rate of return before tax on the net investment. Unguaranteed residual values are subject to regular review to identify


 
63

 
 
Accounting policies continued


potential impairment. If there has been a reduction in the estimated unguaranteed residual value, the income allocation is revised and any reduction in respect of amounts accrued is recognised immediately.

Rental income from operating leases is credited to the income statement on a receivable basis over the term of the lease. Operating lease assets are included within Property, plant and equipment and depreciated over their useful lives (see accounting policy 6).

11. Provisions
The Group recognises a provision for a present obligation resulting from a past event when it is more likely than not that it will be required to transfer economic benefits to settle the obligation and the amount of the obligation can be estimated reliably.

Provision is made for restructuring costs, including the costs of redundancy, when the Group has a constructive obligation to restructure. An obligation exists when the Group has a detailed formal plan for the restructuring and has raised a valid expectation in those affected by starting to implement the plan or announcing its main features.

If the Group has a contract that is onerous, it recognises the present obligation under the contract as a provision. An onerous contract is one where the unavoidable costs of meeting the obligations under it exceed the expected economic benefits. When the Group vacates a leasehold property, a provision is recognised for the costs under the lease less any expected economic benefits (such as rental income).

Contingent liabilities are possible obligations arising from past events whose existence will be confirmed only by uncertain future events or present obligations arising from past events that are not recognised because either an outflow of economic benefits is not probable or the amount of the obligation cannot be reliably measured. Contingent liabilities are not recognised but information about them is disclosed unless the possibility of any outflow of economic benefits in settlement is remote.

12. Taxation
Provision is made for tax at current enacted rates on taxable profits, arising in income or in equity, taking into account relief for overseas taxation where appropriate. Deferred tax is accounted for in full for all temporary differences between the carrying amount of an asset or liability for accounting purposes and its carrying amount for tax purposes, except in relation to overseas earnings where remittance is controlled by the Group, and goodwill.

Deferred tax assets are only recognised to the extent that it is probable that they will be recovered.

13. Financial assets
On initial recognition, financial assets are classified into held-to-maturity investments; available-for-sale financial assets; held-for-trading; designated as at fair value through profit or loss; or loans and receivables.

Held-to-maturity investments a financial asset may be classified as a held-to-maturity investment only if it has fixed or determinable payments, a fixed maturity and the Group has the positive intention and ability to hold to maturity. Held-to-maturity investments are initially recognised at fair value plus directly related transaction costs. They are subsequently measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method (see accounting policy 3) less any impairment losses.

Held-for-trading a financial asset is classified as held-for-trading if it is acquired principally for sale in the near term, or forms part of a portfolio of financial instruments that are managed together and for which there is evidence of short-term profit taking, or it is a derivative (not in a qualifying hedge relationship). Held-for-trading financial assets are recognised at fair value with transaction costs being recognised in profit or loss. Subsequently they are measured at fair value. Gains and losses on held- for-trading financial assets are recognised in profit or loss as they arise.

Designated as at fair value through profit or loss  financial assets may be designated as at fair value through profit or loss only if such designation (a) eliminates or significantly reduces a measurement or recognition inconsistency; or (b) applies to a group of financial assets, financial liabilities or both that the Group manages and evaluates on a fair value basis; or (c) relates to an instrument that contains an embedded derivative which is not evidently closely related to the host contract.

Financial assets that the Group designates on initial recognition as being at fair value through profit or loss are recognised at fair value, with transaction costs being recognised in profit or loss, and are subsequently measured at fair value. Gains and losses on financial assets that are designated as at fair value through profit or loss are recognised in profit or loss as they arise.

The Group has designated financial assets as at fair value through profit or loss principally: (a) where the assets are economically hedged by derivatives and fair value designation eliminates the measurement inconsistency that would arise if the assets were carried at amortised cost or classified as available-for-sale and (b) financial assets held in the Groups venture capital portfolio managed on a fair value basis.

Loans and receivables non-derivative financial assets with fixed or determinable repayments that are not quoted in an active market are classified as loans and receivables except those that are classified as available-for-sale or as held-for-trading, or designated as at fair value through profit or loss. Loans and receivables are initially recognised at fair value plus directly related transaction costs. They are subsequently measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method (see accounting policy 3) less any impairment losses.



64



Available-for-sale financial assets that are not classified as held-to- maturity; held-for-trading; designated as at fair value through profit or loss; or loans and receivables are classified as available-for-sale. Financial assets can be designated as available-for-sale on initial recognition. Available-for-sale financial assets are initially recognised at fair value plus directly related transaction costs. They are subsequently measured at fair value. Unquoted equity investments whose fair value cannot be measured reliably are carried at cost and classified as available-for-sale financial assets. Impairment losses and exchange differences resulting from retranslating the amortised cost of foreign currency monetary available-for-sale financial assets are recognised in profit or loss together with interest calculated using the effective interest method (see accounting policy 3). Other changes in the fair value of available-for-sale financial assets are reported in a separate component of shareholders equity until disposal, when the cumulative gain or loss is recognised in profit or loss.

Reclassifications  held-for-trading and available-for-sale financial assets that meet the definition of loans and receivables (non-derivative financial assets with fixed or determinable payments that are not quoted in an active market) may be reclassified to loans and receivables if the Group has the intention and ability to hold the financial asset for the foreseeable future or until maturity. The Group typically regards the foreseeable future as twelve months from the date of reclassification. Additionally, held-for- trading financial assets that do not meet the definition of loans and receivables may, in rare circumstances, be transferred to available-for- sale financial assets or to held-to-maturity investments.

Regular way purchases of financial assets classified as loans and receivables are recognised on settlement date; all other regular way purchases are recognised on trade date.

Fair value for a net open position in a financial asset that is quoted in an active market is the current bid price times the number of units of the instrument held. Fair values for financial assets not quoted in an active market are determined using appropriate valuation techniques including discounting future cash flows, option pricing models and other methods that are consistent with accepted economic methodologies for pricing financial assets.

14. Impairment of financial assets
The Group assesses at each balance sheet date whether there is any objective evidence that a financial asset or group of financial assets classified as held-to-maturity, available-for-sale or loans and receivables is impaired. A financial asset or portfolio of financial assets is impaired and an impairment loss incurred if there is objective evidence that an event or events since initial recognition of the asset have adversely affected the amount or timing of future cash flows from the asset.

Financial assets carried at amortised cost if there is objective evidence that an impairment loss on a financial asset or group of financial assets classified as loans and receivables or as held-to- maturity investments has been incurred, the Group measures the amount of the loss as the difference between the carrying amount of the asset or group of assets and the present value of estimated future cash flows from the asset or group of assets discounted at the effective interest rate of the instrument at initial recognition.
 
Impairment losses are assessed individually for financial assets that are individually significant and individually or collectively for assets that are not individually significant. In making collective assessment of impairment, financial assets are grouped into portfolios on the basis of similar risk characteristics. Future cash flows from these portfolios are estimated on the basis of the contractual cash flows and historical loss experience for assets with similar credit risk characteristics. Historical loss experience is adjusted, on the basis of current observable data, to reflect the effects of current conditions not affecting the period of historical experience.

Impairment losses are recognised in profit or loss and the carrying amount of the financial asset or group of financial assets reduced by establishing an allowance for impairment losses. If in a subsequent period the amount of the impairment loss reduces and the reduction can be ascribed to an event after the impairment was recognised, the previously recognised loss is reversed by adjusting the allowance. Once an impairment loss has been recognised on a financial asset or group of financial assets, interest income is recognised on the carrying amount using the rate of interest at which estimated future cash flows were discounted in measuring impairment.

Financial assets carried at fair value when a decline in the fair value of a financial asset classified as available-for-sale has been recognised directly in equity and there is objective evidence that the asset is impaired, the cumulative loss is removed from equity and recognised in profit or loss. The loss is measured as the difference between the amortised cost of the financial asset and its current fair value. Impairment losses on available-for-sale equity instruments are not reversed through profit or loss, but those on available-for-sale debt instruments are reversed, if there is an increase in fair value that is objectively related to a subsequent event.

15. Financial liabilities
On initial recognition financial liabilities are classified into held-for-trading, designated as at fair value through profit or loss, or amortised cost.

A financial liability is classified as held-for-trading if it is incurred principally for the repurchase in the near term, or forms part of a portfolio of financial instruments that are managed together and for which there is evidence of short-term profit taking, or it is a derivative (not in a qualifying hedge relationship). Held-for-trading financial liabilities are recognised at fair value with transaction costs being recognised in profit or loss. Subsequently they are measured at fair value. Gains and losses are recognised in profit or loss as they arise.

Financial liabilities that the Group designates on initial recognition as being at fair value through profit or loss are recognised at fair value, with transaction costs being recognised in profit or loss, and are subsequently measured at fair value. Gains and losses on financial liabilities that are designated as at fair value through profit or loss are recognised in profit or loss as they arise.

Financial liabilities may be designated as at fair value through profit or loss only if such designation (a) eliminates or significantly reduces a measurement or recognition inconsistency; or (b) applies to a group of financial assets, financial liabilities or both that the Group manages and evaluates on a fair value basis; or (c) relates to an instrument that contains an embedded derivative which is not evidently closely related to the host contract.
 
65



Accounting policies continued

 
The principal category of financial liabilities designated as at fair value through profit or loss is structured liabilities issued by the Group: designation significantly reduces the measurement inconsistency between these liabilities and the related derivatives carried at fair value.

All other financial liabilities are measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method (see accounting policy 3).

Fair value for a net open position in a financial liability that is quoted in an active market is the current offer price times the number of units of the instrument held or issued. Fair values for financial liabilities not quoted in an active market are determined using appropriate valuation techniques including discounting future cash flows, option pricing models and other methods that are consistent with accepted economic methodologies for pricing financial liabilities.

16. Loan commitments
Provision is made for loan commitments, other than those classified as held-for-trading, if it is probable that the facility will be drawn and the resulting loan will be recognised at a value less than the cash advanced. Syndicated loan commitments in excess of the level of lending under the commitment approved for retention by the Group are classified as held-for-trading and measured at fair value.

17. Derecognition
A financial asset is derecognised when it has been transferred and the transfer qualifies for derecognition. A transfer requires that the Group either: (a) transfers the contractual rights to receive the assets cash flows; or (b) retains the right to the assets cash flows but assumes a contractual obligation to pay those cash flows to a third party. After a transfer, the Group assesses the extent to which it has retained the risks and rewards of ownership of the transferred asset. If substantially all the risks and rewards have been retained, the asset remains on the balance sheet. If substantially all the risks and rewards have been transferred, the asset is derecognised. If substantially all the risks and rewards have been neither retained nor transferred, the Group assesses whether or not it has retained control of the asset. If it has not retained control, the asset is derecognised. Where the Group has retained control of the asset, it continues to recognise the asset to the extent of its continuing involvement.

A financial liability is removed from the balance sheet when the obligation is discharged, or cancelled, or expires.

18. Sale and repurchase transactions
Securities subject to a sale and repurchase agreement under which substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership are retained by the Group continue to be shown on the balance sheet and the sale proceeds recorded as a deposit. Securities acquired in a reverse sale and repurchase transaction under which the Group is not exposed to substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership are not recognised on the balance sheet and the consideration is recorded in Loans and advances to banks or Loans and advances to customers as appropriate.
 
Securities borrowing and lending transactions are usually secured by cash or securities advanced by the borrower. Borrowed securities are not recognised on the balance sheet or lent securities derecognised. Cash collateral received or given is treated as a loan or deposit; collateral in the form of securities is not recognised. However, where securities borrowed are transferred to third parties, a liability for the obligation to return the securities to the stock lending counterparty is recorded.

19. Netting
Financial assets and financial liabilities are offset and the net amount presented in the balance sheet when, and only when, the Group currently has a legally enforceable right to set off the recognised amounts; and it intends either to settle on a net basis, or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously. The Group is party to a number of arrangements, including master netting agreements, that give it the right to offset financial assets and financial liabilities but where it does not intend to settle the amounts net or simultaneously and therefore the assets and liabilities concerned are presented gross.

20. Capital instruments
The Group classifies a financial instrument that it issues as a financial asset, financial liability or an equity instrument in accordance with the substance of the contractual arrangement. An instrument is classified as a liability if it is a contractual obligation to deliver cash or another financial asset, or to exchange financial assets or financial liabilities on potentially unfavourable terms. An instrument is classified as equity if it evidences a residual interest in the assets of the Group after the deduction of liabilities. The components of a compound financial instrument issued by the Group are classified and accounted for separately as financial assets, financial liabilities or equity as appropriate.

21. Derivatives and hedging
Derivative financial instruments are initially recognised, and subsequently measured, at fair value. Derivative fair values are determined from quoted prices in active markets where available. Where there is no active market for an instrument, fair value is derived from prices for the derivatives components using appropriate pricing or valuation models.

A derivative embedded in a contract is accounted for as a stand-alone derivative if its economic characteristics are not closely related to the economic characteristics of the host contract; unless the entire contract is carried at fair value through profit or loss.

Gains and losses arising from changes in the fair value of a derivative are recognised as they arise in profit or loss unless the derivative is the hedging instrument in a qualifying hedge. The Group enters into three types of hedge relationship: hedges of changes in the fair value of a recognised asset or liability or firm commitment (fair value hedges); hedges of the variability in cash flows from a recognised asset or liability or a forecast transaction (cash flow hedges); and hedges of the net investment in a foreign operation.
 
66



Hedge relationships are formally documented at inception. The documentation includes identification of the hedged item and the hedging instrument, details the risk that is being hedged and the way in which effectiveness will be assessed at inception and during the period of the hedge. If the hedge is not highly effective in offsetting changes in fair values or cash flows attributable to the hedged risk, consistent with the documented risk management strategy, hedge accounting is discontinued.

Fair value hedge in a fair value hedge, the gain or loss on the hedging instrument is recognised in profit or loss. The gain or loss on the hedged item attributable to the hedged risk is recognised in profit or loss and adjusts the carrying amount of the hedged item. Hedge accounting is discontinued if the hedge no longer meets the criteria for hedge accounting or if the hedging instrument expires or is sold, terminated or exercised or if hedge designation is revoked. If the hedged item is one for which the effective interest rate method is used, any cumulative adjustment is amortised to profit or loss over the life of the hedged item using a recalculated effective interest rate.

Cash flow hedge  where a derivative financial instrument is designated as a hedge of the variability in cash flows of a recognised asset or liability or a highly probable forecast transaction, the effective portion of the gain or loss on the hedging instrument is recognised directly in equity. The ineffective portion is recognised in profit or loss. When the forecast transaction results in the recognition of a financial asset or financial liability, the cumulative gain or loss is reclassified from equity in the same periods in which the asset or liability affects profit or loss. Otherwise the cumulative gain or loss is removed from equity and recognised in profit or loss at the same time as the hedged transaction. Hedge accounting is discontinued if the hedge no longer meets the criteria for hedge accounting; if the hedging instrument expires or is sold, terminated or exercised; if the forecast transaction is no longer expected to occur; or if hedge designation is revoked. On the discontinuance of hedge accounting (except where a forecast transaction is no longer expected to occur), the cumulative unrealised gain or loss recognised in equity is recognised in profit or loss when the hedged cash flow occurs or, if the forecast transaction results in the recognition of a financial asset or financial liability, in the same periods during which the asset or liability affects profit or loss. Where a forecast transaction is no longer expected to occur, the cumulative unrealised gain or loss is recognised in profit or loss immediately.

Hedge of net investment in a foreign operation  in the hedge of a net investment in a foreign operation, the portion of foreign exchange differences arising on the hedging instrument determined to be an effective hedge is recognised directly in equity. Any ineffective portion is recognised in profit or loss. Non-derivative financial liabilities as well as derivatives may be the hedging instrument in a net investment hedge.
 
22. Share-based payments
The Group grants options over shares in The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc under various share option schemes. The Group has applied IFRS 2 Share-based Payment to grants under these schemes after 7 November 2002 that had not vested on 1 January 2005. The expense for these transactions is measured based on the fair value on the date the options are granted. The fair value is estimated using valuation techniques which take into account the options exercise price, its term, the risk free interest rate and the expected volatility of the market price of The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plcs shares. Vesting conditions are not taken into account when measuring fair value, but are reflected by adjusting the number of options included in the measurement of the transaction such that the amount recognised reflects the number that actually vest. The fair value is expensed on a straight-line basis over the vesting period.

23. Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents comprises cash and demand deposits with banks together with short-term highly liquid investments that are readily convertible to known amounts of cash and subject to insignificant risk of change in value.

24. Shares in Group entities
The Banks investments in its subsidiaries are stated at cost less any impairment.
 
Critical accounting policies and key sources of  estimation uncertainty
The reported results of the Group are sensitive to the accounting policies, assumptions and estimates that underlie the preparation of its financial statements. UK company law and IFRS require the directors, in preparing the Group's financial statements, to select suitable accounting policies, apply them consistently and make judgements and estimates that are reasonable and prudent. In the absence of an applicable standard or interpretation, IAS 8 Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors, requires management to develop and apply an accounting policy that results in relevant and reliable information in the light of the requirements and guidance in IFRS dealing with similar and related issues and the IASBs Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements. The judgements and assumptions involved in the Groups accounting policies that are considered by the Board to be the most important to the portrayal of its financial condition are discussed below. The use of estimates, assumptions or models that differ from those adopted by the Group would affect its reported results.

Loan impairment provisions
The Groups loan impairment provisions are established to recognise incurred impairment losses in its portfolio of loans classified as loans and receivables and carried at amortised cost. A loan is impaired when there is objective evidence that events since the loan was granted have affected expected cash flows from the loan. The impairment loss is the difference between the carrying value of the loan and the present value of estimated future cash flows at the loans original effective interest rate.

67


 
Accounting policies continued


At 31 December 2008, gross loans and advances to customers totalled £626,075 million (2007  £555,682 million) and customer loan impairment provisions amounted to £6,572 million (2007  £4,233 million).

There are two components to the Groups loan impairment provisions: individual and collective.

Individual component  all impaired loans that exceed specific thresholds are individually assessed for impairment. Individually assessed loans principally comprise the Groups portfolio of commercial loans to medium and large businesses. Impairment losses are recognised as the difference between the carrying value of the loan and the discounted value of managements best estimate of future cash repayments and proceeds from any security held. These estimates take into account the customers debt capacity and financial flexibility; the level and quality of its earnings; the amount and sources of cash flows; the industry in which the counterparty operates; and the realisable value of any security held. Estimating the quantum and timing of future recoveries involves significant judgement. The size of receipts will depend on the future performance of the borrower and the value of security, both of which will be affected by future economic conditions; additionally, collateral may not be readily marketable. The actual amount of future cash flows and the date they are received may differ from these estimates and consequently actual losses incurred may differ from those recognised in these financial statements.
 
Collective component  this is made up of two elements: loan impairment provisions for impaired loans that are below individual assessment thresholds (collective impaired loan provisions) and for loan losses that have been incurred but have not been separately identified at the balance sheet date (latent loss provisions). These are established on a portfolio basis using a present value methodology taking into account the level of arrears, security, past loss experience, credit scores and defaults based on portfolio trends. The most significant factors in establishing these provisions are the expected loss rates and the related average life. These portfolios include credit card receivables and other personal advances including mortgages. The future credit quality of these portfolios is subject to uncertainties that could cause actual credit losses to differ materially from reported loan impairment provisions. These uncertainties include the economic environment, notably interest rates and their effect on customer spending, the unemployment level, payment behaviour and bankruptcy trends.

Pensions
The Group operates a number of defined benefit pension schemes as described in Note 4 on the accounts. The assets of the schemes are measured at their fair value at the balance sheet date. Scheme liabilities are measured using the projected unit method, which takes account of projected earnings increases, using actuarial assumptions that give the best estimate of the future cash flows that will arise under the scheme liabilities. These cash flows are discounted at the interest rate applicable to high-quality corporate bonds of the same currency and term as the liabilities. Any recognisable surplus or deficit of scheme assets over liabilities is recognised in the balance sheet as an asset (surplus) or liability (deficit). In determining the value of scheme liabilities, assumptions are made as to price inflation, dividend growth, pension increases, earnings growth and employees. There is a range of assumptions that could be adopted in valuing the schemes liabilities. Different assumptions could significantly alter the amount of the surplus or deficit recognised in the balance sheet and the pension cost charged to the income statement. The assumptions adopted for the Groups pension schemes are set out in Note 4 on the accounts. A pension asset of £4 million and a liability of £1,446 million were recognised in the balance sheet at 31 December 2008 (2007 asset £566 million; liability £334 million).
 
Fair value- financial instruments
Financial instruments classified as held-for-trading or designated as at fair value through profit or loss and financial assets classified as available-for-sale are recognised in the financial statements at fair value. All derivatives are measured at fair value. Gains or losses arising from changes in the fair value of financial instruments classified as held-for-trading or designated as at fair value through profit or loss are included in the income statement. Unrealised gains and losses on available-for-sale financial assets are recognised directly in equity unless an impairment loss is recognised.

Financial instruments measured at fair value include:

Loans and advances (held-for-trading and designated as at fair value though profit or loss) – principally comprise reverse repurchase agreements (reverse repos) and syndicated loans. In repurchase agreements one party agrees to sell securities to another and simultaneously agrees to repurchase the securities at a future date for a specified price. The repurchase price is fixed at the outset, usually being the original sale price plus an amount representing interest for the period from the sale to the repurchase. Syndicated loans measured at fair value are amounts retained, from syndications where the Group was lead manager or underwriter, in excess of the Group’s intended long term participation.

Debt securities (held-for-trading, designated as at fair value though profit or loss and available-for-sale) – debt securities include those issued by governments, municipal bodies, mortgage agencies and financial institutions as well as corporate bonds, debentures and residual interests in securitisations.

Equity securities (held-for-trading, designated as at fair value though profit or loss and available-for-sale)  comprise equity shares of companies or corporations both listed and unlisted.

Deposits by banks and customer accounts (held-for-trading and designated as at fair value though profit or loss)  deposits measured at fair value principally include repurchase agreements (repos) discussed above.

 
68


 
Debt securities in issue (held-for-trading and designated as at fair value though profit or loss)  measured at fair value and principally comprise medium term notes.

Short positions (held-for-trading)  arise in dealing and market making activities where debt securities and equity shares are sold which the Group does not currently possess.

Derivatives  these include swaps, forwards, futures and options. They may be traded on an organised exchange (exchange-traded) or over-the-counter (OTC). Holders of exchange traded derivatives are generally required to provide margin daily in the form of cash or other collateral.

Swaps include currency swaps, interest rate swaps, credit default swaps, total return swaps and equity and equity index swaps. A swap is an agreement to exchange cash flows in the future in accordance with a pre-arranged formula. In currency swap transactions, interest payment obligations are exchanged on assets and liabilities denominated in different currencies; the exchange of principal may be notional or actual. Interest rate swap contracts generally involve exchange of fixed and floating interest payment obligations without the exchange of the underlying principal amounts.

Forwards include forward foreign exchange contracts and forward rate agreements. A forward contract is a contract to buy (or sell) a specified amount of a physical or financial commodity, at an agreed price, on an agreed future date. Forward foreign exchange contracts are contracts for the delayed delivery of currency on a specified future date. Forward rate agreements are contracts under which two counterparties agree on the interest to be paid on a notional deposit of a specified term starting on a specific future date; there is no exchange of principal.

Futures are exchange-traded forward contracts to buy (or sell) standardised amounts of underlying physical or financial commodities. The Group buys and sells currency, interest rate and equity futures.

Options include exchange-traded options on currencies, interest rates and equities and equity indices and OTC currency and equity options, interest rate caps and floors and swaptions. They are contracts that give the holder the right but not the obligation to buy (or sell) a specified amount of the underlying physical or financial commodity at an agreed price on an agreed date or over an agreed period.

Fair value is the amount for which an asset could be exchanged, or a liability settled, between knowledgeable, willing parties in an arms length transaction. Fair values are determined from quoted prices in active markets for identical financial assets or financial liabilities where these are available. Fair value for a net open position in a financial asset or financial liability in an active market is the current bid or offer price times the number of units of the instrument held. Where a trading portfolio contains both financial assets and financial liabilities which are derivatives of the same underlying instrument, fair value is determined by valuing the gross long and short positions at current mid market prices, with an adjustment at portfolio level to the net open long or short position to amend the valuation to bid or offer as appropriate. Where the market for a financial instrument is not active, fair value is established using a valuation technique. These valuation techniques involve a degree of estimation, the extent of which depends on the instruments complexity and the availability of market-based data. The sensitivity to reasonably possible alternative assumptions of the fair value of financial instruments valued using techniques where at least one significant input is unobservable is given in Note 10 on pages 85 and 86.

Goodwill
The Group capitalises goodwill arising on the acquisition of businesses, as disclosed in accounting policy 5. The carrying value of goodwill as at 31 December 2008 was £11,832 million (2007 £16,783 million).

Goodwill is the excess of the cost of an acquired business over the fair value of its net assets. The determination of the fair value of assets and liabilities of businesses acquired requires the exercise of management judgement; for example those financial assets and liabilities for which there are no quoted prices, and those non-financial assets where valuations reflect estimates of market conditions such as property. Different fair values would result in changes to the goodwill arising and to the post-acquisition performance of the acquisition. Goodwill is not amortised but is tested for impairment annually or more frequently if events or changes in circumstances indicate that it might be impaired.

For the purposes of impairment testing, goodwill acquired in a business combination is allocated to each of the Groups cash-generating units or groups of cash-generating units expected to benefit from the combination. Goodwill impairment testing involves the comparison of the carrying value of a cash-generating unit or group of cash generating units with its recoverable amount. The recoverable amount is the higher of the unit's fair value and its value in use. Value in use is the present value of expected future cash flows from the cash-generating unit or group of cash-generating units. Fair value is the amount obtainable for the sale of the cash-generating unit in an arms length transaction between knowledgeable, willing parties. Impairment testing inherently involves a number of judgmental areas: the preparation of cash flow forecasts for periods that are beyond the normal requirements of management reporting; the assessment of the discount rate appropriate to the business; estimation of the fair value of cash- generating units; and the valuation of the separable assets of each business whose goodwill is being reviewed. Sensitivity to changes in assumptions is discussed in Note 16 on page 107.

Deferred tax
The Group makes provision for deferred tax on short-term and other temporary differences where tax recognition occurs at a different time from accounting recognition.

The Group has recognised deferred tax assets in respect of losses, principally in the UK, and short-term timing differences. Tax relief is given for operating losses by offset when future profits arise and therefore the recoverability of deferred tax assets is a matter of judgement.

69


Accounting policies continued

 
Accounting developments

International Financial Reporting Standards

The International Accounting Standards Board issued a revised IAS 23 Borrowing Costs in March 2007. Entities are required to capitalise borrowing costs attributable to the development or construction of intangible assets or property plant or equipment. The standard is effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009 and is not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

The IASB issued a revised IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements in September 2007 effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009. The amendments to the presentation requirements for financial statements are not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

The IASB published a revised IFRS 3 Business Combinations and related revisions to IAS 27 Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements following the completion in January 2008 of its project on the acquisition and disposal of subsidiaries. The standards improve convergence with US GAAP and provide new guidance on accounting for changes in interests in subsidiaries. The cost of an acquisition will comprise only consideration paid to vendors for equity; other costs will be expensed immediately. Groups will only account for goodwill on acquisition of a subsidiary; subsequent changes in interest will be recognised in equity and only on a loss of control will there be a profit or loss on disposal to be recognised in income. The changes are effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 July 2009 but both standards may be adopted together for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 July 2007. These changes will affect the Group's accounting for future acquisitions and disposals of subsidiaries.

The IASB published revisions to IAS 32 Financial Instruments: Presentation and consequential revisions to other standards in February 2008 to improve the accounting for and disclosure of puttable financial instruments. The revisions are effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009 but together they may be adopted earlier. They are not expected to have a material affect on the Group or the Bank.

The IASB issued an amendment, 'Vesting Conditions and Cancellations, to IFRS 2 'Share-based Payment' in January 2008 that will change the accounting for share awards that have non-vesting conditions. The fair value of these awards does not currently take account of the effect of non-vesting conditions and where such conditions are not subsequently met, costs recognised up to the date of cancellation are reversed. The amendment requires costs not recognised up to the date of cancellation to be recognised immediately. The amendment is effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009. The Group estimates that adoption will cause a restatement of 2008 results, reducing profit by £110 million with no material affect on earlier periods. There is not expected to be a material effect on the Bank.

The IASB issued amendments to a number of standards in May 2008 as part of its annual improvements project. The amendments are effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009 and are not expected to have a material effect on the Group or Bank.
 
Also in May 2008, the IASB issued amendments to IFRS 1 'First-time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards' and IAS 27 'Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements' that change the investor's accounting for the cost of an investment in a subsidiary, jointly controlled entity or associate. It does not affect the consolidated accounts but may prospectively affect the Banks accounting and presentation of receipts of dividends from such entities.

The IASB issued an amendment to IAS 39 in July 2008 to clarify the IFRS stance on eligible hedged items. The amendment is effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009 and is not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

The International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC) issued interpretation IFRIC 15 'Agreements for the Construction of Real Estate' in July 2008. This interpretation clarifies the accounting for construction profits. It is applicable for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009 and is not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

The IFRIC issued interpretation IFRIC 16 'Hedges of a Net Investment in a Foreign Operation' in July 2008. The interpretation addressed the nature of the hedged risk and the amount of the hedged item; where in a group the hedging item could be held; and what amounts should be reclassified from equity on the disposal of a foreign operation that had been subject to hedging. The interpretation is effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 October 2008 and is not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

The IFRIC issued interpretation IFRIC 17 Distributions of Non-Cash Assets to Owners and the IASB made consequential amendments to IFRS 5 'Non-Current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations' in December 2008. The interpretation requires distributions to be presented at fair value with any surplus or deficit to be recognised in income. The amendment to IFRS 5 extends the definition of disposal groups and discontinued operations to disposals by way of distribution. The interpretation is effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 July 2009, to be adopted at the same time as IFRS 3 (revised 2008), and is not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

The IFRIC issued interpretation IFRIC 18 Transfers of Assets from Customers in January 2009. The interpretation addresses the accounting by suppliers that receive assets from customers, requiring measurement at fair value. The interpretation is effective for assets from customers received on or after 1 July 2009 and is not expected to have a material effect on the Group or the Bank.

In March 2009, the IASB improved IFRS 7 Financial Instruments: Disclosure by enhancing the disclosure requirements for fair value measurements and liquidity risk. The changes are effective for accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2009, although comparative information is not needed in the first year of application, and will be adopted by the Group and the Bank for 2009 reporting.

 
 
70

 
 
1  Net interest income

         
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Loans and advances to customers
    28,240       25,886       22,145  
Loans and advances to banks
    1,302       1,126       688  
Debt securities
    1,871       1,298       1,486  
Interest receivable
    31,413       28,310       24,319  
Customer accounts: demand deposits
    2,970       3,680       3,095  
Customer accounts: savings deposits
    2,348       2,266       1,437  
Customer accounts: other time deposits
    5,408       5,848       4,642  
Deposits by banks
    3,147       2,802       2,625  
Debt securities in issue
    5,446       4,325       3,068  
Subordinated liabilities
    1,694       1,452       1,161  
Internal funding of  trading business
    (3,109 )     (3,179 )     (2,101 )
Interest payable
    17,904       17,194       13,927  
Net interest income
    13,509       11,116       10,392  
 
2  Non-interest income

         
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Fees and commissions receivable
    7,483       7,519       7,060  
Fees and commissions payable
    (1,733 )     (1,496 )     (1,426 )
(Loss)/income from trading activities:
                       
Foreign exchange (1)
    707       798       612  
Interest rate (2)
    561       1,796       967  
Credit (3)
    (7,691 )     (1,620 )     841  
Equities and commodities (4)
    840       168       123  
      (5,583 )     1,142       2,543  
Other operating income:
                       
Operating lease and other rental income
    1,232       1,187       1,288  
Changes in the fair value of  own debt
    665       152        
Changes in the fair value of  securities and other financial assets and liabilities
    (325 )     846       430  
Changes in the fair value of  investment properties
    (86 )     288       486  
Profit on sale of  securities
    174       496       252  
Profit on sale of  property, plant and equipment
    177       672       215  
Profit on sale of  subsidiaries and associates
    417       67       41  
Dividend income
    50       70       67  
Share of  profits less losses of  associated entities
    (19 )     2       36  
Other income
    (104 )     246       184  
      2,181       4,026       2,999  

The analysis of  trading income is based on how the business is organised and the underlying risks managed.

Notes:
 
Trading income comprises gains and losses on financial instruments held for trading, both realised and unrealised, interest income and dividends and the related funding costs. The types of instruments include:
 
(1)
Foreign exchange: spot foreign exchange contracts, currency swaps and options, emerging markets and related hedges and funding.
(2)
Interest rate: interest rate swaps, forward foreign exchange contracts, forward rate agreements, interest rate options, interest rate futures and related hedges and funding.
(3)
Credit: asset-backed securities, corporate bonds, credit derivatives and related hedges and funding.
(4)
Equities and commodities: equities, commodities, equity derivatives, commodity contracts and related hedges and funding.


71


Notes on the accounts continued
 
3  Operating expenses

         
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Wages, salaries and other staff  costs
    5,234       5,249       5,285  
Social security costs
    365       357       342  
Shared-based compensation
          65       65  
Pension costs
                       
– defined benefit schemes (Note 4)
    351       479       578  
– defined contribution schemes
    23       31       10  
Staff  costs
    5,973       6,181       6,280  
Premises and equipment
    1,760       1,521       1,405  
Other administrative expenses
    2,759       2,147       2,241  
Property, plant and equipment (see Note 17)
    1,221       1,021       1,055  
Intangible assets (see Note 16)
    341       417       360  
Depreciation and amortisation
    1,562       1,438       1,415  
Write-down of  goodwill and other assets
    8,144              
      20,198       11,287       11,341  
 
Integration costs included in operating expenses comprise expenditure incurred in respect of cost reduction and revenue enhancement programmes set in connection with the various acquisitions made by the Group.

         
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Staff  costs
    246       18       76  
Premises and equipment
    25       4       10  
Other administrative expenses
    194       10       18  
Depreciation and amortisation
    22       60       16  
      487       92       120  
Restructuring costs included in operating expenses comprise:
                       
                   
2008
 
                      £m  
Staff  costs
                    111  
Premises and equipment
                    15  
Other administrative expenses
                    34  
                      160  
 
No restructuring costs were incurred in 2007 and 2006.
72



The average number of persons employed by the Group during the year, excluding temporary staff, was 123,000 (2007 – 123,500; 2006 – 122,600). The number of persons employed by the Group at 31 December, excluding temporary staff, was as follows:

         
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
Global Banking & Markets
    10,100       9,300       8,100  
Global Transaction Services
    2,900       2,700       2,500  
UK Retail & Commercial Banking
    45,800       45,500       46,000  
US Retail & Commercial Banking
    18,700       19,000       19,800  
Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking
    5,600       6,400       5,700  
Asia Retail & Commercial Banking
    4,200       5,200       3,800  
Group Manufacturing
    32,300       33,500       34,100  
Centre
    3,200       3,000       2,700  
Total
    122,800       124,600       122,700  
UK
    86,600       88,600       88,300  
US
    26,000       25,600       26,200  
Europe
    6,600       7,600       6,900  
Rest of  the World
    3,600       2,800       1,300  
Total
    122,800       124,600       122,700  
 
           
Bank
         
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Wages, salaries and other staff  costs
    2,499       2,910       2,847  
Social security costs
    192       203       193  
Share-based compensation
          65       65  
Pension costs
                       
– defined benefit schemes
    8       5       8  
– defined contribution schemes
    298       310       295  
Staff  costs
    2,997       3,493       3,408  

The average number of persons employed by the Bank during the year, excluding temporary staff, was 63,500 (2007 – 63,700; 2006 – 60,900). The number of persons employed by the Bank at 31 December, excluding temporary staff, was as follows:

         
Bank
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
Global Banking & Markets
    8,500       8,200       6,600  
Global Transaction Services
    1,200       1,100       900  
UK Retail & Commercial Banking
    22,600       24,000       22,600  
Group Manufacturing
    27,500       29,200       28,700  
Centre
    3,100       2,900       2,500  
Total
    62,900       65,400       61,300  
UK
    58,100       61,700       60,100  
US
    1,100       400        
Europe
    1,000       1,300       1,100  
Rest of  the World
    2,700       2,000       100  
Total
    62,900       65,400       61,300  

 
73


Notes on the accounts continued

4  Pension costs
 
Members of  the Group sponsor a number of  pension schemes in the UK and overseas, defined benefit schemes, whose assets are independent of  the Group’s finances. Defined benefit pensions generally provide a pension of  one-sixtieth of  final pensionable salary for each year of  service prior to retirement up to a maximum of 40 years. Employees do not make contributions for basic pensions but may make voluntary contributions to secure additional benefits on a money-purchase basis. Since October 2006 the defined benefit section of  The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group Pension Fund (‘Main scheme’) has been closed to new entrants.

The Group also provides post-retirement benefits other than pensions, principally through subscriptions to private healthcare schemes in the UK and the US and unfunded post-retirement benefit plans. Provision for the costs of  these benefits is charged to the income statement over the average remaining future service lives of  the eligible employees. The amounts are not material.

There is no contractual agreement or policy on the way that the cost of The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group defined benefit pension schemes and healthcare plans are allocated to the Bank. The Bank therefore accounts for the charges it incurs as payments to a defined contribution scheme.

Interim valuations of the Group’s schemes were prepared to 31 December by independent actuaries, using the following assumptions:
 
Principal actuarial assumptions at 31 December (weighted average)
 
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
Discount rate
    6.3 %     6.0 %     5.3 %
Expected return on plan assets
    7.1 %     6.9 %     6.9 %
Rate of  increase in salaries*
    3.8 %     4.4 %     4.1 %
Rate of  increase in pensions in payment
    2.5 %     3.1 %     2.8 %
Inflation assumption
    2.6 %     3.2 %     2.9 %
 
* Rate of increase in salaries in the Main scheme assumed to be 2.0% over the next two years.
 
Major classes of  plan assets as a percentage of  total plan assets
 
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
Equities
    58.2 %     61.3 %     60.7 %
Index-linked bonds
    16.7 %     16.9 %     16.1 %
Government fixed interest bonds
    2.9 %     2.3 %     3.3 %
Corporate and other bonds
    17.9 %     14.8 %     13.9 %
Property
    4.1 %     4.0 %     4.5 %
Cash and other assets
    0.2 %     0.7 %     1.5 %

Ordinary shares of the holding company with a fair value of £15 million (2007 – £69 million; 2006 – £89 million) are held by the Group’s pension schemes together with holdings of other financial instruments issued by the Group with a value of £421 million (2007 – £606 million; 2006 – £258 million).

Post-retirement mortality assumptions (Main scheme)
 
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
Longevity at age 60 for current pensioners (years)
                 
Males
    26.1       26.0       26.0  
Females
    26.9       26.8       28.9  
Longevity at age 60 for future pensioners (years)
                       
Males
    28.1       28.1       26.8  
Females
    28.2       28.2       29.7  
 
     
Fair value
of plan
assets
     
Present
value of
defined
benefit
obligations
     
Net
pension
deficit/
(surplus)
 
Changes in value of  net pension deficit/(surplus)
    £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January 2007
    18,894       20,865       1,971  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    38       45       7  
Income statement:
                       
Expected return
    1,297             (1,297 )
Interest cost
          1,105       1,105  
Current service cost
          649       649  
Past service cost
          22       22  
      1,297       1,776       479  
Statement of  recognised income and expense:
                       
Actuarial gains and losses
    140       (2,013 )     (2,153 )
Contributions by employer
    536             (536 )
Contributions by plan participants
    4       4        
Benefits paid
    (605 )     (605 )      
Expenses included in service cost
    (40 )     (40 )      
At 1 January 2008
    20,264       20,032       (232 )
Currency translation and other adjustments
    522       623       101  
Income statement:
                       
Expected return
    1,401             (1,401 )
Interest cost
          1,196       1,196  
Current service cost
          528       528  
Past service cost
          28       28  
      1,401       1,752       351  
Statement of  recognised income and expense:
                       
Actuarial gains and losses
    (5,318 )     (3,602 )     1,716  
Disposal of  subsidiaries
          (3 )     (3 )
Contributions by employer
    491             (491 )
Contributions by plan participants
    6       6        
Benefits paid
    (689 )     (689 )      
Expenses included in service cost
    (26 )     (26 )      
At 31 December 2008
    16,651       18,093       1,442  


75


Notes on the accounts continued
 
4  Pension costs (continued)
 
Net pension liability comprises:
    £m  
Net assets of  schemes in surplus (included in Prepayments, accrued income and other assets, Note 18)
    (4 )
Net liabilities of  schemes in deficit
    1,446  
      1,442  

The Group expects to contribute £488 million to its defined benefit pension schemes in 2009. Of the net liabilities of schemes in deficit, £118 million (2007 – £94 million) relates to unfunded schemes.

Cumulative net actuarial losses of £180 million (2007 – £1,536 million gains; 2006 – £617 million losses) have been recognised in the statement of recognised income and expense.

   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2005
   
2004
 
History of  defined benefits schemes
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Fair value of  plan assets
    16,651       20,264       18,894       17,331       14,752  
Present value of  defined benefit obligations
    18,093       20,032       20,865       21,040       17,674  
Net (deficit)/surplus
    (1,442 )     232       (1,971 )     (3,709 )     (2,922 )
Experience losses on plan liabilities
    (91 )     (204 )     (20 )     (68 )     (631 )
Experience (losses)/gains on plan assets
    (5,318 )     140       585       1,654       408  
Actual return on pension schemes assets
    (3,917 )     1,437       1,654       2,667       1,327  


The table below sets out the sensitivities of the pension cost for the year and the present value of defined benefit obligations at the balance sheet dates to a change in the principal actuarial assumptions:
 
   
Increase/(decrease)
   
Increase/(decrease)
 
   
in pension cost for the year
   
in obligation at 31 December
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
25 bps increase in the discount rate
    (44 )     (47 )     (786 )     (963 )
25 bps increase in inflation
    86       91       696       872  
25 bps additional rate of  increase in pensions in payment
    46       47       423       503  
25 bps additional rate of  increase in deferred pensions
    9       6       103       121  
25 bps additional rate of  increase in salaries
    33       39       199       246  
Longevity increase of  1 year
    34       33       337       419  

 
76


 
5  Auditors remuneration
 
Amounts paid to the Bank’s auditors for statutory audit and other services were as follows:
 
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Fees payable for the audit of  the Group’s annual accounts
    4.3       3.7  
Fees payable to the auditors and their associates for other services to the Group:
               
– The audit of  the Bank’s subsidiaries pursuant to legislation
    7.9       5.3  
Total audit fees
    12.2       9.0  

Fees payable to the auditors for non-audit services are disclosed in the consolidated financial statements of  The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group plc.

6  Tax

 
       
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Current taxation:
                       
Charge for the year
    646       2,373       2,355  
Over provision in respect of  prior periods
    (257 )     (25 )     (167 )
Relief  for overseas taxation
    (34 )     (198 )     (147 )
      355       2,150       2,041  
Deferred taxation:
                       
(Credit)/charge for the year
    (849 )     89       365  
(Under)/over provision in respect of  prior periods
    (11 )     (336 )     27  
Tax (credit)/charge for the year
    (505 )     1,903       2,433  
 
The actual tax charge differs from the expected tax charge computed by applying the standard rate of UK corporation tax of 28.5% (2007 – 30%, 2006 – 30%) as follows:
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Expected tax (credit)/charge
    (2,578 )     2,747       2,506  
Non-deductible goodwill impairment
    1,949       12        
Unrecognised timing differences
    274       29        
Other non-deductible items
    245       218       280  
Non-taxable items
    (305 )     (568 )     (252 )
Taxable foreign exchange movements
    161       4       (33 )
Foreign profits taxed at other rates
    4       (13 )     61  
Increase/(decrease) in deferred tax liability following change in the rate of  UK corporation tax
    1       (156 )      
Unutilised losses brought forward and carried forward
    12       (9 )     11  
Adjustments in respect of  prior periods
    (268 )     (361 )     (140 )
Actual tax (credit)/charge
    (505 )     1,903       2,433  

The effective tax rate for the year was 5.6% (2007 – 20.8%; 2006 – 29.1%).

7  Profit attributable to preference shareholders
 
         
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
Dividends paid to equity preference shareholders
    £m       £m       £m  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  US$0.01
    350       210       160  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  €0.01
    205       110       92  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  £1
    83       11        
Total
    638       331       252  

Notes:
(1)
In accordance with IAS 32, several of  the Group’s preference share issues are included in subordinated liabilities and the related finance cost in interest payable.
(2)
Between 1 January 2009 and the date of approval of these accounts, dividends amounting to US$194 million have been declared in respect of equity preference shareholders for payment on 31 March 2009.
 
77

 
Notes on the accounts continued

8  Ordinary dividends
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Ordinary dividend paid to holding company
    4,000       2,000       3,250  


9  Profit dealt with in the accounts of the Bank

As permitted by section 230(3) of the Companies Act 1985, no income statement for the Bank has been presented as a primary financial statement. Of the loss attributable to ordinary shareholders, £1,778 million (2007 – £6,924 million profit; 2006 – £3,267 million profit) has been dealt with in the accounts of the Bank.


10 Financial instruments
Classification

The following tables analyse the Group’s financial assets and financial liabilities in accordance with the categories of financial instruments in IAS 39. Assets and liabilities outside the scope of IAS 39 are shown separately.

                           
Group
                         
         
Designated
                                           
         
as at fair
                                 
Non
       
         
value
                     
Other
         
financial
       
   
Held-for-
   
through
   
Hedging
   
Available-
   
Loans and
   
(amortised
   
Finance
   
assets/
       
   
trading
   
profit or loss
   
derivatives
   
for-sale
   
receivables
   
cost)
   
leases
   
liabilities
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                                                       
Cash and balances at central banks
                              6,806                             6,806  
Loans and advances to banks (1)
    60,957                           18,430                             79,387  
Loans and advances to customers (2, 3)
    52,173       1,767                     551,110               14,453               619,503  
Debt securities (4)
    101,773       2,599               61,638       11,756                             177,766  
Equity shares
    577       275               1,839                                   2,691  
Settlement balances
                              10,871                             10,871  
Derivatives
    933,203             4,254                                         937,457  
Intangible assets
                                                            12,591       12,591  
Property, plant and equipment
                                                            16,628       16,628  
Deferred taxation
                                                            2,833       2,833  
Prepayments, accrued income and other assets
                              32                     11,365       11,397  
      1,148,683       4,641       4,254       63,477       599,005               14,453       43,417       1,877,930  
Liabilities
                                                                       
Deposits by banks (5)
    86,938                                     95,044                     181,982  
Customer accounts (6, 7)
    57,817       2,707                               392,605                     453,129  
Debt securities in issue (8, 9)
    3,991       12,164                               163,787                     179,942  
Settlement balances and short positions
 
  37,172                                     8,785                     45,957  
Derivatives
    905,546             3,559                                           909,105  
Accruals, deferred income and other liabilities
    260                                     1,619       22       14,784       16,685  
Retirement benefit liabilities
                                                            1,446       1,446  
Deferred taxation
                                                            2,483       2,483  
Subordinated liabilities (10)
          708                               39,243                   39,951  
      1,091,724       15,579       3,559                       701,083       22       18,713       1,830,680  
Equity
                                                                    47,250  
                                                                      1,877,930  


78


                           
Group
                         
         
Designated
                                           
         
as at fair
                                 
Non
       
         
value
                     
Other
         
financial
       
   
Held-for-
   
through
   
Hedging
   
Available-
   
Loans and
   
(amortised
   
Finance
   
assets/
       
   
trading
   
profit or loss
   
derivatives
   
for-sale
   
receivables
   
cost)
   
leases
   
liabilities
   
Total
 
2007
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                                                       
Cash and balances at central banks
                              5,559                             5,559  
Loans and advances to banks (1)
    72,697                           23,649                             96,346  
Loans and advances to customers (2, 3)
    105,420       2,622                     430,837               12,570               551,449  
Debt securities (4)
    136,785       2,854               24,293       500                             164,432  
Equity shares
    3,786       156               1,567                                   5,509  
Settlement balances
                              5,326                             5,326  
Derivatives
    205,056             919                                         205,975  
Intangible assets
                                                            17,761       17,761  
Property, plant and equipment
                                                            13,025       13,025  
Deferred taxation
                                                      240       240  
Prepayments, accrued income
                                                                   
and other assets
                              19                     6,097       6,116  
      523,744       5,632       919       25,860       465,890               12,570       37,123       1,071,738  
Liabilities
                                                                       
Deposits by banks (5)
    71,714                                     79,794                     151,508  
Customer accounts (6, 7)
    61,990       1,920                               379,072                     442,982  
Debt securities in
issue (8, 9)
    9,455       9,021                               111,656                     130,132  
                                                                         
Settlement balances and short positions
    47,058             1,270                       6,791                     53,849  
Derivatives
    201,802                                                       203,072  
Accruals, deferred income
                                                                 
and other liabilities
    210                                     1,545       19       10,393       12,167  
Retirement benefit liabilities
                                                            334       334  
Deferred taxation
                                                            2,063       2,063  
Subordinated liabilities (10)
          358                               27,438                     27,796  
      392,229       11,299       1,270                       606,296       19       12,790       1,023,903  
Equity
                                                                    47,835  
                                                                      1,071,738  

Notes:
(1)
Includes reverse repurchase agreements of £31,436 million (2007 – £67,619 million), items in the course of collection from other banks of £2,779 million (2007 – £2,729 million) and amounts due from fellow subsidiaries of £7,297 million (2007 – £1,966 million).
(2)
Includes reverse repurchase agreements of £27,972 million (2007 – £79,056 million), amounts due from holding company of £1,828 million (2007 – £5,572 million) and amounts due from fellow subsidiaries of £2,656 million (2007 – £3,516 million).
(3)
The change in the fair value of loans and advances to customers designated as at fair value through profit and loss attributable to changes in credit risk was £301 million for the year and £408 million cumulatively. The amounts for 2007 were not material.
(4)
Includes treasury bills and similar securities of  £23,797 million (2007 – £14,604 million) and other eligible bills of  £54 million (2007 – £1,914 million).
(5)
Includes repurchase agreements of  £66,006 million (2007 – £75,154 million) and items in the course of  transmission to other banks of  £542 million (2007 – £372 million).
(6)
Includes repurchase agreements of £54,095 million (2007 – £75,029 million), amounts due to holding company of £15,801 million (2007 – £1,012 million) and amounts due to fellow subsidiaries of £2,488 million (2007 – £2,105 million).
(7)
The carrying amount of other customer accounts designated as at fair value through profit or loss is £44 million lower (2007 – £77 million, greater) than the principal amount. No amounts have been recognised in profit or loss for changes in credit risk associated with these liabilities as the changes are immaterial measured as the change in fair value from movements in the period in the credit risk premium payable.
(8)
Comprises bonds and medium term notes of  £70,153 million (2007 – £40,945 million) and certificates of  deposit and other commercial paper of  £109,789 million (2007 – £89,187 million).
(9)
£665 million (2007 – £152 million) has been recognised in profit or loss for changes in credit risk associated with these liabilities measured as the change in fair value from movements in the period in the credit risk premium payable by the Group. The carrying amount is £1,145 million (2007 – £317 million) lower than the principal amount.
(10)
Includes amounts due to holding company of  £11,572 million (2007 – £6,113 million).
(11)
During 2008 the Group reclassified financial assets from the held-for-trading and available-for-sale categories into loans and receivables category and from held-for-trading category into the available-for-sale category (see page 91).
 
79


 
Notes on the accounts continued
 
10  Financial instruments (continued)

The following tables analyse the Bank’s financial assets and financial liabilities in accordance with the categories of financial instruments in IAS 39. Assets and liabilities outside the scope of IAS 39 are shown separately.

                     
Bank
                         
         
Designated
                                     
         
as at fair
                           
Non
       
         
value
                     
Other
   
financial
       
   
Held-for-
   
through
   
Hedging
   
Available-
   
Loans and
   
(amortised
   
assets/
       
   
trading
   
profit or loss
   
derivatives
   
for-sale
   
receivables
   
cost)
   
liabilities
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
                              3,714                       3,714  
Loans and advances to banks (1)
    56,089                           35,628                       91,717  
Loans and advances to customers (2)
    59,146       1,160                     266,734                       327,040  
Debt securities (3)
    67,911       906               41,898       48,983                       159,698  
Equity shares
    463       28               529                             1,020  
Investments in Group undertakings
                                            26,814       26,814  
Settlement balances
                              5,335                       5,335  
Derivatives
    934,709             3,796                                   938,505  
Intangible assets
                                                    136       136  
Property, plant and equipment
                                                    2,368       2,368  
Deferred taxation
                                                    1,323       1,323  
Prepayments, accrued income and other assets
                                            5,930       5,930  
      1,118,318       2,094       3,796       42,427       360,394               36,571       1,563,600  
Liabilities
                                                               
Deposits by banks (4)
    85,126                                     116,140               201,266  
Customer accounts (5, 6)
    46,178       170                               182,918               229,266  
Debt securities in issue (7, 8)
    3,993       12,099                               99,057               115,149  
Settlement balances and short positions
    23,827                                     5,534               29,361  
Derivatives
    910,188             986                                     911,174  
Accruals, deferred income and other liabilities
    260                                     1,087       8,271       9,618  
Retirement benefit liabilities
                                                    23       23  
Subordinated liabilities
          708                               32,990             33,698  
      1,069,572       12,977       986                       437,726       8,294       1,529,555  
Equity
                                                            34,045  
                                                              1,563,600  



80

                     
Bank
                         
         
Designated
                                     
         
as at fair
                           
Non
       
         
value
                     
Other
   
financial
       
   
Held-for-
   
through
   
Hedging
   
Available-
   
Loans and
   
(amortised
   
assets/
       
   
trading
   
profit or loss
   
derivatives
   
for-sale
   
receivables
   
cost)
   
liabilities
   
Total
 
2007
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
                              3,333                       3,333  
Loans and advances to banks (1)
    60,640                           31,342                       91,982  
Loans and advances to customers (2)
    109,992       791                     218,364                       329,147  
Debt securities (3)
    97,455       996               8,799                             107,250  
Equity shares
    3,634       10               375                             4,019  
Investments in Group undertakings
                                            22,210       22,210  
Settlement balances
                              2,046                       2,046  
Derivatives
    207,266             647                                   207,913  
Intangible assets
                                                    295       295  
Property, plant and equipment
                                                    2,116       2,116  
Deferred taxation
                                                    319       319  
Prepayments, accrued income and other assets
                                            1,680       1,680  
      478,987       1,797       647       9,174       255,085               26,620       772,310  
Liabilities
                                                               
Deposits by banks (4)
    71,261                                     125,707               196,968  
Customer accounts (5, 6)
    57,823       54                               140,049               197,926  
Debt securities in issue (7, 8)
    9,455       8,895                               61,527               79,877  
Settlement balances and short positions
    30,567                                     3,110             33,677  
Derivatives
    203,733             501                                   204,234  
Accruals, deferred income and other liabilities
    210                                     1,080       4,493       5,783  
Retirement benefit liabilities
                                                    11       11  
Subordinated liabilities
          358                               22,387             22,745  
      373,049       9,307       501                       353,860       4,504       741,221  
Equity
                                                            31,089  
                                                              772,310  

Notes:
(1)
Includes reverse repurchase agreements of £19,263 million (2007 – £52,128 million), items in the course of collection from other banks of £484 million (2007 – £530 million), amounts due from subsidiaries of £29,619 million (2007 – £22,367 million) and amounts due from fellow subsidiaries of £6,862 million (2007 – £1,748 million).
(2)
Includes reverse repurchase agreements of £22,564 million (2007 – £58,785 million), amounts due from subsidiaries of £39,908 million (2007 – £66,102 million), amounts due from fellow subsidiaries of £2,632 million (2007 – £2,666 million) and amounts due from holding company of £1,828 million (2007 – £5,572 million).
(3)
Includes treasury bills and similar securities of  £23,415 million (2007 – £14,200 million).
(4)
Includes repurchase agreements of £52,290 million (2007 – £59,955 million), items in the course of transmission to other banks of £312 million (2007 – £68 million), amounts due to subsidiaries of £63,198 million (2007 – £74,006 million) and amounts due to fellow subsidiaries of £5,715 million (2007 – £8,473 million).
(5)
Includes repurchase agreements of £24,041 million (2007 – £30,177 million), amounts due to fellow subsidiaries of £1,940 million (2007 – £123 million), amounts due to holding company of £15,800 million (2007 – £1,013 million) and amounts due to subsidiaries of £68,282 million (2007 – £53,565 million).
(6)
The carrying amount of other customer accounts designated as at fair value through profit or loss is £2 million (2007 – £15 million) lower than the principal amount. No amounts have been recognised in profit or loss for changes in credit risk associated with these liabilities as the changes are immaterial measured as the change in fair value from movements in the period in the credit risk premium payable.
(7)
Comprises bonds and medium term notes of  £40,595 million (2007 – £17,274 million) and certificates of  deposit and other commercial paper of  £74,553 million (2007 – £62,603 million).
(8)
£665 million (2007 – £152 million) has been recognised in profit or loss for changes in credit risk associated with these liabilities measured as the change in fair value from movements in the period in the credit risk premium payable by the Group. The carrying amount is £1,055 million (2007 – £252 million) lower than the principal amount.
(9)
During 2008 the Group reclassified financial assets from the held-for-trading and available-for-sale categories into loans and receivables category and from held-for-trading category into the available-for-sale category (see page 92).
 
 
81

 
Notes on the accounts continued

10  Financial instruments (continued)

Valuation of financial instruments

Control environment
The Group’s control environment for the determination of the fair value of financial instruments has been designed to ensure there are formalised review protocols for independent review and validation of fair values separate from those businesses entering into the transactions. This includes specific controls to ensure consistent pricing policies and procedures, incorporating disciplined price verification for both proprietary and counterparty risk trades. The Group ensures special attention is given to bespoke transactions, structured products, illiquid products, and other assets which are difficult to price.

The business entering into the transaction is responsible for the initial determination and recording of the fair value of the transaction. There are daily controls over the profit or loss recorded by trading and treasury front office traders.

A key element of the control environment, segregated from the recording of the transaction’s valuation, is the independent price verification (IPV) process. Valuations are first calculated by the business which entered into the transaction. Such valuations may be direct prices, or may be derived using a model and variable model inputs. These valuations are reviewed, and if necessary amended, by the IPV process. This process involves a team, independent of those trading the financial instruments, reviewing valuations in the light of available pricing evidence. IPV is performed at a frequency to match the availability of independent data, and the size of the Group’s exposure. For liquid instruments the process is performed daily. The minimum frequency of review in GBM is monthly for regulatory trading book positions, and six monthly for regulatory banking book positions. The IPV control includes formalised reporting and escalation of any valuation differences in breach of defined thresholds. In addition, within GBM, there is a dedicated team (the Global Pricing Unit) which determines IPV policy, monitors adherence to policy, and performs additional independent review on highly subjective valuation issues.

In GBM, when models are used to value products, those models are subject to a review process which requires different levels of model documentation, testing and review, depending on the complexity of the model and the size of the Group’s exposure. A key element of the control environment over model use in GBM is a review committee which comprises of valuations experts from several functions within GBM. The committee sets the policy for model documentation, testing and review, and prioritises models with significant exposure for review by the Group’s quantitative research centre. This centre, which is independent of the trading businesses, assesses the appropriateness of the application of the model to the product, the mathematical robustness of the model, and (where appropriate), considers alternative modelling approaches.
 
GBM also maintains a valuation control committee that meets formally on a monthly basis to discuss and review escalated items and to consider highly complex and subjective valuation matters. The committee includes valuation specialists representing several independent review functions (including market risk, quantitative research and finance) and senior members of the Group’s front office trading businesses.

Certain financial instruments have become more difficult and subjective to value and have therefore been transferred to a centrally managed asset unit, to separate them from business as usual activities and to allow dedicated focus on the management and valuation of the exposures. The unit has a valuation committee comprising senior representatives of the trading function, risk management and GBM Global Pricing Unit which meets regularly and is responsible for monitoring, assessing and enhancing the adequacy of the valuation techniques being adopted for these instruments.

Valuation techniques
The Group uses a number of methodologies to determine the fair values of financial instruments for which observable prices in active markets for identical instruments are not available. These techniques include: relative value methodologies based on observable prices for similar instruments; present value approaches where future cash flows from the asset or liability are estimated and then discounted using a risk-adjusted interest rate; option pricing models (such as Black-Scholes or binomial option pricing models) and simulation models such as Monte-Carlo.

The principal inputs to these valuation techniques are listed below. Values between and beyond available data points are obtained by interpolation and extrapolation. When utilising valuation techniques, the fair value can be significantly affected by the choice of valuation model and underlying assumptions made concerning factors such as the amounts and timing of cash flows, discount rates and credit risk.
 
Bond prices quoted prices are generally available for government bonds, certain corporate securities and some mortgage-related products.

Credit spreads where available, these are derived from prices of CDS or other credit based instruments, such as debt securities. For others, credit spreads are obtained from pricing services.

Interest rates  these are principally benchmark interest rates such as the London Inter-Bank Offered Rate (LIBOR) and quoted interest rates in the swap, bond and futures markets.

Foreign currency exchange rates there are observable markets both for spot and forward contracts and futures in the worlds major currencies.
 

82

 
Equity and equity index prices quoted prices are generally readily available for equity shares listed on the worlds major stock exchanges and for major indices on such shares.

Commodity prices many commodities are actively traded in spot and forward contracts and futures on exchanges in London, New York and other commercial centres.

Price volatilities and correlations volatility is a measure of the tendency of a price to change with time. Correlation measures the degree to which two or more prices or other variables are observed to move together. If they move in the same direction there is positive correlation; if they move in opposite directions there is negative correlation. Volatility is a key input in valuing options and the valuation of certain products such as derivatives with more than one underlying variable that are correlation-dependent. Volatility and correlation values are obtained from broker quotations, pricing services or derived from option prices.

Prepayment rates the fair value of a financial instrument that can be prepaid by the issuer or borrower differs from that of an instrument that cannot be prepaid. In valuing prepayable instruments that are not quoted in active markets, the Group considers the value of the prepayment option.

Counterparty credit spreads adjustments are made to market prices (or parameters) when the creditworthiness of the counterparty differs from that of the assumed counterparty in the market price (or parameters).

Recovery rates/loss given default these are used as an input to valuation models and reserves for ABS and other credit products as an indicator of severity of losses on default. Recovery rates are primarily sourced from market data providers or inferred from observable credit spreads.
 
In order to determine a reliable fair value, where appropriate, the Group applies valuation adjustments to the pricing information derived from the above sources. These adjustments reflect the Group’s assessment of factors that market participants would consider in setting a price, to the extent that these factors have not already been included in the information from the above sources. Furthermore, on an ongoing basis, the Group assesses the appropriateness of any model used. To the extent that the price provided by internal models does not represent the fair value of the instrument, for instance in highly stressed market conditions, the Group makes adjustments to the model valuation to calibrate to other available pricing sources. Where unobservable inputs are used, the Group may determine a range of possible valuations based upon differing and stress scenarios to determine the sensitivity associated with the valuation. When establishing the fair value of a financial instrument using a valuation technique, the Group considers certain adjustments to the modelled price which market participants would make when pricing that instrument. Such adjustments include the credit quality of the counterparty and adjustments to correct model valuations for any known limitations. In addition, the Group makes adjustments to defer income for financial instruments valued at inception where the valuation of that financial instrument materially depends on one or more unobservable model inputs.

The Group refines and modifies its valuation techniques as markets and products develop and as the pricing for individual products becomes more or less readily available. While the Group believes its valuation techniques are appropriate and consistent with other market participants, the use of different methodologies or assumptions could result in different estimates of fair value at the balance sheet date.

 
83

 
Notes on the accounts continued
 
10  Financial instruments (continued)
 
Valuation hierarchy
 
The table below shows the financial instruments carried at fair value by valuation method.
 
         
2008
                     
2007
             
   
Level 1(1)
   
Level 2 (2)
   
Level 3 (3)
   
Total
   
Level 1(1)
   
Level 2 (2)
   
Level 3(3)
   
Total
 
   
£bn
   
£bn
   
£bn
   
£bn
   
£bn
   
£bn
   
£bn
   
£bn
 
Assets
                                               
Fair value through profit or loss:
                                               
Loans and advances to banks
          61.0             61.0             72.6       0.1       72.7  
Loans and advances to customers
          50.8       3.1       53.9             94.9       13.1       108.0  
Debt securities
    50.1       50.5       3.8       104.4       59.0       70.2       10.4       139.6  
Equity shares
    0.5             0.4       0.9       3.7             0.2       3.9  
Derivatives
    1.4       929.7       6.3       937.4       1.0       201.9       3.1       206.0  
      52.0       1,092.0       13.6       1,157.6       63.7       439.6       26.9       530.2  
Available-for-sale:
                                                               
Debt securities
    16.2       43.1       2.3       61.6       2.2       21.8       0.3       24.3  
Equity shares
    0.1       1.6       0.1       1.8       0.1       1.0       0.5       1.6  
      16.3       44.7       2.4       63.4       2.3       22.8       0.8       25.9  
      68.3       1,136.7       16.0       1,221.0       66.0       462.4       27.7       556.1  
Liabilities
                                                               
Deposits by banks and customers
          147.1       0.3       147.4             134.1       1.5       135.6  
Debt securities in issue
          15.4       0.8       16.2             13.3       5.2       18.5  
Short positions
    32.0       5.2             37.2       43.3       3.7             47.0  
Derivatives
    0.7       905.6       2.8       909.1       1.3       199.5       2.3       203.1  
Other financial liabilities (4)
          0.7       0.3       1.0             0.4       0.2       0.6  
      32.7       1,074.0       4.2       1,110.9       44.6       351.0       9.2       404.8  

Notes:
(1)
Valued using unadjusted quoted prices in active markets for identical financial instruments. This category includes listed equity shares, certain exchange-traded derivatives, G10 government securities and certain US agency securities.
 
(2)
Valued using techniques based significantly on observable market data. Instruments in this category are valued using:
(a)
quoted prices for similar instruments or identical instruments in markets which are not considered to be active; or
(b)
valuation techniques where all the inputs that have a significant effect on the valuation are directly or indirectly based on observable market data.
The type of instruments that trade in markets that are not considered to be active, but are based on quoted market prices, broker dealer quotations, or alternative pricing sources with reasonable levels of price transparency and those instruments valued using techniques include most government agency securities, investment-grade corporate bonds, certain mortgage products, certain bank and bridge loans, repos and reverse repos, less liquid listed equities, state and municipal obligations, most physical commodities, and certain money market securities and loan commitments and most OTC derivatives.
 
(3)
Instruments in this category have been valued using a valuation technique where at least one input (which could have a significant effect on the instrument’s valuation) is not based on observable market data. Where inputs can be observed from market data without undue cost and effort, the observed input is used. Otherwise, the Group determines a reasonable level for the input.
 
Financial instruments included within level 3 of the fair value hierarchy primarily consist of cash instruments which trade infrequently, certain syndicated and commercial mortgage loans, unlisted equity shares, certain residual interests in securitisations, super senior tranches of high grade and mezzanine collateralised debt obligations (CDOs), and other mortgage-based products and less liquid debt securities, certain structured debt securities in issue and OTC derivatives where valuation depends upon unobservable inputs such as certain credit and exotic derivatives. No gain or loss is recognised on the initial recognition of a financial instrument valued using a technique incorporating significant unobservable data.

(4)
Other financial liabilities comprise subordinated liabilities and write downs relating to undrawn syndicated loan facilities.


84



Level 3 portfolios
Level 3 loans and advances decreased by £10 billion, primarily reflecting reclassification of certain loans (leveraged finance and other corporate loans) to loans and receivables (LAR) and fair value adjustments on the remaining portfolio at the end of the year.

Debt securities categorised as level 3 at the end of the year include £4.4 billion of asset-backed securities and £1.7 billion of corporate and other debt securities. The decrease during the year reflects termination of a deal in early 2008, reclassification of illiquid mortgage-backed securities (MBS) to loans and receivables, fair value changes, and the transfer of certain previous illiquid MBS, primarily sub-prime from level 3 to level 2.
 
Level 3 derivative assets at 31 December 2008 include credit derivative trades with credit derivative product companies (CDPCs) with a fair value of £2.8 billion (2007 – £90 million) after credit valuation adjustments of £0.7 billion (2007 – nil). Other level 3 derivative assets at 31 December 2008 include illiquid credit default swaps (CDSs), other credit derivatives, commodity derivatives and illiquid interest rate derivatives.
 
Debt securities in issue, categorised as level 3, were structured medium term notes and the decrease in the year primarily reflects the termination of a deal in the first half of 2008.
 
The tables below presents the Level 3 financial instruments carried at fair value as at the balance sheet date, valuation basis, main assumptions used in the valuation of these instruments and reasonably possible increases or decreases in fair value based on reasonably possible alternative assumptions:

             
Reasonably possible
 
             
alternative assumptions
 
       
Carrying
   
Increase in
   
Decrease in
 
Valuation basis/
Main
 
value
   
fair value
   
fair value
 
Assets
technique
assumptions
 
£bn
      £m       £m  
Loans and advances
Proprietary model
Credit spreads, indices
    3.1       70       50  
Debt securities:
                           
– RMBS (1)
Industry standard model
Prepayment rates, probability of
default, loss severity and yield
    0.5       40       90  
– CMBS (2)
Industry standard model
Prepayment rates, probability of
default, loss severity and yield
    0.5       20       20  
– CDOs
Proprietary model
Implied collateral
valuation, defaults rates,
housing prices, correlation
    1.1       230       230  
– CLOs (3)
Industry standard simulation model
Credit spreads, recovery rates, correlation
    1.0       40       40  
– Other
Proprietary model
Credit spreads
    3.0       50       50  
Derivatives
                           
– credit
Proprietary CVA model, industry
option models, correlation model
Counterparty credit risk,
correlation, volatility
    4.4       580       560  
– interest rate and commodity
Proprietary model
Volatility, correlation
    1.9       130       130  
Equity shares – private equity
Valuation statements
Fund valuations
    0.5       70       140  
2008
        16.0       1,230       1,310  
2007
        27.7       510       600  

Notes:
(1)
Residential mortgage-backed securities.
(2)
Commercial mortgage-backed securities.
(3)
Collateralised loan obligations.

85

 
10  Financial instruments (continued)

             
Reasonably possible 
alternative assumptions
 
Liabilities
Valuation basis/
technique
Main
assumptions
 
Carrying
amount
£bn
   
Increase
fair value
£m
   
Decrease
fair value
£m
 
Debt securities in issue
Proprietary model
Credit spreads
    0.8       20       20  
Derivatives:
                           
Credit derivatives
Proprietary CVA model,
Counterparty credit risk,
    1.6       100       100  
 
industry option models, correlation model
correlation, volatility
                       
Other derivatives
Proprietary model
Volatility, correlation
    1.2       90       90  
Other portfolios
Proprietary model
Credit spreads, correlation
    0.6       40       60  
2008
        4.2       250       270  
2007
        9.2       25       25  

For each of the portfolio categories shown in the above table, set out below is a description of the types of products that comprise the portfolio and the valuation techniques that are applied in determining fair value, including a description of valuation techniques used, including for those in level 2, and inputs to those models and techniques. Where reasonably possible alternative assumptions of unobservable inputs used in models would change the fair value of the portfolio significantly, the alternative inputs are indicated along with the impact this would have on the fair value. Where there have been significant changes to valuation techniques during the year a discussion of the reasons for this are also included.

Loans and advances to customers
Loans in level 3 primarily comprise US commercial mortgages and syndicated loans.

Commercial mortgages
These senior and mezzanine commercial mortgages are loans secured on commercial land and buildings that were originated or acquired by GBM for securitisation. Senior commercial mortgages carry a variable interest rate and mezzanine or more junior commercial mortgages may carry a fixed or variable interest rate. Factors affecting the value of these loans may include, but are not limited to, loan type, underlying property type and geographic location, loan interest rate, loan to value ratios, debt service coverage ratios, prepayment rates, cumulative loan loss information, yields, investor demand, market volatility since the last securitisation, and credit enhancement. Where observable market prices for a particular loan are not available, the fair value will typically be determined with reference to observable market transactions in other loans or credit related products including debt securities and credit derivatives. Assumptions are made about the relationship between the loan and the available benchmark data. Using reasonably possible alternative assumptions for credit spreads (taking into account all other applicable factors) would reduce the fair value of these mortgages of £1.1 billion by up to £18 million or increase the fair value by up to £25 million.

Syndicated lending
The Group’s syndicated lending activities are conducted by the syndicate business in conjunction with the various product lines covering corporate, leveraged, real estate and project finance activities. When a commitment to lend is entered into, the Group estimates the proportion of the loan that is intended to be held for trading on draw down, and the proportion it anticipates to retain on its balance sheet as a loan and receivable. Where the commitment is intended to be syndicated, the commitment to lend is fair valued through profit or loss. On drawdown, the portion of the loan expected to be syndicated is recorded at fair value as a held-for-trading asset, and the expected hold portion is measured at amortised cost less, where appropriate, impairment.

The Group values the portion of the loan expected to be syndicated held at fair value by using market observable syndication prices in the same or similar assets. Where these prices are not available, a discounted cash flow model is used. The model incorporates observable assumptions such as current interest rates and yield curves, the notional and tender amount of the loan, and counterparty credit quality where it is derived from credit default swap spreads using market indices. The model also incorporates unobservable assumptions, including expected refinancing periods, and counterparty credit quality where it is derived from the Group’s internal risk assessments. Derivatives arising from commitments to lend are measured using the same model, based on proxy notional amounts.

Using reasonably possible alternative assumptions for expected cash flows to value these assets of £2.0 billion would reduce the fair value by up to £32 million or increase the fair value by up to £45 million. The assumptions to determine these amounts were based on restructuring scenarios and expected margins.

Debt securities
 
Residential mortgage backed securities (RMBS)
RMBS where the underlying assets are US agency-backed mortgages and there is regular trading are generally classified as level 2 in the fair value hierarchy. RMBS are also classified as level 2 when regular trading is not prevalent in the market, but similar executed trades or third-party data including indices, broker quotes and pricing services can be used to substantiate the fair value. RMBS are classified as level 3 when trading activity is not available and a model is utilised which uses significant unobservable data.

In determining whether an instrument is similar to that being valued, the Group considers a range of factors, principally: the lending standards of the brokers and underwriters that originated the mortgages, the lead manager of the security, the issue date of the respective securities, the underlying asset composition (including origination date, loan to value ratios, historic loss information and geographic location of the mortgages), the credit rating of the instrument, and any credit protection that the instrument may benefit from, such as insurance wraps or subordinated tranches. Where there are instances of market observable data for several similar RMBS tranches, the Group considers the extent of similar characteristics shared with the instrument being valued, together with the frequency,

86



tenor and nature of the trades that have been observed. This method is most frequently used for US and UK RMBS. The RMBS of Dutch and Spanish originated mortgages guaranteed by those governments are valued using the credit spreads of the respective government debt and certain assumptions made by the Group, or based on observable prices from Bloomberg or consensus pricing services.
 
Where there is an absence of trading activity, models are used. The Group primarily uses an industry standard model to project the expected future cash flows to be received from the underlying mortgages and to forecast how these cash flows will be distributed to the various holders of the RMBS. This model utilises data provided by the servicer of the underlying mortgage portfolio, layering on assumptions for mortgage prepayments, probability of default, expected losses, and yield. The Group uses data from third-party sources to calibrate its assumptions, including pricing information from third party pricing services, independent research, broker quotes, and other independent sources. An assessment is made of third-party data source to determine its applicability and reliability. The Group adjusts the model price with a liquidity premium to reflect the price that the instrument could be traded at in the market and may also make adjustments for model deficiencies.
 
The weighted average of the key significant inputs utilised in valuing US level 3 RMBS positions are shown in the table below.
 
   
Weighted–average inputs
2008
 
Non-agency
prime RMBS
   
Alt-A RMBS
Yield
    11.02 %     20.69 %
Probability of  default
  3.00 CDR(1)  
40.00 CDR(1)
Loss severity
    45.00 %(2)     52.25 %(2)
Prepayment
 
12.67 CPR
 
10.65 CPR

Notes:
(1) Constant default rate or probability of  default.
(2) Constant prepayment rate.
 
The fair value of securities within each class of asset changes on a broadly consistent basis in response to changes in given market factors. However, the extent of the change, and therefore the range of reasonably possible alternative assumptions, may be either more or less pronounced, depending on the particular terms and circumstances of the individual security. Through most of 2008, while default rates on sub-prime mortgages were on the rise, there was less transparency and historical data to predict future defaults on both Alt-A and prime securities. As such, the Group felt that probability of default was the least transparent input into Alt-A and prime RMBS modelled valuations throughout 2008 (and most sensitive to variations). The Group believes that a range of 500 basis points greater than and 500 basis points less than the weighted average constant default rate, and a range of 200 basis points greater than and 200 basis points less than the weighted average constant default rate represents a reasonably possible set of acceptable pricing alternatives for Alt-A and prime RMBS, respectively. These assumptions consider the inherently risky nature of Alt-A over prime securities, as well as declining economic condition leading to an increased likelihood of default at year-end. While other key inputs may possess characteristics of unobservability in both Alt-A and prime modelled valuations, the effect of utilising reasonably possible alternatives for these respective inputs would have an immaterial effect on the overall valuation. Using these reasonably possible alternative assumptions the fair value of RMBS of £0.5 billion would be £90 million lower or £40 million higher.
 
Commercial mortgage backed securities
CMBS is valued using an industry standard model and the inputs, where possible, are corroborated using observable market data.
 
For senior CMBS and subordinated tranches, the Group determined that the most sensitive input to reasonably possible alternatives valuation is probability of default and yield respectively. Using reasonably possible alternative assumptions for these inputs, the fair value of CMBS of £0.5 billion would be £20 million lower or £20 million higher.
 
Collateralised debt obligations
CDOs purchased from third parties are valued using independent, third- party quotes or independent lead manager indicative prices. For super senior CDOs which have been originated by the Group no specific third- party information is available. The valuation of these super senior CDOs therefore takes into consideration outputs from a proprietary model, market data and appropriate valuation adjustments.
 
The Group’s proprietary model calculates the expected cashflows from the underlying mortgages using assumptions, derived from publicly available data on future macroeconomic conditions (including house price appreciation and depreciation) and on defaults and delinquencies on these underlying mortgages. The model used by the Group comprises an econometric loan-level model which provides the input to an industry standard ABS model, the output of which feeds a proprietary model generating expected cashflows which are discounted using a risk adjusted rate.
 

87

 
 
 

10  Financial instruments (continued)

Due to the subjectivity of the inputs to the pricing model, alternative valuation points are constructed to benchmark the output of the model. These valuation points include determining an ABS index implied collateral valuation, which provides a market calibrated valuation data point. A collateral net asset value methodology is also considered which uses dealer buy side marks to determine an upper bound for super senior CDO valuations. Both the ABS index implied valuation and the collateral net asset value methodology apply an assumed immediate liquidation approach.
 
The Group, using all pricing points available, may make necessary and appropriate valuation adjustments to the pricing information derived from the proprietary model. These adjustments reflect the Group’s assessment of factors that market participants would consider in setting a price, to the extent that these factors that have not already been included in the model and may include adjustments made for liquidity discounts.
 
In order to provide disclosures of the valuation of super senior CDOs using reasonably possible alternative assumptions, the Group has considered macroeconomic conditions, including house price appreciation and depreciation, and the effect of regional variations. The output from using these alternative assumptions has been compared with inferred pricing from other published data. The Group believes that reasonably possible alternative assumptions could reduce or increase valuations by up to 4%. Using these alternative assumptions would reduce the fair value of level 3 CDOs of £1.1 billion by up to £230 million (super senior CDOs: £190 million) and increase the fair value by up to £230 million (super senior CDOs: £190 million).
 
Collateralised loan obligations
To determine the fair value of CLOs purchased from third parties, the Group use third-party broker or lead manager quotes as the primary pricing source. These quotes are benchmarked to consensus pricing sources where they are available.
 
For CLOs originated and still held by the Group, the fair value is determined using a correlation model based on a Monte Carlo simulation framework. The main model inputs are credit spreads and recovery rates of the underlying assets and their correlation. A credit curve is assigned to each underlying asset based on prices, from third- party dealer quotes, and cash flow profiles, sourced from an industry standard model. Losses are calculated taking into account the attachment and detachment point of the exposure. As the correlation inputs to this model are not observable CLOs are deemed to be level 3. Using reasonably possible alternative assumptions the fair value of CLOs of £1.0 billion would be £40 million lower or £40 million higher.
 
Other debt securities
Other level 3 debt securities comprise £1.3 billion of other ABS of £1.7 billion of other debt securities. Where observable market prices for a particular debt security are not available, the fair value will typically be determined with reference to observable market transactions in other related products, such as similar debt securities or credit derivatives. Assumptions are made about the relationship between the individual debt security and the available benchmark data. Where significant management judgement has been applied in identifying the most relevant related product, or in determining the relationship between the related product and the instrument itself, the valuation is shown in level 3. Using differing assumptions about this relationship would result in different fair values for these assets. The main assumption made is that of relative creditworthiness. Using reasonably possible alternative assumption credit assumptions, taking into account the underlying currency, tenor, and rating of the debt securities within each portfolio, would reduce the fair value of the debt securities of £3.0 billion by up to £50 million or increase the fair value by up to £50 million.
 
Derivatives
Level 3 derivative assets comprised credit derivatives of £4.4 billion and interest rate, foreign exchange rate and commodity derivative contracts of £1.9 billion. Derivative liabilities comprise credit derivatives of £1.6 billion and interest rate, foreign exchange rate and commodity derivatives contracts of £1.2 billion.
 
Derivatives are priced using quoted prices for the same or similar instruments where these are available. However, the majority of derivatives are valued using pricing models. Inputs for these models are usually observed directly in the market, or derived from observed prices. However, it is not always possible to observe or corroborate all model inputs. Unobservable inputs used are based on estimates taking into account a range of available information including historic analysis, historic traded levels, market practice, comparison to other relevant benchmark observable data and consensus pricing data.
 
Credit derivatives
The Group’s credit derivatives include vanilla and bespoke portfolio tranches, gap risk products and certain other unique trades. The bespoke portfolio tranches are synthetic tranches referenced to a bespoke portfolio of corporate names on which the Group purchases credit protection. Bespoke portfolio tranches are valued using Gaussian Copula, a standard method which uses observable market inputs (credit spreads, index tranche prices and recovery rates) to generate an output price for the tranche via a mapping methodology. In essence this method takes the expected loss of the tranche expressed as a fraction of the expected loss of the whole underlying portfolio and calculates which detachment point on the liquid index, and hence which correlation level, coincides with this expected loss fraction. Where the inputs into this valuation technique are observable in the market, bespoke tranches are considered to be level 2 assets. Where inputs are not observable, bespoke tranches are considered to be level 3 assets. However, all transactions executed with a CDPC counterparty are considered level 3 as the counterparty credit risk assessment is a significant component of these valuations.
 
Gap risk products are leveraged trades, with the counterparty’s potential loss capped at the amount of the initial principal invested. Gap risk is the probability that the market will move discontinuously too quickly to exit a portfolio and return the principal to the counterparty without incurring losses, should an unwind event be triggered. This optionality is embedded within these portfolio structures and is very rarely traded outright in the market. Gap risk is not observable in the markets and, as such, these structures are deemed to be level 3 instruments.
 
Other unique trades are valued using a specialised model for each instrument and the same market data inputs as all other trades where applicable. By their nature, the valuation is also driven by a variety of other model inputs, many of which are unobservable in the market.
 
Where these instruments have embedded optionality it is valued using a variation of the Black-Scholes option pricing formula, and where they have correlation exposure it is valued using a variant of the Gaussian Copula model. The volatility or unique correlation inputs required to value these products are generally unobservable and the instruments are therefore deemed to be level 3 instruments.
 
88

 
Other derivatives
Exotic equity, interest rate and commodity options provide a payout (or series of payouts) linked to the performance of one or more underlying, including equities, interest rates, foreign exchange rates and commodities. Included in commodities derivatives are energy contracts entered into by RBS Sempra Commodities. Most of these contracts are valued using models that incorporate observable data. A small number are more complex, structured derivatives which incorporate in their valuation assumptions regarding power price volatilities and correlation between inputs, which are not market observable. These include certain tolling agreements, where power is purchased in return for a given quantity of fuel, and load deals, where a seller agrees to deliver a fixed proportion of power used by a client’s utility customers.
 
Exotic options do not trade in active markets except in a small number of cases. Consequently, the Group uses models to determine fair value using valuation techniques typical for the industry. These techniques can be divided, firstly, into modelling approaches and, secondly, into methods of assessing appropriate levels for model inputs. The Group uses a variety of proprietary models for valuing exotic trades. Exotic valuation inputs include correlation between equities, interest rates, foreign exchange rates and commodity prices. Correlations for more liquid equity and rate pairs are valued using independently sourced consensus pricing levels. Where a consensus pricing benchmark is unavailable, these instruments are categorised as level 3.
 
Reasonably possible alternative assumptions
In determining the effect of reasonably possible alternative assumptions for unobservable inputs, the Group has considered credit derivative trades with CDPCs separately from all other level 3 derivatives due to the significant element of subjectivity in determining the counterparty credit risk.
 
The fair value of credit derivative trades with CDPCs as at 31 December 2008 was £2.6 billion before applying a CVA of £0.7 billion. The Group’s credit derivative exposures to CDPCs are valued using pricing models with inputs observed directly in the market. An adjustment is made to the model valuation as the creditworthiness of CDPC counterparties differs from that of the credit risk assumptions used in the model. The adjustment reflects the estimated cost of hedging the counterparty risk arising from each trade. In the absence of market observable credit spreads of CDPCs, the cost of hedging the counterparty risk is estimated from an analysis of the underlying trades and the cost of hedging expected default losses in excess of the capital available in each vehicle. A reasonably possible alternative approach would be to estimate the cost of hedging the counterparty risk from market observable credit spreads of entities considered similar to CDPCs (for example monoline insurers with similar business or similarly rated entities). These reasonably possible alternative approaches would reduce the fair value credit derivatives with CDPCs by up to £390 million or increase the fair value by up to £400 million.
 
For all other level 3 derivatives, unobservable inputs are principally comprised of correlations and volatilities. Where a derivative valuation relies significantly on an unobservable input, the valuation is shown in level 3. It is usual for such derivative valuations to depend on several observable, and one or few unobservable model inputs. In determining reasonably possible alternative assumptions, the relative impact of unobservable inputs as compared to those which may be observed was considered. Using reasonably possible alternative assumptions the fair value of all other level 3 derivative assets (excluding CDPCs) would be reduced by up to £300 million or increased by up to £310 million and derivative liabilities would be reduced by up to £190 million or increased by up to £190 million.
 
Equity shares  private equity
Private equity investments include unit holdings and limited partnership interests primarily in corporate private equity funds, debt funds and fund of hedges funds. Externally managed funds are valued using recent prices where available. Where not available, the fair value of investments in externally managed funds is generally determined using statements or other information provided by the fund managers.
 
Although such valuations are provided from third parties, the Group recognises that such valuations may rely significantly on the judgements and estimates made by those fund managers, particularly in assessing private equity components. Following the decline in liquidity in world markets, the Group believes that there is sufficient subjectivity in such valuations to report them in level 3.
 
Reasonably possible alternative valuations have been determined based on the historic trends in valuations received, and by considering the possible impact of market movements towards the end of the reporting period, which may not be fully reflected in valuations received. Using these reasonably possible alternate assumptions would reduce the fair value of externally managed funds of £0.5 billion by up to £140 million or increase the fair value by up to £70 million.
 
Other financial instruments
Other than the portfolios discussed above, there are other financial instruments which are held at fair value determined from data which are not market observable, or incorporating material adjustments to market observed data. Using reasonably possible alternate assumptions appropriate to the liability in question, such as credit spreads, derivative inputs and equity correlations, would reduce the fair value of other financial instruments held at fair value of £1.4 billion, mainly debt securities in issue of £0.8 billion, by up to £80 million or increase the fair value by up to £60 million.
 
 
89


Notes on the accounts continued
 
10  Financial instruments (continued)
Own credit
When valuing financial liabilities recorded at fair value, the Group takes into account the effect of its own credit standing. The categories of financial liabilities on which own credit spread adjustments are made are issued debt, including issued structured notes, and derivatives. An own credit adjustment is applied to positions where it is believed that counterparties would consider the Group’s creditworthiness when pricing trades.
 
For issued debt and structured notes, this adjustment is based on independent quotes from market participants for the debt issuance spreads above average inter-bank rates (at a range of tenors) which the market would demand when purchasing new senior or sub-debt issuances from the Group. Where necessary, these quotes are interpolated using a curve shape derived from CDS prices.
 
The fair value of the Group’s derivative financial liabilities reflects the Group’s own credit risk. The adjustment takes into account collateral posted by the Group and the effects of master netting agreements. No adjustments were made for own credit risk in relation to derivative liabilities in prior periods as it was not a significant factor in the pricing of derivative transactions by market participants. The change in methodology reflects market turbulence in 2008 which led to participants focussing increased attention on counterparty credit quality.
 
The table below shows the own credit spread adjustments on liabilities recorded in the income statement during the year.
 
   
  Debt securities in issue
 
   
Held-for-
trading
£m
   
Designated at
fair value through
profit and loss
£m
   
Total
£m
   
Derivatives
£m
   
Total
£m
 
At 1 January 2008
    123       152       275             275  
Effect of  changes to credit spreads
    396       373       769       360       1,129  
Benefit of  foreign exchange hedges
    208       195       403             403  
New issues
    78       97       175             175  
At 31 December 2008
    805       817       1,622       360       1,982  

 
 
90

 
 
Reclassification of financial instruments
 
As discussed in accounting policies on page 61, during 2008 the Group reclassified financial assets from the held-for-trading (HFT) and available-for- sale categories (AFS) into the loans and receivables (LAR) category (as permitted by paragraph 50D of IAS 39 as amended) and from the held-for-trading category into the available-for-sale category (as permitted by paragraph 50B of IAS 39 as amended).
 
The turbulence in the financial markets during the second half of 2008 was regarded by management as rare circumstances in the context of paragraph 50B of IAS 39 as amended.
 
The balance sheet values of these assets, the effect of the reclassification on the income statement for the period from the date of reclassification to 31 December 2008 and the gains and losses relating to these assets recorded in the income statement for the years ended 31 December 2008, 2007 and 2006 were as follows:
 
   
Group
 
                                 
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
   
2008 – on reclassification
   
31 December 2008
         
After reclassification
                   
   
Carrying
value
   
Effective
interest
rate
   
Expected
cash
flows
   
Carrying
value
   
Fair
value
   
Gains/(losses)
up to the
date of
reclassi-
fication
   
Income
   
Impairment
losses
   
Gains/
(losses)
in AFS
reserves
   
Amount
that would
have been
recognised
   
Gains/(losses)
recognised in
the income
statement
in prior
periods
 
      £m    
%
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Reclassified from HFT to LAR:
                                                                                             
Loans:
                                                                                             
Leveraged finance
    3,602       10.15       6,083       4,304       2,523       (457 )     454                     (1,206 )     (155 )      
Corporate loans
    5,040       6.19       7,582       5,827       4,940       (76 )     198                     (681 )     (50 )     3  
      8,642               13,665       10,131       7,463       (533 )     652                     (1,887 )     (205 )     3  
Debt securities:
                                                                                               
CDO of  RMBS
    215       4.92       259       236       221       4       5                     (11 )     5       6  
RMBS
    1,534       6.05       1,815       1,695       1,311       (108 )     157                     (227 )     (12 )      
CMBS
    1       11.11       4       1       1       1                                        
CLOs
    744       6.65       1,040       827       598       (21 )     104                     (125 )     (14 )     (2 )
Other ABS
    1,649       5.24       2,547       1,757       1,382       (61 )     116                     (259 )     3       (1 )
Other
    2,538       2.62       2,764       2,602       2,388       72       3                     (166 )     94       476  
      6,681               8,429       7,118       5,901       (113 )     385                     (788 )     76       479  
Total
    15,323               22,094       17,249       13,364       (646 )     1,037                     (2,675 )     (129 )     482  
Reclassified from HFT to AFS:
                                                                                               
Debt securities:
                                                                                               
CDO of  RMBS
    3,382       4.65       4,178       3,077       3,077       (438 )     1,281       (43 )     (441 )     798       (119 )      
RMBS
    5,205       8.03       8,890       5,171       5,171       (530 )     24             (162 )     (122 )     (4 )     73  
CMBS
    32       6.81       85       31       31       (5     5             (3     2       (4      
CLOs
    1,207       4.88       1,477       1,063       1,063       (128 )     435             (267 )     168       (34 )     1  
Other ABS
    786       4.47       1,262       761       761       (67 )     64             (42 )     22       (8 )     72  
Other
    210       20.23       610       175       175       7       4             (58 )     (41 )            
      10,822               16,502       10,278       10,278       (1,161 )     1,813       (43 )     (973 )     827       (169 )     146  
Reclassified from AFS to LAR:
                                                                                               
Debt securities
    704       1.38       772       1,028       968       (12 )(1)     6                   (37 ) (1)            
Total
    26,849               39,368       28,555       24,610       (1,819 )     2,856       (43 )     (973 )     (1,885 )     (298 )     628  
 
Note:
(1)   Gains/(losses) recognised in the available-for-sale reserve.
 
 
91


Notes on the accounts continued

10  Financial instruments (continued)
   
Bank
 
                                 
After
 
   
2008 – on reclassification
   
31 December 2008
   
reclassification
 
                                 
Gains/
 
         
Effective
   
Expected
               
(losses)
 
   
Carrying
   
interest
   
cash
   
Carrying
   
Fair
   
in AFS
 
   
value
   
rate
   
flows
   
value
   
value
   
reserves
 
2008
    £m    
%
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Reclassified from HFT to LAR:
                                             
Loans:
                                             
Leveraged finance
    3,602       10.15       6,083       4,304       2,523        
Corporate loans
    4,874       6.10       6,960       5,625       4,738        
      8,476               13,043       9,929       7,261        
Debt securities:
                                               
CDO of  RMBS
    215       4.92       259       236       221        
RMBS
    1,533       6.05       1,815       1,695       1,311        
CMBS
    1       11.11       4       1       1        
CLOs
    744       6.65       1,040       827       598        
Other ABS
    1,649       5.24       2,547       1,757       1,382        
Other
    2,538       2.62       2,765       2,602       2,387        
      6,680               8,430       7,118       5,900        
Total
    15,156               21,473       17,047       13,161        
Reclassified from HFT to AFS:
                                               
Debt securities:
                                               
CDO of RMBS
    3,382       4.65       4,177       3,077       3,077       (441 )
RMBS
    5,205       8.03       8,890       5,171       5,171       (162 )
CMBS
    32       6.81       85       31       31       (3 )
CLOs
    1,207       4.88       1,477       1,063       1,063       (267 )
Other ABS
    786       4.47       1,262       761       761       (42 )
Other
    210       20.23       610       175       175       (58 )
      10,822               16,501       10,278       10,278       (973 )
Reclassified from AFS to LAR:
                                               
Debt securities (1)
    704       1.38       772       1,028       968        
Total
    26,682               38,746       28,353       24,407       (973 )

Note:
(1)   The available-for-sale reserve was £12 million loss to the date of reclassification and would have increased by a further £37 million loss if reclassification had not occurred.

92

 
Amounts included in the income statement:
       
Group
       
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Gains on financial assets/liabilities designated as at fair value through profit or loss
    198       721       344  
Gains on disposal or settlement of  loans and receivables
    4       10       21  

On the initial recognition of  financial assets and liabilities valued using valuation techniques incorporating information other than observable market data, any difference between the transaction price and that derived from the valuation technique is deferred. Such amounts are recognised in profit or loss over the life of  the transaction; when market data become observable; or when the transaction matures or is closed out as appropriate. At 31 December 2008, net gains of  £42 million (2007 – £62 million) were carried forward in the balance sheet. During the year net gains of  £25 million (2007 – £57 million) were deferred and £47 million (2007 – £10 million) released to profit or loss.


Fair value of  financial instruments not carried at fair value.
 
The following table shows the carrying values and the fair values of  financial instruments on the balance sheets carried at amortised cost.
 
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2008
   
2007
   
2007
   
2008
   
2008
   
2007
   
2007
 
   
Carrying
   
Fair
   
Carrying
   
Fair
   
Carrying
   
Fair
   
Carrying
   
Fair
 
   
value
   
value
   
value
   
value
   
value
   
value
   
value
   
value
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Financial assets
                                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
    6,806       6,806       5,559       5,559       3,714       3,714       3,333       3,333  
Loans and advances to banks
                                                               
Loans and receivables
    18,430       18,441       23,649       23,644       35,628       35,663       31,342       31,343  
Loans and advances to customers
                                                               
Loans and receivables
    551,110       507,219       430,837       433,655       266,734       238,345       218,364       218,490  
Finance leases
    14,453       14,527       12,570       12,376                          
Debt securities
                                                               
Loans and receivables
    11,756       10,479       500       500       48,983       47,706              
Settlement balances
    10,871       10,871       5,326       5,326       5,335       5,335       2,046       2,046  
                                                                 
Financial liabilities
                                                               
Deposits by banks
    95,044       94,414       79,794       79,614       116,140       115,993       125,707       125,697  
Customer accounts
    392,605       392,106       379,072       378,793       182,918       182,426       140,049       139,985  
Debt securities in issue
    163,787       158,707       111,656       111,676       99,057       98,700       61,527       61,530  
Settlement balances and short positions
    8,785       8,785       6,791       6,791       5,534       5,534       3,110       3,110  
Subordinated liabilities
    39,243       36,084       27,438       26,206       32,990       30,528       22,387       21,137  
 
Notes:
(1)  
Financial assets and financial liabilities for which carrying amount approximates to fair value because they are of  short maturity.
(2)  
Fair values are estimated by discounting expected future cash flows; using current interest rates and making adjustments for credit.
(3)  
The fair value of deposits repayable on demand is equal to their carrying value. The fair value of other deposits by banks and customer accounts is estimated by discounting expected future cash flows at current rates and adjusting, where appropriate, for the Group’s own credit spread. The fair value of many of these instruments approximates to their carrying value because they are of short maturity or reprice frequently.
(4)  
The fair value of short-term debt securities in issue is close to their carrying value. The fair value of other debt securities in issue is based on quoted prices; where these are unavailable fair value is estimated using other valuation techniques.
(5)  
The fair value of  subordinated liabilities in issue is based on quoted prices; where these are unavailable fair value is estimated using other valuation techniques.

 
93

 
Notes on the accounts continued


10  Financial instruments (continued)
 
Remaining maturity

The following tables show the residual maturity of  financial instruments, based on contract date of  maturity.

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Less than
   
More than
         
Less than
   
More than
       
   
12 months
   
12 months
   
Total
   
12 months
   
12 months
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
    6,804       2       6,806       5,559             5,559  
Loans and advances to banks
    77,874       1,513       79,387       91,951       4,395       96,346  
Loans and advances to customers
    245,607       373,896       619,503       251,553       299,896       551,449  
Debt securities
    54,909       122,857       177,766       34,593       129,839       164,432  
Equity shares
          2,691       2,691             5,509       5,509  
Settlement balances
    10,869       2       10,871       5,298       28       5,326  
Derivatives
    175,147       762,310       937,457       41,432       164,543       205,975  
                                                 
Liabilities
                                               
Deposits by banks
    176,319       5,663       181,982       143,919       7,589       151,508  
Customer accounts
    438,114       15,015       453,129       430,297       12,685       442,982  
Debt securities in issue
    122,495       57,447       179,942       79,552       50,580       130,132  
Settlement balances and short positions
    18,090       27,867       45,957       30,597       23,252       53,849  
Derivatives
    166,208       742,897       909,105       45,362       157,710       203,072  
Subordinated liabilities
    1,859       38,092       39,951       811       26,985       27,796  
 
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Less than
   
More than
         
Less than
   
More than
       
   
12 months
   
12 months
   
Total
   
12 months
   
12 months
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
    3,714             3,714       3,333             3,333  
Loans and advances to banks
    84,230       7,487       91,717       85,920       6,062       91,982  
Loans and advances to customers
    179,790       147,250       327,040       185,992       143,155       329,147  
Debt securities
    48,458       111,240       159,698       27,045       80,205       107,250  
Equity shares
          1,020       1,020             4,019       4,019  
Settlement balances
    5,334       1       5,335       2,018       28       2,046  
Derivatives
    172,539       765,966       938,505       41,750       166,163       207,913  
                                                 
Liabilities
                                               
Deposits by banks
    194,512       6,754       201,266       190,825       6,143       196,968  
Customer accounts
    200,767       28,499       229,266       183,887       14,039       197,926  
Debt securities in issue
    83,500       31,649       115,149       58,420       21,457       79,877  
Settlement balances and short positions
    13,277       16,084       29,361       26,100       7,577       33,677  
Derivatives
    163,500       747,674       911,174       45,367       158,867       204,234  
Subordinated liabilities
    850       32,848       33,698       603       22,142       22,745  


94


 
Balance sheet
 
The following tables show the contractual undiscounted cash flows payable up to a period of  20 years including future payments of  interest.

   
Group
 
   
0-3 months
   
3-12 months
   
1-3 years
   
3-5 years
   
5-10 years
   
10-20 years
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Deposits by banks
    83,879       5,938       3,114       1,758       662       34  
Customer accounts
    368,115       18,634       2,313       2,811       4,105       2,718  
Debt securities in issue
    110,728       30,213       22,461       3,581       5,600       4,038  
Derivatives held for hedging
    67       755       1,926       674       597       317  
Subordinated liabilities
    972       2,659       5,113       5,583       17,213       13,287  
Settlement balances and other liabilities
    10,407       5       7       4       7       6  
      574,168       58,204       34,934       14,411       28,184       20,400  
2007
                                               
Deposits by banks
    71,944       4,739       1,539       2,344       39       48  
Customer accounts
    367,881       6,043       1,833       1,697       4,732       2,488  
Debt securities in issue
    73,927       20,638       15,256       7,789       4,884       2,200  
Derivatives held for hedging
    38       357       531       227       210       97  
Subordinated liabilities
    402       1,909       4,686       3,305       15,770       9,540  
Settlement balances and other liabilities
    7,242       5       14       6       12       7  
      521,434       33,691       23,859       15,368       25,647       14,380  
 
   
Bank
 
   
0-3 months
   
3-12 months
   
1-3 years
   
3-5 years
   
5-10 years
   
10-20 years
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Deposits by banks
    102,525       9,033       2,990       1,840       778       47  
Customer accounts
    156,050       16,035       1,216       4,353       4,241       2,801  
Debt securities in issue
    59,229       25,623       18,247       2,299       4,752       2,178  
Derivatives held for hedging
    24       195       349       154       206       152  
Subordinated liabilities
    718       1,541       3,210       4,832       16,647       10,819  
Settlement balances and other liabilities
    6,621                                
      325,167       52,427       26,012       13,478       26,624       15,997  
2007
                                               
Deposits by banks
    115,262       6,782       2,170       1,859       901       58  
Customer accounts
    125,043       4,170       3,978       3,197       4,840       2,673  
Debt securities in issue
    39,694       17,282       8,155       1,801       2,478       2,123  
Derivatives held for hedging
    36       143       157       101       110       31  
Subordinated liabilities
    328       1,172       2,994       2,681       14,536       7,889  
Settlement balances and other liabilities
    3,093       1       8       4       8        
      283,456       29,550       17,462       9,643       22,873       12,774  

 
The tables above show the timing of cash outflows to settle financial liabilities. They have been prepared on the following basis:
 
Financial liabilities are included at the earliest date on which the counterparty can require repayment regardless of whether or not such early repayment results in a penalty. If repayment is triggered by, or is subject to, specific criteria such as market price hurdles being reached, the liability is included at the earliest possible date that the conditions could be fulfilled without considering the probability of the conditions being met. For example, if a structured note is automatically prepaid when an equity index exceeds a certain level, the cash outflow will be included in the less than three months period whatever the level of the index at the year end. The settlement date of debt securities in issue issued by certain securitisation vehicles consolidated by the Group depends on when cash flows are received from the securitised assets. Where these assets are prepayable, the timing of the cash outflow relating to securities assumes that each asset will be prepaid at the earliest possible date.
 
Liabilities with a contractual maturity of greater than 20 years  the principal amounts of financial liabilities that are repayable after 20 years or where the counterparty has no right to repayment of the principal are excluded from the table as are interest payments after 20 years.
 
Held-for-trading liabilities  held-for-trading liabilities amounting to £1,091.7 billion (2007 – £392.2 billion) and £1,069.6 billion (2007 – £373.0 billion) for the Bank have been excluded from the table in view of their short term nature.


95

 
 
Notes on the accounts continued
 
11  Past due and impaired financial assets

The following tables show the movement in the provision for impairment losses for loans and advances.

   
Group
 
   
Individually
   
Collectively
         
Total
             
   
assessed
   
assessed
   
Latent
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January
    639       2,996       600       4,235       3,929       3,886  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    164       113       176       453       30       (62 )
(Disposals)/acquisitions
          (148 )     (30 )     (178 )     6        
Amounts written-off
    (636 )     (1,811 )           (2,447 )     (1,652 )     (1,841 )
Recoveries of  amounts previously written-off
    23       188             211       245       215  
Charged to the income statement
    1,790       2,183       582       4,555       1,843       1,873  
Unwind of  discount
    (33 )     (141 )           (174 )     (166 )     (142 )
At 31 December (1)
    1,947       3,380       1,328       6,655       4,235       3,929  
 
Note:
(1)   The provision for impairment losses at 31 December 2008 includes £83 million relating to loans and advances to banks (2007 – £2 million; 2006 – £2 million).

   
Bank
 
   
Individually
   
Collectively
         
Total
             
   
assessed
   
assessed
   
Latent
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January
    277       814       182       1,273       1,353       1,219  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    91       1             92       (9 )     76  
Amounts written-off
    (358 )     (436 )           (794 )     (553 )     (634 )
Recoveries of  amounts previously written-off
    6       51             57       76       63  
Charged to the income statement
    1,212       519       177       1,908       471       692  
Unwind of  discount
    (9 )     (52 )           (61 )     (65 )     (63 )
At 31 December
    1,219       897       359       2,475       1,273       1,353  
 
Note:
(1)
The provision for impairment losses at 31 December 2008 includes £81 million relating to loans and advances to banks (2007 and 2006 - nil).
 
 
   
Group
 
 
 
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
    £m       £m       £m  
Impairment charged to the income statement
                       
Loans and advances to customers
    4,474       1,843       1,873  
Loans and advances to banks
    81              
      4,555       1,843       1,873  
Debt securities
    71       20        
Equity shares
    80       2        
      151       22        
      4,706       1,865       1,873  
   
 
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Gross income not recognised but which would have been recognised under the original terms of non-accrual and restructured loans
                       
Domestic
    384       390       370  
Foreign
    229       64       77  
      613       454       447  
Interest on non-accrual and restructured loans included in net interest income
                       
Domestic
    150       165       142  
Foreign
    24       16       15  
      174       181       157  
 
 

96

 
The following tables show analyses of impaired financial assets.

   
  2008
   
  2007
 
               
Net book
               
Net book
 
   
Cost
   
Provision
   
value
   
Cost
   
Provision
   
value
 
Group
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Impaired financial assets
                                               
Loans and advances to banks (1)
    83       83             2       2        
Loans and advances to customers (2)
    13,643       5,244       8,399       6,665       3,633       3,032  
Debt securities (1)
    33       18       15       1             1  
Equity shares (1)
    164       124       40       54       45       9  
      13,923       5,469       8,454       6,722       3,680       3,042  
 
     
  2008
   
  2007
 
                   
Net book
                   
Net book
 
   
Cost
   
Provision
   
value
   
Cost
   
Provision
   
value
 
Bank
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Impaired financial assets
                                               
Loans and advances to banks (1)
    81       81                          
Loans and advances to customers (3)
    5,622       2,035       3,587       2,088       1,091       997  
Debt securities (1)
    17       2       15                    
Equity securities (1)
    75       44       31                    
      5,795       2,162       3,633       2,088       1,091       997  

Notes:
(1)
Impairment provisions individually assessed.
(2)
Impairment provisions individually assessed on balances of  £6,864 million (2007 £1,226 million).
(3)
Impairment provisions individually assessed on balances of  £3,761 million (2007 £518 million).


The Group and Bank hold collateral in respect of certain loans and advances to banks and to customers that are past due or impaired. Such collateral includes mortgages over property (both personal and commercial); charges over business assets such as plant, inventories and trade debtors; and guarantees of lending from parties other than the borrower.

The following table shows financial and non-financial assets, recognised on the Group's balance sheet, obtained during the year by taking possession of collateral or calling on other credit enhancements.

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Residential property
    41       31  
Cash
    59       18  
Other assets
    30       4  
      130       53  
               
               
   
Bank
   
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Cash
    30       15  
 
In general, the Group seeks to dispose of property and other assets obtained by taking possession of collateral that are not readily convertible into cash as rapidly as the market for the individual asset permits.
 
 
97

 
Notes on the accounts continued


11  Past due and impaired financial assets (continued)
 
The following loans and advances to customers were past due at the balance sheet date but not considered impaired:

   
  Group
               
Bank
             
                     
Past due
                           
Past due
       
   
Past due
   
Past due
   
Past due
   
90 days
         
Past due
   
Past due
   
Past due
   
90 days
       
   
1-29 days
   
30-59 days
   
60-89 days
   
or more
   
Total
   
1-29 days
   
30-59 days
   
60-89 days
   
or more
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
2008
    7,851       2,138       1,139       1,669       12,797       1,201       415       221       645       2,482  
                                                                                 
2007
    6,233       1,613       981       256       9,083       1,703       440       190       168       2,501  

These balances include loans and advances to customers that are past due through administrative and other delays in recording payments or in finalising documentation and other events unrelated to credit quality.

Loans that have been renegotiated in the past 12 months that would otherwise have been past due or impaired amounted to £2,637 million (Bank £2,141 million) as at 31 December 2008 (2007: Group £577 million; Bank £259 million).


12  Derivatives

Companies in the Group transact derivatives as principal either as a trading activity or to manage balance sheet foreign exchange, interest rate and credit risk.

The Group enters into fair value hedges, cash flow hedges and hedges of net investments in foreign operations. The majority of the Groups interest rate hedges relate to the management of the Groups non- trading interest rate risk. The Group manages this risk to Value-at-Risk limits. The risk is assessed using gap reports that show maturity mismatches. To the extent that such mismatches exceed predetermined limits they are closed by executing derivatives principally interest rate swaps. Suitable larger ticket financial instruments are fair value hedged; the remaining exposure, where possible, is hedged by derivatives documented as cash flow hedges and qualifying for hedge accounting. The majority of the Groups fair value hedges involve interest rate swaps hedging the interest rate risk in recognised financial assets and financial liabilities. Cash flow hedges relate to exposure to variability in future interest payments and receipts on forecast transactions and on recognised financial assets and financial liabilities. The Group hedges its net investments in foreign operations with currency borrowings and forward exchange contracts.

For cash flow hedge relationships of interest rate risk, the hedged items are actual and forecast variable interest rate cash flows arising from financial assets and financial liabilities with interest rates linked to LIBOR, EURIBOR or the Bank of England Official Bank Rate. The financial assets are customer loans and the financial liabilities are customer deposits and LIBOR linked medium-term notes and other issued securities. As at 31 December 2008, variable rate financial assets of £24.0 billion for the Group and £21.3 billion for the Bank, and variable rate financial liabilities of £27.4 billion for the Group and £5.7 billion for the Bank were hedged in such cash flow hedge relationships.

For cash flow hedging relationships, the initial and ongoing prospective effectiveness is assessed by comparing movements in the fair value of the expected highly probable forecast interest cash flows with movements in the fair value of the expected changes in cash flows from the hedging interest rate swap or by comparing the respective changes in the price value of a basis point. Prospective effectiveness is measured on a cumulative basis i.e. over the entire life of the hedge relationship. The method of calculating hedge ineffectiveness is the hypothetical derivative method. Retrospective effectiveness is assessed by comparing the actual movements in the fair value of the cash flows and actual movements in the fair value of the hedged cash flows from the interest rate swap over the life to date of the hedging relationship.

For fair value hedge relationships of interest rate risk, the hedged items are typically large corporate fixed rate loans, fixed rate finance leases, fixed rate medium-term notes or preference shares classified as debt. As at 31 December 2008, fixed rate financial assets of £13.9 billion for the Group and £4.8 billion for the Bank, and fixed rate financial liabilities of £26.5 billion for the Group and £20.1 billion for the Bank were hedged by interest rate swaps in fair value hedge relationships.

The initial and ongoing prospective effectiveness of fair value hedge relationships is assessed on a cumulative basis by comparing movements in the fair value of the hedged item attributable to the hedged risk with changes in the fair value of the hedging interest rate swap. Retrospective effectiveness is assessed by comparing the actual movements in the fair value of the hedged items attributable to the hedged risk with actual movements in the fair value of the hedging derivative over the life to date of the hedging relationship.
 
 
98

 


   
  Group
 
   
  2008
         
2007
       
   
Notional
               
Notional
             
   
amounts
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
   
amounts
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
 
   
£bn
      £m       £m    
£bn
      £m       £m  
Exchange rate contracts
                                           
Spot, forwards and futures
    2,230       84,165       82,395       1,669       16,486       18,091  
Currency swaps
    848       41,004       44,241       359       8,231       7,628  
Options purchased
    656       39,025             450       11,943        
Options written
    702             37,024       469             11,317  
                                                 
Interest rate contracts
                                               
Interest rate swaps
    36,701       517,731       502,408       20,479       115,928       114,799  
Options purchased
    5,774       99,924             3,886       27,609        
Options written
    3,887             97,842       3,424             27,553  
Futures and forwards
    9,049       8,530       7,273       2,805       708       876  
                                                 
Credit derivatives
    2,111       131,680       122,198       1,112       21,234       18,537  
                                                 
Equity and commodity contracts
    534       15,398       15,724       110       3,836       4,271  
              937,457       909,105               205,975       203,072  

Certain derivative asset and liability balances with the London Clearing House, which meet the offset criteria in IAS 32 Financial Instruments: Presentation, are now shown net. Comparative figures have been restated, reducing derivative assets and liabilities at 31 December 2007 by £43,930 million for the Group and the Bank.

Included in the above are derivatives held for hedging purposes as follows:

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Fair value hedging:
                               
Interest rate swaps
    2,047       1,290       546       379  
                                 
Cash flow hedging:
                               
Exchange rate contracts
          77       4       24  
Interest rate swaps
    2,168       2,178       369       777  
Commodity contracts
    39       14              
                                 
Net investment hedging:
                               
Exchange rate contracts
                      90  
                                 
Amounts above include:
                               
Due from/to holding company
    361       1,168       179       173  
Due from/to fellow subsidiaries
    56,063       53,222       2,771       2,740  
 
 
99

 
 
Notes on the accounts continued


12  Derivatives (continued)
 
Hedge ineffectiveness recognised in other operating income comprised:

   
  Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m  
Fair value hedging:
                       
Gains on the hedged items attributable to the hedged risk
    (949 )     66       219  
Losses on the hedging instruments
    905       (72 )     (215 )
Fair value ineffectiveness
    (44 )     (6 )     4  
Cash flow hedging ineffectiveness
    (16 )     9       4  
      (60 )     3       8  

The following tables show for interest rate swaps in cash flow hedges for the Group, when the hedged cash flows are expected to occur and when they will affect profit or loss.

   
2008
 
Hedged forecast cash flows
    0-1       1-2       2-3       3-4       4-5       5-10       10-20    
Over 20
       
 
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
Total
 
expected to occur
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Forecast receivable cash flows
    648       641       568       459       329       869       240       41       3,795  
Forecast payable cash flows
    (417 )     (357 )     (273 )     (232 )     (197 )     (527 )     (307 )     (47 )     (2,357 )
 
   
  2008
 
Hedged forecast cash flows
    0-1       1-2       2-3       3-4       4-5       5-10       10-20    
Over 20
       
 
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
Total
 
affect profit or loss
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Forecast receivable cash flows
    649       639       561       453       327       835       237       36       3,737  
Forecast payable cash flows
    (413 )     (355 )     (268 )     (229 )     (192 )     (513 )     (305 )     (47 )     (2,322 )

   
  Bank
 
   
  2008
 
  2007
 
   
Notional
               
Notional
             
   
amounts
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
   
amounts
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
 
   
£bn
      £m       £m    
£bn
      £m       £m  
Exchange rate contracts
                                           
Spot, forwards and futures
    2,260       85,353       83,417       1,683       16,877       18,061  
Currency swaps
    863       41,783       48,100       363       8,896       7,927  
Options purchased
    659       39,133             452       12,022        
Options written
    706             37,134       471             11,400  
                                                 
Interest rate contracts
                                               
Interest rate swaps
    36,786       522,729       504,692       20,544       116,633       115,141  
Options purchased
    5,750       99,648             3,816       27,549        
Options written
    3,873             97,812       3,364             27,545  
Futures and forwards
    8,991       8,524       7,270       2,781       707       876  
                                                 
Credit derivatives
    2,358       132,531       123,555       1,124       21,539       18,998  
                                                 
Equity and commodity contracts
    374       8,804       9,194       109       3,690       4,286  
              938,505       911,174               207,913       204,234  

 
 
100


 

Included in the above are derivatives held for hedging purposes as follows:

   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Fair value hedging:
                               
Interest rate swaps
    1,850       411       372       241  
                                 
Cash flow hedging:
                               
Exchange rate contracts
          77       4       24  
Interest rate swaps
    1,907       498       271       236  
Commodity contracts
    39                    
                                 
Amounts above include:
                               
Due from/to holding company
    361       1,168       179       173  
Due from/to fellow subsidiaries
    56,054       52,954       2,771       2,740  
Due from/to subsidiaries
    12,445       11,141       4,059       2,443  

The following tables show for interest rate swaps in cash flow hedges for the Bank, when the hedged cash flows are expected to occur and when they will affect profit or loss.

   
2008
Hedged forecast cash flows
    0-1       1-2       2-3       3-4       4-5       5-10       10-20    
Over 20
     
 
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
Total
   
expected to occur
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m    
Forecast receivable cash flows
    594       587       521       418       300       771       177       41       3,409  
Forecast payable cash flows
    (137 )     (107 )     (66 )     (54 )     (49 )     (182 )     (175 )     (47 )     (817 )
 
   
2008
Hedged forecast cash flows
    0-1       1-2       2-3       3-4       4-5       5-10       10-20    
Over 20
           
 
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
years
   
Total
affect profit or loss
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Forecast receivable cash flows
    595       585       514       412       298       737       174       36       3,351  
Forecast payable cash flows
    (135 )     (107 )     (64 )     (54 )     (49 )     (180 )     (175 )     (47 )     (811 )

 
101

 
Notes on the accounts continued


13  Debt securities

   
  Group
 
                           
Mortgage
                   
   
UK central
   
US central
   
Other central
   
Bank and
   
and other
                   
   
and local
   
and local
   
and local
   
building
   
asset backed
                   
   
government
   
government
   
government
   
society
   
securities(1)
   
Corporate
   
Other(2)
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Held-for-trading
    5,363       9,842       33,223       1,590       35,771       15,275       709       101,773  
Designated as at fair value through profit or loss
    1,994       510                   1       88       6       2,599  
Available-for-sale
    10,915       1,008       2,796       8,625       36,052       2,218       24       61,638  
Loans and receivables
                      102       7,915       3,738       1       11,756  
      18,272       11,360       36,019       10,317       79,739       21,319       740       177,766  
                                                                 
Available-for-sale
                                                               
Gross unrealised gains
    16       30       25       13       308       1       1       394  
Gross unrealised losses
          (5 )     (95 )     (86 )     (2,763 )     (136 )     (1 )     (3,086 )
 
                                                               
2007
                                                               
Held-for-trading
    8,952       14,405       36,410       1,016       50,606       25,026       370       136,785  
Designated as at fair value through profit or loss
    1,881       397       6       123       203       140       104       2,854  
Available-for-sale
    605       562       1,545       5,816       13,609       1,415       741       24,293  
Loans and receivables
                            500                   500  
      11,438       15,364       37,961       6,955       64,918       26,581       1,215       164,432  
                                                                 
Available-for-sale
                                                               
Gross unrealised gains
    23       13       7       4       14       8       1       70  
Gross unrealised losses
          (35 )     (2 )     (29 )     (125 )     (5 )           (196 )

Notes:
(1)
Includes securities issued by US federal agencies and government sponsored entities.
(2)
Includes non asset-backed securities issued by US federal agencies and government sponsored entities.
(3)
During 2008 the Group reclassified financial assets from the held-for-trading and available-for-sale categories into the loans and receivables category and from the held-for-trading category into the available-for-sale category (see page 91).

Gross gains of  £64 million (2007 £56 million) and gross losses of  £72 million (2007 £5 million) were realised by the Group on the sale of  available- for-sale securities.

   
Bank
 
                           
Mortgage
                   
   
UK central
   
US central
   
Other central
   
Bank and
   
and other
                   
   
and local
   
and local
   
and local
   
building
   
 asset backed
                   
   
government
   
government
   
government
   
society
   
securities(1)
   
Corporate
   
Other(2)
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Held-for-trading
    5,363       1,960       29,693       1,595       15,433       13,200       667       67,911  
Designated as at fair value through profit or loss
          296                         610             906  
Available-for-sale
    10,915             1,452       7,912       18,506       3,113             41,898  
Loans and receivables
                      290       44,954       3,738       1       48,983  
      16,278       2,256       31,145       9,797       78,893       20,661       668       159,698  
                                                                 
Available-for-sale
                                                               
Gross unrealised gains
    16             1       12       16       1             46  
Gross unrealised losses
                (95 )     (62 )     (2,173 )     (204 )           (2,534 )
 
                                                               
2007
                                                               
Held-for-trading
    8,952       3,306       28,598       1,016       30,329       24,320       934       97,455  
Designated as at fair value through profit or loss
          241                   202       553             996  
Available-for-sale
    605       3       606       4,740       682       2,016       147       8,799  
      9,557       3,550       29,204       5,756       31,213       26,889       1,081       107,250  
                                                                 
Available-for-sale
                                                               
Gross unrealised gains
    23             7       4       7       22             63  
Gross unrealised losses
                      (3 )     (1 )     (3 )           (7 )

Notes:
(1)
Includes securities issued by US federal agencies and government sponsored entities.
(2)
Includes non asset-backed securities issued by US federal agencies and government sponsored entities.
(3)
During 2008 the Bank reclassified financial assets from the held-for-trading and available-for-sale categories into the loans and receivables category and from the held-for-trading category into the available-for-sale category (see page 92).
 
 
102

 
Impairment losses on available-for-sale debt securities are recognised when there is objective evidence of  impairment. The Group reviews its portfolios of  available-for-sale financial assets for such evidence which includes: default or delinquency in interest or principal payments; significant financial difficulty of  the issuer or obligor; and it becoming probable that the issuer will enter bankruptcy or other financial  reorganisation. However, the disappearance of  an active market because an entitys financial instruments are no longer publicly traded is not evidence of  impairment. Furthermore, a downgrade of  an entitys credit rating is not, of  itself, evidence of  impairment, although it may be evidence of impairment when considered with other available information. A decline in the fair value of  a financial asset below its cost or amortised cost is not necessarily evidence of  impairment. Determining whether objective evidence of  impairment exists requires the exercise of  management judgment. The unrecognised losses on the Groups available-for-sale debt securities are concentrated in its portfolios of  mortgage-backed securities. The losses reflect the widening of  credit spreads as a result of  the reduced market liquidity in these securities and the current uncertain macro-economic outlook in US and Europe. The underlying securities remain unimpaired.

14  Equity shares

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Listed
   
Unlisted
   
Total
   
Listed
   
Unlisted
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Held-for-trading
    438       139       577       3,617       169       3,786  
Designated as at fair value through profit or loss
    24       251       275       32       124       156  
Available-for-sale
    57       1,782       1,839       76       1,491       1,567  
      519       2,172       2,691       3,725       1,784       5,509  
                                                 
Available-for-sale
                                               
Gross unrealised gains
    4       142       146       27       108       135  
Gross unrealised losses
    (95 )     (59 )     (154 )     (3 )     (7 )     (10 )
      (91 )     83       (8 )     24       101       125  

Gross gains of  £188 million (2007 – £445 million) and gross losses of £6 million (2007 – £0.2 million) were realised by the Group on the sale of  available-for-sale equity shares.

Dividend income from available-for-sale equity shares was £50 million (2007 – £70 million; 2006 – £67 million).

Unquoted equity investments whose fair value cannot be reliably measured are carried at cost and classified as available-for-sale financial assets. They include the Groups investments in the Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank that are redeemable at cost of  £0.9 billion (2007 – £0.5 billion), together with a number of individually small shareholdings. Disposals in the year generated no gains or losses (2007 – £0.5 million gain; 2006 – £56 million gain).

   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Listed
   
Unlisted
   
Total
   
Listed
   
Unlisted
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Held-for-trading
    431       32       463       3,605       29       3,634  
Designated as at fair value through profit or loss
          28       28             10       10  
Available-for-sale
    17       512       529       5       370       375  
      448       572       1,020       3,610       409       4,019  
                                                 
Available-for-sale
                                               
Gross unrealised gains
    1       45       46       4       53       57  
Gross unrealised losses
    (46 )     (19 )     (65 )                  
      (45 )     26       (19 )     4       53       57  


Disposals in the year of unquoted equity instruments classified as available-for-sale financial assets generated no gains or losses (2007 £0.1 million loss; 2006 £21 million gain).
 
 
103

 
Notes on the accounts continued


15  Investments in Group undertakings
 
Investments in Group undertakings are carried at cost less impairment. Movements during the year were as follows:

   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
At 1 January
    22,210       21,918  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    898       23  
Additions
    3,943       137  
Additional investments in Group undertakings
    212       424  
Repayment of  investments
    (349 )     (281 )
Increase in provisions
    (100 )     (11 )
At 31 December
    26,814       22,210  

The principal subsidiary undertakings of  the Bank are shown below. Their capital consists of ordinary and preference shares, which are unlisted with the exception of certain preference shares issued by National Westminster Bank Plc. All of the subsidiary undertakings are owned directly or indirectly through intermediate holding companies and are all wholly-owned. All of  these subsidiaries are included in the Group’s consolidated financial statements and have an accounting reference date of  31 December.
 
     
Country of  incorporation
 
Nature of
 
and principal area
 
business
 
of  operation
National Westminster Bank Plc (1)
Banking
 
Great Britain
Citizens Financial Group, Inc.
Banking
 
US
Coutts & Co (2)
Private Banking
 
Great Britain
Greenwich Capital Markets Inc (3)
Broker dealer
 
US
Ulster Bank Limited (3, 4)
Banking
 
Northern Ireland

Notes:
(1)
The Bank does not hold any of  the NatWest preference shares in issue.
(2)
Coutts & Co is incorporated with unlimited liability. Its registered office is 440 Strand, London WC2R 0QS.
(3)
Shares are not directly held by the Bank.
(4)
Ulster Bank Limited and its subsidiaries also operate in the Republic of  Ireland.

The above information is provided in relation to the principal related undertakings as permitted by section 231(5) of the Companies Act 1985. Full information on all related undertakings will be included in the Annual Return delivered to the Registrar of Companies for Scotland.
 
104

 
16  Intangible assets

   
Group
 
         
Core
   
Other
   
Internally
       
         
deposit
   
purchased
   
generated
       
   
Goodwill
   
intangibles
   
intangibles
   
software
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Cost:
                                       
At 1 January 2008
    16,783       275       278       2,883       20,219  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    2,689       130       80       9       2,908  
Acquisition of subsidiaries
    211                         211  
Additions
                23       340       363  
Disposal of subsidiaries
    (47 )                       (47 )
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
          (4 )     (1 )     (16 )     (21 )
At 31 December 2008
    19,636       401       380       3,216       23,633  
                                         
Accumulated amortisation and impairment:
                                       
At 1 January 2008
          176       131       2,151       2,458  
Currency translation and other adjustments
          81       54       1       136  
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
          (3 )     (1 )     (14 )     (18 )
Charge for the year
          55       45       241       341  
Write down of goodwill and other intangible assets
    7,804             21       300       8,125  
At 31 December 2008
    7,804       309       250       2,679       11,042  
Net book value at 31 December 2008
    11,832       92       130       537       12,591  
                                         
2007
                                       
Cost:
                                       
At 1 January 2007
    16,834       265       275       2,518       19,892  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    (77 )     (2 )           4       (75 )
Acquisitions of subsidiaries
    66       12                   78  
Additions
                6       445       451  
Goodwill written off
    (40 )                       (40 )
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
                (3 )     (84 )     (87 )
At 31 December 2007
    16,783       275       278       2,883       20,219  
                                         
Accumulated amortisation:
                                       
At 1 January 2007
          127       97       1,897       2,121  
Currency translation and other adjustments
                      1       1  
Disposals and write-off  of  fully amortised assets
                (1 )     (80 )     (81 )
Charge for the year
          49       35       333       417  
At 31 December 2007
          176       131       2,151       2,458  
Net book value at 31 December 2007
    16,783       99       147       732       17,761  
 
 
 
105

 
Notes on the accounts continued


16  Intangible assets (continued)

   
 Bank
 
         
Internally
       
         
generated
       
   
Goodwill
   
software
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m  
Cost:
                       
At 1 January 2008
    11       844       855  
Currency translations and other adjustments
    3       2       5  
Acquisitions of  subsidiaries
    9             9  
Additions
          179       179  
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
          (14 )     (14 )
At 31 December 2008
    23       1,011       1,034  
                         
Accumulated amortisation and impairment:
                       
At 1 January 2008
          560       560  
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
          (12 )     (12 )
Charge for the year
          142       142  
Write-down of  goodwill and other intangible assets
    12       196       208  
At 31 December 2008
    12       886       898  
                         
Net book value at 31 December 2008
    11       125       136  
                         
2007
                       
Cost:
                       
At 1 January 2007
    10       617       627  
Currency translations and other adjustments
    1             1  
Additions
          307       307  
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
          (80 )     (80 )
At 31 December 2007
    11       844       855  
                         
Accumulated amortisation:
                       
At 1 January 2007
          455       455  
Disposals and write-off of fully amortised assets
          (79 )     (79 )
Charge for the year
          184       184  
At 31 December 2007
          560       560  
                         
Net book value at 31 December 2007
    11       284       295  

Impairment review

The Group’s goodwill acquired in business combinations is reviewed annually at 30 September for impairment by comparing the recoverable amount of each cash generating unit (CGU) to which goodwill has been allocated with its carrying value. In light of  the unprecedented market conditions the review has been updated to reflect the latest position as at 31 December 2008.

Following the reorganisation of  the Group reporting structure, NatWest and Citizens goodwill was reallocated to the appropriate CGUs.
 
The CGUs where the goodwill arising is significant, principally on the acquisition of  NatWest and Charter One are as follows:
 
     
Goodwill
             
 
Recoverable
 
prior to
         
Goodwill at
 
 
amount
 
write down
   
Write down
   
31 December
 
2008
based on
    £m       £m       £m  
Global Banking & Markets
Value in use
    2,225       (2,225 )      
Global Transaction Services
Value in use
    1,919             1,919  
UK Retail & Commercial Banking
Value in use
    6,009             6,009  
US Retail & Commercial Banking
Value in use
    7,405       (4,382 )     3,023  
Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking
Value in use
    1,036       (1,036 )      
Asia Retail & Commercial Banking
Value in use
    180       (70 )     110  

 
 
106

 

   
Recoverable
 
Goodwill at
 
   
amount
 
30 September
 
2007
 
based on
    £m  
Global Banking & Markets
 
Fair value less cost to sell
    2,346  
UK Corporate Banking
 
Fair value less cost to sell
    1,630  
Retail
 
Fair value less cost to sell
    4,278  
Wealth Management
 
Fair value less cost to sell
    1,100  
Citizens  Retail Banking
 
Value in use
    2,067  
Citizens  Retail and Commercial Banking
 
Value in use
    2,274  
Citizens  Consumer Financial Services
 
Value in use
    1,701  


In 2007, the recoverable amounts for all CGUs, except Citizens, were based on fair value less costs to sell. Fair value was based upon a price- earnings methodology using current earnings for each unit. Approximate price earnings multiples, validated against independent analyst information, were applied to each CGU. The multiples used were in the range 9.5 13.0 times earnings after charging manufacturing costs. The goodwill allocated to Global Banking & Markets, UK Corporate Banking, Retail and Wealth Management principally arose from the acquisition of NatWest in 2000. The recoverable amount of these cash generating units exceeded their carrying value by over £15 billion. The multiples or earnings would have to be less than one third of those used to cause the value in use of the units to equal their carrying value.

In light of the unprecedented market turmoil, fair value was increasingly hard to appraise and consequently the Group has generally adopted value in use tests for CGUs in 2008, based upon managements latest five year forecasts. The long-term growth rates have been based on respective country GDP rates adjusted for inflation. The risk discount rates are based on observable market long-term government bond yields and average industry betas adjusted for an appropriate risk premium based on independent analysis.

Goodwill in respect of Global Banking & Markets principally arose from the acquisition of Natwest in 2000. The failure of a number of banks and severe weakness in the global economy during the second half of 2008 resulted in a fundamental reappraisal of business forecasts, leading to the conclusion that the Global Banking & Markets business at 31 December 2008 could support no goodwill. In addition, impairments were recognised in respect of capitalised software of £0.3 billion. The value in use was based on a 3% terminal growth rate and pre-tax discount rate of 19.5%. The result was insensitive to reasonably possible changes in key assumptions.

The recoverable amount of the Global Transaction Services business based on a 3% terminal growth rate and 15.7% pre tax risk discount rate exceeded its carrying value by more than 100% and was insensitive to a reasonably possible change in key assumptions. The goodwill arises principally from the cash management and corporate money transmission businesses previously in Citizens and Regional businesses.

UK Retail & Commercial Banking was formed at the beginning of 2008 when the Group brought together the businesses that use its UK branch network. It primarily comprised the UK Retail and Corporate banks but excluded their transaction services business. The recoverable amount was equal to the carrying amount including goodwill arising from the NatWest acquisition. This is based on a 4% terminal growth rate and 15.9% pre tax risk discount rate. A 1% change in discount rate or the terminal growth rate would change the recoverable amount by over £2 billion and £1 billion respectively. In addition, a 5% change in forecast pre-tax earnings would change the recoverable amount by approximately £1 billion.

The goodwill in Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking arose from the Groups interests in Ulster Bank Group principally arising out of the acquisitions of NatWest and First Active. The Irish economy stalled in 2008, with the Government providing rescue packages to local banks, and forecasts within the Eurozone economies have reduced accordingly. The impairment review, based on a 3% terminal growth rate and 14.1% pre-tax risk discount rate, showed all goodwill associated with the business was impaired. The result was insensitive to reasonably possible changes in key assumptions.

The Asia Retail & Commercial Banking business comprises much of the Groups Wealth management business and retail operations in Asia. The outlook in the Asian economies has deteriorated and falling investment values have reduced the yield from managed portfolios. The allocated goodwill principally arising on the acquisition of Natwest was impaired by £70 million based on a 5% terminal growth rate and 14% pre-tax risk discount rate. A 1% change in the discount rate or similar change in the terminal growth rate would change the recoverable amount by approximately £200 million and £100 million respectively. In addition, a 5% change in forecast pre-tax earnings would change the recoverable amount by approximately £50 million.

Further developments in the Groups US businesses have led to the separation of the transaction services business, with the retail and commercial business being managed as a single unit. The 2007 impairment review indicated the recoverable amount of Citizens exceeded its carrying value by over £2.5 billion ($5 billion) using a terminal growth rate of 5% and a pre tax discount rate of 16.5%. In 2008, rates of 5% and 18% were used respectively and the recoverable amount indicated an impairment of £4.4 billion ($6.4 billion). A 1% change in discount rate or the terminal growth rate would change the recoverable amount and hence goodwill impairment by over £1 billion ($2 billion) and £0.7 billion ($1 billion) respectively. In addition, a 5% change in forecast pre-tax earnings would change the recoverable amount by approximately £0.5 billion ($0.8 billion).


107



 


17  Property, plant and equipment
                                         
                     
Group
                   
               
Long
   
Short
   
Computers
   
Operating
       
   
Investment
   
Freehold
   
leasehold
   
leasehold
   
and other
   
lease
       
   
properties
   
premises
   
premises
   
premises
   
equipment
   
assets
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Cost or valuation:
                                                       
At 1 January 2008
    3,431       2,225       214       1,445       3,387       6,385       17,087  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    320       162       5       131       414       1,183       2,215  
Acquisition of subsidiaries
                      30       31             61  
Disposal of subsidiaries
                      (2 )     (52 )           (54 )
Reclassifications
          (196 )           197       (1 )            
Additions
    417       458       22       26       663       3,448       5,034  
Expenditure on investment properties
    8                                     8  
Change in fair value of investment properties
    (86 )                                   (86 )
Transfers to disposal groups
          (15 )     (18 )                 (27 )     (60 )
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
    (222 )     (21 )           (56 )     (599 )     (2,007 )     (2,905 )
At 31 December 2008
    3,868       2,613       223       1,771       3,843       8,982       21,300  
Accumulated impairment, depreciation and amortisation:
                                                       
At 1 January 2008
          376       74       438       1,888       1,286       4,062  
Transfers to disposal groups
                                  (1 )     (1 )
Currency translation and other adjustments
          10       1       49       203       176       439  
Disposal of subsidiaries
                      (1 )     (35 )           (36 )
Reclassifications
          (1 )     (2 )     1       2              
Write down of property, plant and equipment
          19                               19  
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
          (1 )           (12 )     (531 )     (488 )     (1,032 )
Charge for the year
          63       6       108       455       589       1,221  
At 31 December 2008
          466       79       583       1,982       1,562       4,672  
Net book value at 31 December 2008
    3,868       2,147       144       1,188       1,861       7,420       16,628  
                                                         
2007
                                                       
Cost or valuation:
                                                       
At 1 January 2007
    4,884       2,420       276       1,254       2,959       7,151       18,944  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    96       5       1       3       5       (63 )     47  
Acquisition of  subsidiaries
          14       6             1             21  
Reclassifications
    3       (4 )     (2 )     1       2              
Additions
    449       276       35       231       569       2,328       3,888  
Expenditure on investment properties
    41                                     41  
Change in fair value of investment properties
    288                                     288  
Transfers to disposal groups
          (4 )     (13 )                 (422 )     (439 )
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
    (2,330 )     (482 )     (89 )     (44 )     (149 )     (2,609 )     (5,703 )
At 31 December 2007
    3,431       2,225       214       1,445       3,387       6,385       17,087  
Accumulated depreciation and amortisation:
                                                       
At 1 January 2007
          435       95       374       1,630       1,360       3,894  
Currency translation and other adjustments
          1             1       5       (4 )     3  
Acquisition of  subsidiaries
                2                         2  
Transfers to disposal groups
                                  (52 )     (52 )
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
          (124 )     (30 )     (25 )     (109 )     (518 )     (806 )
Charge for the year
          64       7       88       362       500       1,021  
At 31 December 2007
          376       74       438       1,888       1,286       4,062  
Net book value at 31 December 2007
    3,431       1,849       140       1,007       1,499       5,099       13,025  
 
                                           
2008
   
2007
 
                                              £m       £m  
Contracts for future capital expenditure not provided for in the accounts
           
at the year end (excluding investment properties and operating lease assets)
    97       108  
Contractual obligations to purchase, construct or develop investment
               
properties or to repair, maintain or enhance investment property
    7       9  


108



Investment properties are valued to reflect fair value, that is, the market value of  the Groups interest at the reporting date excluding any special terms or circumstances relating to the use or financing of  the property and transaction costs that would be incurred in making a sale. Observed market data such as rental yield, replacement cost and useful life, reflect relatively few transactions involving property that, necessarily, is not identical to property owned by the Group.
 
Valuations are carried out by management with the support of  qualified surveyors who are members of  the Royal Institution of  Chartered Surveyors, or an equivalent overseas body. The valuation as at 31 December 2008 for a significant majority of  the Groups investment properties was undertaken by external valuers.
 
The fair value of  investment properties includes £172 million (2007 £234 million) of  appreciation since purchase.
 
Rental income from investment properties was £237 million (2007 £291 million; 2006 – £270 million). Direct operating expenses of  investment properties were £2 million (2007 £49 million; 2006 £54 million).
 
Property, plant and equipment, excluding investment properties, include £1,132 million (2007 £382 million) assets in the course of  construction.
 
Freehold and long leasehold properties with a net book value of  nil (2007 £374 million; 2006 £161 million) were sold subject to operating leases.
 
               
Bank
                   
         
Long
   
Short
   
Computers
   
Operating
       
   
Freehold
   
leasehold
   
leasehold
   
and other
   
lease
       
   
premises
   
premises
   
premises
   
equipment
   
assets
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Cost or valuation:
                                               
At 1 January 2008
    860       52       628       2,083       126       3,749  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    2             17       19             38  
Additions
    207       1       28       406       7       649  
Transfer from fellow subsidiary
                8       6             14  
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
    (4 )           (48 )     (523 )     (23 )     (598 )
At 31 December 2008
    1,065       53       633       1,991       110       3,852  
Accumulated impairment, depreciation and amortisation:
                                               
At 1 January 2008
    122       22       167       1,221       101       1,633  
Currency translation and other adjustments
                5       7             12  
Transfer from fellow subsidiary
                1       2             3   
Write down of property, plant and equipment
    7                               7  
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
                (7 )     (482 )     (23 )     (512 )
Charge for the year
    30       2       37       260       12       341  
At 31 December 2008
    159       24       203       1,008       90       1,484  
Net book value at 31 December 2008
    906       29       430       983       20       2,368  
                                                 
2007
                                               
Cost or valuation:
                                               
At 1 January 2007
    1,017       55       509       1,786       124       3,491  
Currency translation and other adjustments
                      2             2  
Additions
    15       8       140       369       7       539  
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
    (172 )     (11 )     (21 )     (74 )     (5 )     (283 )
At 31 December 2007
    860       52       628       2,083       126       3,749  
Accumulated depreciation and amortisation:
                                               
At 1 January 2007
    164       23       144       1,044       94       1,469  
Disposals and write-off of fully depreciated assets
    (72 )     (3 )     (10 )     (46 )     (6 )     (137 )
Charge for the year
    30       2       33       223       13       301  
At 31 December 2007
    122       22       167       1,221       101       1,633  
Net book value at 31 December 2007
    738       30       461       862       25       2,116  
 
                                   
2008
   
2007
 
                                      £m       £m  
Contracts for future capital expenditure not provided for in the accounts
                         
at the year end (excluding investment properties and operating lease assets)
              39       22  


109


 

 
18  Prepayments, accrued income and other assets
                       
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Prepayments
    768       730       301       270  
Accrued income
    1,189       962       858       685  
Deferred expenses
    289       47       252       30  
Pension schemes in net surplus
    4       566       4        
Other assets
    9,147       3,811       4,515       695  
      11,397       6,116       5,930       1,680  
 
 
19  Settlement balances and short positions
                               
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Settlement balances (amortised cost)
    8,785       6,791       5,534       3,110  
Short positions (held-for-trading):
                               
Debt securities  Government
    31,899       41,048       19,930       26,685  
  – Other issues
    4,521       5,561       3,145       3,433  
Equity shares
    752       449       752       449  
      45,957       53,849       29,361       33,677  
 
 
20  Accruals, deferred income and other liabilities
                               
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Notes in circulation
    1,619       1,545       1,087       1,080  
Current taxation
    201       1,017       47       159  
Accruals
    5,870       4,155       3,826       2,807  
Deferred income
    1,564       601       1,143       143  
Other liabilities (1)
    7,431       4,849       3,515       1,594  
      16,685       12,167       9,618       5,783  
 
Note:
(1)  Other liabilities include £1 million (2007 £9 million) in respect of  share-based compensation.
 
Included in other liabilities are provisions for liabilities and charges as follows:
 
   
Group
   
Bank
 
      £m       £m  
At 1 January 2008
    143       76  
Currency translation and other movements
    3       2  
Charge to income statement
    99       36  
Releases to income statement
    (41 )     (19 )
Provisions utilised
    (24 )     (14 )
At 31 December 2008
    180       81  

Note:
(1)   Comprises property provisions and other provisions arising in the normal course of  business.


110


21  Deferred taxation
                       
Provision for deferred taxation has been made as follows:
                       
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Deferred tax liability
    2,483       2,063              
Deferred tax asset
   
(2,833
)    
(240
   
(1,323
   
(319
Net deferred tax
   
(350
)    
1,823
     
(1,323
)    
(319
) 

                                 
Group
                                     
                                 
Fair
   
Available-
                               
         
Accelerated
                     
value of
   
for-sale
               
Losses
             
         
capital
         
Deferred
   
IAS
   
financial
   
financial
   
Cash flow
   
carried
             
   
Pension
   
allowances
   
Provisions
   
gains
   
transition
   
instruments
   
assets
   
Intangibles
   
hedging
   
forward
   
Other
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January 2007
    (624 )     3,224       (278 )     266       (664 )     (143 )           210       (94 )           (135 )     1,762  
Charge/(credit)
                                                                                               
to income statement
    33       (130 )     (29 )     (141 )     45       65             16       (57 )           (49 )     (247 )
Charge/(credit)
                                                                                               
to equity directly
    661                   (17 )           30                   (108 )           57       623  
Acquisitions/(disposals)
                                                                                               
of  subsidiaries
          (284 )           (3 )                                               (287 )
Other
    (4 )     (12 )     2             4       1             (4 )                 (15 )     (28 )
At 1 January 2008
    66       2,798       (305 )     105       (615 )     (47 )           222       (259 )           (142 )     1,823  
Charge/(credit) to income statement
    66       16       (372 )     21       203       (125 )     (24 )     (291 )     260       (805 )     191       (860 )
(Credit)/charge to equity directly
    (464 )                 (6 )           3       7             (78 )     (709 )     6       (1,241 )
Acquisitions/(disposals)
                                                                                               
of  subsidiaries
                            5       2       (2 )                       (11 )     (6 )
Other
    (20 )     267       (203 )     7       (2 )     (2 )     (27 )     90       (102 )     (39 )     (35 )     (66 )
At 31 December 2008
    (352 )     3,081       (880 )     127       (409 )     (169 )     (46 )     21       (179 )     (1,553 )     9       (350 )
 
 
                                 
Bank
                                     
                                 
Fair
   
Available-
                               
         
Accelerated
                     
value of
   
for-sale
               
Losses
             
         
capital
         
Deferred
   
IAS
   
financial
   
financial
   
Cash flow
   
carried
             
   
Pension
   
allowances
   
Provisions
   
gains
   
transition
   
instruments
   
assets
   
Intangibles
   
hedging
   
forward
   
Other
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January 2007
    (67 )     48       (117 )     56       (257 )     (1 )                 (136 )           (75 )     (549 )
Charge/(credit)
                                                                                               
to income statement
    57       20       36       (26 )     42                                     8       137  
Charge to equity directly
                                                    36             57       93  
At 1 January 2008
    (10 )     68       (81 )     30       (215 )     (1 )                 (100 )           (10 )     (319 )
Charge/(credit) to income statement
    4       (17 )     33       1       34                         1       (699 )     1       (642 )
Charge/(credit) to equity directly
    (3 )                                   (3 )           344       (709 )     6       (365 )
Other
                                  1       (1 )           2             1       3  
At 31 December 2008
    (9 )     51       (48 )     31       (181 )           (4 )           247       (1,408 )     (2 )     (1,323 )

Notes:
(1)  
Deferred tax assets are recognised, as set out above, that depend on the availability of future taxable profits in excess of profits arising from the reversal of other temporary differences. Business projections prepared for impairment reviews indicate it is probable that sufficient future taxable income will be available against which to offset these recognised tax assets within 8 years. UK losses do not expire. In jurisdictions where doubt exists over the availability of future taxable profits, deferred tax assets of £29 million (2007 £34 million) have not been recognised in respect of tax losses carried forward of £108 million (2007 £110 million). These losses have no expiry date.
(2)  
Deferred tax liabilities of £844 million (2007 £972 million) have not been recognised in respect of retained earnings of overseas subsidiaries and held-over gains on the incorporation of overseas branches. Retained earnings of overseas subsidiaries are expected to be reinvested indefinitely or remitted to the UK free from further taxation. No taxation is expected to arise in the foreseeable future in respect of held-over gains.
 

111

 
 



22  Subordinated liabilities
                       
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Dated loan capital
    20,594       14,605       17,135       11,892  
Undated loan capital
    15,208       10,240       12,774       8,206  
Preference shares
    4,149       2,951       3,789       2,647  
      39,951       27,796       33,698       22,745  

Certain preference shares are classified as liabilities; these securities remain subject to the capital maintenance rules of  the Companies Act 1985.
 
The following tables analyse the remaining maturity of  subordinated liabilities by (1) the final redemption date; and (2) the next callable date.

 
                     
Group
                   
2008  final redemption
 
2009
   
2010
      2011-2013       2014-2018    
Thereafter
   
Perpetual
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
    186             167       736       370       7,911       9,370  
US dollar
    1,268       342       1,125       5,362       86       7,237       15,420  
Euro
    379       590       1,991       4,891       1,454       3,271       12,576  
Other
    26                   1,882             677       2,585  
      1,859       932       3,283       12,871       1,910       19,096       39,951  
 
 
                     
Group
                         
2008  call date
 
Currently
   
2009
   
2010
      20112013       20142018    
Thereafter
   
Perpetual
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
          186       737       1,030       3,507       3,740       170       9,370  
US dollar
    1,833       3,207       1,537       5,668       1,597       1,578             15,420  
Euro
          857       877       4,246       6,098       447       51       12,576  
Other
          497       405       553       914       216             2,585  
      1,833       4,747       3,556       11,497       12,116       5,981       221       39,951  
 
 
                     
Group
                   
2007  final redemption
 
2008
   
2009
      2010-2012       2013-2017    
Thereafter
   
Perpetual
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
    186                   771       389       5,942       7,288  
US dollar
    183       747       620       4,003       233       3,987       9,773  
Euro
    417       220       815       3,731       937       2,567       8,687  
Other
    25                   1,560             463       2,048  
      811       967       1,435       10,065       1,559       12,959       27,796  
 
 
                     
Group
                         
2007  call date
 
Currently
   
2008
   
2009
      20102012       20132017    
Thereafter
   
Perpetual
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
          186             1,463       1,822       3,652       165       7,288  
US dollar
    1,348       543       1,795       3,235       1,681       1,171             9,773  
Euro
          1,265       591       2,495       4,075       222       39       8,687  
Other
          25       431       837       652       103             2,048  
      1,348       2,019       2,817       8,030       8,230       5,148       204       27,796  



112




                     
Bank
                   
2008  final redemption
 
2009
   
2010
      2011-2013       2014-2018    
Thereafter
   
Perpetual
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
    132             167       298             6,935       7,532  
US dollar
    371             840       5,362       86       5,999       12,658  
Euro
    326             1,515       4,891       1,454       2,742       10,928  
Other
    21                   1,882             677       2,580  
      850             2,522       12,433       1,540       16,353       33,698  
 
 
                     
Bank
                   
2008  call date
 
Currently
   
2009
   
2010
      2011-2013       2014-2018    
Thereafter
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
          132       397       964       3,135       2,904       7,532  
US dollar
    582       2,323       1,195       5,383       1,597       1,578       12,658  
Euro
          326       287       3,770       6,098       447       10,928  
Other
          492       405       553       914       216       2,580  
      582       3,273       2,284       10,670       11,744       5,145       33,698  
 
 
                     
Bank
                   
2007  final redemption
 
2008
   
2009
      2010-2012       2013-2017    
Thereafter
   
Perpetual
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
    132                   429             4,973       5,534  
US dollar
    75       199       159       4,004       233       3,077       7,747  
Euro
    376       220             3,731       937       2,157       7,421  
Other
    20                   1,560             463       2,043  
      603       419       159       9,724       1,170       10,670       22,745  
 
 
                     
Bank
                   
2007  call date
 
Currently
   
2008
   
2009
      2010-2012       2013-2017    
Thereafter
   
Total
 
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Sterling
          132             1,129       1,415       2,858       5,534  
US dollar
    425       449       1,247       2,774       1,681       1,171       7,747  
Euro
          1,224       220       1,680       4,075       222       7,421  
Other
          20       431       837       652       103       2,043  
      425       1,825       1,898       6,420       7,823       4,354       22,745  


113


 

22  Subordinated liabilities (continued)
   
2008
   
2007
 
Dated loan capital
    £m       £m  
The Bank
               
255 million 5.25% subordinated notes 2008 (redeemed July 2008)
          192  
300 million 4.875% subordinated notes 2009
    298       228  
1,000 million floating rate subordinated notes 2013 (redeemed October 2008)
          744  
US$50 million floating rate subordinated notes 2013
    36       26  
1,000 million 6.0% subordinated notes 2013
    1,083       790  
500 million 6.0% subordinated notes 2013
    487       374  
£150 million 10.5% subordinated bonds 2013(2)
    180       169  
US$1,250 million floating rate subordinated notes 2014 (callable July 2009)
    862       630  
AUD590 million 6.0% subordinated notes 2014 (callable October 2009)
    281       254  
AUD410 million floating rate subordinated notes 2014 (callable October 2009)
    195       182  
CAD700 million 4.25% subordinated notes 2015 (callable March 2010)
    409       358  
£250 million 9.625% subordinated bonds 2015
    311       286  
US$750 million floating rate subordinated notes 2015 (callable September 2010)
    513       374  
750 million floating rate subordinated notes 2015
    783       564  
CHF400 million 2.375% subordinated notes 2015
    257       166  
CHF100 million 2.375% subordinated notes 2015
    72       41  
CHF200 million 2.375% subordinated notes 2015
    125       86  
US$500 million floating rate subordinated notes 2016 (callable October 2011)
    346       252  
US$1,500 million floating rate subordinated notes 2016 (callable April 2011)
    1,038       757  
500 million 4.5% subordinated notes 2016 (callable January 2011)
    511       379  
CHF200 million 2.75% subordinated notes 2017 (callable December 2012)
    129       89  
100 million floating rate subordinated notes 2017
    97       73  
500 million floating rate subordinated notes 2017 (callable June 2012)
    482       371  
750 million 4.35% subordinated notes 2017 (callable October 2017)
    770       548  
AUD450 million 6.5% subordinated notes 2017 (callable February 2012)
    217       202  
AUD450 million floating rate subordinated notes 2017 (callable February 2012)
    214       199  
US$1,500 million floating rate subordinated callable step-up notes 2017 (callable August 2012)
    1,029       752  
2,000 million 6.93% subordinated notes 2018 (issued April 2008)
    2,136        
US$125.6 million floating rate subordinated notes 2020
    87       64  
1,000 million 4.625% subordinated notes 2021 (callable September 2016)
    1,019       724  
300 million CMS linked floating rate subordinated notes 2022
    303       228  
144 million floating rate subordinated notes 2022 (issued June 2008)
    152        
                 
Due to the holding company
               
US$400 million 6.4% subordinated notes 2009 (1)
    278       202  
US$300 million 6.375% subordinated notes 2011 (1)
    231       163  
US$750 million 5% subordinated notes 2013 (1)
    581       384  
US$750 million 5% subordinated notes 2014 (1)
    617       386  
US$250 million 5% subordinated notes 2014 (1)
    168       123  
US$675 million 5.05% subordinated notes 2015 (1)
    551       358  
US$350 million 4.7% subordinated notes 2018 (1)
    287       174  
      17,135       11,892  
National Westminster Bank Plc
               
US$1,000 million 7.375% subordinated notes 2009
    697       507  
600 million 6.0% subordinated notes 2010
    623       474  
500 million 5.125% subordinated notes 2011
    488       376  
£300 million 7.875% subordinated notes 2015
    379       349  
£300 million 6.5% subordinated notes 2021
    376       330  
                 
Charter One Financial, Inc.
               
US$400 million 6.375% subordinated notes 2012
    287       212  
                 
Greenwich Capital Holdings, Inc.
               
US$100 million 5.575% senior subordinated revolving credit 2009
    69       50  
US$170 million subordinated loan capital floating rate notes 2009
    116       85  
US$500 million subordinated loan capital floating rate notes 2010 (callable on any interest payment date)
    342       249  
                 
First Active plc
               
£60 million 6.375% subordinated bonds 2018 (callable April 2013)
    66       65  
                 
Other minority interest subordinated issues
    16       16  
      20,594       14,605  
 
Notes:
(1)
On-lent to The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group plc on a subordinated basis.
(2)
Unconditionally guaranteed by The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group plc.
(3)
In the event of certain changes in tax laws, dated loan capital issues may be redeemed in whole, but not in part, at the option of the issuer, at the principal amount thereof plus accrued interest, subject to prior regulatory approval.
(4)
Except as stated above, claims in respect of  the Groups dated loan capital are subordinated to the claims of  other creditors. None of  the Groups dated loan capital is secured.
(5)
Interest on all floating rate subordinated notes is calculated by reference to market rates.
 
 
114

 
 


   
2008
   
2007
 
Undated loan capital
    £m       £m  
The Bank
               
£150 million 5.625% undated subordinated notes (callable June 2032)
    144       144  
£175 million 7.375% undated subordinated notes (callable August 2010)
    190       183  
152 million 5.875% undated subordinated notes (redeemed October 2008)
          114  
£350 million 6.25% undated subordinated notes (callable December 2012)
    380       354  
£500 million 6.0% undated subordinated notes (callable September 2014)
    565       517  
500 million 5.125% undated subordinated notes (callable July 2014)
    516       371  
1,000 million floating rate subordinated notes (callable July 2014)
    966       742  
£500 million 5.125% undated subordinated notes (callable March 2016)
    556       499  
£200 million 5.625% undated subordinated upper tier 2 notes (callable September 2026)
    210       210  
£600 million 5.5% undated subordinated notes (callable December 2019)
    677       595  
£500 million 6.2% undated subordinated notes (callable March 2022)
    614       543  
£200 million 9.5% undated subordinated bonds (callable August 2018) (3)
    253       228  
£400 million 5.625% undated subordinated upper tier 2 notes (callable September 2026)
    397       397  
£300 million 5.625% undated subordinated notes (callable September 2026)
    431       318  
£350 million 5.625% undated subordinated notes (callable June 2032)
    364       363  
£400 million 5% undated subordinated notes (callable March 2011)
    424       402  
JPY25 billion 2.605% undated subordinated notes (callable November 2034)
    217       103  
CAD700 million 5.37% fixed rate undated subordinated notes (callable May 2016)
    464       363  
                 
Due to the holding company
               
US$350 million undated floating rate primary capital notes (callable on any interest payment date) (1)
    240       175  
1,250 million 6.467% perpetual regulatory tier one securities (callable June 2012)  (1)
    1,325       979  
US$1,200 million 7.648% perpetual regulatory tier one securities (callable September 2031) (1, 2)
    831       606  
£1,500 million floating rate perpetual subordinated notes (issued March 2008)
    1,500        
$600 million floating rate perpetual subordinated notes (issued March 2008)
    412        
$1,600 million floating rate perpetual subordinated notes (issued March 2008)
    1,098        
      12,774       8,206  
National Westminster Bank Plc
               
US$500 million primary capital floating rate notes, Series A (callable on any interest payment date)
    343       251  
US$500 million primary capital floating rate notes, Series B (callable on any interest payment date)
    347       256  
US$500 million primary capital floating rate notes, Series C (callable on any interest payment date)
    346       255  
400 million 6.625% fixed/floating rate undated subordinated notes (callable October 2009)
    388       303  
100 million floating rate undated step-up notes (callable October 2009)
    97       74  
£325 million 7.625% undated subordinated step-up notes (callable January 2010)
    363       357  
£200 million 7.125% undated subordinated step-up notes (callable October 2022)
    201       205  
£200 million 11.5% undated subordinated notes (callable December 2022) (4)
    269       269  
                 
First Active plc
               
£20 million 11.75% perpetual tier two capital
    26       23  
38 million 11.375% perpetual tier two capital
    52       39  
£1.3 million floating rate perpetual tier two capital
    2       2  
      15,208       10,240  
 
Notes:
(1)
On lent to The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group plc on a subordinated basis.
(2)
The company can satisfy interest payment obligations by issuing ordinary shares to appointed Trustees sufficient to enable them, on selling those shares, to settle the interest payment.
(3)
Guaranteed by the company.
(4)
Exchangeable at the option of  the issuer into 200 million 8.392% (gross) non-cumulative preference shares of  £1 each of  National Westminster Bank Plc at any time.
(5)
Except as stated above, claims in respect of  the Group's undated loan capital are subordinated to the claims of  other creditors. None of  the Group's undated loan capital is secured.
(6)
In the event of certain changes in tax laws, undated loan capital issues may be redeemed in whole, but not in part, at the option of the Group, at the principal amount thereof plus accrued interest, subject to prior regulatory approval.
(7)
Interest on all floating rate subordinated notes is calculated by reference to market rates.


115


 
 
22  Subordinated liabilities (continued)

2008
2007
 
Preference shares
£m
£m
 
The Bank
     
Non-cumulative preference shares of  US$0.01 (1)
     
Series F US$200 million 7.65% (redeemable at option of  issuer)
137
100
 
Series H US$300 million 7.25% (redeemable at option of  issuer)
205
150
 
Series L US$750 million 6.8% (callable March 2009)
514
374
 
Series M US$850 million 4.709% (callable July 2013)
640
421
 
Series N US$650 million 6.425% (redeemable January 2034)
677
344
 
Series R US$850 million 5.75% (callable September 2009)
582
424
 
Series 1 US$1,000 million 9.118% (callable March 2010)
698
508
 
       
Non-cumulative preference shares of  £1
     
Series 1 £200 million 7.387% (callable December 2010) (1)
211
201
 
£125 million 7.25%
125
125
 
 
3,789
2,647
 
National Westminster Bank Plc
     
Non-cumulative preference shares of  £1
     
Series A £140 million 9% (non-redeemable)
145
143
 
       
Non-cumulative preference shares of  US$25
     
Series C US$300 million 7.7628% (2)
215
161
 
 
4,149
2,951
 

Notes:
(1)
Issued by the Bank to the holding company on terms which, in general, mirror the original issues by the holding company.
(2)
Series C preference shares each carry a gross dividend of  8.625% inclusive of  associated tax credit. Redeemable at the option of  the issuer at US$25 per share.

 
116

 
 
 
23  Minority interests

   
                      Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
At 1 January
    152       396  
Currency translation adjustments and other movements
    344       (11 )
Profit attributable to minority interests
    208       53  
Dividends paid
    (84 )     (31 )
Equity raised
    812        
Equity withdrawn and disposals
    (140 )     (255 )
At 31 December
    1,292       152  
 
 
24  Share capital
 
   
Allotted, called up
and fully paid
   
Authorised
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
   
£m
 
Ordinary shares of  £1
    6,481       5,481       £7,980       £7,980  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  US$0.01
    2       2       $5       $3  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  €0.01
                       
Perpetual zero coupon preference shares of  £1
                £100       £100  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  £1
    126       126       £2,200       £2,200  

   
Allotted, called up
and fully paid
   
Authorised
 
Number of  shares  millions
 
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
Ordinary shares of  £1
    6,481       5,481       7,980       7,980  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  US$0.01
    313       313       549       349  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  €0.01
    3       3       66       66  
Perpetual zero coupon preference shares of  £1
                100       100  
Non-cumulative preference shares of  £1
    126       126       2,200       2,200  

 
Ordinary shares
In June 2008, the Bank issued 1 billion new ordinary shares of £1 each to the holding company at £10 per share.
 
Preference shares
The non-cumulative preference shares have been issued by the Bank to the holding company on terms which, in general, mirror the original issues by the holding company.

Under IFRS, certain of the Groups preference shares are classified as debt and are included in subordinated liabilities on the balance sheet.


117


 


25  Shareholders equity

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Called-up share capital
                                               
At 1 January
    5,483       5,482       5,481       5,483       5,482       5,481  
Shares issued during the year
    1,000       1       1       1,000       1       1  
At 31 December
    6,483       5,483       5,482       6,483       5,483       5,482  
                                                 
Share premium account
                                               
At 1 January
    16,175       12,526       11,435       16,175       12,526       11,435  
Shares issued during the year
    9,000       3,649       1,091       9,000       3,649       1,091  
At 31 December
    25,175       16,175       12,526       25,175       16,175       12,526  
                                                 
Merger reserve
                                               
At 1 January and 31 December
    10,881       10,881       10,881                    
                                                 
Available-for-sale reserve
                                               
At 1 January
    (35 )     (65 )     (198 )     72       52       12  
Unrealised (losses)/gains in the year
    (2,585 )     511       365       (2,592 )     249       123  
Realised (gains)/losses in the year
    (11 )     (465 )     (196 )     49       (231 )     (71 )
Taxation
    738       (16 )     (36 )     716       2       (12 )
At 31 December
    (1,893 )     (35 )     (65 )     (1,755 )     72       52  
                                                 
Cash flow hedging reserve
                                               
At 1 January
    (511 )     (142 )     68       (211 )     (260 )     (150 )
Amount recognised in equity during the year
    (461 )     (408 )     (108 )     1,292       60       (138 )
Amount transferred from equity to earnings
in the year (1)
    185       (141 )     (143 )     (54 )     25       2  
Tax
    64       180       41       (344 )     (36 )     26  
At 31 December
    (723 )     (511 )     (142 )     683       (211 )     (260 )
                                                 
Foreign exchange reserve
                                               
At 1 January
    (782 )     (833 )     469       3       (2 )     (2 )
Retranslation of  net assets
    7,254       287       (2,117 )     (331 )     5        
Foreign currency (losses)/gains on hedges of  net assets
    (2,630 )     (267 )     815                    
Tax
    361       31                          
At 31 December
    4,203       (782 )     (833 )     (328 )     3       (2 )
                                                 
Retained earnings
                                               
At 1 January
    16,472       10,087       6,374       9,567       4,633       4,535  
(Loss)/profit attributable to ordinary and equity preference shareholders
    (8,750 )     7,199       5,876       (1,140 )     7,255       3,519  
Ordinary dividends paid
    (4,000 )     (2,000 )     (3,250 )     (4,000 )     (2,000 )     (3,250 )
Equity preference dividends paid
    (638 )     (331 )     (252 )     (638 )     (331 )     (252 )
Actuarial (losses)/gains recognised in retirement benefit schemes net of  tax
    (1,252 )     1,509       1,259       (2 )     2       1  
Share-based payments, net of  tax
          8       80             8       80  
At 31 December
    1,832       16,472       10,087       3,787       9,567       4,633  
                                                 
Shareholders equity at 31 December
    45,958       47,683       37,936       34,045       31,089       22,431  
 
Note:
(1)   The amounts transferred to earnings are included in net interest income.
 
The merger reserve comprises the premium on shares issued to acquire NatWest less goodwill amortisation charged under previous GAAP. No share premium was recorded in the Bank financial statements through the operation of the merger relief provisions of the Companies Act 1985.

UK law prescribes that only reserves of the Bank are taken into account for the purpose of making distributions and the permissible applications of the share premium account.
 
The Group optimises capital efficiency by maintaining reserves in subsidiaries, including regulated entities. Certain preference shares and subordinated debt are also included within regulatory capital. The remittance of reserves to the parent or the redemption of shares or subordinated capital by regulated entities may be subject to maintaining the capital resources required by the relevant regulator.


118



26  Leases
 
Minimum amounts receivable and payable under non-cancellable leases.

   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Year in which receipt or payment will occur
   
Year in which receipt or payment will occur
 
         
After 1 year
                     
After 1 year
             
   
Within 1
   
but within
   
After 5
         
Within 1
   
but within
   
After 5
       
   
year
   
5 years
   
years
   
Total
   
year
   
5 years
   
years
   
Total
 
Group
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Finance lease assets:
                                                               
Amounts receivable
    1,485       6,112       12,567       20,164       1,297       4,968       11,648       17,913  
Present value adjustment
    (613 )     (2,004 )     (3,094 )     (5,711 )     (390 )     (1,766 )     (3,187 )     (5,343 )
Other movements
    (24 )     (128 )     (341 )     (493 )     (23 )     (144 )     (288 )     (455 )
Present value amounts receivable
    848       3,980       9,132       13,960       884       3,058       8,173       12,115  
                                                                 
Operating lease assets:
                                                               
Future minimum lease receivables
    897       2,307       1,058       4,262       670       1,612       682       2,964  
                                                                 
Operating lease obligations:
                                                               
Future minimum lease payables:
                                                               
Premises
    395       1,342       3,010       4,747       341       1,179       3,010       4,530  
Equipment
    12       12             24       9       14             23  
      407       1,354       3,010       4,771       350       1,193       3,010       4,553  
                                                                 
Amounts above include:
                                                               
Obligations to fellow subsidiaries  Premises
    7       28       49       84       7       28       56       91  

   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Year in which receipt or payment will occur
   
Year in which receipt or payment will occur
 
         
After 1 year
                     
After 1 year
             
   
Within 1
   
but within
   
After 5
         
Within 1
   
but within
   
After 5
       
   
year
   
5 years
   
years
   
Total
   
year
   
5 years
   
years
   
Total
 
Bank
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Operating lease obligations:
                                                               
Future minimum lease payables:
                                                               
Premises
    159       586       1,808       2,553       141       525       1,758       2,424  
                                                                 
Amounts above include:
                                                               
Obligations to fellow subsidiaries  Premises
    7       28       49       84       7       28       56       91  
 

119





26  Leases (continued)
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
Group
    £m       £m  
Nature of  operating lease assets in balance sheet
               
Transportation
    5,883       3,502  
Cars and light commercial vehicles
    1,199       1,282  
Other
    338       315  
      7,420       5,099  
Amounts recognised as income and expense
               
Finance lease receivables  contingent rental income
    (37 )     (23 )
Operating lease payables  minimum payments
    380       305  
                 
Contracts for future capital expenditure not provided for at the year end
               
Operating leases
    237       78  
                 
Finance lease receivables
               
Unearned finance income
    5,711       5,343  
Accumulated allowance for uncollectable minimum lease receivables
    96       63  
                 
Bank
               
Amounts recognised as expense
               
Operating lease payables  minimum payments
    164       116  
 
 
Residual value exposures
The table below gives details of  the unguaranteed residual values included in the carrying value of  finance lease receivables (see above) and  operating lease assets (see Note 17).

   
Group
 
   
Year in which residual value will be recovered
 
         
After 1 year
   
After 2 years
             
   
Within 1
   
but within
   
but within
   
After 5
       
   
year
   
2 years
   
5 years
   
years
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Operating leases
                                       
Transportation
    794       130       1,701       2,103       4,728  
Cars and light commercial vehicles
    577       195       182       8       962  
Other
    112       35       48       7       202  
Finance leases
    24       29       99       341       493  
      1,507       389       2,030       2,459       6,385  
                                         
2007
                                       
Operating leases
                                       
Transportation
    259       207       758       1,535       2,759  
Cars and light commercial vehicles
    331       467       118             916  
Other
    26       47       64       18       155  
Finance leases
    23       29       115       288       455  
      639       750       1,055       1,841       4,285  


The Group provides asset finance to its customers through acting as a lessor. It purchases plant, equipment and intellectual property; renting them to customers under lease arrangements that, depending on their terms, qualify as either operating or finance leases.


120



27  Collateral and securitisations
Securities repurchase agreements and lending transactions

The Group enters into securities repurchase agreements and securities lending transactions under which it receives or transfers collateral in accordance with normal market practice. Generally, the agreements require additional collateral to be provided if  the value of  the securities falls below a predetermined level.

Under standard terms for repurchase transactions in the UK and US markets, the recipient of  collateral has an unrestricted right to sell or repledge it, subject to returning equivalent securities on settlement of the transaction.

The fair value (and carrying value) of  securities transferred under repurchase transactions included within debt securities on the balance sheet were £75,660 million (2007  £75,001 million) for the Group and £70,206 million (2007 – £30,633 million) for the Bank. All of  these securities could be sold or repledged by the holder. Securities received as collateral under reverse repurchase agreements amounted to £54.9 billion (2007  £159.8 billion), of  which £49.1 billion (2007  £128.4 billion) had been resold or repledged as collateral for the Groups own transactions.

Other collateral given
   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
Group assets charged as security for liabilities
    £m       £m       £m       £m  
Loans and advances to customers
    107,409       55,227       16,480       5,411  
Debt securities
    15,108       8,911       4,872        
Loans and advances to banks
    13                    
Other
    8                    
      122,538       64,138       21,352       5,411  

     
Group
     
Bank
 
     
2008
     
2007
     
2008
     
2007
 
Liabilities secured by charges on Group assets
    £m       £m       £m       £m  
Deposits by banks
    11,322       6,171              
Customer accounts
    11,050       6,670       4,867       5,398  
Debt securities in issue
    52,755       34,090       343        
      75,127       46,931       5,210       5,398  


Of the assets above, £84.2 billion (2007 £36.4 billion) relate to securitisations. In securitisations, debt securities are issued that are secured on assets of the Group; the rights to the cash flows from those assets are transferred to special purpose vehicles which issue debt securities. The remaining balances primarily relate to assets charged as security against deposits from federal banks and other public sector bodies.
 

Securitisations and other asset transfers

Continuing recognition
The table below sets out the asset categories together with the carrying amounts of the assets and associated liabilities for those securitisations and other asset transfers where substantially all of the risks and rewards of the asset have been retained by the Group.

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
Asset type
 
Assets
£m
   
Liabilities
£m
   
Assets
£m
   
Liabilities
£m
 
Residential mortgages
    46,998       18,613       19,657       19,441  
Credit card receivables
    3,004       3,197       2,948       2,664  
Other loans
    1,679       1,071       1,703       1,149  
Commercial paper conduits
    31,473       30,833       11,043       11,092  
Finance lease receivables
    1,077       857       1,038       823  
      84,231       54,571       36,389       35,169  

Continuing involvement
At 31 December 2008, securitised assets were £1.1 billion (2007 £17.6 billion); retained interest £50 million (2007 £888 million) subordinated assets £9 million (2007 £314 million) and related liabilities £9 million (2007 £314 million).


121





28  Capital resources
The Groups regulatory capital resources at 31 December in accordance with Financial Services Authority (FSA) definitions were as follows:

   
Basel II
   
Basel I
 
Composition of  regulatory capital
 
2008
   
2007
 
    £m       £m  
Tier 1:
               
Ordinary shareholders' equity
    36,711       38,436  
Minority interests
    1,292       152  
Adjustment for:
               
 Goodwill and other intangible assets
    (12,591 )     (17,761 )
 Unrealised losses on available-for-sale debt securities
    1,855       110  
 Reserves arising on revaluation of  property and unrealised gains on available-for-sale equities
    (154 )     (281 )
 Other regulatory adjustments
    (56 )     423  
Core Tier 1 capital
    27,057       21,079  
                 
Preference shares
    10,896       10,126  
Innovative Tier 1 securities
    4,177       3,538  
Tax on the excess of  expected losses over provisions
    615        
Tier 1 deductions
    (1,725 )      
Total Tier 1 capital
    41,020       34,743  
                 
Tier 2:
               
Reserves arising on revaluation of  property and unrealised gains on available-for-sale equities
    154       281  
Collective impairment allowances
    666       2,582  
Perpetual subordinated debt
    12,085       8,291  
Term subordinated debt
    16,488       12,605  
Minority and other interests in Tier 2 capital
    11       109  
Tier 2 deductions
    (1,725 )      
Total Tier 2 capital
    27,679       23,868  
                 
Supervisory deductions:
               
Unconsolidated investments
    (119 )     (130 )
Other deductions
    (111 )     (2,324 )
Total deductions other than from Tier 1 capital
    (230 )     (2,454 )
Total regulatory capital
    68,469       56,157  

 
In the management of capital resources, the Group is governed by the RBS Groups policy which is to maintain a strong capital base, to expand it as appropriate and to utilise it efficiently throughout its activities to optimise the return to shareholders while maintaining a prudent relationship between the capital base and the underlying risks of the business. In carrying out this policy, the Group has regard to the supervisory requirements of the FSA. The FSA uses Risk Asset Ratio (RAR) as a measure of capital adequacy in the UK banking sector, comparing a banks capital resources with its risk-weighted assets (the assets and off-balance sheet exposures are weighted to reflect the inherent credit and other risks); by international agreement, the RAR should be not less than 8% with a tier 1 component of not less than 4%. The Group has complied with the FSAs capital requirements throughout the year.

A number of subsidiaries and sub-groups within the Group, principally banking entities, are subject to various individual regulatory capital requirements in the UK and overseas.


122


29  Memorandum items

Contingent liabilities and commitments
The amounts shown in the table below are intended only to provide an indication of the volume of business outstanding at 31 December. Although the Group is exposed to credit risk in the event of non-performance of the obligations undertaken by customers, the amounts shown do not, and are not intended to, provide any indication of the Groups expectation of future losses.

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Contingent liabilities:
                               
Guarantees and assets pledged as collateral security
    15,075       11,661       7,248       6,838  
Other contingent liabilities
    17,842       11,215       15,067       8,168  
      32,917       22,876       22,315       15,006  
Commitments:
                               
Undrawn formal standby facilities, credit lines and other commitments to lend
                               
 less than one year
    156,290       153,348       75,800       61,582  
 one year and over
    138,059       105,915       111,241       82,603  
Other commitments
    6,788       2,491       366       1,630  
      301,137       261,754       187,407       145,815  

Notes:
(1)  
In the normal course of business, the Bank guarantees specified third party liabilities of certain subsidiaries; it also gives undertakings that individual subsidiaries will fulfil their obligations to third parties under contractual or other arrangements.
(2)
Includes commitments for £5,705 million (2007 £805 million) in respect of the construction of aircraft.
 
 
Banking commitments and contingent obligations, which have been entered into on behalf of customers and for which there are corresponding obligations from customers, are not included in assets and liabilities. The Groups maximum exposure to credit loss, in the event of non-performance by the other party and where all counterclaims, collateral or security proves valueless, is represented by the contractual nominal amount of these instruments included in the table above. These commitments and contingent obligations are subject to the Groups normal credit approval processes.

Contingent liabilities
Guarantees the Group gives guarantees on behalf of customers. A financial guarantee represents an irrevocable undertaking that the Group will meet a customers obligations to third parties if the customer fails to do so. The maximum amount that the Group could be required to pay under a guarantee is its principal amount as disclosed in the table above. The Group expects most guarantees it provides to expire unused.

Other contingent liabilities these include standby letters of credit, supporting customer debt issues and contingent liabilities relating to customer trading activities such as those arising from performance and customs bonds, warranties and indemnities.

Commitments
Commitments to lend under a loan commitment the Group agrees to make funds available to a customer in the future. Loan commitments, which are usually for a specified term may be unconditionally cancellable or may persist, provided all conditions in the loan facility are satisfied or waived. Commitments to lend include commercial standby facilities and credit lines, liquidity facilities to commercial paper conduits and unutilised overdraft facilities.

Other commitments these include forward asset purchases, forward deposits placed and undrawn note issuance and revolving underwriting facilities, documentary credits and other short-term related transactions.
 
Trustee and other fiduciary activities
In its capacity as trustee or other fiduciary role, the Group may hold or place assets on behalf of individuals, trusts, companies, pension schemes and others. The assets and their income are not included in the Groups financial statements. The Group earned fee income of £476 million (2007 £507 million; 2006 £472 million) from these activities. The Bank earned fee income of £45 million (2007 £49 million; 2006 £42 million).

The Financial Services Compensation Scheme
The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS), the UK's statutory fund of last resort for customers of authorised financial services firms, pays compensation if a firm is unable to meet its obligations. The FSCS funds compensation for customers by raising management expenses levies and compensation levies on the industry. In relation to protected deposits, each deposit-taking institution contributes towards these levies in proportion to their share of total protected deposits on 31 December of the year preceding the scheme year (which runs from 1 April to 31 March), subject to annual maxima set by the Financial Services Authority (FSA). In addition, the FSCS has the power to raise levies (exit levies) on firms who have ceased to participate in the scheme and are in the process of ceasing to be authorised for the amount that the firm would otherwise have been asked to pay during the relevant levy year. The FSCS also has the power to raise exit levies on such firms which look at their potential liability to pay levies in future years.

FSCS has borrowed from HM Treasury to fund the compensation costs associated with Bradford & Bingley, Heritable Bank, Kaupthing Singer & Friedlander, Landsbanki Icesave and London Scottish Bank plc. These borrowings are on an interest-only basis until September 2011. The annual limit on the FSCS management expenses levy for the three years from September 2008 in relation to these institutions has been capped at £1 billion per annum.


123

 
 
 

29  Memorandum items (continued)

The FSCS will receive funds from asset sales, surplus cash flow, or other recoveries in relation to these institutions which will be used to reduce the principal amount of the FSCS's borrowings. Only after the interest only period, which is expected to end in September 2011, will a schedule for repayment of any remaining principal outstanding (after recoveries) on the borrowings be agreed between the FSCS and HM Treasury. It is expected that, from that point, the FSCS will begin to raise compensation levies (principal repayments). No provision has been made for these levies as the amount is not yet known and is unlikely to be determined before 2011.

The Group has accrued £150 million for its share of FSCS management expenses levies for the 2008/9 and 2009/10 scheme years.

Investigations
The Groups businesses and financial condition can be affected by the fiscal or other policies and other actions of various governmental and regulatory authorities in the United Kingdom, the European Union, the United States and elsewhere.

The Group has engaged, and will continue to engage, in discussions with relevant regulators, including in the United Kingdom and the United States, on an ongoing and regular basis informing them of operational, systems and control evaluations and issues as deemed appropriate or required and it is possible that any matters discussed or identified may result in investigatory actions by the regulators, increased costs being incurred by the Group, remediation of systems and controls, public or private censure or fines. Any of these events or circumstances could have a material adverse impact on the Group its business, reputation, results of operations or RBS share price.

There is continuing political and regulatory scrutiny of the operation of the retail banking and consumer credit industries in the United Kingdom and elsewhere. The nature and impact of future changes in policies and regulatory action are not predictable and are beyond the Groups control but could have an adverse impact on the Groups businesses and earnings.

European Union
In the European Union, regulatory actions included an inquiry into retail banking in all of the then 25 member states by the European Commissions Directorate General for Competition. The inquiry examined retail banking in Europe generally. On 31 January 2007, the European Commission announced that barriers to competition in certain areas of retail banking, payment cards and payment systems in the European Union had been identified. The European Commission indicated that it will consider using its powers to address these barriers and will encourage national competition authorities to enforce European and national competition laws where appropriate.
 
In 2007, the European Commission issued a decision that, while interchange is not illegal per se, MasterCards current multilateral interchange fee (MIF) arrangement for cross border payment card transactions with MasterCard and Maestro-branded consumer credit and debit cards in the European Union are in breach of competition law. MasterCard was required by the decision to withdraw the relevant cross border MIFs by 21 June 2008. MasterCard lodged an appeal against the decision with the European Court of First Instance on 1 March 2008, and on 12 June 2008 it announced that it would be temporarily withdrawing its cross border MIF, pending the outcome of the appeal. The Group has been granted leave to intervene in the appeal proceedings. Visas MIFs were exempted in 2002 by the European Commission for a period of five years up to 31 December 2007 subject to certain conditions. On 26 March 2008, the European Commission opened a formal inquiry into Visas current MIF arrangements for cross border payment card transactions with Visa-branded debit and consumer credit cards in the European Union. There is no deadline for the closure of the inquiry.

United Kingdom
In the United Kingdom, in September 2005, the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) received a super-complaint from the Citizens Advice Bureau relating to payment protection insurance (PPI). As a result, the OFT commenced a market study on PPI in April 2006. In October 2006, the OFT announced the outcome of the market study and, on 7 February 2007, following a period of consultation, the OFT referred the PPI market to the Competition Commission (CC) for an in-depth inquiry. The CC published its final report on 29 January 2009. It found a lack of competition in the PPI market as a result of various factors, including a lack of transparency and barriers to entry for standalone providers. The CC will therefore impose by Order a range of remedies, including a prohibition on actively selling PPI at point of sale of the credit product (and for 7 days thereafter), a ban on single premium policies and other measures to increase transparency (in order to improve customers ability to search and improve price competition). The deadline for implementation will be 2010.

The FSA has been conducting a broad industry thematic review of PPI sales practices and in September 2008 announced that it intends to escalate its level of regulatory intervention. The FSA is expected to publish a further update in 2009. Substantial numbers of customer complaints alleging the mis-selling of PPI policies have been made to banks and to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) and many of these are being upheld by the FOS against the banks. Discussions continue between the FSA, the FOS and industry bodies on how best to handle these complaints. Separately, discussions are ongoing between the FSA and the Group in respect of concerns expressed by the FSA over certain categories of historic PPI sales.

The OFT has carried out investigations into Visa and MasterCard domestic credit card interchange rates. The decision by the OFT in the MasterCard interchange case was set aside by the Competition Appeals Tribunal in June 2006. The OFTs investigations in the Visa


124


interchange case and a second MasterCard interchange case are ongoing. The outcome is not known, but these investigations may have an impact on the consumer credit industry in general and, therefore, on the Groups business in this sector. On 9 February 2007, the OFT announced that it was expanding its investigation into domestic interchange rates to include debit cards.

On 29 March 2007, the OFT announced that, following an initial review into bank current account charges, it had decided to conduct a market study into personal current accounts in the United Kingdom and a formal investigation into the fairness of bank current account charges.

On 16 July 2008, the OFT published the results of its market study into personal current accounts in the United Kingdom. The OFT found evidence of competition and several positive features in the personal current account market but believes that the market as a whole is not working well for consumers and that the ability of the market to function well has become distorted. The OFT is currently consulting with the banking industry, consumer groups and interested parties on its report. After this consultation the OFT will decide on next steps, which could include further discussions or agreed remedies with the industry, or possibly a reference of the market to the CC.

The OFTs investigation into the fairness of bank current account charges is ongoing. On 12 August 2008, the OFT indicated to the Group and other banks that, although it had not concluded its investigation and had reached no final view, it had serious concerns that contractual terms relating to Relevant Charges in personal current account agreements were unfair under the Regulations. The OFT is currently consulting with the Group and other banks on this issue. Given the stage of the investigation, the Group cannot reliably estimate the impact of any adverse outcome of the OFTs market study or investigation upon it, if any. However, the Group is co-operating fully with the OFT to achieve resolution of the matters under investigation.

On 26 January 2007, the FSA issued a Statement of Good Practice relating to Mortgage Exit Administration Fees. On 1 March 2007, the Group adopted a policy of charging all customers the fee applicable at the time the customers took out the mortgage or, if later, varied their mortgage. The Group believes that it is currently in compliance with the Statement of Good Practice and will continue to monitor its performance against those standards.

United States
The New York State Attorney General has issued subpoenas to a wide array of participants in the sub-prime mortgage industry, including mortgage originators, appraisers, due diligence firms, investment banks and rating agencies, focusing on the information underwriters obtained as part of the due diligence process from the independent due diligence firms and whether that information is adequately disclosed to investors. RBS Greenwich Capital has produced documents requested by the New York State Attorney General principally related to sub-prime loans that were pooled into one securitisation transaction.

In addition to the above, certain RBS Groups subsidiaries have received requests for information from various US governmental agencies and self-regulatory organisations including in connection with sub-prime mortgages and securitisations, collateralised debt obligations and synthetic products related to sub-prime mortgages. In particular, during March 2008, the RBS Group was advised by the SEC that it had commenced a non-public, formal investigation relating to the RBS Groups US sub-prime securities exposures and US residential mortgage exposures. The RBS Group and its subsidiaries are co-operating with these various requests for information and investigations.

Litigation

United Kingdom
In common with other banks in the United Kingdom, The Royal Bank of Scotland plc (“the Royal Bank”) and National Westminster Bank Plc (“NatWest”) have received claims and complaints from a large number of customers challenging unarranged overdraft charges (the Charges) as contravening the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999 (the Regulations) or being unenforceable penalties (or both).

On 27 July 2007, the OFT issued proceedings in a test case against the banks which was intended to determine certain preliminary issues concerning the legal status and enforceability of contractual terms relating to the Charges. Because of the test case, most existing and new claims in the County Courts are currently stayed, the FSA temporarily waived the customer complaints-handling process and there is a standstill of Financial Ombudsman Service decisions.

A High Court judgment in April 2008 addressed preliminary issues in respect of the banks contractual terms relating to the Charges in force in early 2008 (the Current Terms). The judgment held that the Current Terms used by the Royal Bank and NatWest (i) are not unenforceable as penalties, but (ii) are not exempt from assessment for fairness under the Regulations.

The RBS Group (in common with the other banks) has accepted that the ruling in the April judgment that the Current Terms are not exempt from assessment for fairness applies also to a sample of the Royal Bank and NatWest contractual terms relating to the Charges in force between 2001 and 2007 (the Historic Terms). The High Court made an order to this effect in October 2008.

The RBS Group and the other banks have appealed against the rulings in April 2008 and October 2008 that the Current Terms and Historic Terms are not exempt from assessment for fairness under the Regulations. The hearing of the appeal in relation to Current Terms took place before the Court of Appeal in October and November 2008. The Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 26 February 2009 and rejected the appeals. The RBS Group and the other banks intend to seek leave from the House of Lords to appeal the Court of Appeals decision. The appeal in relation to the Historic Terms is stayed pending the resolution of the appeal in relation to the Current Terms.

High Court judgments on further preliminary issues were handed down in October 2008 and January 2009. These judgments primarily addressed the question of whether certain Historic Terms were capable of being unenforceable penalties. The Judge decided that all of the Royal Banks and most of NatWests Historic Terms were not penalties, but that a term contained in a set of NatWest 2001 terms and conditions was a contractual prohibition against using a card to obtain an unarranged overdraft. The Judge did not decide whether any charge payable upon a breach of this prohibition was a penalty. The RBS Group has not appealed that decision.


125


 
 
 
29  Memorandum items (continued)

The issues relating to the legal status and enforceability of the Charges are complex. The RBS Group maintains that its Charges are fair and enforceable and believes that it has a number of substantive and credible defences. The RBS Group cannot at this stage predict with any certainty the final outcome of the customer claims and complaints, the appeals referred to above and any further stages of the test case. It is unable reliably to estimate the liability, if any, that may arise as a result of or in connection with these matters or its effect on the Groups consolidated net assets, operating results or cash flows in any particular period.

United States
Proceedings, including consolidated class actions on behalf of former Enron securities holders, have been brought in the United States against a large number of defendants, including the Group, following the collapse of Enron. The claims against the Group could be significant; the class plaintiffs position is that each defendant is responsible for an entire aggregate damage amount less settlements they have not quantified claimed damages against the Group in particular. The Group considers that it has substantial and credible legal and factual defences to these claims and will continue to defend them vigorously. Recent decisions by the US Supreme Court and the US Federal Court for the Fifth Circuit provide further support for the Groups position. The Group is unable reliably to estimate the liability, if any, that might arise or its effect on the Groups consolidated net assets, operating results or cash flows in any particular period.

RBS Group companies have been named as defendants in a number of purported class action and other lawsuits in the United States that relate to the sub-prime mortgage business. In general, the cases involve the issuance of sub-prime-related securities or the issuance of shares in companies with sub-prime-related exposure, where the plaintiffs have brought actions against the issuers and underwriters (including RBS Group companies) of such securities claiming that certain disclosures made in connection with the relevant offerings of such securities were false or misleading. The RBS Group considers that it has substantial and credible legal and factual defences to these claims and will continue to defend them vigorously. The RBS Group does not currently expect that these lawsuits, individually or in the aggregate, will have a material impact on its consolidated net assets, operating results or cash flows in any particular period.

The holding company and a number of its subsidiaries and certain individual officers and directors have been named as defendants in a number of class action complaints filed in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. The complaints allege that public filings in connection with the issuance of RBS Group Non- cumulative Dollar Preference Shares, ADS, including Series Q, Series R, Series S and Series T, together with the much broader class of RBS Group publicly traded securities between 26 June 2007 and 19 January 2009, contained false and misleading statements, and variously assert claims under Sections 11, 12 and 15 of the Securities Act 1933, Section 10 of the Securities Exchange Act 1934 and SEC Rule 10b-5. Plaintiffs seek unquantified damages on behalf of purchasers of these shares. The proceedings are in their initial stages. The RBS Group considers that it has substantial and credible legal and factual defences to these claims and will defend them vigorously. The RBS Group is unable reliably to estimate the liability, if any, that might arise or its effect on the Groups consolidated net assets, operating results or cash flows in any particular period.

Summary of  other disputes, legal proceedings and litigation
Members of the Group are engaged in other litigation in the United Kingdom and a number of overseas jurisdictions, including the United States, involving claims by and against them arising in the ordinary course of business. The Group has reviewed these other actual, threatened and known potential claims and proceedings and, after consulting with its legal advisers, does not expect that the outcome of these other claims and proceedings will have a material adverse effect on its consolidated net assets, operating results or cash flows in any particular period.
 
 
126

 
 
 

30  Net cash flow from operating activities

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Operating (loss)/profit before tax
    (9,047 )     9,155       8,354       (2,204 )     7,759       4,039  
(Increase)/decrease in prepayments and accrued income
    (513 )     (411 )     55       (426 )     (221 )     76  
Interest on subordinated liabilities
    1,694       1,452       1,161       1,487       1,200       878  
Increase/(decrease) in accruals and deferred income
    2,497       (248 )     701       2,089       220       682  
Provisions for impairment losses
    4,706       1,865       1,873       2,007       473       692  
Loans and advances written-off  net of  recoveries
    (2,236 )     (1,407 )     (1,626 )     (737 )     (477 )     (571 )
Unwind of  discount on impairment losses
    (174 )     (166 )     (142 )     (61 )     (65 )     (63 )
Profit on sale of  property, plant and equipment
    (177 )     (672 )     (215 )     (4 )     (740 )     (1 )
(Profit)/loss on sale of  subsidiaries and associates
    (417 )     (67 )     (41 )     (617 )     8       (2 )
Profit on sale of  securities
    (174 )     (496 )     (252 )     (94 )     (231 )     (92 )
Charge for defined benefit pension schemes
    351       479       578       8       5       8  
Cash contribution to defined benefit pension schemes
    (491 )     (536 )     (533 )     (8 )     (16 )     (1 )
Other provisions utilised
    (24 )     (200 )     (40 )     (14 )     (65 )     (11 )
Depreciation and amortisation
    1,562       1,438       1,415       483       485       390  
Write-down of  goodwill and other assets
    8,144                   215              
Elimination of  foreign exchange differences
    (20,997 )     (2,137 )     4,515       (16,892 )     (2,034 )     1,345  
Other non-cash items
    1,417       969       (1,447 )     2,692       523       (492 )
Net cash (outflow)/inflow from trading activities
    (13,879 )     9,018       14,356       (12,076 )     6,824       6,877  
Increase in loans and advances to banks and customers
    (69,339 )     (92,494 )     (46,036 )     (10,544 )     (88,570 )     (24,025 )
Decrease/(increase) in securities
    19,719       (25,033 )     (16,632 )     14,127       (16,069 )     (13,136 )
(Increase)/decrease in other assets
    (4,494 )     (5,122 )     404       (3,920 )     (3,003 )     (1,068 )
Increase in derivative assets
    (724,306 )     (103,852 )     (18,649 )     (730,592 )     (105,426 )     (19,044 )
Changes in operating assets
    (778,420 )     (226,501 )     (80,913 )     (730,929 )     (213,068 )     (57,273 )
Increase in deposits by banks and customers
    42,367       79,408       63,733       35,638       72,435       76,496  
Increase/(decrease) in debt securities in issue
    49,810       47,526       (3,616 )     35,272       38,056       (22,990 )
(Decrease)/increase in other liabilities
    (3,650 )     405       814       2,102       325       532  
Increase in derivative liabilities
    706,052       99,559       19,206       706,940       100,577       19,016  
(Decrease)/increase in settlement balances and short positions
    (13,314 )     6,472       4,068       (7,605 )     10,253       1,034  
Changes in operating liabilities
    781,265       233,370       84,205       772,347       221,646       74,088  
Total income taxes paid
    (886 )     (1,802 )     (2,122 )     83       (526 )     (298 )
Net cash (outflow)/inflow from operating activities
    (11,920 )     14,085       15,526       29,425       14,876       23,394  
 

 
31  Analysis of the net investment in business interests and intangible assets

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Fair value given for businesses acquired
    (1,491 )     (147 )     (21 )     (47 )     (6 )     (236 )
Additional investments in Group undertakings
          5             (4,155 )     (560 )     (449 )
Net outflow of  cash in respect of  purchases
    (1,491 )     (142 )     (21 )     (4,202 )     (566 )     (685 )
Cash and cash equivalents in businesses sold
          21       229                    
Other assets sold
    552       16       41       146              
Repayment of  investments
                      349       281       340  
Non-cash consideration
    (35 )     (2 )     (3 )                  
Profit/(loss) on disposal
    417       67       41       617       (8 )     2  
Net inflow of  cash in respect of  disposals
    934       102       308       1,112       273       342  
Dividends received from joint ventures
    9       9       29       3       2       3  
Cash expenditure on intangible assets
    (360 )     (399 )     (335 )     (177 )     (299 )     (105 )
Net outflow of  cash
    (908 )     (430 )     (19 )     (3,264 )     (590 )     (445 )


127





32  Interest received and paid

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Interest received
    30,876       27,641       25,284       16,169       12,897       12,669  
Interest paid
    (17,581 )     (15,482 )     (15,189 )     (11,576 )     (10,071 )     (9,534 )
      13,295       12,159       10,095       4,593       2,826       3,135  
 

 
33  Analysis of changes in financing during the year

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
Share capital,
share premium
   
Subordinated
   
Share capital and
   
Subordinated
 
   
and merger reserve
   
liabilities
   
share premium
   
liabilities
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January
    32,539       28,889       27,796       27,786       21,658       18,008       22,745       22,403  
Issue of  ordinary shares
    10,000                             10,000                        
Issue of  equity preference shares
          3,650                             3,650                  
Net proceeds from issue of subordinated liabilities
                    5,055       1,018                       5,055       968  
Repayment of  subordinated liabilities
                    (1,035 )     (1,708 )                     (1,035 )     (1,288 )
Net cash inflow/(outflow) from financing
    10,000       3,650       4,020       (690 )     10,000       3,650       4,020       (320 )
Currency translation and other adjustments
                8,135       700                   6,933       662  
At 31 December
    42,539       32,539       39,951       27,796       31,658       21,658       33,698       22,745  
 

 
34  Analysis of cash and cash equivalents

   
Group
   
Bank
 
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January
                                               
 cash
    27,289       28,175       25,333       16,591       16,025       9,629  
 cash equivalents
    57,472       41,972       27,352       60,658       47,561       29,778  
      84,761       70,147       52,685       77,249       63,586       39,407  
Net cash (outflow)/inflow
    (4,347 )     14,614       17,462       (3,800 )     13,663       24,179  
At 31 December
    80,414       84,761       70,147       73,449       77,249       63,586  
                                                 
Comprising:
                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
    6,442       5,121       5,752       3,432       3,003       3,424  
Treasury bills and debt securities
    14,006       6,818       1,596       14,006       6,521       1,595  
Loans and advances to banks
    59,966       72,822       62,799       56,011       67,725       58,567  
Cash and cash equivalents
    80,414       84,761       70,147       73,449       77,249       63,586  


The Bank and certain subsidiaries are required to maintain balances with the Bank of England which, at 31 December 2008, amounted to £282 million (2007 £330 million). Certain subsidiary undertakings are required by law to maintain reserve balances with the Federal Reserve Bank in the US. Such reserve balances were nil at 31 December 2008 (2007 US$1 million).


128




35 Segmental analysis
(a) Divisions

The directors manage the Group primarily by class of business and present the segmental analysis on that basis. The Groups activities are organised as follows:

Global Markets is focused on the provision of debt and equity financing, risk management and transaction banking services to large businesses and financial institutions in the United Kingdom and around the world. Its activities have been organised into two divisions; Global Banking & Markets (GBM) and Global Transaction Services (GTS), in order best to serve the Groups customers whose financial needs are global.

GBM is a leading banking partner to major corporations and financial institutions around the world, providing an extensive range of debt and equity financing, risk management and investment services to its customers.

GTS ranks among the top five global transaction services providers, offering global payments, cash and liquidity management, as well as trade finance, UK and international merchant acquiring and commercial card products and services. It includes the Groups corporate money transmission activities in the United Kingdom and the United States.

Regional Markets is organised around the provision of retail and commercial banking to customers in four regions; the United Kingdom, the United States, Europe and the Middle East and Asia. This includes the provision of wealth management services both in the United Kingdom and internationally.

UK Retail & Commercial Banking comprises retail, commercial and corporate banking, and wealth management services in the United Kingdom. It supplies financial services through both the RBS and NatWest brands.

US Retail & Commercial Banking comprises Citizens which is engaged in retail and corporate banking activities through its branch network in 12 states in the United States and through non-branch offices in other states. Citizens Financial Group provides financial services through the Citizens and Charter One brands.

Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking comprises Ulster Bank and the Groups combined retail and commercial businesses in Europe and the Middle East.
 
Ulster Bank, including First Active, provides a comprehensive range of financial services across the island of Ireland. Its retail banking arm has a network of branches and operates in the personal, commercial and wealth management sectors, while its corporate markets operations provide services in the corporate and institutional markets.

Asia Retail & Commercial Banking holds prominent market positions in India, Pakistan, China and Taiwan, as well as presences in Hong Kong, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore . It provides financial services across four segments: affluent banking, cards and consumer finance, business banking and international wealth management, which offers private banking and investment services to clients in selected markets through the RBS Coutts brand.

Group Manufacturing comprises the Groups worldwide manufacturing operations. It supports the Groups customer-facing businesses and provides operational technology, customer support in telephony, account management, lending and money transmission, global purchasing, property and other services.

The Centre comprises group and corporate functions, such as capital raising, finance, risk management, legal, communications and human resources. The Centre manages the Groups capital resources and Group- wide regulatory projects and provides services to the operating divisions.

Segments charge market prices for services rendered to other parts of the Group with the exception of Group Manufacturing and central items. The expenditure incurred by Manufacturing relates to costs principally in respect of the Groups banking and insurance operations in the UK and Ireland. These costs reflect activities that are shared between the various customer-facing divisions. These shared costs and related assets and liabilities are not allocated to divisions in the day-to-day management of the businesses and the results below reflect this. Funding charges between segments are determined by Group Treasury, having regard to commercial demands. The results of each division before amortisation of purchased intangible assets, integration and restructuring and write down of goodwill costs (Contribution) are shown in the following tables.


129





35  Segmental analysis (continued)

   
Group
 
   
Revenue
   
Total Income
                         
                                             
Depreciation
         
 
 
         
Inter
               
Inter
         
Operating
   
and
   
Impairment
   
 
 
   
External
   
segment
   
Total
   
External
   
segment
   
Total
   
expenses
   
amortisation
   
losses
   
Contribution
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Global Markets
                                                                               
 Global Banking & Markets
    5,361       12,325       17,686       1,249       (2,258 )     (1,009 )     (1,946 )     (286 )     (1,255 )     (4,496 )
 Global Transaction Services
    2,253       81       2,334       1,743       (28 )     1,715       (430 )     (9 )     (29 )     1,247  
Regional Markets
                                                                               
 UK Retail & Commercial Banking
    18,424       3,605       22,029       12,069       (1,462 )     10,607       (2,554 )     (413 )     (1,964 )     5,676  
 US Retail & Commercial Banking
    5,031             5,031       3,049       (39 )     3,010       (942 )     (144 )     (1,041 )     883  
 Europe & Middle East Retail
                                                                               
& Commercial Banking
    3,626       584       4,210       2,030       (677 )     1,353       (480 )           (410 )     463  
 Asia Retail & Commercial Banking
    353       346       699       15       282       297       (199 )     (8 )     (5 )     85  
Group Manufacturing
    33             33       (204 )     (9 )     (213 )     (3,055 )     (577 )           (3,845 )
Central items
    413       11,328       11,741       (4,094 )     4,191       97       (261 )     (3 )     (2 )     (169 )
Eliminations
            (28,269 
)
      (28,269 )              —                                        —   
      35,494             35,494       15,857             15,857       (9,867 )     (1,440 )     (4,706 )     (156 )
Amortisation of  purchased intangible assets
                                              (100 )           (100 )
Integration and restructuring costs
                                        (625 )     (22 )           (647 )
Goodwill and other asset write-downs
                                        (8,144 )                 (8,144 )
      35,494             35,494       15,857             15,857       (18,636 )     (1,562 )     (4,706 )     (9,047 )
                                                                                 
                                                                                 
2007
                                                                               
Global Markets
                                                                               
 Global Banking & Markets
    11,585       9,501       21,086       7,711       (1,634 )     6,077       (2,156 )     (247 )     (36 )     3,638  
 Global Transaction Services
    2,502       77       2,579       1,983       (356 )     1,627       (394 )     (6 )     (15 )     1,212  
Regional Markets
                                                                               
 UK Retail & Commercial Banking
    17,460       3,642       21,102       11,187       (865 )     10,322       (2,499 )     (337 )     (1,368 )     6,118  
 US Retail & Commercial Banking
    5,184             5,184       2,837       (56 )     2,781       (844 )     (118 )     (340 )     1,479  
 Europe & Middle East Retail
                                                                               
& Commercial Banking
    2,841       197       3,038       1,794       (477 )     1,317       (435 )     (6 )     (104 )     772  
 Asia Retail & Commercial Banking
    281       330       611       (22 )     272       250       (170 )     (5 )           75  
Group Manufacturing
    44       1       45       (192 )     (4 )     (196 )     (2,569 )     (593 )           (3,358 )
Central items
    1,100       8,906       10,006       (2,991 )     3,120       129       (710 )     18       (2 )     (565 )
Eliminations
            (22,654  )       (22,654  )             —                                           
      40,997             40,997       22,307             22,307       (9,777 )     (1,294 )     (1,865 )     9,371  
Amortisation of purchased intangible assets
                                        (40 )     (84 )           (124 )
Integration costs
                                        (32 )     (60 )           (92 )
      40,997             40,997       22,307             22,307       (9,849 )     (1,438 )     (1,865 )     9,155  


130


   
Group
 
   
Revenue
   
Total Income
                         
                                             
Depreciation
         
 
 
         
Inter
               
Inter
         
Operating
   
and
   
Impairment
   
 
 
   
External
   
segment
   
Total
   
External
   
segment
   
Total
   
expenses
   
amortisation
   
losses
   
Contribution
 
2006
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Global Markets
                                                                               
 Global Banking & Markets
    10,824       7,627       18,451       8,015       (1,607 )     6,408       (2,313 )     (248 )     (85 )     3,762  
 Global Transaction Services
    2,073       4       2,077       1,527       2       1,529       (334 )     (6 )     (4 )     1,185  
Regional Markets
                                                                               
 UK Retail & Commercial Banking
    15,438       2,725       18,163       10,852       (1,002 )     9,850       (2,357 )     (345 )     (1,497 )     5,651  
 US Retail & Commercial Banking
    5,456       2       5,458       3,072       (82 )     2,990       (910 )     (156 )     (180 )     1,744  
 Europe & Middle East Retail
                                                                               
& Commercial Banking
    2,361       196       2,557       1,296       (153 )     1,143       (360 )     (5 )     (104 )     674  
 Asia Retail & Commercial Banking
    218       252       470       2       210       212       (141 )     (5 )     1       67  
Group Manufacturing
    52       5       57       (210 )     (21 )     (231 )     (2,520 )     (557 )     2       (3,306 )
Central items
    499       6,900       7,399       (2,986 )     2,653       (333 )     (887 )     17       (6 )     (1,209 )
Eliminations
          (17,711 )     (17,711 )                                          
      36,921             36,921       21,568             21,568       (9,822 )     (1,305 )     (1,873 )     8,568  
Amortisation of  purchased intangible assets
                                              (94 )           (94 )
Integration costs
                                        (104 )     (16 )           (120 )
      36,921             36,921       21,568             21,568       (9,926 )     (1,415 )     (1,873 )     8,354  

Notes:
(1)   Revenue represents total income included in the income statement grossed-up for interest payable and commissions payable.
(2)   Segmental results for 2007 and 2006 have been restated to reflect transfers of  businesses between segments in 2008.

   
Group
 
   
2008
   
2007
 
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
   
Cost to
acquire
fixed assets
and intangible
assets
   
Assets
   
Liabilities
   
Cost to
acquire
fixed assets
and intangible
assets
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Global Markets
                                               
 Global Banking & Markets
    1,421,892       1,361,207       2,755       678,122       612,712       1,645  
 Global Transaction Services
    11,603       36,971       4       13,629       36,421       15  
Regional Markets
                                               
 UK Retail & Commercial Banking
    245,315       189,856       1,447       227,816       192,277       1,497  
 US Retail & Commercial Banking
    104,026       94,026       204       78,979       68,458       171  
 Europe & Middle East Retail & Commercial Banking
    68,454       51,708       2       56,316       45,185       35  
 Asia Retail & Commercial Banking
    5,283       9,077       18       4,338       7,549       14  
Group Manufacturing
    5,820       2,166       966       5,528       2,065       1,001  
Central items
    15,537       85,669       9       7,010       59,236       2  
Group
    1,877,930       1,830,680       5,405       1,071,738       1,023,903       4,380  
 
Note:
(1) Segmental results for 2007 have been restated to reflect transfer of businesses between segments in 2008.

 
Segmental analysis of  goodwill is as follows:
 
   
Global
Banking &
Markets
   
Global
Transaction
Services
   
UK Retail &
Commercial
Banking
   
US Retail &
Commercial
Banking
   
Europe &
Middle East
Retail &
Commercial
Banking
   
Asia
Retail &
Commercial
Banking
   
Central
items
   
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
At 1 January 2007
    2,279       1,742       6,158       5,429       904       298       24       16,834  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    (4 )     (18 )           (103 )     41       7             (77 )
Acquisitions
                      66                         66  
Goodwill written off
          (40 )                                   (40 )
At 1 January 2008
    2,275       1,684       6,158       5,392       945       305       24       16,783  
Currency translation and other adjustments
    56       425             2,013       138       57             2,689  
Acquisitions
    211                                           211  
Disposals
                            (47 )                 (47 )
Write down of  goodwill
    (2,225 )     (44 )     (47 )     (4,382 )     (1,036 )     (70 )           (7,804 )
At 31 December 2008
    317       2,065       6,111       3,023             292       24       11,832  

131

 
 
 
 
35 Segmental analysis (continued)
(b) Geographical segments
 
The geographical analyses in the tables below have been compiled on the basis of  location of  office where the transactions are recorded.


               
Group
             
                     
Rest of
       
   
UK
   
US
   
Europe
   
the World
   
Total
 
2008
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Total revenue
    20,755       6,744       5,542       2,453       35,494  
Net interest income
    9,917       2,576       802       214       13,509  
Net fees and commissions
    3,982       1,341       333       94       5,750  
(Loss)/income from trading activities
    (3,835 )     (1,657 )     (302 )     211       (5,583 )
Other operating income
    1,556       158       489       (22 )     2,181  
Total income
    11,620       2,418       1,322       497       15,857  
Operating (loss)/profit before tax
    (2,772 )     (5,514 )     (764 )     3       (9,047 )
Total assets
    1,131,765       583,149       102,318       60,698       1,877,930  
Total liabilities
    1,104,026       568,344       98,126       60,184       1,830,680  
Net assets attributable to equity shareholders and minority interests
    27,739       14,805       4,192       514       47,250  
Contingent liabilities and commitments
    178,411       106,921       36,886       11,836       334,054  
Cost to acquire property, plant and equipment and intangible assets
    3,167       444       1,687       107       5,405  
                                         
2007
                                       
Total revenue
    27,057       7,488       4,658       1,794       40,997  
Net interest income
    8,150       2,098       756       112       11,116  
Net fees and commissions
    4,299       1,140       435       149       6,023  
Income/(loss) from trading activities
    1,582       (567 )     73       54       1,142  
Other operating income
    3,167       241       562       56       4,026  
Total income
    17,198       2,912       1,826       371       22,307  
Operating profit before tax
    7,533       721       797       104       9,155  
Total assets
    705,372       251,514       78,419       36,433       1,071,738  
Total liabilities
    674,989       238,345       74,363       36,206       1,023,903  
Net assets attributable to equity shareholders and minority interests
    30,383       13,169       4,056       227       47,835  
Contingent liabilities and commitments
    170,361       66,283       40,135       7,851       284,630  
Cost to acquire property, plant and equipment and intangible assets
    2,864       238       1,255       23       4,380  


132



               
Group
             
                     
Rest of
       
   
UK
   
US
   
Europe
   
the World
   
Total
 
2006
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Total revenue
    22,644       9,001       4,249       1,027       36,921  
Net interest income
    7,418       2,212       697       65       10,392  
Net fees and commissions
    3,883       1,245       412       94       5,634  
Income from trading activities
    1,453       939       108       43       2,543  
Other operating income
    2,186       295       506       12       2,999  
Total income
    14,940       4,691       1,723       214       21,568  
Operating profit before tax
    5,299       2,267       762       26       8,354  
Total assets
    562,689       197,421       59,784       13,733       833,627  
Total liabilities
    542,422       183,432       55,797       13,644       795,295  
Net assets attributable to equity shareholders and minority interests
    20,267       13,989       3,987       89       38,332  
Contingent liabilities and commitments
    186,827       57,873       13,244       7,159       265,103  
Cost to acquire property, plant and equipment and intangible assets
    2,708       254       1,346       19       4,327  


36  Directors and key management remuneration

The directors of the Bank are also directors of the holding company and are remunerated for their services to the RBS Group as a whole. The remuneration of the directors is disclosed in the Report and Accounts of the RBS Group.

Compensation of  key management
The aggregate remuneration of  directors and other members of  key management during the year, borne by the RBS Group, was as follows:

   
2008
   
2007
 
      £000       £000  
Short-term benefits
    16,813       37,763  
Post-employment benefits
    13,174       10,051  
Other long-term benefits
    496       708  
Termination benefits
    345        
Share-based payments
    2,078       5,165  
      32,906       53,687  
 
 
37  Transactions with directors, officers and others

(a)   At 31 December 2008, the amounts outstanding in relation to transactions, arrangements and agreements entered into by authorised institutions in the Group, as defined in UK legislation, were £117,847 in respect of  loans to 27 persons who were directors of  the Bank (or persons connected with them) at any time during the financial period and £4,196,374 to 16 people who were officers of  the Bank at any time during the financial period.

(b)   For the purposes of  IAS 24 ‘Related Party Disclosures’, key management comprise directors of  the Bank and members of  RBS Group’s Group Executive Management Committee. The captions in the Group’s primary financial statements include the following amounts attributable, in aggregate, to key management:


   
2008
   
2007
 
      £000       £000  
Loans and advances to customers
    4,217       2,023  
Customer accounts
    9,572       13,309  

Key management have banking relationships with Group entities which are entered into in the normal course of business and on substantially the same terms, including interest rates and security, as for comparable transactions with other persons of a similar standing or, where applicable, with other employees. These transactions did not involve more than the normal risk of repayment or present other unfavourable features.

Key management had no reportable transactions or balances with the holding company except for dividends.


133


 


38  Related parties
 
(a)  Group companies and the Bank provide development and other types of  capital support to businesses in their roles as providers of finance. These investments are made in the normal course of business and on arms-length terms. In some instances, the investment may extend to ownership or control over 20% or more of the voting rights of  the investee company. However, these investments are not considered to give rise to transactions of  a materiality requiring disclosure under IAS 24.

(b)  The Group recharges The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group Pension Fund with the cost of  administration services incurred by it. The amounts involved are not material to the Group.
 
(c)  In accordance with IAS 24, transactions or balances between Group entities that have been eliminated on consolidation are not reported.

(d)  The captions in the primary financial statements of  the Bank include amounts attributable to subsidiaries. These amounts have been disclosed in aggregate in the relevant notes to the financial statements. The table below discloses items included in income and operating expenses on transactions between the Group and fellow subsidiaries of  the RBS Group.


   
2008
   
2007
 
      £m       £m  
Income
               
Interest receivable
    569       175  
Interest payable
    885       498  
Fees and commissions receivable
    237       200  
Fees and commissions payable
    14       4  
                 
Expenses
               
Premises and equipment
    7       7  

(e) 
On 1 December 2008, the UK Government through HM Treasury became the ultimate controlling party of  The Royal Bank of  Scotland Group plc. The UK Governments shareholding is managed by UK Financial Investments Limited, a company wholly owned by the UK Government. As a result, the UK Government and UK Government controlled bodies became related parties of  the Group. The Group enters into transactions with many of  these bodies on an arms’ length basis. The volume and diversity of  such transactions are such that disclosure of  their amounts in the period 1 December 2008 to 31 December 2008 is impractical.

As at 31 December 2008, balances with the UK Government and UK Government controlled bodies were:

         
Group
       
   
Central
government
(including the
Bank of England)
   
Local
government
   
Banks,
financial
corporations
and public
corporations
   
2008
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                               
Balances at central banks
    282                       282  
Loans and advances to banks
                  1,053       1,053  
Loans and advances to customers
    1       575       431       1,007  
Debt securities
    19,732                   19,732  
Derivatives
    1,286       60       10       1,356  
Other
    249                   249  
                                 
Liabilities
                               
Deposits by banks
    26,541               605       27,146  
Customer accounts
    222       1,436       149       1,807  
Derivatives
    276       69       18       365  
Other
    176                   176  


134




   
Bank
 
   
Central
government
(including the
Bank of England)
   
Local
government
   
Banks,
financial
corporations
and public
corporations
   
2008
Total
 
      £m       £m       £m       £m  
Assets
                               
Balances at central banks
    282                       282  
Loans and advances to banks
                  1,053       1,053  
Loans and advances to customers
          399       14       413  
Debt securities
    19,111                   19,111  
Derivatives
    1,286       60       10       1,356  
Other
    249                   249  
                                 
Liabilities
                               
Deposits by banks
    26,541               605       27,146  
Customer accounts
    222       1,436       149       1,807  
Derivatives
    276       69       18       363  
Other
    176                   176  

Notes:
(1)  
In addition to the UK Governments shareholding in the Group, the UK Government and UK Government controlled bodies may hold debt securities, subordinated liabilities and other liabilities or shares issued by the Group in the normal course of their business. It is not practicable to ascertain and disclose these amounts.
(2)  
Certain of  the liability balances are secured.

No impairment losses were recognised by the Group in 2008 in respect of balances with UK Government and UK Government controlled bodies.

The Group participates in a number of schemes operated by the Bank of England and the UK Government and made available to eligible banks and building societies.

Bank of  England facilities include:
  
Open market operations these provide market participants with funding at market rates on a tender basis in the form of short and long-term repos on a wide range of collateral and outright purchases of high-quality bonds to enable them to meet the reserves that they must hold at the Bank of England.

  
US dollar repo operations these commenced in September 2008 taking the form of an auction. Eligible collateral consists of securities routinely eligible in the Bank's short-term repo open market operations together with conventional US Treasuries.

  
The special liquidity scheme this was launched in April 2008 to allow financial institutions to swap temporarily illiquid assets for treasury bills, with fees charged based on the spread between 3-month LIBOR and the 3-month gilt repo rate.

As at 31 December 2008, the Groups utilisation of these facilities amounted to £41.8 billion.
 
Government credit guarantee scheme this was announced in October 2008. The Government, in return for a fee (50 basis points plus the banks median five-year credit default spread during the twelve months to 7 October 2008), guarantees new unsecured borrowing.

As at 31 December 2008, the Group had obtained funding from the Bank of England and issued debt guaranteed by the government totalling £32.2 billion.

39  Ultimate holding company

The Groups ultimate holding company is The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc which is incorporated in Great Britain and registered in Scotland. As at 31 December 2008, The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc heads the largest group in which the Group is consolidated. Copies of the consolidated accounts may be obtained from The Secretary, The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc, Gogarburn, PO Box 1000, Edinburgh EH12 1HQ.

Following a placing and open offer by The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc in December 2008, the UK Government, through HM Treasury, currently holds 57.9% of the issued ordinary share capital of the holding company and is therefore the Groups ultimate controlling party.

40  Post balance sheet events

There have been no significant events between the year end and the date of approval of these accounts which would require a change to or disclosure in the accounts.


135






Amounts in accordance with IFRS
 
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2005
   
2004
 
Summary consolidated income statement  IFRS
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Net interest income
    13,509       11,116       10,392       9,711       8,790  
Non-interest income
    2,348       11,191       11,176       9,963       8,441  
Total income
    15,857       22,307       21,568       19,674       17,231  
Operating expenses (1)
    20,198       11,287       11,341       10,672       9,225  
Profit before impairment
    (4,341 )     11,020       10,227       9,002       8,006  
Impairment
    4,706       1,865       1,873       1,709       1,485  
Operating profit before tax
    (9,047 )     9,155       8,354       7,293       6,521  
Tax
    (505 )     1,903       2,433       2,267       1,751  
(Loss)/profit from continuing operations
    (8,542 )     7,252       5,921       5,026       4,770  
Profit from discontinued operations, net of  tax
                            258  
(Loss)/profit for the year
    (8,542 )     7,252       5,921       5,026       5,028  
                                         
(Loss)/profit attributable to:
                                       
Minority interests
    208       53       45       27       53  
Other owners
    638       331       252       154       315  
Ordinary shareholders
    (9,388 )     6,868       5,624       4,845       4,660  
 
Note:
(1)  Includes integration and restructuring expenditure of  £661 million (2007 £92 million, 2006 £120 million, 2005 £349 million, 2004 £499 million).

   
2008
   
2007
   
2006
   
2005
   
2004
 
Summary consolidated balance sheet  IFRS
    £m       £m       £m       £m       £m  
Loans and advances
    698,890       647,795       547,042       485,488       405,512  
Debt securities and equity shares
    180,457       169,941       126,621       120,351       91,356  
Derivatives and settlement balances (1)
    948,328       211,301       109,548       89,479       15,297  
Other assets
    50,255       42,701       50,416       49,806       50,436  
Total assets
    1,877,930       1,071,738       833,627       745,124       562,601  
Shareholders equity
    45,958       47,683       37,936       34,510       34,320  
Minority interests
    1,292       152       396       104       679  
Subordinated liabilities
    39,951       27,796       27,786       28,422       21,262  
Deposits
    635,111       594,490       516,462       452,729       383,669  
Derivatives, settlement balances and short positions (1)
    955,062       256,921       152,989       128,295       43,812  
Other liabilities
    200,556       144,696       98,058       101,064       78,859  
Total liabilities and equity
    1,877,930       1,071,738       833,627       745,124       562,601  
 
Note:
(1)   Derivative balances in 2007 to 2004 have been restated for the netting of  certain balances with the London Clearing House.
 
136

 
 

 
SIGNATURE
 
Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned, thereunto duly authorised.
 
 
Date: 28 May 2009
The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc
Registrant
   
/s/ Guy Robert Whittaker  
 
Guy Robert Whittaker  
Group Finance Director  

 
 
137